PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Lets face it..no one likes marching. These boys and girls are good (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/650194-lets-face-no-one-likes-marching-these-boys-girls-good.html)

Coltishall. loved it 7th Dec 2022 20:03

Lets face it..no one likes marching. These boys and girls are good
 

ExAscoteer2 7th Dec 2022 20:12

An awful lot of 'Cow-Kicking' going on there, so no, they are not as good as you assert.

chevvron 7th Dec 2022 20:21


Originally Posted by Coltishall. loved it (Post 11343994)

No different from any other ATC Sqdn including the one I used to command.(1811 Sqdn).
When I saw a TV programme (Masterchef I think) showing ITS at RAF Halton with regular RAF personnel, I was amazed how badly they were drilling.

Hydromet 7th Dec 2022 22:59

Always good to see good marching & drill.

I'm told that the reason women march better than men is that they are counterbalanced.

meleagertoo 8th Dec 2022 01:25

Two questions.
How can anyone be so ridiculous as to assert "no one likes marching"? I loved it, as did most of my colleagues.
What the heck is 'cow-kicking'? It never featured in any drill I ever did.

stevef 8th Dec 2022 06:23

There's a lot of satisfaction in marching when it all comes together. I'll never forget the hours of being screamed by the drill instructors on bitterly cold winter days and told we were the worst intake they'd ever seen and the gradual melding into a smart and efficient parade. The best bits were the perfect-line abreast march-past formations and the spoke of a wheel thing where the left marker was virtually marking time and the thirty or so airmen to his right marching anti-clockwise in increasingly longer steps to maintain a straight line (what was it called?)
Pretty much everyone agreed that the most-hated sessions eventually became the most enjoyable. I could probably still do it today (50 years later) in a reasonably good fashion as long as it was with SLRs. :}
Check, T,L,V, Away!

chevvron 8th Dec 2022 06:25


Originally Posted by meleagertoo (Post 11344117)
How can anyone be so ridiculous as to assert "no one likes marching"? I loved it, as did most of my colleagues.

Especially when being led by a pipe band.

bobward 8th Dec 2022 07:27

Drill is a completely un-natural way of moving. Thus it makes the squad members think as they act. I did it for over 40 years, first as a cadet then ATC AWO and officer. Once the cadets got used to the idea, it gave a great sense of pride and achievement, which, I'm sure you'll agree, is a great thing. I always felt under pressure not to mess thinks up and let them down. I had a piece of paper in my pocket with the orders written on it. Whilst there was no way I could get it out and read it on parade, it was a kind of 'security blanket' for me.

As others have said, watching good drill is a thing of beauty, even now1 Well done all, keep it up!

AR1 8th Dec 2022 07:27

I had a sense of impending doom each time they marched toward a dead end.
I must show this to " our lot" The Sqn was depleted during covid so a good two thirds are the two intakes this year, around half being September. We have some way to go to reach this standard in two parades a week.

huge72 8th Dec 2022 07:55

I have always had the aircrew disdain of Drill, why march when you can fly! QR's used to state that to be on official parades you have to be above 5ft 6inches and below 6ft 10 inches and those who know me know that I definitely fall BELOW that bracket. This was all I needed to avoid it for almost all of my career. However since I joined the ATC on retirement I have been on more parades than I ever did in regular service. The cadets in the main really enjoy it and have immense pride in themselves when they get it right. In October, Bristol & Gloucester Wing attended camp at Halton. The Drill competition was judged by the Recruit Training School Warrant Officer, who stated publicly that he wish half of todays recruits would perform as well as our cadets. And this is after 2 years of COVID with Squadrons unable to parade and a whole raft of new recruits who were new to the corps.

Herod 8th Dec 2022 08:01


I could probably still do it today (50 years later) in a reasonably good fashion as long as it was with SLRs
You newbies!! The last time I did drill with a rifle, it was a .303. Mind you, it's over 57 years

Krystal n chips 8th Dec 2022 08:02


Originally Posted by meleagertoo (Post 11344117)
Two questions.
How can anyone be so ridiculous as to assert "no one likes marching"? I loved it, as did most of my colleagues.
What the heck is 'cow-kicking'? It never featured in any drill I ever did.

Well, it's like this.....ok, drill is part of being in the military...no escaping that but, after a (very!) short while, the novelty wears off...rapidly !....the synchronised walking bit is all very well for those who enjoy pointless wasting of time.....tended to interfere with more valid usage of time, such as a social life, or, work...if you've joined the Army and one of the Regiments for whom drill is part of their work, fine...if you've joined the RAF to maintain / fly or any RAF role for that matter, then it can be dispensed with.

Not forgetting the associated BS of cleaning / kit preparation ....more time needlessly wasted.

There was also the fact, that, those who seemed to take a lot of interest in any of the above, did so as a cover for their inabilities elsewhere.

And besides which, I have a very sensitive nature....and was called some very rude words

DaveReidUK 8th Dec 2022 08:44


Originally Posted by Krystal n chips (Post 11344232)
Well, it's like this.....ok, drill is part of being in the military...no escaping that but, after a (very!) short while, the novelty wears off...rapidly !....the synchronised walking bit is all very well for those who enjoy pointless wasting of time.....tended to interfere with more valid usage of time, such as a social life, or, work...if you've joined the Army and one of the Regiments for whom drill is part of their work, fine...if you've joined the RAF to maintain / fly or any RAF role for that matter, then it can be dispensed with.

Not forgetting the associated BS of cleaning / kit preparation ....more time needlessly wasted.

There was also the fact, that, those who seemed to take a lot of interest in any of the above, did so as a cover for their inabilities elsewhere.

And besides which, I have a very sensitive nature....and was called some very rude words

I fear you're out of step with the other posters.

stevef 8th Dec 2022 09:10


Originally Posted by Herod (Post 11344231)
You newbies!! The last time I did drill with a rifle, it was a .303. Mind you, it's over 57 years

I did that with the Army Cadet Force in the late sixties, we always got the regular army's hand-me-downs. :) I can't remember how to port arms but might still be able to strip down a Bren gun.
I got my indoor marksman's badge with a .22 but when I came to fire the .303 on the range, the kick was too much for this skinny little 14-year-old, I lost confidence and failed to qualify. :{ RAF next stop,
The Queen's (King's) Colour Squadron has got to be one of - if not the - best precision drill units in the world.

LateArmLive 8th Dec 2022 09:14


Originally Posted by DaveReidUK (Post 11344248)
I fear you're out of step with the other posters.

But not out of step with actual Military Aircrew...

MPN11 8th Dec 2022 09:15

Ah, you can't beat a good Drill session for generating a bit of personal pride in getting things right as part of a team.

In my CCF Cadet days, I went on a Drill Course with the Irish Guards at Caterham Barracks. Quite stimulating! Four squads of Cadets drilling at the same time, with 'your' squad on the opposite side of the Square hopefully receiving your commands. Some years later, at OCTU, this all helped when doing and ordering drill. Although our Sqn WO (Mr Matthews) observed "You don't need to shout quite as loudly, Mr. MPN11."


Cornish Jack 8th Dec 2022 09:29


Originally Posted by Herod (Post 11344231)
You newbies!! The last time I did drill with a rifle, it was a .303. Mind you, it's over 57 years

Me too, initially... with (not to be indelicate !), the butt cheeks loosened to make the necessary noises - oh, and don't forget the hob-nailed boots !
My last such occasions were differently attired, with a sword and 'protecting' the CFS colours - indoctrinated into 'twiddly shuffling' turns on the spot by the 'Rocks' at Uxbridge ! Best bit ... last on, first off ! :ok:

DuncanDoenitz 8th Dec 2022 09:41


Originally Posted by meleagertoo (Post 11344117)
Two questions.
How can anyone be so ridiculous as to assert "no one likes marching"? I loved it, as did most of my colleagues.

Certainly saved us from having to walk anywhere.

WB627 8th Dec 2022 09:47


Originally Posted by MPN11 (Post 11344266)
Ah, you can't beat a good Drill session for generating a bit of personal pride in getting things right as part of a team.

In my CCF Cadet days, I went on a Drill Course with the Irish Guards at Caterham Barracks. Quite stimulating! Four squads of Cadets drilling at the same time, with 'your' squad on the opposite side of the Square hopefully receiving your commands. Some years later, at OCTU, this all helped when doing and ordering drill. Although our Sqn WO (Mr Matthews) observed "You don't need to shout quite as loudly, Mr. MPN11."

In my CCF Cadet days I also did a Drill Course with the Irish Guards at Caterham, much to the annoyance of my CO, who was most unhappy that one of his RAF Cadets wanted to do this. It was an absolutely brilliant weekend. He subsequently made me responsible for teaching the RAF section drill, something believe it or not I also enjoyed. I got a lot of satisfaction from turning the new recruits with two left feet, into a coherent and accomplished squad, who were always better than the Army section could manage.

One Easter camp at Brize Norton, we won the drill competition, which put a smile on our CO's face, but I still dont think he ever forgave me for attending that drill course at Caterham in the first place.

I returned to Caterham Barracks when I was billeted there for my gliding course at Kenly.

Happy days!





[email protected] 8th Dec 2022 09:59

And we still don't know what 'cow-kicking' is.

Personally I thought those boys and girls were bloody good and if that was part of a competition, I hope they won it.

charliegolf 8th Dec 2022 10:28


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11344290)
And we still don't know what 'cow-kicking' is.

Personally I thought those boys and girls were bloody good and if that was part of a competition, I hope they won it.

Agreed. Seen way worse Cranwell/Swinditz marching.

CG

chevvron 8th Dec 2022 10:48


Originally Posted by charliegolf (Post 11344312)
Agreed. Seen way worse Cranwell/Swinditz marching.

CG

And as I said at Halton but I should add this was after the brats departed to Cosford; worse still this edition of Masterchef was shown on TV a couple of years ago.

ExAscoteer2 8th Dec 2022 10:52

'Cow Kicking' is when the thigh is brought to the horzontal but the lower limb does not hang vertically but slants backwards.

AR1 8th Dec 2022 11:08

I can understand the Aircrew not getting the marching thing - Standing up for a long period when you're used to being sat down, i appreciate must be quite difficult, but as much as i hated getting pulled in to prepare for parades a stand out moment for me involved exactly that. Following the (shambolic) USAF out onto the front at Weymouth for the 40th DDay parade, in front of all those veterans and halting as one to an outbreak of applause. All that effort paid off. Brought a tear to my eye.
Only the once though.

chevvron 8th Dec 2022 11:53


Originally Posted by ExAscoteer2 (Post 11344328)
'Cow Kicking' is when the thigh is brought to the horzontal but the lower limb does not hang vertically but slants backwards.

That looks to be the way we were taught it, often by very experienced DIs especially the one at Cosford when I was still a cadet.
So what's wrong with that? The 2 squadrons I was involved with (2204 as Adj followed by 1811 as OC) were easily equal to the one shown on the tape.

Sloppy Link 8th Dec 2022 12:10


Originally Posted by stevef (Post 11344260)
I did that with the Army Cadet Force in the late sixties, we always got the regular army's hand-me-downs. :) I can't remember how to port arms but might still be able to strip down a Bren gun.
I got my indoor marksman's badge with a .22 but when I came to fire the .303 on the range, the kick was too much for this skinny little 14-year-old, I lost confidence and failed to qualify. :{ RAF next stop,
The Queen's (King's) Colour Squadron has got to be one of - if not the - best precision drill units in the world.

Brigade of Guards. I shall comment no further!

ExAscoteer2 8th Dec 2022 12:38


Originally Posted by chevvron (Post 11344358)
So what's wrong with that?

Because it's wrong. The lower limb should hang vertically iaw AP818.

Fonsini 8th Dec 2022 12:51

How dare you suggest that someone is better than the Belgian military…..



stevef 8th Dec 2022 15:06


Originally Posted by Fonsini (Post 11344389)
How dare you suggest that someone is better than the Belgian military…..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yzybSQkJNoY

Blimey! That lot would give RasPutin's mobiks a run for their ruble (assuming they ever got paid). :eek:

Arthur Bellcrank 8th Dec 2022 15:44

K&C, funnily enough I recently stumbled on this blurry video of our pass out parade, we all seemed to be in step.


Ninthace 8th Dec 2022 15:53


Originally Posted by Fonsini (Post 11344389)
How dare you suggest that someone is better than the Belgian military…..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yzybSQkJNoY

They must be aircrew, Each part of the brain multitasking independently while controlling a different part of the body. :ok:

Ninthace 8th Dec 2022 15:57


Originally Posted by Arthur Bellcrank (Post 11344466)
K&C, funnily enough I recently stumbled on this blurry video of our pass out parade, we all seemed to be in step.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PviU...annel=MrWhelts

In my first tour, I was a flight commander for one of those blocks in the background, OC Block was a full time job for Apprentice Training Squadron but only a squadron secondary duty for those of us in ETS.

BEagle 8th Dec 2022 16:05

Precison drilling from a certain Flying Circus....


Historical hysterical, definitely non-PC and not for today's snowflakes!!

Union Jack 8th Dec 2022 16:23


Originally Posted by DaveReidUK (Post 11344248)
I fear you're out of step with the other posters.

In the words of the song, "There's a first time for everything!":rolleyes:

Jack

West Coast 8th Dec 2022 16:46

A variation of just straight marching.


Hughes500 8th Dec 2022 16:47

Having been a platoon commander at a training depot I used to have running battles with my platoon sergent over drill. I would always elect to do section attack and platoon attack drills or a good bit of tabbing with an 80lb began , after all in the early 1980's impressing Ivan on the Inner German Border with your marching ability wouldnt cut the mustard.

Krystal n chips 8th Dec 2022 16:55


Originally Posted by Arthur Bellcrank (Post 11344466)
K&C, funnily enough I recently stumbled on this blurry video of our pass out parade, we all seemed to be in step.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PviU...annel=MrWhelts

So we were....probably because it was the last time ..just think, if we hadn't spent all those wasted hours, we could have finished the course and started engineering for a living in about half the time !....nice shot of my former open plan, with panoramic views, top floor luxury spa accom though.

Arthur Bellcrank 8th Dec 2022 17:03


Originally Posted by Krystal n chips (Post 11344524)
So we were....probably because it was the last time ..just think, if we hadn't spent all those wasted hours, we could have finished the course and started engineering for a living in about half the time !....nice shot of my former open plan, with panoramic views, top floor luxury spa accom though.

Yes, the centre block, F Flight if I remember. Funnily enough my son was in the same block a couple of decades later.

Saintsman 8th Dec 2022 17:55

I was once attached to a RN Squadron. On their big annual parade (I think it was called Divisions or something), we RAF types were hid somewhere at the back, because we marched faster and the drill commands were all different. It caused chaos during the rehearsals.

Big Pistons Forever 8th Dec 2022 18:03

Marching is for the professional pedestrians (AKA Infantry). Personally as a proud member of Canada's Navy, I considered marching the Navy's test of my ability to find ways to avoid it in favor of more rewarding pursuits.


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:34.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.