PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Masters of the Air (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/591293-masters-air.html)

PPRuNeUser0211 10th Oct 2023 06:55


Originally Posted by langleybaston (Post 11517662)
Thank you but 8mm? I think not.

​​​​​​As nutty points out above, 8mm Mauser (actually 7.92mm) was the standard German full bore rifle/mg round for the war (as well as a considerable amount of time beforehand!).

Snowbound 612 10th Oct 2023 13:33

Can only pass that my buddy stated it was an 8mm round which ended up in dad's helmet. Was it a 7.92 round or shrapnel? Just relating the story. He flew 32 missions. I routinely shoot my mauser and other milsurp rifles. Amazed at the mess of a round after hitting a half inch armor plate target. Very informative video here.

Snowbound 612 10th Oct 2023 15:14

Buddy just informed me the round did not stop so was not recovered. His father believed it was 8mm.

langleybaston 10th Oct 2023 20:57

My apologies ................. I failed to allow for rounding of rounds!

Plus I am old school Imperial measure forced into metric and easily confused.

Memo to self: WIND NECK IN.

PPRuNeUser0211 9th Nov 2023 17:42


snapper41 12th Nov 2023 15:46

Having watched the trailer, I’m not sure about accuracy. It seems they are showing red-tailed P-51s which indicates the 332nd Fighter Group aka the Tuskegee Airmen. The 332nd served in Italy, not England.

beamer 13th Nov 2023 08:04

I thought Band of Brothers was a great watch, Pacific less so. I just hope that this eagerly awaited series is worthwhile and not spoilt by too much CGI and actors who simply do not look the part.

Geriaviator 13th Nov 2023 10:44

The movie aircrews have superhuman powers in that they don't require oxygen masks at 18000 feet and more where the B-17s usually operated, and they don't need intercom as they can hear one another despite engines which bellow even louder than actors in American war movies. Fond memories of many hours in Hastings/Halifax include shouting directly into the ear until intercom was plugged in, the noise of big pistons is incredible.

CGI etc cannot approach William Wyler's original Memphis Belle of 1943 with its action sequences shot during real life raids.

Ninthace 13th Nov 2023 11:16


Originally Posted by Geriaviator (Post 11538336)
...
CGI etc cannot approach William Wyler's original Memphis Belle of 1943 with its action sequences shot during real life raids.

Costly on cast, crew and props though!

stevef 13th Nov 2023 11:25


Originally Posted by beamer (Post 11538241)
I just hope that this eagerly awaited series is worthwhile and not spoilt by too much CGI and actors who simply do not look the part.

Ah, yes - the predilection for casting pretty boy protagonists in action movies. The 1990 Memphis Belle remake is a good example of unauthenticity and shallow characters in my opinion. That was a one-off watch for me. Likewise The Flight of the Phoenix remake. Appalling ... the list goes on.

typerated 13th Nov 2023 23:25


Originally Posted by stevef (Post 11538363)
Ah, yes - the predilection for casting pretty boy protagonists in action movies. The 1990 Memphis Belle remake is a good example of unauthenticity and shallow characters in my opinion. That was a one-off watch for me. Likewise The Flight of the Phoenix remake. Appalling ... the list goes on.

I saw the trailer and it looks utterly unwatchable.
Hype and over dramatised to a painful degree.
It would be so much more powerful if the program was not trying to squeeze drama and emotion out of every second - might even allow a bit of accuracy to sneak in too.
I certainly won't be watching it

PPRuNeUser0211 6th Dec 2023 18:59


GlobalNav 6th Dec 2023 20:06


Originally Posted by typerated (Post 11538715)
I saw the trailer and it looks utterly unwatchable.
Hype and over dramatised to a painful degree.
It would be so much more powerful if the program was not trying to squeeze drama and emotion out of every second - might even allow a bit of accuracy to sneak in too.
I certainly won't be watching it

I recommend the book, though, not dramatized, but all too real, even painful to consider completely what these young airmen experienced. Proud of that they accomplished what they did.

pr00ne 6th Dec 2023 23:01


Originally Posted by typerated (Post 11538715)
I saw the trailer and it looks utterly unwatchable.
Hype and over dramatised to a painful degree.
It would be so much more powerful if the program was not trying to squeeze drama and emotion out of every second - might even allow a bit of accuracy to sneak in too.
I certainly won't be watching it

So, you will have no idea at all what it is like will you?

This is not a documentary, it is a creative piece of fiction based around real events. It is designed to entertain people with next to no knowledge or real interest in WW2 aircraft, around the world in 2023.


bobward 7th Dec 2023 07:06

From my perspective, trailers only show the 'high' spots of film or serial. They are made to attract viewers who probably didn't know the main course was even coming. Like life, many productions are lng periods of routine, spiced with the odd exciting bit.

On another tack, has anyone seen the trailer for series 2 of Vigil? After their stunning success with series one (alleged life on a nuclear submarine) seeing how they portray life on what looks like a UPAS unit might raise a smile or two. However, since the mistress of misery (Surranne Jones) is a main character, don't get your hopes up.

GlobalNav 7th Dec 2023 15:15


Originally Posted by pr00ne (Post 11552562)
So, you will have no idea at all what it is like will you?

This is not a documentary, it is a creative piece of fiction based around real events. It is designed to entertain people with next to no knowledge or real interest in WW2 aircraft, around the world in 2023.

Well, if that’s the intent, then it is completely out of tune with the book, and even with the Band of Brothers mini series. To appreciate the effort, the suffering and sacrifice, the uncertainties and disappointments, yet the courage and sometimes the exhilaration of success, but at great cost, is what I would hope for. Perhaps the series is much better than the trailer would lead us to believe. If not, it will be a black mark on Spielberg’s otherwise stellar portfolio.

War is not a football game. It is sometimes necessary, fraught with fog, errors, tedium, human faults, and yet the demonstration by many of duty, honor, country in both conspicuous and inconspicuous ways. You take casualties and still press on, even when outcome is uncertain, because the ultimate costs of defeat are unacceptable. It is possible for a work of fiction to help us see that, even better than a documentary newsreel.

PPRuNeUser0211 7th Dec 2023 15:47


Originally Posted by GlobalNav (Post 11553034)
Well, if that’s the intent, then it is completely out of tune with the book, and even with the Band of Brothers mini series. To appreciate the effort, the suffering and sacrifice, the uncertainties and disappointments, yet the courage and sometimes the exhilaration of success, but at great cost, is what I would hope for. Perhaps the series is much better than the trailer would lead us to believe. If not, it will be a black mark on Spielberg’s otherwise stellar portfolio.

War is not a football game. It is sometimes necessary, fraught with fog, errors, tedium, human faults, and yet the demonstration by many of duty, honor, country in both conspicuous and inconspicuous ways. You take casualties and still press on, even when outcome is uncertain, because the ultimate costs of defeat are unacceptable. It is possible for a work of fiction to help us see that, even better than a documentary newsreel.

Given a bet between a) a trailer being hyped up to attract the maximum audience possible and b) Spielberg + hanks doing anything other than treating the subject with the respect it deserves, I genuinely am amazed that anyone thinks b) is remotely likely given their track record.

BEagle 13th Jan 2024 16:18

For those of us who cannot access AppleTV (neither on a NOW TV stick, nor a Panasonic not-so-smart TV), is this series likely to be released on DVD?

MG 13th Jan 2024 16:31


Originally Posted by BEagle (Post 11575500)
For those of us who cannot access AppleTV (neither on a NOW TV stick, nor a Panasonic not-so-smart TV), is this series likely to be released on DVD?

What’s a DVD?

dfv8 13th Jan 2024 17:35


Originally Posted by BEagle (Post 11575500)
For those of us who cannot access AppleTV (neither on a NOW TV stick, nor a Panasonic not-so-smart TV), is this series likely to be released on DVD?

You may be able to to enrol with AppleTV for one month free which will enable you to watch the programme. Just unsubscribe after the month.

I've just changed my mobile 'phone contract and have an offer for same for three months.


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:48.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.