PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Swiss Air Force Team Apologizes for Fly-By in Wrong Place (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/623341-swiss-air-force-team-apologizes-fly-wrong-place.html)

havoc 8th Jul 2019 21:46

Swiss Air Force Team Apologizes for Fly-By in Wrong Place
 
https://www.usnews.com/news/world/ar...in-wrong-place

BERLIN (AP) — The commander of the Swiss air force's aerial display team has apologized after his unit performed a low-altitude pass over the wrong municipality.

Residents of Langenbruck looked up in vain Saturday while expecting to see Switzerland's Patrouille Suisse squadron swoop by to mark the centenary of the death of local aviation pioneer Oskar Bider.

The team flew over nearby Muemliswil instead.

Switzerland's Defense Ministry said Monday that the formation hadn't practiced the maneuver and got distracted by an unauthorized helicopter in the area. The ministry says the team leader spotted what he thought was a tent for the Langenbruck celebration that turned out to be for a yodeling festival in Muemliswil.

The ministry said the Patrouille Suisse team's red and white F-5E Tiger II jets aren't equipped with GPS devices.

NutLoose 8th Jul 2019 22:07

Would that be an unauthorised helicopter because they were in the wrong place and it was where it was meant to be.

ex82watcher 8th Jul 2019 22:23

Didn't a B1 or B52 make an approach and fly-past at Blackbushe a few years ago,rather than Farnborough as intended,before going back to the USA,from where it had departed ?

Warmtoast 8th Jul 2019 22:50

ex82watcher

Didn't a B1 or B52 make an approach and fly-past at Blackbushe a few years ago,rather than Farnborough as intended,before going back to the USA,from where it had departed ?
Mentioned here on PPRuNe way back in 2004: https://www.pprune.org/military-avia...lackbushe.html

...and in Flight Global here: https://www.flightglobal.com/news/ar...-lucky-186086/

SASless 8th Jul 2019 23:00


The ministry said the Patrouille Suisse team's red and white F-5E Tiger II jets aren't equipped with GPS devices.
I bet they are now!

ex82watcher 8th Jul 2019 23:02

Thanks Warmtoast - many years before I found this site.

ve3id 8th Jul 2019 23:13


Originally Posted by SASless (Post 10513332)
I bet they are now!

So much for dead reckoning. I say they made a big mistake when they took away the Swiss Armed Forces' bicycles. Well, at least they were not bombers.

Bladdered 9th Jul 2019 07:10

Swiss Air display over wrong town
 
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-48916084

Asturias56 9th Jul 2019 07:15

Could happen to anyone............. didn't the USAF put on a B-52 display at Blackbushe instead of Farnborough one year?

Pittsextra 9th Jul 2019 07:39

Surely that couldn't happen to the RAF??!

treadigraph 9th Jul 2019 08:45

I recall a Dutch F-16 starting its Biggin display overhead Kenley - I think an absence of audience save a few startled Air Cadets plus some spluttering over the r/t drew him the few miles to Biggin after the first loop...

NutLoose 9th Jul 2019 09:37

Or the F111 that did a high speed pass down the wrong runway scaring the poo out of all the gliding activities going on

bill fly 9th Jul 2019 09:50

Cheese navigation
 
According CNN the Patrouille de Suisse just beat up a yodeling festival this weekend - should have been at an aviation function.
Holes in the cheese etc...

Bonkey 9th Jul 2019 09:52

The company I did my apprenticeship at, Flight Refuelling (now Cobham) had a similar incident in the 60s apparently. To celebrate some event (probably to do with an exploit of the founder, Sir Alan Cobham) the RAF were to carry out a flypast / small display over the Wimborne factory and all the employees came out onto the riverbank to watch at the arranged time. Some rumblings were heard in the distance and it appears the RAF had incorrectly turned up overhead the similar sized Hamworthy Engineering factory in Poole, some 6-7 miles to the south.

Word got round quickly of the RAF's "mishap" and the story has it Sir Alan phoned up a good friend of his at the Fleet Air Arm in Yeovilton and with the Senior Service keen to get one over the RAF, a pair of Sea Vixen's airborne in Lyme Bay quickly obliged and carried out the flypast and display. The event is mentioned in the book "In Cobham's Company" by Colin Cruddas with the note that one of the Vixen's flashed past so low there were visible strong ripples on the surface of the River Stour in front of the factory.

Maninthebar 9th Jul 2019 10:04

Bet they had a debrief with no fondue, no spoons

bill fly 9th Jul 2019 10:14

Yep - tea and biscuits and no wine...

ATC Watcher 9th Jul 2019 10:16

That can happen when you have to fly visually and spot a large marquee with lots of people and car parked around. Not the first time this occur , albeit probably not for them before . Surprisingly they say they did not have someone on the ground to coordinate the slot and make sure no other aircraft is in the display box. We normally all do this . But according the Swiss press it was only a fly-over, not a full show.

BDAttitude 9th Jul 2019 10:29

Who could blame them joinging a yodeling festival instead of a commemoration ceremony - I can't ;-)
Time for the squadron leader to get a privatly funded Garmin handheld or maybe wait until 2035 for a government sponsored onboard one :p

edit:

Originally Posted by BBC
The yodel festival patrons are reported to have enjoyed the unexpected show.

Maybe no tea and biscuits but sounds like there would have been some free beer available.

teeteringhead 9th Jul 2019 10:57

One remembers in the early 70s at the Secret Hampshire Helicopter Base, we were expecting 845 NAS to arrive for some p*ssup or other (sorry - mutual exchange of views and tactics). Airfield waa clear for their arrival, as our RN exchange guys had promised "the Mother of all Beat Ups".

Shame we couldn't see it, but Lasham were very impressed apparently ...........

bill fly 9th Jul 2019 11:12

Red Faces
 

Originally Posted by ATC Watcher (Post 10513680)
That can happen when you have to fly visually and spot a large marquee with lots of people and car parked around. Not the first time this occur , albeit probably not for them before . Surprisingly they say they did not have someone on the ground to coordinate the slot and make sure no other aircraft is in the display box. We normally all do this . But according the Swiss press it was only a fly-over, not a full show.

Too right Watcher -

It happened to a formation consisting of a Victor K1A tanker, Sea Vixen and Buccaneer flying past at Bournemouth Airport to support Sir Alan Cobham's Flight Refuelling celebration. Great excitement as Tankers didn't do low level usually.
There had been a practice run the week before with another crew - mainly to practise the low level RV with the Navy jets. I was Copilot on this one too. We did it at over 500 ft but there were big nav problems on the run in to BOH as the H2S was pretty useless down there and the Plotter, facing rearwards with no window, had to rely on his NBS nav computer. My suggestion to use the backbeam from the ILS would have meant installing a non standard X-tal and was not taken up.... Fortunately we were high enough to see the RW and line up visually.

On the big day we had the following crew:
Captain, Copilot (me) Nav plotter, Nav radar, AEO and a further Nav plotter in the bomb-aimer's window Canberra trained, with a map. I also had a 1/4" map on the knee. What could possible go wrong? After the RV the boss decided we should get a bit lower to do the job, at which point the nose Nav could see below but not ahead, once again the H2S was vague and showed off to the Right and the NBS to the Left. From what I could see of ground clues we were a bit right of track. Plotter has to coordinate and decide. By this time the receivers are plugged in and no large heading changes can be made. Nose Nav suddenly identifies a roundabout (the wrong roundabout according my map) which confirms the Plotter in his belief that we are left and he gives a slight Hdg change right. We are too low to see the RW and go blasting over Bournemouth town a couple of miles or so south of the field.
At the subsequent Tea and Biccies the Captain was told that the crowd just saw the top of the fin and were not too impressed.

Just for fun here is a pic of the gaggle on the practice over the Dorset countriside just after the RV but before the run:

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....0041b6e6f2.jpg

Wensleydale 9th Jul 2019 12:27

Yodelling? Why am I reminded of "The Lonely Goat-herd"?


https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....0172c7d763.png

dead_pan 9th Jul 2019 12:51

I mean, how hard would it be to mark the display site with smoke? Just deploy a spotter aircraft ahead of the main package - job done.

OvertHawk 9th Jul 2019 21:15


Originally Posted by ve3id (Post 10513345)
So much for dead reckoning. I say they made a big mistake when they took away the Swiss Armed Forces' bicycles. Well, at least they were not bombers.

When it comes to bombers being in the wrong place, the last people you should point the finger at is the Swiss.

They spent years being accidentally bombed by the allies during World War Two and suffered significant causalities.

There is a reason that the Swiss used to paint their flags on the roofs of their houses!

OH

astir 8 9th Jul 2019 21:24

But they did interrupt a yodelling competition. Every cloud has a silver lining!

TBM-Legend 9th Jul 2019 23:12

Yodelling up the valley! Those were the days!!!!

AN2 Driver 10th Jul 2019 09:07

What I hear is that the guys at the yodeling festival liked the performance just fine and the only question around was "who the heck organized that superb surprise?"

The village the festival was is a very short distance from Langenbruck and the people there waiting for the pass actually saw them form up and expected them to come back. It was a festivity to honour a famous Swiss army pilot by the name of Oskar Bider who is from and buried in Langenbruck.

The F5's don't have GPS but they do have IRS.

As this was not a full performance but just a fly by, there was considerably less preparation than in a normal display.

NutLoose 10th Jul 2019 10:14

Many moons ago i read about the U2 or blackbird sortie over some bad guys country, they had pushed for a GPS system for years and it and been refused, so the crews chipped in bought a handheld, on one long sortie the nav system failed over bad guys country and the crew managed to complete the mission using their cheap handheld, after that they got them fitted.

NutLoose 10th Jul 2019 10:16


The village the festival was is a very short distance from Langenbruck and the people there waiting for the pass actually saw them form up and expected them to come back.
Rather like the thousands upon thousands that turned up to see the Vulcan do its farewell pass at EGNX to watch it in the far distance turn and disappear to save time by "cutting the corner".

NutLoose 10th Jul 2019 10:25

U2 crews get issued a GPS watch

https://www.garmin.com/en-US/blog/av...aviator-watch/

Fg Off Bloggs 10th Jul 2019 10:34

Reminds me of the time that Upper Heyford F-111s were tasked with an airfield attack at Honington for a station exercise. Such was their navigation skill that the base Hunters tasked with airfield defence were diverted to the Aardvarks to point them in the right direction - which of course resulted in 2 hours in gas masks for us poor unfortunates stuck on the ground, which could have been avoided if the powers that be had left the USAF to find its own way to the target!

I wonder if they ever got home safely!?

Wander00 10th Jul 2019 10:39

85 ish, retirement of wg cdr branch officer FC, John ????? Lightning due to do flypast. Aunty Joan talking to Lightning pilot.
"Where are you?"
"Just pulling up between the two towers"
"We don't have towers",, but there were at Bacton gas terminal.......

Arfur Dent 10th Jul 2019 10:43

Stories like this emphasise just what a brilliant team the Red Arrows are. Never heard of them displaying in the wrong place or confusing timings/run-ins or whatever. Well done chaps - I bet someone will have witnessed something but I never did.

melmothtw 10th Jul 2019 12:32


When it comes to bombers being in the wrong place, the last people you should point the finger at is the Swiss.

They spent years being accidentally bombed by the allies during World War Two and suffered significant causalities.

There is a reason that the Swiss used to paint their flags on the roofs of their houses!
Indeed, The Day We Bombed Switzerland is a great read if you haven't already found it...

melmothtw 10th Jul 2019 12:34


Originally Posted by Arfur Dent (Post 10514831)
Stories like this emphasise just what a brilliant team the Red Arrows are. Never heard of them displaying in the wrong place or confusing timings/run-ins or whatever. Well done chaps - I bet someone will have witnessed something but I never did.

The Reds themselves seem a little more circumspect on the subject than that...


skua 10th Jul 2019 13:05

The Reds do of course have retrofitted GPS to hinder this sort of cock-up.....

walbut 10th Jul 2019 16:46

I worked at Pilatus Aircraft in the late 1980's, on loan from British Aerospace, to help sort out some PC 9 engine issues that were particularly problematic in high temperature operations. The relationship between Pilatus Aircraft and Pratt and Whitney Canada was pretty fractious and both companies were blaming each other for the main problem. The local P and WC rep had served as aircrew in the USAF during the second world war, if I remember rightly he had been a B17 pilot. When relations between the companies were particularly strained, he used to take great delight in telling us that he had bombed Switzerland during the war. I don't think it had been entirely accidental as there was some suggestion that the Swiss had been supplying the Germans with engineering components, possibly bearings.

Walbut

ShyTorque 10th Jul 2019 16:48


Originally Posted by Arfur Dent (Post 10514831)
Stories like this emphasise just what a brilliant team the Red Arrows are. Never heard of them displaying in the wrong place or confusing timings/run-ins or whatever. Well done chaps - I bet someone will have witnessed something but I never did.

But it only takes one mistake.....

There's a joke about Welsh professionals taking years to earn their reputation but Dai only had to $ha& one sheep for him to get his nickname.

fallmonk 10th Jul 2019 17:47

Wasnt there a SR71 crew did something similar in England many moons back?
Am sure i watched a interview with a crew member or read it in a book, The got mixed up in a foggy day when ment to do a fly by.

Mil-26Man 10th Jul 2019 17:54


Originally Posted by fallmonk (Post 10515229)
Wasnt there a SR71 crew did something similar in England many moons back?
Am sure i watched a interview with a crew member or read it in a book, The got mixed up in a foggy day when ment to do a fly by.

"You've never been lost until you've been lost at Mach 3" is a quote I heard from an SR71 pilot.

dead_pan 10th Jul 2019 21:56


Originally Posted by fallmonk (Post 10515229)
Wasnt there a SR71 crew did something similar in England many moons back?
Am sure i watched a interview with a crew member or read it in a book, The got mixed up in a foggy day when ment to do a fly by.

​​​​​​The story I remember (here on PPRuNe?) was when an SR-71 almost came a cropper when looking for a group of air cadets promised a fly-by, the crew in question spent a little too much time looking out of the window, too little on their airspeed. Fortunately they realised their predicament in time, and gave the cadets one helluva surprise


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:28.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.