PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Air Fraser (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/628471-air-fraser.html)

splitty 2nd Jan 2020 05:34

Air Fraser
 
Airvan bites the sand
https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....e11525d09.jpeg
Not A Seaplane !

Konev 2nd Jan 2020 06:08

Has that lost its nose wheel or just sunk?

takeonme 2nd Jan 2020 06:57

If it sunk just hang off the tail and pivot 😉

runway16 2nd Jan 2020 08:01

I have heard of tail draggers but this gives real meaning to the expression nose dragger!

aroa 2nd Jan 2020 08:59

Is there a tide scum, looks like sand and its just dropped over the bank into the creek. Interesting foreground to that pic
Or, as for beach driving .. beware the sand that is loosened by running water. As learnt up remote Cape beaches !!
Kerplonk.!..now extricate yourself.... Tide incoming...better hurry .

cowl flaps 2nd Jan 2020 11:19

Just put two big fat bastards in the rear seats,- get the nose up and stick a 5 gallon drum behind the prop. :D

flywatcher 2nd Jan 2020 19:29

That looks like a very strange piece of beach to put an aircraft on.

Squawk7700 2nd Jan 2020 21:16


Originally Posted by flywatcher (Post 10652315)
That looks like a very strange piece of beach to put an aircraft on.

I’d be guessing it was dragged up there to elude the incoming tide.

RatsoreA 3rd Jan 2020 12:50

The timid airvan sneaks up the waters edge for drink, always alert for predators... They are at their most vulnerable and would be easy pickings for a hungry Catalina hiding out of site, waiting to strike...

601 4th Jan 2020 03:29


easy pickings for a hungry Catalina hiding out of site, waiting to strike...
Or an Orion sneaking up the beach at ? feet

Cloudee 6th Jan 2020 10:09


https://www.atsb.gov.au/publications...r/ao-2020-001/

The ATSB is investigating a runway overrun involving GippsAero GA8, VH-BNX, at Fraser Island, Queensland, on 2 January 2020.

During landing, the aircraft overran the runway resulting in the nose landing gear collapsing and the propeller striking the ground. There were no injuries to the pilot or seven passengers.


Ixixly 6th Jan 2020 12:59

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....1b8b4c00ec.jpg

wheels_down 25th Jan 2020 02:42

Seven News seems to have got hands of the landing video.

Trying to find it, appeared on my Facebook feed.

Certainly floated for a bit.

Car RAMROD 25th Jan 2020 04:11

https://7news.com.au/news/qld/pilot-...d-c-634847.amp

video there.

nice of the owner to publicly throw the pilot under the bus like that too. Sounds like a great place to work.

gchriste 25th Jan 2020 05:13

Wow. If ever a case of throwing your employee under the bus to save business, this is it. We are awesome, just a pesky bad pilot of ours.

who would want to work for that mob Urgh.

wheels_down 25th Jan 2020 05:25

Well that’s disturbing...

spektrum 25th Jan 2020 06:52

Sounds fair enough really.

Stickshift3000 25th Jan 2020 07:03

This operator really doesn't do its pilots or GA in general any favours. What a top notch tool.

Pilotette 25th Jan 2020 10:37

Looks like a strange bit of flap movement there. Not quite pulled into the notch? Or some kind of random "procedure"?

longrass 26th Jan 2020 00:48

What on earth are those flaps up to? I had a girlfriend once that couldn’t control hers either...

Squawk7700 26th Jan 2020 01:27

The operator doesn’t need to throw the pilot under the bus when the video does it on it’s own.

Car RAMROD 26th Jan 2020 01:56


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 10671672)
The operator doesn’t need to throw the pilot under the bus when the video does it on it’s own.

so why does the owner make such comments then?

I would be pretty confident in saying that the pilot did not intend that as the outcome for their days flying. So why did that happen?

poor training? Poor oversight of standards? Boss man said standards weren’t adhered to by the pilot; but whose job is it to oversee that those standards are maintained hmm?
was the area that was picked for landing really suitable or could it have been better?
I don’t know the Airvan so I don’t know what was happening with the flaps. A guess (yes speculation) is that the pilot MAY have been trying to lose some lift during a float to help get the plane on the ground. If so, why do that? Who taught them that? Why not go around instead? Is there a culture issue at play?

Theres probably more to it than just “100% pilot error” and that they will be “disciplined”.
How about a different statement along the lines of “the investigation is ongoing and if required the pilot will undergo some additional training” rather than the publicised vindictive blame.

p.s where is the rest of the registration under the wing? Isn’t that a CASR requirement?

longrass 26th Jan 2020 02:38


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 10671672)
The operator doesn’t need to throw the pilot under the bus when the video does it on it’s own.

He does in his mind when every man and his dog is trying to ban beach landings...

no_one 29th Jan 2020 04:29


Originally Posted by Car RAMROD (Post 10671680)
p.s where is the rest of the registration under the wing? Isn’t that a CASR requirement?

There is an exemption for that:
https://www.legislation.gov.au/Details/F2015L02066

yet again the CASA rule writers couldn't get it right and rather than fixing the rule publish an exemption...

Nipper 29th Jan 2020 06:10

no one, that piece of legislation self cancelled on 03 July 2016. :ugh:

flying-spike 29th Jan 2020 07:08

And they just ditched another one with “rudder failure?”. Fortunately no serious injuries.

wheels_down 29th Jan 2020 07:52

So is that the whole fleet now out of action or they have some more?

lucille 29th Jan 2020 07:57

I just saw this on the news. Rudder failure? Unusual reason to ditch one would have thought - especially as the beach looked like being about 100 metres away.

Im guessing stall/spin with recovery too low and not enough energy to do anything but plonk it in the surf. Pure speculation of course.

tio540 29th Jan 2020 08:23


Originally Posted by lucille (Post 10674339)
I just saw this on the news. Rudder failure? Unusual reason to ditch one would have thought - especially as the beach looked like being about 100 metres away.

Im guessing stall/spin with recovery too low and not enough energy to do anything but plonk it in the surf. Pure speculation of course.

investigation complete!

spinex 29th Jan 2020 08:26

Old Mate Karma seems to have been having a little fun with this one, pilot identified as the same fella quoted in news reports above.

737pnf 29th Jan 2020 08:48

https://media2.giphy.com/media/qefhh...f0&rid=200.gif

Stickshift3000 29th Jan 2020 10:35


Originally Posted by spinex (Post 10674372)
Old Mate Karma seems to have been having a little fun with this one, pilot identified as the same fella quoted in news reports above.

100% pilot error Gerry?!

lucille 29th Jan 2020 11:42


Originally Posted by tio540 (Post 10674367)
investigation complete!

Which part of “I’m guessing” and “pure speculation” did you fail to comprehend?

Pappa Smurf 30th Jan 2020 00:31

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....754e6ba923.jpg
https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....eef16df9b3.jpg

Squawk7700 30th Jan 2020 01:23

There’s your problem right there folks. The engine is missing. That is surely an offence of strict liability.

tootle pip.

Duck Pilot 30th Jan 2020 07:23

Haven’t read the stuff for a while, however there are probably a few hooks in the Act that the ATSB operate under as well.

Also throw any insurance claim out the window if the engine was removed without their approval.

runway16 30th Jan 2020 10:38

Cessna Ditching
 
Could there be another reason?

Like nose wheel issue/failure/falling off = rudder jaming issue = fuel supply interference = engine failure = ditching off shore.

One pilot noted to be wearing a life jacket as he emerged from the water.

Car RAMROD 30th Jan 2020 11:06

News article here:

https://amp.9news.com.au/article/88e...6-d971490cf4fd


rudder failure and an engine failure, and a ditching. Sheesh what a day of bad luck!

Kulwin Park 30th Jan 2020 11:06

Before some idiot says it .......... Sorry folks, THIS WILL NOT BUFF OUT !!! :8

j3pipercub 30th Jan 2020 11:22

Not with that attitude


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:11.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.