PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   MiG-23 Crash - Michigan - 13 Aug 23 (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/654210-mig-23-crash-michigan-13-aug-23-a.html)

RAFEngO74to09 13th Aug 2023 21:37

MiG-23 Crash - Michigan - 13 Aug 23
 
Thunder Over Michigan Airshow


RAFEngO74to09 13th Aug 2023 21:45

Wreckage narrowly missed a busy multiple lane highway


rattman 13th Aug 2023 21:49

Dodgy maintainence ? Same plane lost its canopy in flight at Oshkosh this year.

MiG-23UB N23UB (8107) #A207EB lost a forward canopy window over EAA Airventure 2023 at Oshkosh.

RAFEngO74to09 13th Aug 2023 21:53

It was the MiG-23UB owned by Dan Filer who has 7 other former Soviet jets in his collection.

He is a former USN A-6 pilot and now an A320 captain



RAFEngO74to09 13th Aug 2023 22:06

Happier day at an earlier show


GeeRam 13th Aug 2023 22:08

Another angle in this Youtube clip.......its almost as if the donk had flamed out, it sounds in this clip if it's no more than idle perhaps?


Crew were lucky to get out looking at the KM-1 seat parameters and method of ejecting.
Could have been a terrible outcome on the ground, but seems luck intervened.

RAFEngO74to09 13th Aug 2023 22:14

Debris narrowly missed the apartment complex in this photo

https://www.detroitnews.com/gcdn/aut...pjpg&auto=webp

RAFEngO74to09 13th Aug 2023 22:15

Another view of the ejections


LowObservable 13th Aug 2023 22:28

This was the airplane that struck fear into the USAF Red Hats at Tonopah. Can't help wondering about the judgement behind making it a civilian air show performer.

itsnotthatbloodyhard 13th Aug 2023 22:35

Interesting that they didn’t roll wings level before ejecting - perhaps they couldn’t, for some reason?

Capt Fathom 13th Aug 2023 22:59


Could have been a terrible outcome on the ground, but seems luck intervened.
I guess it’s natural to want to save yourself, but it’s a big call to abandon your jet in a residential area.

421dog 13th Aug 2023 23:06


Originally Posted by Diff Tail Shim (Post 11484285)
They got out for a reason, quickly and in plenty of time. The yanks really are gash as far in the maintenance requirements of ex military jets. Why so many crash or have incidents.

I fail to understand the “gash” idiom.
Having flown this side of the pond in all kinds of my personal, and other’s expensive multi/warbird hardware, I am impressed at the level of maintenance.

Bring It….

RickNRoll 13th Aug 2023 23:39


Originally Posted by GeeRam (Post 11484260)
Another angle in this Youtube clip.......its almost as if the donk had flamed out, it sounds in this clip if it's no more than idle perhaps?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAEWIxlIOwM

Crew were lucky to get out looking at the KM-1 seat parameters and method of ejecting.
Could have been a terrible outcome on the ground, but seems luck intervened.

I don't think air shows should be relying on luck.

RAFEngO74to09 14th Aug 2023 00:24

https://assets3.cbsnewsstatic.com/hu...282c47f58b17f#

flopzone 14th Aug 2023 01:11

Bird strike, flameout, too low to recover, SOP eject.

Ignition Override 14th Aug 2023 04:47

A Fedex (MD-11 pilot) neighbor knows the owner of the "former" Mig-23.

Glad to see that the Mig was able to avoid a steeper bank before they bailed out. The pilot probably has an attorney keeping the FAA off of his back.

This video is from right next to a Canadian AFB (CFB), about 12 years ago.
----flopzone: this is partly for you, and you might have seen this successful Dual Bailout from CFB Cold Lake Canada ("12 years ago"), from an jet, with a Danish student in the front (red & white shoulder patch):
A different video might depict their slow flight (near Vmc?) and the quick roll into the failed or "stalled" engine.. Iirc, this accident was caused by either birds or an unrelated (not birds) compressor stall due to whatever factors.

Sidenote: please be aware that a pilot had a fatal accident at Cold Lake in an F-18 in 2016 or so-----


PPRuNeUser0211 14th Aug 2023 05:31


Originally Posted by Ignition Override (Post 11484378)
A Fedex (MD-11 pilot) neighbor knows the owner of the "former" Mig-23.

Glad to see that the Mig was able to avoid a steeper bank before they bailed out. The pilot probably has an attorney keeping the FAA off of his back.

flopzone: this is partly for you, and you might have seen this successful Dual Bailout from CFB Cold Lake Canada ("12 years ago"), from an F-18 with a Danish student in the front (red & white shoulder patch):
A different video might depict their slow flight (near Vmc?) and the quick roll into the failed or "stalled" engine.. Iirc, this accident was caused by either birds or an unrelated (not birds) compressor stall due to whatever factors.

Sidenote: please be aware that a pilot had a fatal accident at Cold Lake in an F-18 in 2016 or so-----

Brave Pilots Emerge after ejecting from fighter Jet 2.AVI - YouTube

That video isn't from an F-18. It's a Hawk crew (two QFIs) who jumped out after the engine threw a compressor blade at medium level and they were outside of glide range to a runway.

Aviation safety summary

India Four Two 14th Aug 2023 05:53

What surprises me is that there were two crew in an aircraft performing at an air display.

DogTailRed2 14th Aug 2023 06:59


Originally Posted by itsnotthatbloodyhard (Post 11484278)
Interesting that they didn’t roll wings level before ejecting - perhaps they couldn’t, for some reason?

I was at a talk regarding ejection from the early Starfighter. Procedure for ejecting was to roll inverted as the seat came out downwards. To quote the pilot giving the talk
"If I had enough control to roll inverted I didn't need to eject".

DogTailRed2 14th Aug 2023 07:03

I've seen several ejections from heavy cold war, high energy aircraft like Phantoms. They all seem to have one thing in common in that they appear to have zero control, appear to wallow before ejection.
Is this just the nature of the beast with these aircraft?

itsnotthatbloodyhard 14th Aug 2023 07:07


Originally Posted by munnst (Post 11484424)
I was at a talk regarding ejection from the early Starfighter. Procedure for ejecting was to roll inverted as the seat came out downwards. To quote the pilot giving the talk
"If I had enough control to roll inverted I didn't need to eject".

??? Sort of why I was wondering whether there was a control problem, I guess. Because in all the time I spent spent flying ejection seat aircraft, we’d always want to get the wings level and ideally try to get an upwards vector prior to pulling the handle in a low-level ejection.

(I never flew the 104, but suspect there may have been other potential reasons to eject than a lack of roll control… ;) )

ehwatezedoing 14th Aug 2023 08:11


Originally Posted by Capt Fathom (Post 11484286)
I guess it’s natural to want to save yourself, but it’s a big call to abandon your jet in a residential area.

Not saying that's what happened but if, for example, that was a total loss of hydraulics there is not much else they could have done.

Mig: Manufactured In Garage :p

Rhys S. Negative 14th Aug 2023 08:20

A large crate of expensive drinks to whoever maintained the ejection seats, though.

treadigraph 14th Aug 2023 08:28

Some pics on this site:

https://eu.freep.com/picture-gallery...ti/8349703001/

ORAC 14th Aug 2023 08:32

No need to speculate - both crew ejected so they’ll be able to tell us.

212man 14th Aug 2023 09:41


Originally Posted by pba_target (Post 11484388)
That video isn't from an F-18. It's a Hawk crew (two QFIs) who jumped out after the engine threw a compressor blade at medium level and they were outside of glide range to a runway.

Aviation safety summary

As described extensively in the comments section under the video, but hey, it's the internet and people just love to spout bollocks here!

Dora-9 14th Aug 2023 10:39

An East German saying: "If you want a MiG-23, buy a field near an aerodrome and then wait for one to fall in it".

Skeleton 14th Aug 2023 10:50


Originally Posted by Dora-9 (Post 11484583)
An East German saying: "If you want a MiG-23, buy a field near an aerodrome and then wait for one to fall in it".

Given the number and frequency of German Starfighter losses during it's service, that saying was in use on the other side of the wall as well. Trust me.

DogTailRed2 14th Aug 2023 12:13


Originally Posted by Skeleton (Post 11484590)
Given the number and frequency of German Starfighter losses during it's service, that saying was in use on the other side of the wall as well. Trust me.

Wasn't the Starfighters nickname "The Lawn Dart" ?

WillowRun 6-3 14th Aug 2023 12:52

The air show narrator in fact referred earlier in the day to the F-104 as "Widowmaker".
I can't provide any eye-witness account of the MiG crash.... Thunder Over Michigan is presented twice on two consecutive days, and the morning and afternoon shows are mostly the same. I really enjoyed the morning show . . .

atakacs 14th Aug 2023 13:37

Well very lucky outcome for all involved. I muss say as ejections wold go I'd rather not attempt it out of a 50y soviet jet...

punkalouver 14th Aug 2023 13:53

4:05 of video in post #4. Sorry guys for the digress but he says that the Tomcat had a yaw string? On a Mach 2 aircraft?


Update: Apparently true:
https://www.google.ca/search?q=f14+t...h=961&biw=1865

Toryu 14th Aug 2023 14:28


Originally Posted by punkalouver (Post 11484701)
4:05 of video in post #4. Sorry guys for the digress but he says that the Tomcat had a yaw string? On a Mach 2 aircraft?

Yep.
Spoiler
 


DogTailRed2 14th Aug 2023 14:47


Originally Posted by India Four Two (Post 11484396)
What surprises me is that there were two crew in an aircraft performing at an air display.

I believe the rule for essential crew only doesn't apply to American shows.

GeeRam 14th Aug 2023 15:03

Two crew ended up landing in the lake, from what I've seen, which could have ended up badly for them as well.

DuncanDoenitz 14th Aug 2023 16:41


Originally Posted by atakacs (Post 11484697)
Well very lucky outcome for all involved. I muss say as ejections wold go I'd rather not attempt it out of a 50y soviet jet...

On this occasion at least, seems to be a better option than remaining in the 50-year old soviet jet.

dixi188 14th Aug 2023 18:20

The European F104s had upward ejection seats by Martin Baker.
A guy I flew with ejected on short finals with an engine fire warning, the aircraft landed on its own and was stopped by the barrier. No damage, no fire.

212man 14th Aug 2023 19:48


Originally Posted by GeeRam (Post 11484733)
Two crew ended up landing in the lake, from what I've seen, which could have ended up badly for them as well.

Which lake? Clearly not the water in the foreground. Plus, reports are saying they landed on the ground.

GeeRam 14th Aug 2023 20:03

I presume one of the three interlinked lakes south of the I-94 as the jet hit the ground around the apartment blocks between the water and the I-94, and crew banged out over the lake.....possibly Ford Lake, the western one of the three?

GeeRam 14th Aug 2023 20:23

Just seen this, which confirms crew landed in Belleville Lake and pilot sustained serious, but not life threatening injuries, back seater minor injuries. NTSB investigator already saying crash caused by engine problems (as mentioned in post above cited by witnesses) and crew had declared emergency before banging out.

https://www.clickondetroit.com/news/...t-was-injured/



All times are GMT. The time now is 17:33.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.