PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Valiant Tankers (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/502446-valiant-tankers.html)

Fareastdriver 28th Feb 2018 07:35


I was posted from Bruggen,24/12/1964 to 214 Sqdn.Honington
That was definitely 90 Sqn.

XD814 was the first to go. We aircrew had no warning that the fleet was going to be broken up; they were still talking about resparring etc.. We were sitting in the crew room and 214 was towed past, flaps and engine panels hanging down looking a sorry mess.

Despite that we kept flying.

I delivered XD 863 to Filton on 20th Oct: XD 820 to St. Athan on 9th November. A Lone Ranger to Khormaksa with XD813 on 22nd November.

Honington's runway was closed for resurfacing in December so our remaining serviceable aircraft were repositioned at Marham and I took XD 820 up there on 3rd December.

On the 8th December I was a on a night Frex with Lightnings from 92 at Leconfield. On one engagement the basket detached from the hose and locked itself over the Lightning's probe. He then bolted off back to Leconfield where apparently he had considerable difficulty landing with the asymmetric drag.

We did the normal bomb bay ventilation procedures and returned to Marham. As we crossed the threshold I saw a Valiant at the holding point with a Standard Vanguard Estate drawn across the front of it. This was to prevent it taking off as the Valiants had been grounded. Shortly after a bomber landed and that was it.............

ian16th 28th Feb 2018 07:52


Originally Posted by Fareastdriver (Post 10067794)
That was definitely 90 Sqn.

Oh! You mentioned that number.:uhoh:

Fareastdriver 28th Feb 2018 08:01

I believe that 214 Sqn had to run around and look all steely whenever there was a Mick or Micky Finn.

When the hooters went I just rolled over in bed; We had two Victor Squadrons to do all that stuff.

Herod 28th Feb 2018 08:16

FWIW, I've just been looking at the records available to the public on the Cosford website. It records that 818 went to 32 MU at Hurn on 16 Jul 61 for modifications to a tanker., although several flights are recorded after this, until 28 Sep 62, when it was returned to 49 Sqn. If anyone wants to read what Cosford has, here is the link. https://www.rafmuseum.org.uk/documen...iant-XD818.pdf

RetiredBA/BY 28th Feb 2018 08:36


Originally Posted by Fareastdriver (Post 10067794)
That was definitely 90 Sqn.

XD814 was the first to go. We aircrew had no warning that the fleet was going to be broken up; they were still talking about resparring etc.. We were sitting in the crew room and 214 was towed past, flaps and engine panels hanging down looking a sorry mess.

Despite that we kept flying.

I delivered XD 863 to Filton on 20th Oct: XD 820 to St. Athan on 9th November. A Lone Ranger to Khormaksa with XD813 on 22nd November.

Honington's runway was closed for resurfacing in December so our remaining serviceable aircraft were repositioned at Marham and I took XD 820 up there on 3rd December.

On the 8th December I was a on a night Frex with Lightnings from 92 at Leconfield. On one engagement the basket detached from the hose and locked itself over the Lightning's probe. He then bolted off back to Leconfield where apparently he had considerable difficulty landing with the asymmetric drag.

We did the normal bomb bay ventilation procedures and returned to Marham. As we crossed the threshold I saw a Valiant at the holding point with a Standard Vanguard Estate drawn across the front of it. This was to prevent it taking off as the Valiants had been grounded. Shortly after a bomber landed and that was it.............

Are you sure of the date, 8th December. My log book shows my last landing on 9th December, 865,
F/l Gibbons, capt., me in RHS. Was that the last Valiant sortie, I vaguely remember being recalled?

The Oberon 28th Feb 2018 09:05

As previously posted, I arrived at Marham and the wreckers had already started, this would have been Jan. 65. What struck me as odd was that Marham was still holding QRA, I remember this because in addition to the RAF police guard, each A/C had a rather large USAF "Custodian" on the pan.

racingrigger 28th Feb 2018 09:17

I stand corrected, thanks Pontifex, it was obviously 8 Valiants modified for Grapple not the 4 I stated. An interesting aside; during the scrapping process and coincident to the craze at the time of fitting compasses to cars, the two E2B Standby Compasses fitted to one particular aircraft "disappeared" during the dismantling process! These compasses were not "special to type" and were to be returned through the normal channels for use on other aircraft. Just before lunch on the day they had disappeared the flight commander assembled all the dis-mantling team, read them the "riot act" and advised that if the two missing compasses had not been returned by the time lunch was over, the RAF Police would be called in.

After lunch I accompanied the Flight Commander into the cockpit of the aircraft concerned to find both compasses refitted in their rightful places with a third lying on its side in the middle of the coaming! Somebody obviously took fright, but it was never established where the third one came from!

Fareastdriver 28th Feb 2018 10:07


My log book shows my last landing on 9th December, 865,
Could well be the 9th. I would fill in my log book monthly but when we shut down we were told that the Valiants had been grounded.

Somebody told me that when the Station Commander got the message he tried to phone ATC to stop everything. There was no reply so he drove around the airfield to tell them personally. That's when he met a Valiant coming the other way.

Fareastdriver 28th Feb 2018 10:17

Herod.


It records that 818 went to 32 MU at Hurn on 16 Jul 61 for modifications to a tanker
A fair number of Valiants were 'modified' as tankers. The fuelling and fuel delivery system was modified so that if a probe was fitted to the stub then all tanks could be refuelled from the probe. With this came the ability to pump underwing, forward. transfer and bomb bay tank, if fitted, fuel to a central point in the bomb bay. The obvious clue is the pipe housing that wraps around the cockpit so the fuel line does not go through the pressure cabin.

We picked up a 543 Sqn Valiant in about 1963 and it was on the line as a tanker within a week.

The Victor's did go through the cabin and one day the pipe sprang a leak. The crew found themselves up to their backsides in fuel so they went to emergency oxygen and flew it back. They tried to warn the ground crew about it but were unsuccessful. Somebody opened the door and found themselves staring up at eighteen inches of Avtur.

ian16th 28th Feb 2018 14:19


Originally Posted by Fareastdriver (Post 10067979)
Herod.

We picked up a 543 Sqn Valiant in about 1963 and it was on the line as a tanker within a week.

For the Vulcan that flew none-stop from Scampton to Sydney, 214 had to put Valiant's in Cyprus-Karachi-Singapore. We didn't have enough a/c, so we borrowed one from one of the other Marham Sqdn's, it was fitted with a HDU very quickly.

So as FED says, the basics must have been fitted earlier.

ian16th 1st Mar 2018 11:03

I rejoined 214 in Oct 64, returning to Marham as my posting of choice for my last 6 months of service. I was pleased to be assigned to my old squadron and see old friends, but it was a heartbreaking period.

There was very little flying and the a/c were subjected to daily 'anti-deterioration checks'. This for the radio trades was almost the same as a pre-flight.

From my point of view, the lack of work meant that when I requested leave for job interviews I got the days I wanted. So the demise of the Valiant had a small silver lining.

When I left RAF Marham, and 214 Sqdn for the second time, on Friday 5th February 1965 to commence my demob leave; the decision to scrap the Valiant had not reached the Squadrons.

I believe it happened the next week.

Fareastdriver 1st Mar 2018 13:55


5th February 1965 to commence my demob leave; the decision to scrap the Valiant had not reached the Squadrons.
Marham still had the Nato nuclear deterrent so politically there were still operational.

Daun Sauf at Honington we had already packed it in so I was fully occupied with Chipmunk WP850, at that time in a camouflage finish being ex Cyprus, running an air experience flight for all our squadron groundcrew.

Herod 4th Mar 2018 16:38

I was at Cosford today, and had a look at 818. There don't appear to be any multiple rows of rivets, and if I can I'll post a couple of photos. From what I can gather, the wings were removed when it was transported to Cosford, but this was just a case of dismantling and reassembling. No cutting involved. BTW, she still looks a pretty aeroplane.

Sorry, can't post pictures at the moment. Will try later.

rickyricks 5th May 2019 12:42

DTD 683
Just to set the record straight about the issues with the UK aluminium alloy DTD 683. This alloy was a refinement of an earlier alloy (DTD 363) and was a member of the 7xxx alloys (as designated today) and contained the major alloying elements zinc, copper and magnesium. The alloy was developed by High Duty Alloys, based in Slough where they had a large research and development centre. It was first shown to the public around 1937 and was given the trade name Hiduminium RR77. This alloy suffered from poor resistance to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) and was particularly prone to SCC as a result of quenched-in residual stresses. DTD 683 is strengthened by precipitation hardening - the formation of nano-meter sized intermetallic particles in the aluminium matrix by a combination of high temperature heat treatment, quenching and then ageing to form the precipitates. After quenching and ageing the residual stresses in the component were sufficient to drive SCC, hence the unused spars developing cracks during storage. It was this, rather than fatigue, that caused the failure of DTD 683 as used in the Valiant, although fatigue stresses in service obviously didn't help.
Note the USA developed a similar alloy, today known as AA7075, which contains a small chromium addition and Alcoa in America used this alloy successfully in the B29 Superfortress, amongst others. High Duty Alloys did not like the use of chromium as it tended to make the alloy less strong unless given a severe quench, which of course, increased the residual stresses. The UK alloy underwent various changes to composition and process, including chromium containing variants and boiling water quenching, but was ultimately dropped from use when over-aged tempers were developed which reduced the susceptibility of the American alloy to SCC, but did not work with the UK alloy due to the lower copper level used.
I understand the R&D effort of High Duty Alloys was led by one William Doyle who was apparently a very "colourful" gentleman in his time.

Wander00 6th May 2019 17:27

Anyone remember a nav by the name of Andy McHugh, sadly I believe no longer with us. Andy and I were in the same year at Harrow County School. He joined the RAF "direct entry" about the same time I went to the Towers. After the Valiants were grounded a party of "ex" Valiant aircrew came on a visit to Cranwell. Amongst them was Andy as a fg off with nav brevet, I was still ploughing through, but close to the end of, the Towers course. I always wondered where he went after that

Pontius Navigator 6th May 2019 19:57


Originally Posted by Wander00 (Post 10464730)
Anyone remember a nav by the name of Andy McHugh, sadly I believe no longer with us. Andy and I were in the same year at Harrow County School. He joined the RAF "direct entry" about the same time I went to the Towers. After the Valiants were grounded a party of "ex" Valiant aircrew came on a visit to Cranwell. Amongst them was Andy as a fg off with nav brevet, I was still ploughing through, but close to the end of, the Towers course. I always wondered where he went after that

Andy Mac Chuguhuff was posted to Javelins but fortunately they discovered an anthropomorphic incompatible - he would have lost his knees. Where he went after that for two tours I do not know but from the outset he was slated to be a radar operator and I next saw him of phantoms at Coningsby as a flt cdr. It is possible he had gone to Sea Vixen before F4.

JW411 7th May 2019 11:15

We had a Nav called Andy McHugh on 105 Sqn (Argosys) in Aden. Great chap but sadly no longer with us.

Pontius Navigator 7th May 2019 13:30

JW, so not Sea Vixens but Argosy when did he go then?

Wander00 8th May 2019 13:40

OK, Guys, many thanks. W

racingrigger 3rd Sep 2019 20:13

For HEROD _ I thought memory was playing tricks but having just been to Cosford and had a look at XD 818 the multiple rows of rivets securing the reinforcing skins for Op Grapple are indeed present. Look at the mainplanes outboard of the underwing tanks and you will see many, many rows of rivets from mid wing to trailing edge all the way outboard to the wing tip.

Fareastdriver 4th Sep 2019 12:30

When I was on 90 Sqn. in the early sixties I flew with Fred Jones. He was a keen cine enthusiast and would take moving pictures when ever he could. In 1963 we wen off to India and the Fareast on Exercise Shiksha. He made a movie of the occasion and his son gave me an electronic copy after Fred's death this year. I had doubts about sharing it but it is now on Youtube so it is in the public domain.

Sorry about that. I took a closer look at the Youtube entry and it states that it is not on the search menu and only available via a link. On that basis I have to consider it as private so I have deleted it.

hunterboy 5th Sep 2019 05:38

A pity about the link deletion as it sounds like a real piece of British aviation history, taken from the grass roots level rather than the Pathe propaganda perspective.

Wensleydale 5th Sep 2019 07:21

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....96bd957df1.jpg

ICM 5th Sep 2019 08:14

I clearly missed this thread back in May. Andy McHugh was with me on 21 Argosy Course, March - August 1966 and then, as mentioned, to 105 Sqn in Aden. The ARDET site shows his death as having been in July 2008.

ian16th 5th Sep 2019 14:57

https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....872c75a02f.jpg
214 at Gan 1960. Taking Javelins home after a SEATO exercise. The Brit is for us Erks to follow in.

ian16th 5th Sep 2019 14:58

https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....5d85919880.jpg
Jav's following the Valiant's.

ian16th 5th Sep 2019 15:01

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....f5c0c95fca.jpg
We started early, but the sun came up quickly on the Equator.

Shackman 5th Sep 2019 16:57

Nice pictures of Gan dispersal there Ian (Incidentally, I think some of the (now deleted) link were filmed at Gan as well - spent many two week stints on SAR standby in those huts).

Herod 5th Sep 2019 17:14

Racingrigger. Yes, I agree about the rivets fixing the reinforcing plates. I was at Cosford this afternoon, but my picture loading is playing up. Maybe later. However, I think the original conversation was concerning whether the wings had been riveted on after being removed for transportation to the museum. What was the thinking behind the strengthening plates? Was there concern about blast effect?

Fareastdriver 5th Sep 2019 17:30

I saw 818 in a semi dismantled state when it arrived at Cosford. The main spars had definitely been cut just outboard of the fuselage. I seem to remember from my Valiant conversion course that the basic structure was a reinforced cross that consisted of the fuselage backbone and the wing root structure out to the undercarriage mountings.

818 had been cut almost level with the fuselage skin.

Herod 5th Sep 2019 18:08

I think I know what you mean. There are rivets there. I'm not out for several weeks, but I'll check next time. If this works, a picture of the reinforcing panels.
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....afced4510c.jpg
And the wing/fuselage root.

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....2b08f0637e.jpg

Fareastdriver 5th Sep 2019 19:21

The rivets in front of the aileron look pretty standard to me. The engine panels underneath the engines the same. Any re-attaching wings to fuselage welding would have been hidden by the same panels.

Herod 5th Sep 2019 20:33

Fareastdriver: I'll give way to your knowledge on this. Apart from a valiant that visited RAAF Pearce when I was a teenager, this is the only example I've been up close and personal with. Regarding the riveted panels in the first picture, were they a standard part of the aircraft, or add-ons for the mission it undertook?

racingrigger 7th Sep 2019 16:51

When the 8 Valiants were modified in readiness for Op Grapple the outer wings were strengthened by double skinning (hence the multiple rows of rivets securing the extra skin). At the time it was suspected that the aircraft may have experienced severe turbulence as a result of the blast catching up with the departing aircraft - I believe all previous weapons tests had been carried out with the "bomb" mounted on a tower - this was to be the first air drop.

Herod 7th Sep 2019 17:02

Thanks, racingrigger. That would make sense. Always a day to learn something.


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:40.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.