PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   WWII carrier pigeon message discovered in Surrey chimney (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/499402-wwii-carrier-pigeon-message-discovered-surrey-chimney.html)

Tankertrashnav 24th Nov 2012 16:46

Capot - has it ever occurred to you that perhaps you have too much time on your hands? ;)

Capot 24th Nov 2012 17:32

TTN

Sprained ankle, bored........better by tomorrow! I did order myself to switch the damned thing off a little while ago, but disobeyed....

MightyGem 24th Nov 2012 21:02

No, no, capot is right. It was further developed after the war to counter not only getting lost, but also getting disorientated in cloud. As pigeons were found to be quite happy flying in all weathers, another bird had to be found to do the job; a duck. Combining the duck with a cat, for attitude control, led to the Cat and Duck method for recovering from inadvertent IMC.

Basic rules for the C&D Method of instrument flight are extremely simple. Here's how it's done:

1. Place a live cat on the cockpit floor; because a cat always remains upright. It can be used in lieu of a needle and ball. Merely watch to see which way the cat leans to determine if a wing is low and if so, which one.

2. The duck is used for instrument approach and landing. Because of the fact that any sensible duck will refuse to fly under instrument conditions, it is only necessary to hurl your duck out of the plane and follow it to the ground.

November4 24th Nov 2012 22:47

Noooooo!

You can't be saying that Capot's tale isn't true

Capot 25th Nov 2012 11:41

Now see here, sunshine,

On a serious historical note
means what it says. Every word is Gospel truth. Those little unsung heroes deserve a medal, not doubting Thomas's.

MadsDad 25th Nov 2012 11:45

Regarding pigeon guidance systems:-

"During WW II, Project Pigeon (later Project Orcon, for "organic control") was American behaviorist B.F. Skinner's attempt to develop a pigeon-guided missile. The control system involved a lens at the front of the missile projecting an image of the target to a screen inside, while a pigeon trained (by operant conditioning) to recognize the target pecked at it. As long as the pecks remained in the center of the screen, the missile would fly straight, but pecks off-center would cause the screen to tilt, which would then, via a connection to the missile's flight controls, cause the missile to change course and slowly travel towards its designated target/s."

millerscourt 25th Nov 2012 11:47

Too much time on his hands says Tankertrashnav with 1475 Posts:{

Tankertrashnav 25th Nov 2012 12:01

Guilty as charged :O

sitigeltfel 25th Nov 2012 12:04

Take it to the Papua New Guinea embassy. They will know someone who understands Pidgin language.

Capot 25th Nov 2012 12:18


watch to see which way the cat leans to determine if a wing is low and if so, which one.
With my old man's words ringing in my ears (he was also involved in those trials) I realise that this was just a slip of the pen, but the younger and less aware among us may need to have it pointed out that the cat's angle of lean indicated the amount by which the aircraft was slipping, and not which wing was down; in a perfect turn the cat would, of course, remain upright in the same way as a cabin attendant remains upright (in a turn, not in the slip hotel, of course).

The turn itself was indicated by the movement of the pigeon on the panel, which would also provide a coarse VS indication; as it pointed to the destination its little beak would move up in a descent, and vice versa.*


*Unless the destination was 91 - 269 degrees from the aircraft heading, in which case the beak's vertical angle would indicate the reverse, obviously.

Milo Minderbinder 25th Nov 2012 14:43


Traffic_Is_Er_Was 25th Nov 2012 23:52

Obviously the ability to debrief the pigeon after a mission was quite limited.

500N 26th Nov 2012 00:01

All you need is someone who can speak pigeon english !

Wensleydale 26th Nov 2012 07:25

Capot,

There is photographic evidence of the pigeon trials from Boscombe Down .... However, the early flights were carried out with a dog rather than a cat. I hope that your detractors will appologise!

http://i.ebayimg.com/t/DASTARDLY-MUT...B5Y4Q~~_35.JPG

NutLoose 26th Nov 2012 17:03


albatross

Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Canada
Posts: 390
They had a story on it on ABC National News in the US of A yesterday evening.

Can You Help Spies Crack ‘Impossible’ WWII Pigeon Code? - ABC News
No doubt it will be solved by a 9 year old autistic boy called Simon..

ORAC 16th Dec 2012 14:47

Has the D-Day pigeon riddle been cracked?

A coded message from the Second World War found tied to the remains of a carrier pigeon in a chimney contains details of German tank movements sent by a British soldier, a team of Canadian researchers believe.

TEEEJ 16th Dec 2012 18:37

Some more info from the BBC news website.


Gord Young, from Peterborough, in Ontario, says it took him 17 minutes to decypher the message after realising a code book he inherited was the key.

Mr Young says the 1944 note uses a simple World War I code to detail German troop positions in Normandy.
BBC News - Has World War II carrier pigeon message been cracked?

November4 16th Dec 2012 19:32


He believes it was written by 27-year-old Sgt William Stott, a Lancashire Fusilier, who had been dropped into Normandy - with pigeons - to report on German positions. Sgt Stott was killed a few weeks later and is buried in a Normandy war cemetery.
According to the CWGC, there is no Sgt Stott buried in Normandy.There is a Fusilier William Stott.

FlightlessParrot 17th Dec 2012 00:29

That 'decryption' is about as useful as the 'decipherings' which 'prove' that Bacon wrote Shakespeare.

Imagine you're waiting in Britain for the brave pigeon to bring the message from the undoubtedly brave observer, and you got that. 42 is a better answer.

Sallyann1234 17th Dec 2012 09:24

I have always wondered how a spy could travel around occupied France carrying a pigeon. Wasn't it just a tad suspicious?


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:13.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.