PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   AUKUS (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/642689-aukus.html)

ORAC 16th March 2023 14:42

Hansard have corrected the transcript of the Defence Minister's AUKUS Parliamentary statement to clear up confusion.
.
The first Australian SSN-AUKUS will be built in South Australia, not in Barrow.

All nuclear reactors will be built / assembled in the UK.

rattman 16th March 2023 19:46


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 11403285)
hell - all they need to do is stop buying Australian - the economy would be on its knees in a few months, Labour would be in and goodbye AUKUS

They did try that, it didn't work. The chinese citizens froze in the dark. They stopped buying coal and guess what the australian coal was sold else where and either china had to buy poor qualitiy other coal or they got australian coal from 3rd party whit approprate markup. Now they willing to buy Australian coal again, theres very little available

tartare 16th March 2023 22:26


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 11403072)
Why would China hit targets in Australia - its further away than Finland. I think Rota in Spain is closer to China than Darwin.

Not sure if you're being ironic but in case not - for those not familiar with the detail, there is every likelihood that in the event of a conflict over Taiwan, the US would seek to disperse to bases in the top end of Australia.
US Air Force assets already rotate through RAAF bases here (B-52s, B-2s, B-1s, F-22s etc have all visited).
There are also 1,000+ US marines in Darwin (correct me if I'm wrong on latest numbers).
I have seen suggestions that Australia could suddenly face a request by the US to host upwards of 250,000 troops.
In addition, Pine Gap near Alice Springs would be critical in monitoring any conflict - it downlinks SIGINT and IMINT from US satellites that watch the region - and sends it back to Fort Meade and Chantilly.
Harold E Holt Naval Communications Station near Exmouth in WA is also crucial in providing very low frequency coms to US and Australian submarines.
And JORN, the Jindalee over the horizon radar network uses large transmitter, receivers at various locations in remote Australia , which can effectively watch air and sea-surface activity reportedly to Indonesia - possibly further.
I'd suggest that if China was really serious about taking Taiwan, it would either target some or all of these facilities pre-emptively with conventional strikes, or it would consider doing so as part of second, or third wave strikes.
I think it's unlikely it'd break the taboo and use nuclear weapons.
All of these mainland Australia locations are easily within range of the DF-4 and DF-31.
There is also ongoing interdiction or partial blockade of our sea lanes (how many days of petrol do we have in reserve?!) and sabotage of undersea cables to consider.
If a war looks likely in the South China sea - then Australia definitely is a potential target for discrete Chinese strikes on some or all of these facilities, not Australian urban centres, or a land invasion by Chinese ground forces as Keating alludes to.
He knows that, and is being disingenuous in implying otherwise.

rattman 17th March 2023 03:35

FMS for 200 tomahawks has been granted. These are specifically VLS versions for the hobart Air Warfare Destroyers

Lookleft 17th March 2023 03:40


hell - all they need to do is stop buying Australian - the economy would be on its knees in a few months, Labour would be in and goodbye AUKUS
You don't seem to know much about Australian politics especially suggesting that the Labor party would get rid of AUKUS.

rattman 17th March 2023 04:36


Originally Posted by Lookleft (Post 11403640)
You don't seem to know much about Australian politics especially suggesting that the Labor party would get rid of AUKUS.

Hes a dumbo theres no "labour" party in australia and as I said they already tried and come back begging

Asturias56 17th March 2023 08:49

Labour or Labor - still the same folks

They'll ditch AUKUS when the bills start rolling in


rattman 17th March 2023 09:26


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 11403733)
Labour or Labor - still the same folks

They'll ditch AUKUS when the bills start rolling in


All I can say is lucky the adults are back in power, LNP worked hard to destroy the country. Hopefully labor is around long enough to fix it

Buster Hyman 17th March 2023 10:22


Originally Posted by rattman (Post 11403761)
All I can say is lucky the adults are back in power, LNP worked hard to destroy the country. Hopefully labor is around long enough to fix it

Wow, just wow! :rolleyes:

Lonewolf_50 17th March 2023 15:56


Originally Posted by rattman (Post 11403637)
FMS for 200 tomahawks has been granted. These are specifically VLS versions for the hobart Air Warfare Destroyers

Sone info on that in this news story.
US agrees to sell 220 Tomahawk missiles to Australia | CNN

The US State Department has approved Australia’s request to buy up to 220 long-range Tomahawk cruise missiles, making it only the second US ally to obtain the US-made weapon after the United Kingdom.
According to a statement from the Defense Security Cooperation Agency, the deal will cost as much as 1.3 billion Australian dollars ($895 million), including maintenance and logistical support.
“The proposed sale will improve Australia’s capability to interoperate with US maritime forces and other allied forces as well as its ability to contribute to missions of mutual interest,” the statement added.
CNN, consider the source.

golder 17th March 2023 16:23

Would it be better from Fox?

But it is accurate.
https://www.dsca.mil/press-media/maj...-weapon-system
PDF Version
Press Release - Australia 23-02 CN.pdf
Media/Public Contact
[email protected]
Transmittal No
23-02WASHINGTON, March 16, 2023 - The State Department has made a determination approving a possible Foreign Military Sale to the Government of Australia of Tomahawk Block V and Block IV All Up Rounds

(AUR) and related equipment for an estimated cost of $895 million. The Defense Security Cooperation Agency delivered the required certification notifying Congress of this possible sale today.


Originally Posted by Buster Hyman (Post 11403788)
Wow, just wow! :rolleyes:

Same circus, just different clowns.

pr00ne 18th March 2023 06:17


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 11403285)
hell - all they need to do is stop buying Australian - the economy would be on its knees in a few months, Labour would be in and goodbye AUKUS

Er, Labour ARE in power in Australia!

And they are firmly behind AUKUS.

golder 18th March 2023 07:31


Originally Posted by pr00ne (Post 11404226)
Er, Labour ARE in power in Australia!

And they are firmly behind AUKUS.

Thanks, I missed correcting that

Asturias56 18th March 2023 08:37

they are today but in the future???

golder 18th March 2023 09:32


Originally Posted by Asturias56 (Post 11404273)
they are today but in the future???

What about when we become a fascist republic? Mate, stop digging your hole...move on.

ORAC 19th March 2023 15:45

Sir Humphrey:

The Pinstripedline analysis of the AUKUS SSN deal, why it provides both long term opportunity for the UK but could also be a 'policy albatross' and why Australia may supplant the UK as the key US ally is now live.

https://tinyurl.com/2b8mmh5f

rattman 20th March 2023 04:40

Missed an interview with Richard Marles, Australian defence minister. He said that the first virginia's would be around 2030 and be 13 years old. That would put it at the Washington SSN 787, Block 3.



That would Washington, Colorado and Indiana to australia with South Dakota and Delaware with the possible 2 additionals. All block 3

Cloudee 20th March 2023 06:12


Originally Posted by golder (Post 11403985)
Same circus, just different clowns.

As a clown, Morrison was in a class of his own!

golder 20th March 2023 07:11


Originally Posted by rattman (Post 11405203)
Missed an interview with Richard Marles, Australian defence minister. He said that the first virginia's would be around 2030 and be 13 years old. That would put it at the Washington SSN 787, Block 3.
That would Washington, Colorado and Indiana to australia with South Dakota and Delaware with the possible 2 additionals. All block 3

From what I saw, the first would be secondhand and block 3 fits, With the remainder new build. though not with vertical launch.


the cartoons are numerous.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....b77de5ff72.png

Going Boeing 21st March 2023 00:29


Originally Posted by rattman (Post 11405203)
Missed an interview with Richard Marles, Australian defence minister. He said that the first virginia's would be around 2030 and be 13 years old. That would put it at the Washington SSN 787, Block 3.

That would Washington, Colorado and Indiana to australia with South Dakota and Delaware with the possible 2 additionals. All block 3

It would be unlikely to be USS South Dakota as that vessel has been fitted with a large number of new technologies that are being developed for future Virginias, Columbias & SSN(X) classes.
https://news.usni.org/2016/03/28/sub...ional-concepts

Posted by golder: “From what I saw, the first would be secondhand and block 3 fits, With the remainder new build. though not with vertical launch.

All Virginias have vertical launch - Blocks 1 & 2 via 12 individual launch tubes, Blocks 3 & on via 2 Virginia Payload Tubes (VPT’s) mounted in the bow section. Obviously, the RAN won’t be getting the Block 5’s Virginia Payload Module which has 4 VPT’s that are additional to the bow mounted ones.


I don’t understand the speculation that the possible two extra Virginias would be new builds as these vessels would just be required to fill in until sufficient AUKUS SSNs have been built. The RAN would only need 2nd hand Virginias with sufficient reactor life to fill in any production gap.

Sky News are saying that the Collins class are getting Tomahawk missiles, it would be interesting to find out if this means that production of the tube launched version has been restarted or whether there’s sufficient parts in the USN inventory available to modify the recently ordered 20 RGM-109E Block 4 missiles to the UGM-109 standard.


https://www.skynews.com.au/australia...3f91b3041dd7ba


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:41.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.