PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   No Drone Zones (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/616582-no-drone-zones.html)

nomorecatering 22nd Dec 2018 22:26

No Drone Zones
 
I've been fielding questions from family over the last 2 days after the news of the events at Gatwick regarding no fly zones for drones.

Considering that 50% of houses in Sydney are located in a no drone zone, either near the harbour or Sydney airport. Is a kid flying his drone in the front yard at below treetop height an offense?

My take of the regulations is flying a drone even 1cm above the ground if you are in a no fly zone could get you into hot water.

I called CASA, they said they don't know, and someone will call me back. No one ever called.

The local cops believe no fly means, no fly at any altitude, even 1m above the ground, but are not 100% sure. One said he would confiscate any drone until the law is clarified.

Bend alot 22nd Dec 2018 23:37

If your drone weighs more than 100g, you must keep at least 5.5km away from controlled aerodromes. Flying within 5.5km of a non-controlled aerodrome or helicopter landing site (HLS) is possible,but only if no manned aircraft are operating to or from the aerodrome. If you become aware of manned aircraft operating to or from the aerodrome/HLS, you must manoeuvre away from the aircraft and land as soon as safely possible.

You must not fly your drone higher than 120 metres (400ft) above the ground.

You must keep your drone at least 30 metres away from other people.

Link from CAsA website to this.
https://droneflyer.gov.au/

What is the dimensions of the front yard?

nomorecatering 23rd Dec 2018 00:05

The size of the front yard is irrelevant to the question. But to appease the pedantic, lets take my cousins front yard at San Siouci, on the foreshore of Botany Bay and right next to Sydney airport. The front yard measures 17m wide by 9 m deep. There are two 15m tall oak tress in the front yard. On Christmas morning when the kids get their 1kg drones and fly them in the front yard at a hight of 2-3m, if a council ranger, police car or CASA vehicle drive past, will they be charged with an offense.

If you live within 5.5 km of an airport, can you fly a drone "not above 120m".........or not at all.

Bend alot 23rd Dec 2018 01:39

If your drone is under 100 grams you can fly it up to 120 meters high with or without oak trees (trees are not part of the law) within 5.5km of the controlled airport.

But yours is 1,000 grams - so in your location you will be breaking the law should you fly it. Council Ranger or CAsA on a Christmas morning would be like winning lotto.

So to answer your question it totally depends on the weight.

You can and I know was recently done - fly a sub 100 gram drone, inside an open hanger at a busy International Airport.

Icarus2001 23rd Dec 2018 03:13


On Christmas morning when the kids get their 1kg drones and fly them in the front yard at a hight of 2-3m, if a council ranger, police car or CASA vehicle drive past, will they be charged with an offense.
CASA vehicle on Christmas day? hahahaha It's a miracle.

Probably technically illegal. Like drinking wine on the beach. Would you be at any risk of prosecution? Probably not.

Squawk7700 23rd Dec 2018 03:49

My uncle in law lives in suburban Melbourne and he has resorted to a fishing sinker setup with fishing line to throw at one that hovers over his yard occasionally. It’s not uncommon for them to be flying over your head on the beach. Not really what you want as they definitely go pear shaped occasionally.


CaptainMidnight 23rd Dec 2018 04:29


if a council ranger, police car or CASA vehicle drive past,
Council or CASA - unlikely.

Police, possibly, the location being so close to the airport and particularly if a near neighbour is annoyed/busybody enough and/or aware of the Gatwick business decides to dob you in.

As the link provided above says, quoted again:


If your drone weighs more than 100g, you must keep at least 5.5km away from controlled aerodromes.

WingNut60 23rd Dec 2018 06:11

And to be pedantic, 5.5 km from WHERE in the controlled aerodrome?
Is that 5.5.km from any point on the perimeter fence? From the control tower? End of the runway(s)?

There is nothing like a poorly defined (or explained) rule to attract those who like to test the definition.

CaptainMidnight 23rd Dec 2018 07:12


Originally Posted by WingNut60 (Post 10342638)
And to be pedantic, 5.5 km from WHERE in the controlled aerodrome?
Is that 5.5.km from any point on the perimeter fence? From the control tower? End of the runway(s)?

There is nothing like a poorly defined (or explained) rule to attract those who like to test the definition.

It's defined in CASR and Instruments, 3NM (5.5KM) from the movement area of a controlled aerodrome, but to make it simple for users, the "Can I Fly There" app and CASA maps depict the areas.

http://www.casa.gov.au/aircraft/stan...one-safety-app
http://casa.dronecomplier.com/external#

FWIW some councils/shires prohibit operations at parks and public areas.

https://www.smh.com.au/technology/dr...07-p4yzjz.html

Bend alot 23rd Dec 2018 07:13


Originally Posted by WingNut60 (Post 10342638)
And to be pedantic, 5.5 km from WHERE in the controlled aerodrome?
Is that 5.5.km from any point on the perimeter fence? From the control tower? End of the runway(s)?

There is nothing like a poorly defined (or explained) rule to attract those who like to test the definition.

I expect the perimeter fence - and any area you require to have an ASIC card.

Duck Pilot 23rd Dec 2018 07:36

Answer is no you can't. Get the CASA Can I Fly There App, it's free.

chute packer 23rd Dec 2018 10:58

In NZ they have a shielded operation exemption, you can fly in your front yard ok. Makes sense as any aircraft you might crash into shouldn't really be below the tree or mast near you.

What are the rules for flying shielded?

A shielded operation must meet the below requirements:
  • An operation of an aircraft within 100 metres of, and below the top of, a natural or man-made object; and
  • Outside of the boundary of the aerodrome; and
  • In airspace that is physically separated from the aerodrome by a barrier that is capable of arresting the flight of the aircraft.

Andy_RR 23rd Dec 2018 11:53

I don't get the "only below 400ft" mantra and the 3mn from airports since CASR101 only aeems to be regulating things above 400ft as far as I read them. Can anyone quote me chapter and verse of the regulations or instruments that prohibit unmanned aircraft of any description (and model aircraft in particular) from flight above 400AGL and within 3nm of an airport?

Bend alot 23rd Dec 2018 12:17


Originally Posted by Andy_RR (Post 10342842)
I don't get the "only below 400ft" mantra and the 3mn from airports since CASR101 only aeems to be regulating things above 400ft as far as I read them. Can anyone quote me chapter and verse of the regulations or instruments that prohibit unmanned aircraft of any description (and model aircraft in particular) from flight above 400AGL and within 3nm of an airport?

To get it you MUST understand above and below 100 grams.

If you fail to understand that, then there is no hope.

Vag277 23rd Dec 2018 19:15

101.075 Operation near aerodromes

(1) A person may operate an unmanned aircraft at an altitude above 400 feet AGL within 3 nautical miles of an aerodrome only if:
(a) the operation is permitted by another provision of this Part; or
(b) permission has been given for the operation under regulation 101.080.
Penalty: 25 penalty units.

(2) A person may operate an unmanned aircraft over an area mentioned in paragraph (3)(a) or (b) only if:
(a) the operation is permitted by another provision of this Part; or
(b) permission has been given for the operation under regulation 101.080.
Penalty: 25 penalty units.

(3) The areas for subregulation (2) are:
(a) a movement area or runway of an aerodrome; and
(b) the approach or departure path of a runway of an aerodrome.

(4) A person must not operate an unmanned aircraft in such a manner as to create an obstruction to an aircraft taking off from, or approaching for landing at, a landing area or a runway of an aerodrome.

101.085 Maximum operating height
(1) A person may operate an unmanned aircraft above 400 feet AGL only:
(a) in an area approved under regulation 101.030 as an area for the operation of unmanned aircraft of the same class as the aircraft concerned, and in accordance with any conditions of the approval; or
(b) as otherwise permitted by this Part.

machtuk 23rd Dec 2018 21:09

Its an interesting discussion, if there's debate here among people in the aviation industry imagine what the general public must think?
At the end of the day drones are simply not controllable from the authorities POV. Oh there are regulations in place for sure as they need to be but we also have road rules, who obeys them all? NO ONE on the planet!
As soon as mankind invents something it gets abused, all the rules under the sun mean zip, fact of life!

Sunfish 23rd Dec 2018 21:56

If one starts annoying me at my place, out comes the shotgun. I have a right to privacy and quiet enjoyment of my property.

CaptainMidnight 23rd Dec 2018 22:00


imagine what the general public must think?
That's why the app and brochures have been produced i.e. so they don't have to wade through CASR Part 101 and other regulatory material.


If one starts annoying me at my place, out comes the shotgun.
Given they are legally defined as aircraft, you'd be guilty of interfering with the operation of an aircraft ...

Pera 23rd Dec 2018 22:13

What does a 100g drone look like? Sounds like a good christmas present considering its man christmas shopping day!

Duck Pilot 23rd Dec 2018 22:32

Part of the problem is that the general public can purchase a drone from a retail store and are not made aware (In most cases) that there are rules governing the use of them. If the government advertised the fact that there are rules governing drones, maybe the message would get out a bit better. Commercial television advertises plenty of educational information relating to road safety which appears to have a positive effect particularly for the honest people.

CaptainMidnight 23rd Dec 2018 22:50

Very true.

I just did some quick googling and of the three Australian companies I looked at, only one mentioned the regulatory requirements and even then it was their own text somewhat incomplete and didn't provide links to the app or CASA pages.

I guess putting that sort of thing up might discourage sales.

airspace alpha 23rd Dec 2018 23:44

Last year JB Hifi at Southland had a good but handwritten notice warning about flying drones near airports and some council parks. I might have missed it but its not there this year and I’m not braving christmas eve shopping hell to find out.

Vag277 24th Dec 2018 00:07

This has been provided to retailers in the past: file:///C:/Users/Kim/Downloads/rpa_brochure_recreational_dl_150dpi.pdf

das Uber Soldat 24th Dec 2018 00:08


Originally Posted by Sunfish (Post 10343284)
If one starts annoying me at my place, out comes the shotgun. I have a right to privacy and quiet enjoyment of my property.

Try that course of action and excuse with polair one day and let us all know how it goes.

CaptainMidnight 24th Dec 2018 00:32

The Australian 24 December 2018: New regulations for drone activity
>
https://outline.com/kgqydy

Sunfish 24th Dec 2018 00:53

nobody is talking about shooting at polair. The regs say no drones within 30 metres of people. So anyone doing so is breaking the law and by inference creating a safety hazard. Coincidentally that is about shotgun range. Removing the drone with a shotgun is therefore removing a safety hazard and preventing the commission of any further offence.

A less drastic solution assuming line of sight flying at my place is video of the drone followed by video of the operator and vehicle plus a call to 000.

We live in what is termed a holiday destination and we get a lot of “CUBS” - cashed up bogans with their toys, so a drone incursion is not improbable. We regularly call the police over illegal deer hunting, spotlight shooters, drunken speedsters,unregistered trail bikes etc. as do the neighbors. The police are most attentive at this time of year as we try and prevent them incinerating the neighbourhood, vandalising the infrastructure or killing each other in any number of ways such as throwing butane cartridges into a fire.

Checklist Charlie 24th Dec 2018 02:38

Y shaped thingys with rubber bands and ball shaped mint lollies do a marvelous job as well as tasting nice.

CC

Squawk7700 24th Dec 2018 03:33

You may be somewhat misguided Mr Sunfish, but do tell me please, is flying a drone illegally an indictable offence and does your usage of the shotgun fit with your understanding of section 462A of the Victorian Crimes act 1958?



CRIMES ACT 1958 - SECT 462A

Use of force to prevent the commission of an indictable offence

A person may use such force not disproportionate to the objective as he believes on reasonable grounds to be necessary to prevent the commission, continuance or completion of an indictable offence or to effect or assist in effecting the lawful arrest of a person committing or suspected of committing any offence.

”Reasonable force” in the case of a drone, would be to speak to the operator and advise them to fly elsewhere. Shooting down their $2.5k JB Hifi drone is not “reasonable.”


Sunfish 24th Dec 2018 04:46

I know Sqwawk, but this is Pprune:8

Checklist Charlie 24th Dec 2018 04:55

Often as one takes a lunch break at Southbank one sees a drone tootling around over the Brisbane CBD.

I wonder who and why?

Maybe it's rules for some and open slather for others!

CC

machtuk 24th Dec 2018 06:43


Originally Posted by Sunfish (Post 10343284)
If one starts annoying me at my place, out comes the shotgun. I have a right to privacy and quiet enjoyment of my property.


We'll miss you here Sunny after they lock you up for doing such a foolish thing ! We shall also be following your court case closely, but don't worry we shall drop food parcels off to you over the prison fence, by drone of course:-)

compressor stall 24th Dec 2018 07:23


Originally Posted by Checklist Charlie (Post 10343391)
Y shaped thingys with rubber bands and ball shaped mint lollies do a marvelous job as well as tasting nice.

CC


As an aside, they are illegal too in in many states. Although some states permit home made ones. I bought my kids one each in Bolivia (same ones the herders use to control their flocks on steep ground) as souvenirs. I’m not sure how customs would view it - depending on which state we entered or lived?

Icarus2001 24th Dec 2018 07:29

https://outdoorswarehouse.com.au/wea...d-regulations/

Yet I saw these in a shop the other day, here in Australia.

https://www.globalgear.com.au/armoury/replica-guns.html

http://www.jasperco.com.au/

Pinky the pilot 24th Dec 2018 10:11

I'm with Sunfish here.:ok:

Besides; "Prove it was me what shot it down Officer/Yer Honour/whoever...!":}:E

no_one 24th Dec 2018 20:11


Originally Posted by Pinky the pilot (Post 10343593)
I'm with Sunfish here.:ok:

Besides; "Prove it was me what shot it down Officer/Yer Honour/whoever...!":}:E

​​​​​​
At which point the HDR 4K footage from the drone is played to the court.....

machtuk 24th Dec 2018 21:06


Originally Posted by no_one (Post 10343918)
​​​​​​
At which point the HDR 4K footage from the drone is played to the court.....

Hahaha I wasn't gunna mention that so as not to increase Sunny's chance of a long stay at her Majesties pleasure...lolol

Good time to stay out of the sky today guys, lots of drones no doubt given for Xmas pressies...…...of course all new owners know the laws....cough cough cough

Merry Xmas to all who believe, to those that don't then it's just another day in Prooon world:-)

Pinky the pilot 24th Dec 2018 21:15


At which point the HDR 4K footage from the drone is played to the court.....
Which showed no-one as the person with the shotgun was in a concealed position/out of camera frame/etc.:}

I get your point no-one but there are ways and means....:D

And a Merry Christmas to you and all fellow Ppruners!:ok:

Squawk7700 24th Dec 2018 21:25


Good time to stay out of the sky today guys, lots of drones no doubt given for Xmas pressies...…...of course all new owners know the laws....cough cough cough
The day(s) to keep on the ground were the few days leading up to Christmas, just like when driving on the road. Those once a term fliers out taking family up for their once a year flight and getting their last minute AFR’s done.

LeadSled 25th Dec 2018 00:00

Folks,
An almost insurmountable problem is the very large number of "drones" that arrive mail order from China or elsewhere ---- what percentage of total sales, I do not know, but in numbers it is in the tens, probably hundreds of thousands for quite advanced RPV --- how do I know --- because I was once associated with a company in China, one of who's divisions did huge mail order /E-Bay/Amazon/AliBaba business with Australia, and he was one of many.
Getting the message across about rules and restrictions to most of his customers would be a thankless task.
Tootle pip!!

Sunfish 25th Dec 2018 03:26

Honest yer Honour, I thought it was just another mosquito!


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:38.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.