PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Discussion Closed by Tidbinbilla (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/563770-discussion-closed-tidbinbilla.html)

Dick Smith 30th Jun 2015 00:02

Discussion Closed by Tidbinbilla
 
I recently started a thread in relation to $400,000 in modifications required on a Citation 7 to be imported into Australia. Tidbinbilla closed the thread, saying


This would be more appropriate on an aircraft owners forum. This forum is for professional pilots.
In fact, I don’t know of any Citation 7s that are flown by private pilots. In this particular case it was a commercial company that was planning to import the Citation 7 to Australia and to employ quite a number of professional pilots to fly the aircraft. The aircraft is now not coming so the professional pilots will now not have a job opportunity. What could be more applicable to a professional pilots’ forum?

Plazbot 30th Jun 2015 00:25

If I remember correctly, threads that are started to question why was my/the thread shut down were followed by a banning. Shall we see consistency here?

IFEZ 30th Jun 2015 00:28

Must admit, I was wondering the same thing. Prematurely cut short I thought. And this wasn't the only one. It's their train set I guess, but its not exactly encouraging people to participate wielding the axe so quickly..!

uncleonion 30th Jun 2015 00:52

Maybe it was closed because it's getting really tiresome hearing rich people whinge about their toys

mattyj 30th Jun 2015 00:59

Rich people deserve their say too, plus it might be aeromedical or something..

Dick Smith 30th Jun 2015 01:12

The blokes who own tho company are not rich. That's why they did not bring the aircraft to australia.

Rich people are not effected by the CASA expensive regulations.

Ask Jamie Packer if the unique requirements would stop him from operating an aircraft here.

Probably leave it on the FAA register and use US pilots.

That's why it is important that if we are supporters of Australia that this type of exposure be allowed on prune. Not censored.

OZBUSDRIVER 30th Jun 2015 01:18

Dick, how about a bit of a heads up on the type of modifications you are talking about. A quick google shows a full top down upgrade four screens and boxes for the Honeywell SPZ tops out at $350k stateside....exactly what are you specifying?

Dick Smith 30th Jun 2015 01:33

$350k stateside well over $400 k here

I am not specifying any equipment. Just passing on the statement from an extremely frustrated small business operator who wanted to bring a Citation 7 from Europe to Aus.

Oze. Have you noticed the continued downturn in GA in the last decade or so.?

It should be growing like just about everything else.

Any views on why Bankstown would go from nearly 500 k movements per annum to less than 280k ?

I think it's most likely caused by the one way ratchet in increased CASA imposed costs . Any other views?

The Coalition was elected on a policy of removing uneccessary red tape costs. Has this been complied with by casa ?

And I bet the US quote does not include a FDR. Not required in the US.

Squawk7700 30th Jun 2015 01:33


It's their train set I guess, but its not exactly encouraging people to participate wielding the axe so quickly..!
PPRUNE is owned by a company in the USA called "Internet Brands."

At the back-end it is purely a money making commercial website. The mods are here to wield their stick and keep us in line for their own personal self interest.

Internet Brands, Inc. ? PPRuNe.org

About us admin
OUR HISTORY
Since launching in 1998 as CarsDirect.com, Internet Brands has grown to become a fully integrated online media and client services organization focused on four high-value vertical categories: Automotive, Health, Legal and Home / Travel.

The company’s award-winning consumer websites lead their categories and serve more than 100 million monthly visitors, while a full range of web presence offerings has established deep, long-term relationships with SMB and enterprise clients.

Internet Brands’ powerful, propriety operating platform provides the flexibility and scalability to fuel the company’s continued growth.

RAC/OPS 30th Jun 2015 01:45

Ah Australia, hopelessly pedantic and anal while espousing the loveable larrikin image - you don't see so many threads closed for petty reasons on the other forums. Tid is just the pprune incarnation of a bigger problem.

Global Aviator 30th Jun 2015 01:58

Closed
 
Still can see no reason why thread closed!

Yes it's a professional network/rumor site, and it was a very relevant topic.

CASA will simply force people to bring aircraft in and operate on foreign register if private ops.

I pity the operator that must make it VH and charter ops.

Just as well it's not a small private operator first of type for the PC24!!!

Hey Dick would throwing it on the ZK register and using the pond agreement work like Vuncint did?

Shame one has to float the rules.

Dick Smith 30th Jun 2015 02:23

Pretty clear it was closed because Tidbinbilla did not want this issue openly canvassed.

Possibly he should explain the reason on this thread.

No wonder visits to this site are reducing. That won't impress the owners who make their money from the number if hits.

Username here 30th Jun 2015 02:49

Still amazes me the difference between what gets locked here and the stuff that runs it's full course in the fragrant harbour.

At least the Australian forums are consistant with reality! Regulated to death!

Dick Smith 30th Jun 2015 02:52

I am told that Tidbinbilla is either a CASA employee or a Virgin pilot.

TBM-Legend 30th Jun 2015 03:01

I'm amazed at the negativity on this site at times. We need to celebrate good jobs and people having a "go"....

Dick was pointing out that the extra costs of operating aircraft in Australia vs. say the USA is not a safety issue but an economic one and more aircraft flying here means more good pilot positions as well as business [read employment] for those that maintain and service them.

Why do we require different standards????

PPRuNeUser0182 30th Jun 2015 03:26

Yes, let's hear it Tid!

We can discuss jabiru engines, Hoxton Park and v-tails for ever and ever, but a very relevant question on a very real issue concerning a high performance, multi-crew jet above 5700kg is ruled out of order as this forum is only for 'professional pilots'? Really? :ugh:

Squawk7700 30th Jun 2015 04:13

I keep feeling the urge to Look Left over my shoulder, but alas I don't see any moderators nearby ;)


We can discuss jabiru engines, Hoxton Park and v-tails for ever and ever, but a very relevant question on a very real issue concerning a high performance, multi-crew jet above 5700kg is ruled out of order as this forum is only for 'professional pilots'? Really?
Don't forget LOP operations.

swh 30th Jun 2015 04:47

Dick,

The advice your friend has been given is wrong, the Cessna 650 was issued with an Australian type acceptance data sheet in 1999.

http://www.casa.gov.au/wcmswr/_asset...nload/a160.pdf

It will not be the first of type, there is also no requirement to get an aircraft prepared for an Australian CofA in Australia, it is a commercial decision where they choose to do the work.

A decent prepurchase inspection would identify the work required to meet the Australian requirements, and that would be factored into the purchase price.

Sounds like there is avionics work to be done, which maybe a lot cheaper if the aircraft flew via the US enroute to Australia.

porch monkey 30th Jun 2015 05:16

Dick, you almost had my sympathy, right up until your unsubstantiated post referring to the possible employment of the moderator. He/she could also be QF/Jetstar/RAAF or completely unrelated to the industry. That is completely irrelevant, and simply encourages the divide that is fatally affecting the industry as a whole. You're the first to piss and moan about people playing the man not the ball. You can do good for the industry, but that ain't it.

Dick Smith 30th Jun 2015 05:29

Come on. It's a rumour network. Don't take me so seriously!


All times are GMT. The time now is 05:18.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.