Prop for RV7..Need a new one?
Thread Starter
Prop for RV7..Need a new one?
HI all.
I sent my Hartzell adjustable pitch prop up the prop shop for an inspection. (10yr). They say the blades are out of spec near the tips and i need new blades. $7k plus GST each. The performance has been great, i cant see a safety issue as the RPM is always within limits, so it seems a bit excessive to spend close to $16k on new blades. . It is experimental category but not built by myself. It actually works out more economical to just get a new one ($25k plus GST).
Are there any options here? First i suppose if anyone has a contact for some blades that may be within spec. Secondly, is it actually a requirement? A small margin out of spec is not a safety or performance issue for me, so just wondering if there is any choice in this.
thanks for any suggestions.
I sent my Hartzell adjustable pitch prop up the prop shop for an inspection. (10yr). They say the blades are out of spec near the tips and i need new blades. $7k plus GST each. The performance has been great, i cant see a safety issue as the RPM is always within limits, so it seems a bit excessive to spend close to $16k on new blades. . It is experimental category but not built by myself. It actually works out more economical to just get a new one ($25k plus GST).
Are there any options here? First i suppose if anyone has a contact for some blades that may be within spec. Secondly, is it actually a requirement? A small margin out of spec is not a safety or performance issue for me, so just wondering if there is any choice in this.
thanks for any suggestions.
A short story to explain one reason why the diameter limits exist: Propeller Vibration: Issues, Examples, Consequences, by EPI Inc.
It specifically mentions your situation.
Note it states: "to be sure that a particular prop will survive the fatigue environment produced by a particular engine on a particular airframe". As yours is Experimental the question is what limits the prop shop is using? Did someone make up limits for your manual or are they using TCDS data or just assuming it is like a similar certified airplane?
The Type Certificate Data Sheet for my prop states blade diameters from 68 - 74 inches but the AFM for my airplane has limits of 72 - 74 inches. Performance may be a factor there as it is a certified airplane, I don't know that detail.
It specifically mentions your situation.
Note it states: "to be sure that a particular prop will survive the fatigue environment produced by a particular engine on a particular airframe". As yours is Experimental the question is what limits the prop shop is using? Did someone make up limits for your manual or are they using TCDS data or just assuming it is like a similar certified airplane?
The Type Certificate Data Sheet for my prop states blade diameters from 68 - 74 inches but the AFM for my airplane has limits of 72 - 74 inches. Performance may be a factor there as it is a certified airplane, I don't know that detail.
Join Date: Sep 2018
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
HI all.
I sent my Hartzell adjustable pitch prop up the prop shop for an inspection. (10yr). They say the blades are out of spec near the tips and i need new blades. $7k plus GST each. The performance has been great, i cant see a safety issue as the RPM is always within limits, so it seems a bit excessive to spend close to $16k on new blades. . It is experimental category but not built by myself. It actually works out more economical to just get a new one ($25k plus GST).
Are there any options here? First i suppose if anyone has a contact for some blades that may be within spec. Secondly, is it actually a requirement? A small margin out of spec is not a safety or performance issue for me, so just wondering if there is any choice in this.
thanks for any suggestions.
I sent my Hartzell adjustable pitch prop up the prop shop for an inspection. (10yr). They say the blades are out of spec near the tips and i need new blades. $7k plus GST each. The performance has been great, i cant see a safety issue as the RPM is always within limits, so it seems a bit excessive to spend close to $16k on new blades. . It is experimental category but not built by myself. It actually works out more economical to just get a new one ($25k plus GST).
Are there any options here? First i suppose if anyone has a contact for some blades that may be within spec. Secondly, is it actually a requirement? A small margin out of spec is not a safety or performance issue for me, so just wondering if there is any choice in this.
thanks for any suggestions.
It’s your life (and your passenger) behind the prop!
Have you seen how much a prop bends when in use? Demonstrated by the q-tip effect when you have a prop strike.
Have you seen how much a prop bends when in use? Demonstrated by the q-tip effect when you have a prop strike.
Why do you need a CS prop on an RV7 anyway? A fixed pitch Sensenich, tweaked out to 87 inches will be just as fast, and a heap cheaper and less costly to maintain. You seriously don't need a CS prop on an RV because their takeoff performance is great with FP.
I've flown every make & model of RV except the 12, and just can't see any justification in CS props. Save your money and revamp your avionics instead.
PM me if you like.
happy days,
I've flown every make & model of RV except the 12, and just can't see any justification in CS props. Save your money and revamp your avionics instead.
PM me if you like.
happy days,
Join Date: Sep 2018
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why do you need a CS prop on an RV7 anyway? A fixed pitch Sensenich, tweaked out to 87 inches will be just as fast, and a heap cheaper and less costly to maintain. You seriously don't need a CS prop on an RV because their takeoff performance is great with FP.
I've flown every make & model of RV except the 12, and just can't see any justification in CS props. Save your money and revamp your avionics instead.
PM me if you like.
happy days,
I've flown every make & model of RV except the 12, and just can't see any justification in CS props. Save your money and revamp your avionics instead.
PM me if you like.
happy days,
Two mates of mine did simultaneous RV6 builds. One with CSU and the other fixed pitch timber.
There was barely a knot between them!
The CSU was slightly faster when wound right out.
There was barely a knot between them!
The CSU was slightly faster when wound right out.
Join Date: Sep 2018
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
General Crz speed is not what CS is all about, it's about getting the HP avail from the get go, FP won't achieve rated HP from the start. Also CS better for Aero's. Lots of advantages hence they don't put FP props on a PA31...lol-)
Mind you, a PA31, loaded to the gills needs every bit of HP it can get. Any RV with more than 160HP is massively overpowered. My -9A will get around 1800FPM with a FP prop and makes 145KTAS spinning at 2400RPM at 8500. Unless I was building a -10, I'd never waste the money (or the weight) on a CS prop.
Join Date: Sep 2018
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mind you, a PA31, loaded to the gills needs every bit of HP it can get. Any RV with more than 160HP is massively overpowered. My -9A will get around 1800FPM with a FP prop and makes 145KTAS spinning at 2400RPM at 8500. Unless I was building a -10, I'd never waste the money (or the weight) on a CS prop.
100% agree with Mach, I’ve flown a few Vans and don’t regret my CSU one bit, love being able to takeoff in first.
Why is the prop so dear?
Vans price for my prop is currently 8.5k USD
Why is the prop so dear?
Vans price for my prop is currently 8.5k USD
Thread Starter
Thanks everyone for the tips (get it..tips!) and especially Matchuk and Fred Gassit. I have sent the regulation Matchuk linked to and waiting to hear back on a reply. You may have saved me many 1000's of dollars. I have no idea why the prop is so expensive but i am guessing it has something to do with the prop shops (wont name name's) markup. The RV7's stable mate (Cessna) also needed a new prop apparently when sent off for its inspection as in that case the trailing edge out of limits, but the prop hadnt done much time at all.
As for the constant speed debate. I haven't tried a fixed pitch in anything other than a cessna, but i know my RV is extremely economical going from A to B at 8000-10000ft and I assume among other things that has to do with the prop operating at maximum efficiency. But without trying the same RV side by side who knows for sure and we all have our preferences.
Are there ways to get a new prop directly without the $25k price tag?
As for the constant speed debate. I haven't tried a fixed pitch in anything other than a cessna, but i know my RV is extremely economical going from A to B at 8000-10000ft and I assume among other things that has to do with the prop operating at maximum efficiency. But without trying the same RV side by side who knows for sure and we all have our preferences.
Are there ways to get a new prop directly without the $25k price tag?
Are there ways to get a new prop directly without the $25k price tag?
Prices start at US$8450.00 depending on the model
I think we're all in furious agreement that the RV series are great performers, and do exactly what VANS states they will. If you are prepared to go CS - then there are advantages......but at a price.
For me, what made the greatest difference to my -9A performance in cross country ops was going with fuel injection, plus electronic ignition on the RH 'mag'. Fuel consumption can be stretched far better than the carby versions of the 180HP -360 engine. You soon learn how to hot start them!
happy RV ing,
For me, what made the greatest difference to my -9A performance in cross country ops was going with fuel injection, plus electronic ignition on the RH 'mag'. Fuel consumption can be stretched far better than the carby versions of the 180HP -360 engine. You soon learn how to hot start them!
happy RV ing,
Thread Starter
So upshot is as MAtchuk pointed out, it doesn't need an overhaul. I am getting it disassembled and crack checked. That is still needed and obviously makes sense as well. So this thread has saved me about $20k. Thanks.
Not sure if VANS ships props to Aus as these things are often tied up in distribution agreements which is how local distributers can make such a high margin. But have asked.
Not sure if VANS ships props to Aus as these things are often tied up in distribution agreements which is how local distributers can make such a high margin. But have asked.
I think we're all in furious agreement that the RV series are great performers, and do exactly what VANS states they will. If you are prepared to go CS - then there are advantages......but at a price.
For me, what made the greatest difference to my -9A performance in cross country ops was going with fuel injection, plus electronic ignition on the RH 'mag'. Fuel consumption can be stretched far better than the carby versions of the 180HP -360 engine. You soon learn how to hot start them!
happy RV ing,
For me, what made the greatest difference to my -9A performance in cross country ops was going with fuel injection, plus electronic ignition on the RH 'mag'. Fuel consumption can be stretched far better than the carby versions of the 180HP -360 engine. You soon learn how to hot start them!
happy RV ing,
Same as - 140 kts economy cruise @ 26L/hr.
Join Date: Sep 2018
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Join Date: Sep 2018
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So upshot is as MAtchuk pointed out, it doesn't need an overhaul. I am getting it disassembled and crack checked. That is still needed and obviously makes sense as well. So this thread has saved me about $20k. Thanks.
Not sure if VANS ships props to Aus as these things are often tied up in distribution agreements which is how local distributers can make such a high margin. But have asked.
Not sure if VANS ships props to Aus as these things are often tied up in distribution agreements which is how local distributers can make such a high margin. But have asked.
Remember the whole plane is uncertified. Built by a backyard person, can be fitted with an auto engine or uncert aero engine, Inst/radios cab be bought in KMart, the prop is in the same boat👍 That's the whole idea of LS flying and experimental, to avoid the ludicrous expense involved in rip off Cert flying!
Not sure if VANS ships props to Aus