PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Air to Air kill over Raqqa (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/596038-air-air-kill-over-raqqa.html)

Timelord 18th Jun 2017 22:18

Air to Air kill over Raqqa
 
CNN reporting that a US F18 splashed a Syrian SU22 which was attacking US backed forces near Raqqa.

tonker 18th Jun 2017 22:44


Originally Posted by Timelord (Post 9805962)
CNN reporting that a US F18 splashed a Syrian SU22 which was attacking US backed forces near Raqqa.

https://cdn.liveleak.com/80281E/ll_a_s/2017/Jun/18/LiveLeak-dot-com-e2d_1497820763-21478648_0_1497820773.jpg?oIYq6gQ7kTvhdjpRhteacvyOcrXLTT1iT-LDwu5E2d02meVeGDFa9h3aYykjf7N8&ec_rate=499

sandiego89 19th Jun 2017 00:29

Interesting. First US Navy air to air since first gulf war I believe. Guess carrying those sidewinders and AIM-120's over Syria was a good idea after all...

Lonewolf_50 19th Jun 2017 01:30

A fine illustration of the mess in and around Syria.
After consulting my dance card, I am not sure who these people are.

Syrian Democratic Forces
Splitters?

Whenurhappy 19th Jun 2017 02:40


Originally Posted by Lonewolf_50 (Post 9806031)
A fine illustration of the mess in and around Syria.
After consulting my dance card, I am not sure who these people are.

Splitters?

US supported coalition of Kurds and Syrian Arab fighters. The Kurds are drawn from the PYD/YPG groupings which Turkey claims (with just reason) are linked to the PKK terrorists in Turkey. The authorities (Met Police) are very active against the PKK in the UK - mainly London.

Simples!

Big Pistons Forever 19th Jun 2017 03:13

Has any Western Air Force fighter ever been shot down by another fighter in the Middle East ?

Cazalet33 19th Jun 2017 03:23


Has any Western Air Force fighter ever been shot down by another fighter in the Middle East ?
The last time a Royal Air Force fighter, flown by a Royal Air Force pilot, shot down another fighter was in 1948. It was a Spitfire on Spitfire engagement, believed to be Israeli but turned out to be Egyptian.

Pontius Navigator 19th Jun 2017 06:45

Cazalet, I read the question the other way around. An RAF fighter was shot down by Israeli aircraft in 1949 (one of 5 lost)

westernhero 19th Jun 2017 07:06

The loss of a F-18 to a Iraqi MiG-25 on the first night of GW1



https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scott_Speicher

Unless anyone knows different this is what happened ?

sharpend 19th Jun 2017 09:36


Originally Posted by Pontius Navigator (Post 9806168)
Cazalet, I read the question the other way around. An RAF fighter was shot down by Israeli aircraft in 1949 (one of 5 lost)

An that was my old 14 Sqn Boss Tim McElhaw.

Lonewolf_50 19th Jun 2017 12:45

westernhero: thanks for that, I'd not seen that point being made before by someone who was on the mission.

Vzlet 19th Jun 2017 14:59

F-14 / F-18E
 
Su-22s have provided first-for-the-type kill opportunities for US Navy aircraft for 36 years now!

Lyneham Lad 19th Jun 2017 15:48

Russia warns US-led coalition over downing of Syrian jet
 
In The Graudian:-


Russia’s defence ministry has said it will treat any plane from the US-led coalition flying west of the Euphrates river in Syria as a potential target, after the US military shot down a Syrian air force jet on Sunday.

The ministry also said it was suspending a safety agreement with Washington designed to prevent collisions and dangerous incidents in Syrian airspace.

Lonewolf_50 19th Jun 2017 16:35

As I posted on JB, somewhat edited:
The Russian response is unfortunate, but it is quite understandable.

Russia, Syria's main ally, said it was also halting communications with the US aimed at preventing air incidents.
The situation is a many vs many with a variety of people backing various factions and thus creating chances for error/getting in each other's way. (see the Turk/Russian issue of a shoot down last year)
A variety of forces on the ground are getting air support: except for air support by SAF for Assad's forces, all air support seems to be sourced from various outsiders. Given the mess that this whole thing is, I'd say that something like this was bound to happen. (The Turk F-16 on the Frogger was a clue).


Assad doesn't trust "the West" with much of anything, so an overture like "hey, let's all gang up on the ISIS crew and sort the rest of this out later" is a likely no-sale transaction. Therefore, the many vs many continues.

You are the pilot of a fast jet, and you see some aircraft attacking your ally from the air, or setting up for another target run? What do you do?

I wonder if there was a better way to deal with this than "weapons free" given that (I think) this happened in Syrian Airspace (more or less). Probably not. I suspect this engagement fit a clear RoE.



President Trump authorized the Tomahawk attack on a Syrian air base (some months back, vis a vis the chem weapons attack, reported to be from that base) and I suspect that (given the SU-22 being the delivery platform for that event (alleged)) someone's logic chain at the CJTF (or in DC, since Micro Management is alive and well) was "we are preventing a gas attack" or something like that. Might just have been "stop the attack on our allied ground forces."

It's A Big Freaking Mess that Just Got Messier. :ugh:

stilton 20th Jun 2017 05:48

What could go wrong with President chump in charge ?

TBM-Legend 20th Jun 2017 07:34

Guns or missile??

Dan_Brown 20th Jun 2017 07:40

I believe British a/c will be targeted also.

Buster Hyman 20th Jun 2017 07:43

Have we heard from the Pprune Moscow bureau yet?

Anyway, I see the RAAF are staying on the ground for a bit now...

Dan_Brown 20th Jun 2017 07:48

Less expensive than getting blown out the sky i guess. I thought the ozzies had bigger b**** than that but seems i'm wrong.

seafury45 20th Jun 2017 07:53

Dan Brown

I am sure the Australian serving personnel will do whatever is required of them. Political masters on the other hand..........

Also, perhaps having a pause to think about the situation may not go astray. Lonewolf put it very well "It's A Big Freaking Mess that Just Got Messier."


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:08.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.