PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Red arrows confusing display team make up (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/647134-red-arrows-confusing-display-team-make-up.html)

peterperfect 16th Aug 2022 06:26


Originally Posted by langleybaston (Post 11279033)
Teresa?

Camberwick ?

exMudmover 16th Aug 2022 08:00

Finningley Boy

“I’ve never come across anything like this before”

Er – it’s been a lot worse in the distant past.

In the late 60s a new leader was parachuted into the team without having flown with them before ‘down the back’, so to speak. During the season work-up he was so bad at leading that the rest of the formation broke away during a display practice and landed independently.

The team refused to fly with him again; a previous leader was brought in on the spot and led a successful season.

It happened again in the mid 70s, although it wasn’t quite so dramatic.

Unofficially, the Arrows (that’s what we used to call them - not the Reds), are the only RAF unit which can sack its own boss.
ExMM

Hueymeister 16th Aug 2022 08:09

So, will the Senior Leadership Team replace Red 1 or the team Boss?

Lotoftime 16th Aug 2022 08:47

ExMM that is most definitely not worse than what has been going on lately, and what the investigation is uncovering.

Diff Tail Shim 16th Aug 2022 10:51


Originally Posted by campbeex (Post 11279030)
Apart from the obvious, one of the disappointing aspects of this story is the lack of imagination put into nicknames in today's Royal Air Force (e.g. Damon "Damo" Green).

One of the newbies has a nickname that is not that politically correct. I doubt he will use it and I certainly will not be offering to disclose it here.

alfred_the_great 16th Aug 2022 12:53


Originally Posted by Diff Tail Shim (Post 11279330)
One of the newbies has a nickname that is not that politically correct. I doubt he will use it and I certainly will not be offering to disclose it here.

and this you’ve posted because?

Diff Tail Shim 16th Aug 2022 13:30


Originally Posted by alfred_the_great (Post 11279415)
and this you’ve posted because?

Because non political nicknames still exist?

oldmansquipper 16th Aug 2022 13:46

One of the best nicknames (call signs?) I seen recently was the one used by F35 test pilot Steve Long …..





Stitchbitch 16th Aug 2022 13:52

OMS, we had quite a few on Harrier including LOG (Schlong) and SAK. A good chuckle could be had when BAD, BAK, DIC, & HED were programmed on the same 4 ship...

oldmansquipper 16th Aug 2022 14:15


Originally Posted by Stitchbitch (Post 11279456)
OMS, we had quite a few on Harrier including LOG (Schlong) and SAK. A good chuckle could be had when BAD, BAK, DIC, & HED were programmed on the same 4 ship...

SB

DiC and HeD seem very appropriate for Harrier mates. (IMHO of course)

😉

dervish 16th Aug 2022 15:02


Originally Posted by Finningley Boy (Post 11278933)

I think the RAF hierarchy would have been better to be honest and get this one out of the way, rather than allowing it to drag on. It's a repeat of what was happening about 10 years ago isn't it?

cynicalint 16th Aug 2022 15:13

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....add236e015.jpg
Daily Telegraph this afternoon predicts the future of the Arrows. A phot taken at Balckpool pleasure beach recently

Herod 16th Aug 2022 16:48

Bring back the Yellowjacks; or even the Black Arrows.

57mm 16th Aug 2022 16:55

Firebirds for me!

exMudmover 16th Aug 2022 17:21

LotofTime

Reference historical Red Arrows problems:

‘ExMM that is most definitely not worse than what has been going on lately, and what the investigation is uncovering.’ My italics

I have no idea of the full ins and outs of what has just happened to the team. as I take all media reports about aviation with a large pinch of salt.

However, If you had some experience of formation display aerobatics I’m sure you would agree that the prospect of the entire team being flown into the ground by an incompetent leader would certainly grab your attention.
ExMM

brianj 16th Aug 2022 19:37

Always admired the Arrows over many years. Unfortunately after reading press accounts of this apparent debacle I sadly have to say that should the Government decide we can no longer afford them then I would be saddened but not devastated. To not be able to perform a 9 ship team is totally disappointing and an embarrassment for both the RAF &UK. The resources required have, in recent years, been repaid in global pride and esteem whilst inspiring potential recruits (albeit not it seems of the required ethnic quota). In the current economic crisis there are probably many who feel the money could be spent in more needy areas. Can anyone put forward the argument they deserve to continue to exist or could we have 2 more Wedgetails instead? Personally would like both!!


Melchett01 16th Aug 2022 19:44


Originally Posted by Finningley Boy (Post 11278955)
Not meaning to be nosey but I wonder what the Toxic culture is that's referred to? Just can't imagine this in the days of the Great Red Arrows leaders of the past, Lee Jones, Ray Hannah AFC*, Ian Dick, Brian Hoskins etc.

FB

This one is a stinker. I was told about it a few months ago by a former colleague with links back to the Hawk. Thought it was all gossip or rumour and likely overblown. However, the press reports, as they are, are accurate. But they are a fraction of what’s been going on. If it comes out in full it will be a massive problem given Wigston’s report.

Melchett01 16th Aug 2022 19:58


Originally Posted by brianj (Post 11279650)
Always admired the Arrows over many years. Unfortunately after reading press accounts of this apparent debacle I sadly have to say that should the Government decide we can no longer afford them then I would be saddened but not devastated. To not be able to perform a 9 ship team is totally disappointing and an embarrassment for both the RAF &UK. The resources required have, in recent years, been repaid in global pride and esteem whilst inspiring potential recruits (albeit not it seems of the required ethnic quota). In the current economic crisis there are probably many who feel the money could be spent in more needy areas. Can anyone put forward the argument they deserve to continue to exist or could we have 2 more Wedgetails instead? Personally would like both!!

Yes - the FCDO, DIT and Treasury would be rather upset at the massively reduced trade, goodwill and diplomatic leverage UK plc would lose out on if we got rid of them. Doesn’t mean there aren’t issues to be resolved though.

Finningley Boy 16th Aug 2022 20:09


Originally Posted by exMudmover (Post 11279243)
Finningley Boy

“I’ve never come across anything like this before”

Er – it’s been a lot worse in the distant past.

In the late 60s a new leader was parachuted into the team without having flown with them before ‘down the back’, so to speak. During the season work-up he was so bad at leading that the rest of the formation broke away during a display practice and landed independently.

The team refused to fly with him again; a previous leader was brought in on the spot and led a successful season.

It happened again in the mid 70s, although it wasn’t quite so dramatic.

Unofficially, the Arrows (that’s what we used to call them - not the Reds), are the only RAF unit which can sack its own boss.
ExMM

If my memory serves me correctly, Ray Hannah led the team from '66 to '69 then Den Hazell took over for 1970. Former team member, Bill Loverseed took over following the loss of more than one pilot during a serious incident during a training flight in 1971. I imagine the individual you refer to here remains unnamed.

FB

Diff Tail Shim 16th Aug 2022 21:46


Originally Posted by brianj (Post 11279650)
Always admired the Arrows over many years. Unfortunately after reading press accounts of this apparent debacle I sadly have to say that should the Government decide we can no longer afford them then I would be saddened but not devastated. To not be able to perform a 9 ship team is totally disappointing and an embarrassment for both the RAF &UK. The resources required have, in recent years, been repaid in global pride and esteem whilst inspiring potential recruits (albeit not it seems of the required ethnic quota). In the current economic crisis there are probably many who feel the money could be spent in more needy areas. Can anyone put forward the argument they deserve to continue to exist or could we have 2 more Wedgetails instead? Personally would like both!!

Get pilots to that are there for the achievement, not the ego. They are the best ambassadors for the UK. Crossed paths with the good, the bad and ugly that flew a tour with RAFAT.

cynicalint 16th Aug 2022 21:49

Daddy, Daddy, When I grow up I want to be a Red Arrows pilot! Sorry son, you can't do both!

Diff Tail Shim 16th Aug 2022 22:12


Originally Posted by cynicalint (Post 11279716)
Daddy, Daddy, When I grow up I want to be a Red Arrows pilot! Sorry son, you can't do both!

Above average pilots do have an ego. They must have that to do what they do. But they can have an ego and not be a Richard Cranium. The Daily Mail love one Red for reasons we all know. I met him in a mess one day and he was in bully mode. Why was I there? Invited guest (and I was civilian in rank was my answer). Mentioned the incident to another officer whom was there at the time a few years later and his reply was "He could be like that! Countdown.

Low average 17th Aug 2022 02:46

I think many of the RAF's best fast jet pilots avoid the Reds.

The role requires parading in the public eye, which doesn't sit well with many warfighters and can, in extreme cases, attract the wrong type of individual.

I do hope the RAF get this sorted. It could be seen as a good thing that the dirty laundry is being aired in public and I hope that the problem is dealt with head on, with no half-measures. Whether it's an individual, or a recruitment process - things clearly need to change, for the long-term success of the team, and before the accidents start to happen again.


STIG781 17th Aug 2022 20:22


Originally Posted by Diff Tail Shim (Post 11279446)
Because non political nicknames still exist?

They mean why mention it yet not state the nickname?

Also "political and non-political" pilot nicknames don't exist outside the minds of teenage and twenty-something Twitter users.

Wet blanket.

langleybaston 17th Aug 2022 21:10

"The accidents". one way or another, have not stopped, unless one has short memory.

The very existence of the Reds depends on an unquantifiable belief that they are good for recruiting, image, trade, prestige, ceremonial and the like.

On the cost side they gobble up funds, maintain obsolete aircraft, keep about a dozen trained fast-jet pilots from useful roles, and consume vast amounts of red paint, dye, fuel and vino.

Time was, but this is 2022. Perhaps we should try to do without, as we are practising with fewer and fewer.

Diff Tail Shim 17th Aug 2022 23:40


Originally Posted by STIG781 (Post 11280319)
They mean why mention it yet not state the nickname?

Also "political and non-political" pilot nicknames don't exist outside the minds of teenage and twenty-something Twitter users.

Wet blanket.

They do like they still do in any military organisation. I don't mention it as the guy has not been officially announced as selected yet, even though others screwed up big time on keeping a secret. I was talking to him on Saturday and congratulating him on his selection. Lots of people know the bloke due to his wide range of aeronautical hobbies outside of the RAF sphere and he is respected in the RAF as being a bloody good egg.

dervish 18th Aug 2022 06:15


Originally Posted by Low average (Post 11279805)
I do hope the RAF get this sorted. It could be seen as a good thing that the dirty laundry is being aired in public and I hope that the problem is dealt with head on, with no half-measures. Whether it's an individual, or a recruitment process - things clearly need to change, for the long-term success of the team, and before the accidents start to happen again.

Agreed. But worth saying that the RAF tried to keep this covered up. It isn't they who are airing it. Wash, rinse, repeat.



ancientaviator62 18th Aug 2022 07:13

I agree with LB, I served as groundcrew on 92 (Biue Diamonds) and we still had an AD role in Fighter Command. In these difficult times , good as they are they are a luxury we can ill afford.

Underfoot 18th Aug 2022 07:39

I struggle to see how, if pilots leave as planned at the end of the year, RAFAT will rebuild as a nine ship and bring the rear section back to the show. Reds 4 and 6 have done 5 and 4 years respectively, with Red 5 also coming towards the end of his expected time on the team. That leaves Red 7 to move up to synchro lead with 3 pilots required to move to the back of the team and somehow recreated the Gypo break etc. Public maths, if people leave as planned, there would only be 2 pilots available to move back to the roles of Red 7,8 and 9. It is not a safe course of action unless people stay on for another year and help rebuild the team.

Assuming that things are as bad as they seem at Scampton, why would anybody wish to remain beyond their expected tour? This might be a natural time for the RAF to consign RAFAT to the history books. Their display this year is, at best, lame and I fear that too much damage has been done.

teeteringhead 18th Aug 2022 10:33


Gypo break etc.
Slightly surprised they are still allowed to call it that!

NutLoose 18th Aug 2022 12:01

Well, this will be interesting...


The RAF Red Arrows will return to the Middle East this year as part of a five week tour, making their debut at the Bahrain International Airshow and visiting the nations of Egypt, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates.
The Royal Air Force announced on Monday that the team will be participating at the Bahrain International Airshow on the 9th-11th November 2022 – one of the region’s most important aviation trade shows, held biannually since 2010. While in the region, the team will tour several other nations, including Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, supporting the UK’s business and defence initiatives. The RAF said they also hoped the tour would include the team’s first visit to Egypt in almost 20 years.

Totalling five weeks, the tour will begin after their European display season ends, likely commencing in early October and finishing in mid-November. Their European season began in France on the 28th May, with their final appearance currently scheduled for the Great North Run on Saturday 11th September.

The Middle East is the Red Arrows’ most recent destination outside Europe, with the team having visited in 2014, 2016 and 2017. In 2019, they instead toured North America, but returned to the Middle East for a short mini-tour in 2021 in support of the UK’s participation in the delayed Expo 2020 event in Dubai.

This will be the Red Arrows’ first visit to the region as a seven-ship team; the squadron is performing with just seven jets this year, rather than the usual nine, after the unexpected departure of two pilots during pre-season training.
Red Arrows to undertake five-week Middle East tour in late 2022 - This is Flight


Null Orifice 18th Aug 2022 15:05

Eight performing at Benson today. Pic courtesy of a family member.
https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....d5c7de093.jpeg
Nice cars too!

NutLoose 18th Aug 2022 15:25

I see MT has improved, or is it cutbacks and they haven't been able to replace them yet?

langleybaston 18th Aug 2022 19:13


Originally Posted by NutLoose (Post 11280799)
I see MT has improved, or is it cutbacks and they haven't been able to replace them yet?

They will belong to the SWO and the MT WO [if such posts still exist]

oldgrubber 19th Aug 2022 05:46

I'm afraid the Reds are ready to be consigned to history just like the field gun and mast manning. Nice while it lasted but definitely not the best anymore and hardly relevant as a showcase of British industry. Years ago people on here were claiming that "It only cost 10 million a year" (yeh right) and was "value for money". When a twin rotor Wokka can wow the crowds without all the drama about who's made who cry behind the scenes, that's value for money; especially when the aircraft actually has a day job! Cheers now

The Oberon 19th Aug 2022 06:02


Originally Posted by oldgrubber (Post 11281112)
I'm afraid the Reds are ready to be consigned to history just like the field gun and mast manning. Nice while it lasted but definitely not the best anymore and hardly relevant as a showcase of British industry. Years ago people on here were claiming that "It only cost 10 million a year" (yeh right) and was "value for money". When a twin rotor Wokka can wow the crowds without all the drama about who's made who cry behind the scenes, that's value for money; especially when the aircraft actually has a day job! Cheers now

What he said. I have always been an air show fan but I usually left before the Red Arrows "topped the bill". I have always preferred to watch a solo Lightening, Phantom, Harrier, Tornado or Typhoon solo display and judging from crowd reactions, I wasn't the only one

KrisKringle 19th Aug 2022 06:29


Originally Posted by The Oberon (Post 11281122)
What he said. I have always been an air show fan but I usually left before the Red Arrows "topped the bill". I have always preferred to watch a solo Lightening, Phantom, Harrier, Tornado or Typhoon solo display and judging from crowd reactions, I wasn't the only one

Ha! That's so funny: a wokka having the same wow factor as the Reds.

Watching the Reds at big seaside shows - with the real British public - the massive applause, oohs and ahhs makes me proud to have once served and the crowd's reaction sends a tingle down the spine. But I appreciate for some - a chip on the shoulder or jealously - may not appreciate the excellence on display.

hunterboy 19th Aug 2022 06:34

Does the excellence on display add value to the RAF or U.K. plc ? If so, keep them. If not, well……

DaveReidUK 19th Aug 2022 06:44


Originally Posted by hunterboy (Post 11281133)
Does the excellence on display add value to the RAF or U.K. plc ? If so, keep them. If not, well……

Yes, that would be a good criterion. If only we knew how to measure it ...

ancientaviator62 19th Aug 2022 07:19

KK,
I have neither a chip on my shoulder nor jealousy towards the 'Arrows' I have been there as I stated (as an Air Radar fitter I was on the 'Derv' team !) BUT we also ,as I said we played our part in AD exercises and the like. As we appear to be lacking in FJ pilots and groundcrew my take is that these members of the 'Arrows' could be more usefully employed elsewhere in the RAF.
Given the 'diversity' pause in RAF recruiting I do wonder who would attempt join the RAF just because of one of their displays .


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:54.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.