PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Helicopter downed over Damascus (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/493999-helicopter-downed-over-damascus.html)

tonker 27th Aug 2012 17:13

Helicopter downed over Damascus
 
A couple of videos showing a Mil 4(edited) getting shot down over the once Christian city of Damascus.

http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=4ad_1346051433

Fareastdriver 27th Aug 2012 17:41

Unless I am mistaken that is a Mil 4 Helicopter. They go back to the early fifties. Lots of Avgas to catch fire.

Courtney Mil 27th Aug 2012 17:46

Well it's not exactly HDTV, but the cabin looks quite long, so I would have thought a Hip. Correct me if I'm wrong, Tonker, wasn't the old Mil 4 more like a Wessex? Shorter cab? Does Syria (or anyone) still fly them?

Questions, not disagreements.

Tiger_mate 27th Aug 2012 18:16

A Mil4 is more akin to a Whirlwind. It certainly looks like an Mi4 on some footage I have seen and white in colour which is hardly military spec. The cab will be no loss, the crew however......

Notwithstanding whose side they were on, the loss of aviators is never pretty.

Trim Stab 27th Aug 2012 18:25

More likely to be a Mil 2 Hoplite.

Mil4 really too old.


Update - some still photos elsewhere show five-blade so can't be Mil 2 or Mil 4 - must be an 8 or 17.

Fareastdriver 27th Aug 2012 18:33

My comment is based on the fact that I have seen both types in the air and it looks a lot more like a 4 than an 8. I agree with Trimstab that it could be a 2.

AirShowJunkie 27th Aug 2012 18:47

On the Daily Fail's website they have a half decent image. Looks like a Mil 14.

Rosevidney1 27th Aug 2012 18:58

And I reckon with a 5 blade rotor it is a Mil Mi 8/17 Hip.

Fareastdriver 27th Aug 2012 19:26

I have found something on Sky News here:Syria Army Helicopter 'Shot Down' In Damascus

Stopping it 0.08 secs just before impact shows that what appears to be two three bladed rotors at the point of overlapping which would make it a Karmov.

heli-cal 27th Aug 2012 20:07

For murdering their own citizens, the crew deserved everything they got.

Tourist 27th Aug 2012 20:16

Airshowjunkie

An Mi14.

Seriously?!

Not, perhaps, the most conventional helicopter for the role, but hey...:rolleyes:

ORAC 27th Aug 2012 20:18

Orbat - probably an Mi-2, the others being transports.

Tourist 27th Aug 2012 20:23

A Mi8/17 is just as likely to carry weapons as a Mi2 Hoplite.

The "kamov" effect is just a video camera artefact.

TEEEJ 27th Aug 2012 20:29

Definitely a Mil 8/17 Hip. 5 blades.


AirShowJunkie 27th Aug 2012 20:32

Tourist,

A Mil 8. I'll get me coat!

Nige321 27th Aug 2012 20:32

Report here of a Mil24

Ivan Rogov 27th Aug 2012 21:10

Cabin well alight after departing controlled flight, not a nice way to go, hope they deserved it :\

Oh, cert Mil 17, remedial recce for everyone :E

Tashengurt 27th Aug 2012 21:25

Looked very much like a 17 to me but I'm no steely eyed killer.

parabellum 27th Aug 2012 23:43

One picture I saw yesterday just after being hit showed it alight at the base, rear of cabin by the fillet that leads up to the tail boom, quite a prenounced nose and at least a five bladed rotor.

Tiger_mate 28th Aug 2012 05:31

The fire appears to start on the starboard weapons pylon which with external fuel tanks adjacent to it is quite a recipe. The Mi17 only stores fuel internally when equipped with ferry tanks. This could have its origins in a malfunction rather then a shoot down but the spin and hype is inevitable.


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:36.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.