PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Red Arrows - Flt Lt Jon Egging Inquest (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/502790-red-arrows-flt-lt-jon-egging-inquest.html)

JustT 13th Dec 2012 12:40

Red Arrows - Flt Lt Jon Egging Inquest
 
The Daily Echo are reporting live proceedings from Bournemouth Coroner's Court on the inquest into the death of Flt Lt Jon Egging. Link.

fantom 13th Dec 2012 12:52

Arrows inquest
 
Following the loss of Red 4 at BOH, the inquest has been told there was no evidence of mech failure and the probable cause was Jon Egging's loss of consciousness during the final break to land.

beardy 13th Dec 2012 14:17

That is particularly sad, my heart grieves.

Temp Spike 13th Dec 2012 15:41

How tremendously sad. Rest in peace young man.

Pure Pursuit 13th Dec 2012 16:57

Sky ipad app has a picture of Sean Cunningham instead of Eggman...:ugh:

PAXboy 13th Dec 2012 17:47

This is the BBC: BBC News - Red Arrows' Jon Egging 'almost passed out' before crash

Duncan D'Sorderlee 13th Dec 2012 18:51

LateArmLive,

Whilst I tend to agree with your sentiment, I'm not sure why you posted here.

Duncs:ok:

fantom 13th Dec 2012 20:06

Duncan, I think Late may have reacted to a post which has been deleted.

LateArmLive 13th Dec 2012 20:17

Fantom/Duncs, I was replying to a couple of now-deleted threads.

Maybe it was just me being oversensitive, but Eggman was a good wingman and a great friend to me. I'll go back and delete my flash :O

Duncan D'Sorderlee 13th Dec 2012 21:30

Roger.

Duncs:ok:

FATTER GATOR 13th Dec 2012 22:00

Desperately sad events. My heart goes out family, friends and my heart goes out to the team.

Keep doing what you do so well, it thrills me every time I see it.

The inquest must have been very hard for everyone. C L-S, much respect for holding it together during the hearing.

RIP Egg-man, RIP Sean

Eclat

212man 13th Dec 2012 22:17

Just seen the BBC item. Is there a plausible explanation out there as to how one would experience G-LOC in a break to land, versus an aerobatic display?

orca 13th Dec 2012 23:16

Your G tolerance will decrease with fatigue and as you dehydrate. It will also be affected by G onset rate, exposure time and the position of your head - it's possible to disturb or even close the carotid blood vessels looking over your shoulder for example. Whether or not you grey-out partially or completely will also be affected by how effective your Anti-G Straining Manoeuvre is and how timely it was.

So - not on the board and no idea what happened other than we lost a great bloke. But yes, it is more than plausible that one could A-LOC or G-LOC in a break to land having not been unduly affected by G during an aerobatic display.

RIP Egg man old chap.

Easy Street 13th Dec 2012 23:50

The BBC report quotes 6.3G on the break. This would probably have been the highest G pulled during the sortie: Reds 1 to 5 fly a relatively benign G profile, at least by comparison to Reds 6 to 9. 6.3G is easily enough to cause some loss of consciousness if other aggravating factors are present.

Milo Minderbinder 13th Dec 2012 23:58

I'm sorry to drag this thread down but....
looking at the link to the Daily Echo site, I cannot but help feel theres something fundamentally wrong in publishing a minute by minute account of the Coroners Court like that.
It just feels intrinsically disrespectful to me: its turning a serious issue, the investigation into a mans death, into a media circus masquerading as a public entertainment charade.
I've nothing against the facts being presented, but is a minute by minute "hot press" style of reporting appropriate to a case like this? I don't think so.

I have to say I don't know any of the people involved so I hope I'm not treading on any sensitivities, but to me the method of reporting, from the point of simple common decency, seems basically unsavoury.

Fox3WheresMyBanana 14th Dec 2012 00:04

Agreed. 24 hour news mentality I fear. Doesn't matter what you say, as long as you're always saying something. We'll be right back after these messages.

500N 14th Dec 2012 00:16

Milo

Agreed as well.

For me, he lost consciousness is good enough for the general media.

The rest can be covered by the BOI and any changes required
implemented by the service involved.

Trim Stab 14th Dec 2012 13:39

Well luckily we live in a democracy, so information regarding our military services is in the public domain, except where there are clear operational reasons for it to be kept secret. This was not the case here, so the public have every right to know why one of the aircraft they pay for has crashed.

fantom 14th Dec 2012 13:56


The BBC report quotes 6.3G on the break.
I heard that too but don't understand it. That sort of loading coming off the target is one thing but a break into the cct? I don't think so; I expect something has been lost in the translation unless something has changed.

BOAC?

Party Animal 14th Dec 2012 14:01

Milo,

Very well put sir. I agree with you completely and I suspect 99% of the readers of this post do so too.

Trim Stab,

I doubt you will find anyone on here who disagrees with the public having the right to know. It is how the information is being conveyed that's the problem. Turning the whole thing into 'public entertainment' is indeed unsavoury, indecent and lacking in respect. I would say that about any individual in similar circumstances too and not just because it is a fellow officer.


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:24.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.