PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   PQ17 (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/531072-pq17.html)

Biggus 12th Jan 2014 15:01

PN,

By "...German maritime traffic along the coast of Norway...." I wasn't referring to submarines....

Pontius Navigator 12th Jan 2014 19:06

Biggus, apologies, too tired :)

Could be why the V-bombers were designed with a secondary role as mine layers - Vulcan certainly.

JonnyT1978 13th Jan 2014 22:41


Originally Posted by Hangarshuffle
Russians didn't like either the Hurricane or the tanks (Churchill, Valentine and US Sherman) we sent them and found them markedly inferior to their own T34 or KV1 and varients. Its sometimes hard to find reference to any of the war material we despatched via the North Cape IMHO.
Did it all work as well as the propaganda makes out?
Was it all really that useful to the Russians?

I believe the Russians weren't too enamoured with the Spitfire either. I seem to remember from a Bill Gunston book that they were big fans of the P-39 Airacobra and P-63 Kingcobra, due to their toughness and the large-caliber cannon.

If I remember correctly too, Gunston also recounted the story of meeting some senior officers from the Russian Airforce post-war and they told him they wouldn't let anyone over 35 fly the aircraft. Asked why, the Russian officer replied (straight-faced) "balls get caught in prop-shaft"

Anyway, it was an excellent documentary. JC seems to have a knack for getting the 'tone' of these right.

A A Gruntpuddock 13th Jan 2014 23:32

"Was it all really that useful to the Russians?"

My father-in-law was on the Russian convoys - they were treated with great suspicion and rarely allowed off the ships.

Considering the conditions experienced in getting there (spent a lot of time hacking off ice in atrocious conditions to avoid turning turtle), he was not amused.

Chugalug2 14th Jan 2014 07:09

Whatever the Russian Government said or didn't say, or what it told its own people, the Russian Convoys were an essential lifeline to a beleaguered country. It's all very well to say that a Red Army victory was inevitable over the Wehrmacht, but it takes more than overwhelming manpower to get there. The convoys bought the Soviets time to get their own act together, having lost most of their aircraft and tanks in the initial blitzkrieg.
If your father in law wanted the Nazi regime defeated, then his part in the Arctic War was a vital component in that, no matter how he was treated by our Russian allies.

Toadstool 18th Jan 2014 00:19

Sorry if this has been posted before, too late and too much port to check through thread, but the story is on at 0200 this morning on BBC2


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:07.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.