PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Military 'may have to abandon flood-prone bases' (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/534590-military-may-have-abandon-flood-prone-bases.html)

bcgallacher 23rd Feb 2014 06:20

It's a good thing that pigeons are not the size of Canada geese as they regularly try to fly through my living room windows. The impact on the glass is enough to set off the burglar alarm system as well as leaving the impression of a very surprised pigeon on the pane. Only one survived - the good people of the RSPB revived and released it. Once got involved with a P&W JT 9 that took 3 geese in the fan at JFK - much bent and torn titanium.

GreenKnight121 23rd Feb 2014 08:21

Not to mention a certain Airbus taking off from LaGuardia.

Lima Juliet 23rd Feb 2014 10:45

Yes, but Abbeywood has no runway, nearby Filton's runway was broken up last year and they plan to build 2,500 homes on it.

I say again, who gives a rat's arse about geese at Abbeywood!

LJ

The Helpful Stacker 23rd Feb 2014 12:18


Anyone remember Ploce?
Ah, Ploce Deathcamp. Blue asbestos, rivers of turds and dead horses a go-go.

"Lets dig a bund into a landfill, what could go wrong?"

Mr C Hinecap 23rd Feb 2014 14:04


Typical envirofundamentalist clap trap peddled by the woolly-hatted warmist sandalistas.....

Weren't we supposed to be having 'the coldest winter for years' in 2014?
You are a bright chap. You know the difference between 'climate' and 'weather' don't you?

Climate change is happening. The MoD has to look at it with a view to future capabilities and indeed future conflicts. The US military got the message a long time ago because of the real risk to it's own capabilities.

airpolice 23rd Feb 2014 14:21

What about Linton?

Although the airfield is mostly fine, the road access to it, particularly from the North West, and South East, is not good when the tide comes in.

B Fraser 23rd Feb 2014 14:31

"Meanwhile I was next door in Met O 11"


Mr Baston, I was on the other side of the quad in 08 and 19 at "Brackers" until I went off to do something more profitable.


The computers that predicted the dry winter in Somerset are using a very similar model to those predicting global warming. It speaks volumes don't you think !

chopper2004 23rd Feb 2014 15:16

http://http://i57.photobucket.com/al...pshttd4pew.jpghttp://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g2...pshttd4pew.jpg

http://http://i57.photobucket.com/al...pshttd4pew.jpg

Remember this USN proposal ? Lol :)

Lima Juliet 23rd Feb 2014 16:12


Climate change is happening
It's been happening for years...you'd think we'd be used to it by now! :ugh:

Look at the first graph below I wonder if it was King Canute that was using his gas-guzzling 4x4 to keep the sea back, or King Alfred's burning cakes that caused the last rise in temperature???

Or maybe it was the Caveman farts 8,000 years ago in the second graph that caused the 1.5 degree rise?

I'm not a climate change deny-er, but I don't quite have the same cataclysmic view that some of BEags' "Sandalista" would have you believe! :ok:

LJ

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...Comparison.png

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...Variations.png

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...emperature.png

Lima Juliet 23rd Feb 2014 16:27


The computers that predicted the dry winter in Somerset are using a very similar model to those predicting global warming. It speaks volumes don't you think !
Yup, I believe it can go either one of 3 ways:

1. We'll all fry and be extinct within 500 years

2. We'll all drown because of a biblical flood.

3. The Earth will react to the increase in green-house gases and as long we get to a point of balance then so will the Earth and things will go back to the historical norms. Like it always has done following meteor strikes and huge volcanic eruptions.

LJ

kintyred 23rd Feb 2014 21:31

Spot on LJ!
Palaeloclimatology is an absolutely fascinating subject and while there's no denying that the earth has warmed over the past 70 years or so there's still a lot of work to be done to work out why and what the future holds.
A Hampshire airfield's met station was moved a few years ago and the surroundings were different from the original location. No comparison was made over any length of time to work out what the effect on temperature, wind, rainfall was but the Station still claims to have weather records dating back 60 odd years. No doubt the effect of moving the instruments was small but there was no attempt to quantify it (care to comment Langley Baston?). Clearly alterations of the surroundings of many long-established stations will have had an impact on their readings...the so heat-island effect but also change of use of agricultural land are examples.
A further thought is that the Carboniferous period of geological history was was one of the warmest and yet the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere was negligible.
Finally it looks as though ice ages commence with global temperature falls of about 10 degrees in the space of a few decades. I'm not saying it will happen but that would certainly make your eyes water!!

awblain 23rd Feb 2014 21:40

Lordy, people…

Predicting dry/wet winters is difficult. Atmospheric dynamics on day-month scales is chaotic.

Energy conservation on decade scales is easy. Knowing where warming will occur is difficult, but on average - it's getting warmer.

What happened 1000 years ago isn't of too much relevance. It's the 100 years in front of us that matters.

The condition for a starting an ice age is probably simple - winter snow stays through the summer in the high-latitude northern hemisphere. Off to on in a few seasons. Not so likely with current temperatures.

kintyred 23rd Feb 2014 21:52

Awblain,

I'd love to know what the climate will be in 100 years but the simple truth is that our current knowledge/ technology is not up to that sort of prediction. Seeing how climate has changed in past and trying to work out why is part of the learning process to predict the future...and it's fascinating!

Ice ages commenced from just the sort of climate that we are currently experiencing. You've described the process of establishing an ice age but not the catalyst...we need to keep investigating the past to work out whether it could happen again. Remember that global warming is predicted to be of the order of a few degrees - I can't see that stopping the onset of an ice age.

awblain 23rd Feb 2014 21:57

Energy conservation has been known about for a long time.

It's all it takes to understand global temperature on climate scales, absenting the onset of an ice age. And that is not likely to happen at present, owing to unprecedentedly high summer temperatures over the whole Arctic. You need to make it through a whole not-completely melted taiga summer to set it up, and that's not likely.

Melting permafrost can change the current situation quite the other way.

Detailed predictions of weather patterns in 100 years from now are hard, but it's very very likely it'll be warmer than it is now.

A2QFI 24th Feb 2014 07:45

Brize Norton to be flooded?
 
At 288 ft amsl how is that ever going to happen, never mind "by 2020"?

Roland Pulfrew 24th Feb 2014 08:25


At 288 ft amsl how is that ever going to happen
Well given that the rainfall that closed RAF Innsworth and caused the Gloucester floods in (was it?) 2007 also closed the A40 at Witney (fortunately just after I had driven through the flooded section) then maybe! Think rainfall not rising sea levels.

Sandy Parts 24th Feb 2014 10:19

phew - with all the 'risk' of flooding, lucky the 'future of the RAF' whizjet boys are moving from Leuchars. Now as long as they don't somehow end up at another coastal low-lying base, they'll be safe for years to come...

Metman 24th Feb 2014 12:23


Weren't we supposed to be having 'the coldest winter for years' in 2014?
Ahh BEagle old chap, you've confirmed yourself as a Daily Depress reader - the paper who persist with their not-in-the-slightest-bit-exagerated doom laden headlines from the bloke-in-a-shed weather "forecaster" that proved to be completely wrong on pretty much every occasion. Even seaweed would have given a better prediction!

The headlines do make us chuckle at work, although it worries us a little that people think it's us making those predictions!

As for the Daily Heil's and Depress' claims about the seasonal forecast being wrong, well, they're cherry picking from something they don't understand to make news out of nothing and find someone else to blame - oh, and coincidentally try to claim they got it right (they didn't - as you say, remember the aforementioned coldest winter on record headlines they ran?)

Hopefully not too many people believe every word they read.... Oh, they do? :ugh:

kintyred 24th Feb 2014 13:14

Awblain,

What would the scientific community's prediction have been for the climate at the height of the little ice age 300 years ago? No doubt they would have said it was very, very likely that we were heading for a full-blown ice age. I'm not saying the earth is not warming...and if it is warmer in 100 years you will write and let know, won't you?

langleybaston 24th Feb 2014 14:31

Perhaps metman would care to post the exact wording of the official Met Office winter prediction?

here is one who would certainly understand it.

thinks ....... is this the same Met Office team that promised a BBQ summer? Thought so.

Regarding moving Met instruments on a military base, this is usually driven by customer requirements, which the SMetO should resist, but the bottom line is that he is only the hired hand.
The really nasty instrument to muck about with is the anemo, either moving it, or allowing new and large structures to be sited within a few hundred metres of the mast. Not good for the customer at all.
This happened at an Eastern civil airfield for which I had over-arching Met. responsibility, and I refused to sign the annual certificate of metworthiness [not that it was called that officially].
My boss signed it so that was OK., it was safe after all.
I have never ever flown out of or into that airfield since.


All times are GMT. The time now is 15:30.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.