PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Public sector pensions. (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/603892-public-sector-pensions.html)

tdracer 6th Jan 2018 23:12

Many decades ago, I read a short story where the downfall of western civilization was triggered when it came out that the governments were suppressing a cure for cancer - because of the catastrophic effect the cure would have on public pensions/social security would have bankrupted the governments. When it came to light, the resulting civil unrest caused the western governments to collapse and things simply went downhill from there.
At the time I considered the whole premise horribly far-fetched. Now I'm not so sure...

Haraka 7th Jan 2018 06:40

Ian 16th

To SOME pensioners.

I haven't had a State Pension increase for 15 years.

Mind you, I don't have a vote so I'm not worth bribing.
Same here: My RAF and State Pensions are still summed and taxed at source in U.K. , however no representation. British Democracy in action toward its citizens who chose to retire in certain countries.

Heathrow Harry 7th Jan 2018 06:54

That's the choice you make.........

Some countries allow people to vote if they aren't in country, some don't - tho' I notice the ones that do are often the ones that tax you on your world-wide income

IIRC the UK doesn't allow it because historically there were so many long-term Brits overseas it was felt they had no day-to-day understanding of the issues

(plus of course most of them voted Tory)

MPN11 7th Jan 2018 09:25

Yes, Jersey taxes all global income.
Our RAF and State pensions are paid gross [and then taxed here].
Registered overseas voters [just renewed!].
Proud recipient of £10 Xmas Bonus, but no Winter fuel allowance :(

Basil 7th Jan 2018 09:34

I see our Winter fuel payment as a vey small tax rebate. Why on Earth would one refuse to accept it?

roving 7th Jan 2018 09:47


Originally Posted by Heathrow Harry (Post 10013030)
That's the choice you make.........

Some countries allow people to vote if they aren't in country, some don't - tho' I notice the ones that do are often the ones that tax you on your world-wide income

IIRC the UK doesn't allow it because historically there were so many long-term Brits overseas it was felt they had no day-to-day understanding of the issues

(plus of course most of them voted Tory)

For Australians, voting is compulsory irrespective of where they are.

Australia election: Why is voting compulsory? - BBC News

ian16th 7th Jan 2018 10:02


Originally Posted by Heathrow Harry (Post 10013030)
That's the choice you make.........

Because I made a choice, in spite of the rules, do not make the rules equitable or fair.

If someone points a gun at you and says, 'I'll shoot you if you move'.

You move, and he shoots and kills you, it is still murder, in spite of the warning!

The UK state pension payment system is inequitable, unfair and should be changed.

Asylum seekers and illegal immigrants get treated better than British, fully paid up, state pensioners, who happen to live in the wrong post code.

snippy 7th Jan 2018 20:21


Originally Posted by Herod (Post 10011758)
I plan to live forever. So far, so good. ;)

Steady on Highlander😂

Herod 7th Jan 2018 20:25

Hey Snippy; a man's got to have an ambition; and perhaps a hobby. :)

Melchett01 7th Jan 2018 21:39


Originally Posted by Herod (Post 10013666)
Hey Snippy; a man's got to have an ambition; and perhaps a hobby. :)

Discussing my career aspirations a few years back with my Gp Capt, I said my main aspiration was to draw more in RAF pensions than I had in pay.

He initially thought I was taking the mickey until the cogs turned and gave a wry smile when he worked it out.

Heathrow Harry 8th Jan 2018 07:26

"Because I made a choice, in spite of the rules, do not make the rules equitable or fair."

We all have to learn to live with the consequences of our actions or as my dear old Mum used to say " you can't have everything".

I choose to base in the UK and pay more tax and suffer from the weather - there are always alternatives, such as Dubai, but you have to take the picture as whole

Jumping_Jack 8th Jan 2018 10:18

Life expectancy has dropped because of antibiotic resistance, says ONS

PDR1 8th Jan 2018 10:52


Originally Posted by ian16th (Post 10013164)
Because I made a choice, in spite of the rules, do not make the rules equitable or fair.

I couldn't agree more. I think the rules should be changed to the simple and patently fair formula:

If you live in the UK you can vote and draw your state pension. If you don't, then you should be able to do niether.

What could be fairer than that?

PDR

Bladdered 8th Jan 2018 11:54


Originally Posted by Jumping_Jack (Post 10014087)


Also, RAFG in the 70's and 80's. Great fun but I wouldn't wish my liver on anyone. But for my wife, it would be my lungs too!

Haraka 8th Jan 2018 17:53


If you live in the UK you can vote and draw your state pension. If you don't, then you should be able to do niether.(sic)
So,according to your logic, a person who has worked and paid in all their working life, then leaves on retirement, should receive no National Pension.
Conversely ,I logically presume by your statement, anybody coming to live in the country under the reverse condition (having contributed nothing) should then be entitled to vote and also get a pension.

Well, if Mr. Corbyn, Ms Abbott et al. get elected, I expect you will get your desire.

PDR1 8th Jan 2018 18:25


Originally Posted by Haraka (Post 10014430)
So,according to your logic, a person who has worked and paid in all their working life, then leaves on retirement, should receive no National Pension.
Conversely ,I logically presume by your statement, anybody coming to live in the country under the reverse condition (having contributed nothing) should then be entitled to vote and also get a pension.

No, I'd be happy to restrict the pension rights to people who have paid sufficient NI *AND* live in the UK. I'd even go so far as to say that after retirement you can have 3 months of the year out of the UK without affecting that right. See - I am the model of reasonableness.

But if you don't want to live here then live on your non-state pension and/or your wealth. I see no reason why UK residents should subsidise your lifestyle choices.

PDR

ShyTorque 8th Jan 2018 18:31


Originally Posted by PDR1 (Post 10014458)
No, I'd be happy to restrict the pension rights to people who have paid sufficient NI *AND* live in the UK. I'd even go so far as to say that after retirement you can have 3 months of the year out of the UK without affecting that right. See - I am the model of reasonableness.

But if you don't want to live here then live on your non-state pension and/or your wealth. I see no reason why UK residents should subsidise your lifestyle choices.

PDR

PDR - we in UK are short of housing. We have an NHS that is swamped. Moving abroad eases the load. So why financially penalise those who paid in, vacate a house and are no longer a burden on the health service?

Haraka 8th Jan 2018 18:48


I see no reason why UK residents should subsidise your lifestyle choices.
So who was subsidising whose retirement lifestyles during the 40 years plus may of us paid in monthly during our working lives, whilst taking nothing out?

PPRuNeUser0211 8th Jan 2018 19:28

The don't pay out for people overseas argument probably doesn't stack up.

Take state pension, multiply by life expectancy after 65/65/67 and you probably arrive at a few hundred thousand pounds. I'd suggest the cost of looking after one extra elderly person (NHS/care/other services) wipes out quite a few state pensions, so if you penalise people for living overseas and they instead stay in the UK you'll pretty quickly end up on the wrong side of the money curve...

Sevarg 8th Jan 2018 20:28

PDR Fine by me, no pension for us so none of my NI payments for you. When we leave we sign away our pension rights, you hand us our NI contributions and a sum to cover the amount we save the NHS. We wave goodbye.
By the way don't forget a sum to cover the amount we will save the in the cost for care etc but as I have no wish to bankrupt the country you can keep that.


All times are GMT. The time now is 15:08.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.