PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Ex military pilots formate A350s (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/553040-ex-military-pilots-formate-a350s.html)

ShotOne 20th Dec 2014 11:02

Cracking pictures, Dom. Was that their swan-song? The last I saw of them was parked up at Kemble looking sorry for themselves.

BOAC 20th Dec 2014 11:12

Overall, a good bit of PR and a very well managed and executed operation. Well done all.

BEagle 20th Dec 2014 11:14


Even in close it can get scary if the leader is a plonker.
How true indeed! For the 1977 Silver Jellybean, one large vic formation consisted of a box of 4 Jetstreams, with a box of 4 Dominies on each side. Speed had to be slow enough for the Jetstreams, which didn't leave much margin for the Dominies.

I was on a JP refresher course at the time, so went along to rubberneck this balbo from a jump seat in one of the Jetstreams. Once all 12 were joined up, we set off towards the IP only for the lead Jetstream captain to announce that he needed to lose time, so would fly an orbit.....at 30° AoB! The Dominie box on the outside coped OK, but the poor sods on the inside were almost on the buffet and had a heck of a job keeping in position. After the flypast, the inside Dominies departed with the comment "Be in your office when we land!" to the Jetstream leader. Not happy bunnies!

Dominator2 20th Dec 2014 11:17

The pictures are from a photo shoot just prior to our final 6 ship flypast. Photos by Mr Geoff Lee. Final Flypast on 20/1/11 at CWL with CinC in the formation.
I understand that 4 Doms may be heading to Humberside, possibly by air, for use as engineer trainers.

Onceapilot 20th Dec 2014 12:43

Quality Formation Leaders are a very valuable asset. In times gone by, many would have experienced close formation as an everyday requirement of the job, and most would be well skilled.

OAP

BOAC 20th Dec 2014 12:49


Originally Posted by Beagle
For the 1977 Silver Jellybean,

- think yourself lucky you were not in the flypast over Lizzie's house for the Silver. With lowering cloudbase west of London the lamented late Frank Hoare at the back noticed his boys were in the TV aerials of High wycombe (the middle box had dropped back AND DOWN!...) and he ruddered the 9- ship vic out from under the melee. Another 'late', Andy Penswick , outside right of box 2 in his Lightning, got so unhappy with it all he lit the burners and pulled up to 30k+ through the LHR zone:) Great fun had by all. 'Twas the leader of the second block that were at fault although Tony Woodward, overall leader, initially got the flak but was absolved from blame I recall.

Apoogies for the image size.
http://clarionrecall.org/wp-content/...a/18.jpg?ver=1

ancientaviator62 20th Dec 2014 13:49

BOAC,
super pic. Sorry to hear that Andy Penswick is no longer with us. We were groundcrew together on 92 before he gave up 'mending' to take up 'bending'.

Onceapilot 20th Dec 2014 14:33

Great pic BOAC! Oh boy, formations and flypasts seem to attract lowering cloudbases!:oh:

OAP

dmussen 22nd Dec 2014 06:21

Superb. Shame they couldn't come up with some smoke.
Still a joy to watch all the same.:ok:

Wander00 22nd Dec 2014 08:00

Must find my slides of a 56-ship JP formation at the Towers in the early. Must have been the rehearsal for Grad flypast on which I flew as pax, the only time in the RHS of a JP. I recall we could not log the flight time as it would screw the training stats!

BBadanov 22nd Dec 2014 08:23

I recall we could not log the flight time as it would screw the training stats!

Any time that anyone is in this predicament, log the trip but do not enter the flight time in one of the totalled columns.

This way you have the date, what you did and with whom, where you went - it provides a record for you, but this doesn't "screw the training stats"!

At the age of 66 and no longer flying, I get some enjoyment of sometimes flicking through my logbook and looking at the pics!

newt 22nd Dec 2014 09:08

but you are NOT in close formation.

Actually Dominator2, flat turns can be used in close formation when flying echelon! Often used at Deci on recovery in fours! The leader just has to remember to turn away from the rest of the formation!:ok:

Dominator2 22nd Dec 2014 15:37

Newt,

You missed my point. I was saying that flat turns are not optimum for large ac, particularly with more than 2 ac, even more so if flown cross cockpit!!!!:= I spent 3 years teaching the GAF flat turns in the F4 and so I am very familiar with the benefits and techniques of how to fly them properly. "Looking Good in the Closed Pattern " is one of the most important parts of any sortie.

I must admit that trying to flat turn 9 at initials at Deci was rather adventerous but then it was Battle of Britain Day!

Tester78 23rd Dec 2014 15:22

recceguy...
 


She is just doing acceptance flights at Airbus - which some people call test flights. She wouldn't have been called for the display of the 350s ....
ETPS - a private business now with Qinetiq - is offering abbreviated tailor-made courses (one or thwo months) for production factory pilots. Not much to do with the full one-year TP course - but even after a two-days course, you can get from them the badge and keys Handler....

Being a woman she had some rules being relaxed for her, as is often the case.
Wrong on all counts. But perhaps you're a troll? And your last sentence would be actionable as libellous to both ETPS and the lady concerned, were you to have the guts to post under your own name. Feel free to PM me, and then to publish an apology.

LOMCEVAK 23rd Dec 2014 16:07

Tester78,

Well said!

So far I have restrained from posting on this thread but have been saddened that so many ignorant and, from the likes of recceguy, offensive comments have been made following an excellent video of some very professional and impressive flying; thankfully some sensible remarks have been posted also. Congratulations to all Airbus in putting this formation together and filming it so well.

L

KenV 6th Jan 2015 15:07


But we aren't talking about tactical low level formations Ken, we are talking about flying close formation in large aircraft. Looking at your list of "I've flown close formation in" there doesn't appear to be any large aircraft, so I'm not sure you are qualified to comment. Flying close formation in any aircraft means the wing men manoeuvre in height in a turn and that doesn't matter whether you are in a fast jet, small multi or large multi - the techniques are the same! Take it from someone who has flown close formation against a large number of different types.
"We" are clearly talking about different things. But what I was talking about was large low level formations of tactical transport aircraft (I even provided a photo of such a formation) and the need for eyebrow windows to accomplish that. As I stated numbers of times, these are NOT "close" formations. I asked because I have extensive experience in tactical transport aircraft (C-27, C-130, C-17) where those types of formations are flown and all of which have eyebrow windows. I cannot figure out how those formations could be flown in an A400 which does not have eyebrow windows and specifically asked if Airbus had come up with a different solution.

Regarding this formation of A350s, they do not seem to me to be a close formation at all and I do not believe they were flown in the manner of a close formation.

As for your Bear Foxtrot experience, imagine if you had been at the controls of another Bear Foxtrot in that formation turn. Could it have been done? And if you attempted it, would you be here to talk about it?

As for the various replies concerning dissimilar aircraft formation flights, that is NOT what I was talking about. I was specifically talking about a large formation of tactical transports at low level during a run-in for a large formation airdrop. Those are not done (at least in USAF) with dissimilar aircraft. I cannot speak for how the RAF does it.

Flying Lawyer 6th Jan 2015 17:10


Formidable !

Magnifique, ça !

..... and led by Frank Chapman, a Brit!

RAF 1980–1996, which included four years on exchange with USAF (F-16) and ETPS.
A350 XWB Project Lead Test Pilot.

Extract from an interview about the flight:

How much planning went into the five-formation flight?

CHAPMAN:

The most difficult part of organizing was getting 5 prototype aircraft ready for flight together.
I chose ex-military pilots as they would be very familiar with formation flying (as it is normal military procedure).
The preparation and briefing was done by me and required some thought and planning, but no more. The briefing had to be clearly understood by everyone, so the preparation for this part was critical. Everyone has to know exactly what to do in a large formation so that there is no misunderstanding.
We also had to liaise with the photo chase aircraft that carried not only the photographer but also one of our ex-military Test Pilots. They were the “Whipper In,” which meant he could call the fine adjustments to formation position over the radio to ensure that we were all in the correct position.

Based on the vantage point of the photos and video, the planes look extremely close to each other. How did Airbus ensure a safe flight for everyone?

CHAPMAN:

The aircraft look close but this is perfectly normal formation flight and is perfectly safe, provided a carefully prepared briefing is made.
If you look at Air-to Air refueling, the aircraft are much closer together and there is still no issue.




dragartist 26th Jan 2015 20:49

Cambs RAeS lecture
 
Folks following this thread may be interested in attending the Cambridge Branch of the RAeS Sir Arthur Marshall Lecture on 5th March.

Peter Chandler the A350 test pilot will deliver his lecture at Churchill College, Cambridge starting at 18.00. According to the information I have there is a drinks reception scheduled for 19.30


I am sure folks will have some questions about this formation.


I hope to make it if SWMBO will sign my chit.

D-IFF_ident 27th Jan 2015 11:31

I watched some ex-RAF heavy pilots (or was that some heavy ex-RAF pilots...) fly some close formation in a couple of Airbus twinjets last week. Would you believe, they got close enough the aircraft actually touched each other? About a dozen times!

Sadly no publically available pictures.

:E

John Farley 27th Jan 2015 13:18

KenV

A point you might like to consider is that the sideways and upward view a pilot has through a side window is dependent on the distance the pilot’s eye is from the window and how much the pilot’s eye is below the top of the window.

Could it be that these aspects are better in an A350 than in the types you flew?


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:35.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.