PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   47-year old C150 damaged in Moorabbin accident (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/534300-47-year-old-c150-damaged-moorabbin-accident.html)

VH-Cheer Up 18th Feb 2014 02:15

47-year old C150 damaged in Moorabbin accident
 
VH-RXM - doen't look likely to make it's 50th birthday after this prang: Pair escape injury after single-engine plane crashes at Moorabbin Airport - ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)The occupants were more fortunate and walked away. Should be an interesting accident report.

gfunc 18th Feb 2014 02:29

"Flights have resumed but planes are not using the centre runway where the crash happened. "

Maybe I've been doing it wrong, but I'm pretty sure there isn't a centre runway at MB nowadays! Good to hear those on board walked away.

VH-XXX 18th Feb 2014 03:07

There have been a few pilots over the years that have converted the taxiway into a 3rd (centre) runway.

Bevan666 18th Feb 2014 03:25

Once apon a time, it wasn't a taxiway!

flywatcher 18th Feb 2014 03:27

I was a lovely aircraft, yellow, known as Romeo Christmas Mike when I flew it in 1971.

27/09 18th Feb 2014 03:34

Don't those wooden heads love using foam.

chimbu warrior 18th Feb 2014 06:28


47-year old C150
A shame it was one of the newer ones. ;)

SenZubEanS 18th Feb 2014 08:02

AFAIK was a TIF being undertaken, yanked too hard, stalled, not enough elevation to recover before ground came rushing at them

BlatantLiar 18th Feb 2014 08:31


AFAIK was a TIF being undertaken, yanked too hard, stalled, not enough elevation to recover before ground came rushing at them
L'out, the speculator bashers are going to come out. But, yes, thats whats making the rounds.

>>>Photo Here<<<

Avgas172 18th Feb 2014 09:38

Good to see after 47 years it didn't just fall to bits as the ageing aircraft scene promulgates .... :ugh:

sarge75 18th Feb 2014 10:38

Heard the story from a witness who saw the "take off":ugh::ugh:

Sunfish 18th Feb 2014 18:11

Might it have been the old "Cessna Seat Pin" story, although I thought that was a purely a C172 issue?

Armchairflyer 18th Feb 2014 18:46

Not sure; at least the need to check that the seat is indeed locked in place by rocking back and forth before starting the engine was strenuously communicated to all student pilots in the 152s of our club, too.

Stikman 18th Feb 2014 21:03

Saw the impact yesterday. Wasn't a nice thing to watch. I was very relieved to see them both exit the aircraft unassisted.

Tee Emm 19th Feb 2014 01:17

"AFAIK was a TIF being undertaken, yanked too hard, stalled,"


Giving a TIF person a take off or landing?? "A courageous decision, Prime Minister" More like stupidity on the part of the instructor

VH-XXX 19th Feb 2014 02:06

Looking back on it I swear I nearly crashed a 152 on landing during my TIF at Moorabbin which was my first time in a small aircraft. Shortly after I wondered why on earth the instructor let it go so pear shaped.

That's the problem with a TIF, you want the potential student to get a good experience the first time to entice them to sign up with you, but on the other hand you need to be safe.

NutLoose 19th Feb 2014 02:14


Sunfish

Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 5,212
Might it have been the old "Cessna Seat Pin" story, although I thought that was a purely a C172 issue?

Shouldn't happen on a 172 now, there is a free ( last time I looked) kit from Cessna that adds an inertia seatbelt to the base of the seat that bolts to the floor, stopping the P1 seat shooting back. Just look up the current revision as they keep extending the deadline.

See

http://www.pprune.org/private-flying...seb07-5r1.html

mickjoebill 19th Feb 2014 03:11


Don't those wooden heads love using foam.
Are you suggesting they shouldn't cover leaking fuel with foam?


Saw the impact yesterday.
How long did it take for the fire trucks to arrive at the scene?



Mickjoebill

VH-Cheer Up 19th Feb 2014 03:25

Same thing used to happen on Piper Cherokees, too. And (no connection) the bloody door would come unlatched at 1000'!

Adjusting the seat pitch and rocking back and forth to check positive engagement became part of my pre-start checklist.

Never seen either unwanted event happen on a Bonanza!

MakeItHappenCaptain 19th Feb 2014 04:04


Giving a TIF person a take off or landing?? "A courageous decision, Prime Minister" More like stupidity on the part of the instructor
There's absolutely nothing wrong with letting a TIF student do a take-off or following the instructor on the landing. It is a Trial INSTRUCTIONAL Flight. At what point would you let any other student do a take off? Wait until they get up to circuits?

If the instructor allowed the situation to degrade to the point where the aircraft stalled, (if that even is the actual cause) then there's a bigger issue to be dealt with, but there is nothing illegal or stupid about letting a TIF take off.


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:09.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.