PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   "Creeping Jesus" Approach (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/642919-creeping-jesus-approach.html)

Ascend Charlie 28th Sep 2021 07:12

"Creeping Jesus" Approach
 
I am wondering how this term arose, describing an approach where the aircraft doesn't intercept a point on final to fly a straight line to the threshold, but rather follows a tractrix to make an asymptotic path to the threshold.

Apparently I flew some of these when doing flapless approaches from the back seat of a Macchi. Mainly because the visibility was so poor, it was the only way to see where we were going.

Fareastdriver 28th Sep 2021 08:25

In the old days where there was a big piston in front of the pilot a curved approach was quite common. Old films about the Pacific War show that carrier borne aircraft did it as well.

switch_on_lofty 28th Sep 2021 08:49

Not exactly answering the question but the F-4U Corsair was prone to fatal stalling/spinning on final due to the asymmetric effect of the huge prop. I read somewhere that the RN alleviated this problem by conducting a curved approach to the carriers. Guessing this improved visibility as well as improving the airflow over the wind prone to drop.

57mm 28th Sep 2021 08:53

Or as my QFI used to say to me "stalking the runway using all available cover".

oxenos 28th Sep 2021 09:49


"stalking the runway using all available cover".
and from an unexpected direction

Ninthace 28th Sep 2021 09:52

I remember a 230 Sqn pilot getting told off for not making sufficient use of cover then approaching a deployed site.

SpazSinbad 28th Sep 2021 10:11

MACCHI MB326H Flapless Approach Circuit Diagram from the RAAF Flight Manual Jun 1973.
https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....c52816a76b.gif

212man 28th Sep 2021 10:55

I think we all understand the various rationales for the technique - AC is asking where the term "creeping Jesus" arose from?

Herod 28th Sep 2021 11:04


I remember a 230 Sqn pilot getting told off for not making sufficient use of cover then approaching a deployed site.
If we are talking rotary, as I suspect. "If you don't hit your wheels on the ground every hundred yards, you are not low-flying". Pre-Puma days, of course.

Ascend Charlie 28th Sep 2021 11:07

Sinbad, do you recall when the "corporal stripes" on the runway were done away with?

SpazSinbad 28th Sep 2021 11:32

I don't recall seeing 'corporal stripes on the runway during my RAAF training days' (some 50+ years ago now). They were not used at NAS Nowra from 1969 until at least mid 1974. Perhaps some old runway photos may show them in the RAAF bygone era? By GOSH by GOLLEE a Wal Nelowkin photo of Point Cook in 1972. LAVERTON just north of Point Cook had the stripes in 1965, also a WALLY photo. What a nice chap indeed.

Photo later shows the stripes still there in the 1990s.... FROM: http://www.radschool.org.au/Books/An...ng%20Point.pdf

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....aabdab5a1a.jpg
https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....e789c4ebbf.jpg
https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....2025413ec5.jpg

MPN11 28th Sep 2021 11:50

Sorry, staying OT …. As an RAF ATCO, those chevrons are new to me. Please elaborate on their purpose!

Video Mixdown 28th Sep 2021 11:54


Originally Posted by 212man (Post 11118077)
I think we all understand the various rationales for the technique - AC is asking where the term "creeping Jesus" arose from?

It appears that Creeping Jesus refers to a Roman Catholic ‘seeking to make a public display of religiosity in a manner which seems hypocritical and simply for show’. Perhaps someone - maybe an instructor with a religious bent - deemed this type of approach unnecessarily showy.

Ninthace 28th Sep 2021 12:07


Originally Posted by Herod (Post 11118084)
If we are talking rotary, as I suspect. "If you don't hit your wheels on the ground every hundred yards, you are not low-flying". Pre-Puma days, of course.

Indeed. It was in the Puma days at Gütersloh. I was filming the helicopter's approach to the site and I think boss was disappointed that I kept the aircraft in frame throughout. Something about not enough use of hedges and trees.

212man 28th Sep 2021 13:05


Originally Posted by Video Mixdown (Post 11118121)
It appears that Creeping Jesus refers to a Roman Catholic ‘seeking to make a public display of religiosity in a manner which seems hypocritical and simply for show’. Perhaps someone - maybe an instructor with a religious bent - deemed this type of approach unnecessarily showy.

I see that now, and "By the end of the 20th century, the term had evolved somewhat away from a purely religion-focused term to one levelled at any public display presumed to be totally hypocritical."

Asturias56 28th Sep 2021 13:38

I thought it came from the practise of new RC priests prostrating themselves fully before the alter on ordination. As low as you can go....

Amazing anyone would use such language even in the lat 20th Century..


ORAC 28th Sep 2021 14:40

The origins are from sanctimonious worshippers slowly going around the inside wall of the church doing their novenas at each station of the cross, praying iously, whilst looking over their shoulder at the altar and those seated in the pews.

Compare it to flying the various stages of a circuit whilst not looking ahead, but over your shoulder at the runway instead…

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creepi...rigins_of_term

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stations_of_the_Cross

old,not bold 28th Sep 2021 15:29

My basic PPL instructor at Sleap, the late, great Adam Wojda, ex-Polish and Royal Air Forces, taught me what he called fishtailing on final approach, used, he said, by piston-engine fighter pilots to keep the runway in sight.

It was an exhilarating and fun manoeuvre even in an Auster, side-slipping from 500 ft towards the threshold with full flap and a trickle of power for 10-20 seconds to one side, then changing rapidly to the other side, 20 seconds, change again and so on until straightening out at 30 ft to land. The difficult part was staying on the centre-line all the way down. I don't think it was called "Creeping Jesus", though.

He also taught me curved approaches that involved side-slipping all the way round the 180 degree turn from 800 ft downwind to the threshold at 30 ft, as a good way to get down quickly. That was fun, too, but you needed to know there wasn't anyone getting too close on final.

FullWings 28th Sep 2021 16:55

It’s interesting that this kind of approach often leads to a landing half way down the runway (or several landings...)

First use of “tractrix” that I’ve seen on PPRuNe. Congratulations!

sycamore 28th Sep 2021 19:06

MPN11,think the chevrons maybe " if you ain`t on the ground by here,it`s time to go-around".....


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:34.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.