PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Kinloss glows in the dark. (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/485762-kinloss-glows-dark.html)

Al R 18th May 2012 21:59

Kinloss glows in the dark.
 
BBC News - Investigation into radioactive contamination concerns at RAF Kinloss



.. a review of the quality of the land at RAF Kinloss was already under way, ahead of the transfer of the base to the Army.
Bet they can't wait..!

Runaway Gun 18th May 2012 22:35

Imagine the low carbon footprint, if no outside lighting nor heating is required ;)

500N 18th May 2012 22:40

Reminds me of a certain suburb here which made a big song and dance
about Nuclear Free Zone when it was all trendy, putting up signs and
everything else.

One sign as you entered the suburb was right out the front of the Hospital
and if you looked at the hospital entrance, you would see the names of the
departments - including X Ray and Radiology !

newt 19th May 2012 08:50

Just proves the point that we should keep all our old aircraft and not let the engineers burn them up!!:ok:

airpolice 19th May 2012 09:21

It would take something like buckets of instant sunshine to Kinloss glow.

green granite 19th May 2012 09:29

This sounds typical of the BBC, making environmental mountains out of molehills, deliberately hyped up to stir up the locals before any proper survey of the extent of the problem is conducted, as well as expecting the MOD to have applied today's level of safety and envoiromental risk documentation at the end of a war that had killed several million people. :ugh:

NutLoose 19th May 2012 10:08

No problem, they could bottle the local water and sell it as Peckham Spring :O

Fareastdriver 19th May 2012 12:34

When I started flying we had U/V, Red lights and Luminous markings in the cockpit. With a total electric failure at night, no standbye, one flew with your nose agains the luminous markings on the instruments.
Years ago the Standardisers insisted that helicopter pilots moved around an active dispersal with their helmets removed to prevent them walking into tail rotors. As a result of this I was awarded a lump sum (£4,500) for subsequent hearing loss.

HOW MUCH CAN I CLAIM FOR BEING SUBJECTED TO RADIOACTIVE EMISSIONS?

Stuart Sutcliffe 19th May 2012 13:52


No problem, they could bottle the local water and sell it as Peckham Spring http://images.ibsrv.net/ibsrv/res/sr...s/embarass.gif
Nope! That would create a problem. The name 'Peckham Spring' is already trademarked, and bottles of it are on sale from the corner shop across the road from Nelson Mandela house. The shop often has a crappy yellow Reliant Regal parked outside, with a suitcase strapped to the roof .....

5aday 19th May 2012 14:39

It could be the Findhorn Foundation spreading rumours before the pongos finally take over.

Agaricus bisporus 19th May 2012 17:38

As if the amount of radium involved in even a thousand aircraft was significant. On the same proportions as squealing "drowning hazard" when they find a damp tissue...

This is surely just another idiotic example of the massive job creation scheme that is the scottish parliament and all the stupidity that goes with it. All they want is $squillions in "compensation" from the MoD for a pointless job-creation "clean-up" and a big dollop of smug self publicity for the risibly named scottish Environmental Protection Agency. And, of course, never miss an opportunity to take a cheap shot at the "English" for being the cause of all their problems. As if.

What a pointless, stupid, criminal waste of money all that doubled-up bureaucracy is in a recession when we should be reducing the parasites in government, not generating entire new species of them!

NutLoose 19th May 2012 18:06

I seem to remember Basingstoke had similar problems with the site of an old Smiths Factory that produced wartime instruments.

Found it

http://www2.basingstoke.gov.uk/test/...4/00842465.PDF

draken55 19th May 2012 18:07

"What a pointless, stupid, criminal waste of money all that doubled-up bureaucracy is in a recession"

In their favour, our MSP's are amalgamating all the current Police Services in favour of an all Scottish one with the Fire Service next in line. Do not be surprised if soon after that, the many pointless District Councils we were landed with (by the last Conservative Government) in 1997 go. With an Edinburgh Parliament, there's not a lot left for them to do.

BTW SEPA apply the Law as it applies across the UK. The issue at Kinloss is over land already sold by the MOD and doubt that required procedures were carried out to render it usable by others. This differs from the problem at Dalgety Bay in Fife where surplus WW2 aircraft had been dumped and radium particles are now being found on the beach.

grousehunter 19th May 2012 19:25

As far as I am aware SEPA have known about this for years, so not sure why it's suddenly news.

draken55 19th May 2012 19:46

It's probably "news" because someone chose to make it so. Issuing a press release to drum up media interest not too long after the Dalgety Bay story cant help but keep SEPA in the Public eye when it's Budget is under scrutiny!

Al R 20th May 2012 17:46

Blister Agent too..?

BBC News - Chemical weapon 'risk' at RAF Kinloss in Moray


RAF Kinloss authorities knew the public could be at risk from chemical weapons buried near the base, according to documents obtained by BBC Scotland. The Moray base is already the focus of an investigation into radioactive contamination. A 2004 land quality assessment also warned sulphur mustard chemical weapons may be present within landfill and waste areas accessible to the public.
Stashes found near Cott a while back as I recall.

crippen 20th May 2012 18:57

Trimphone glows also
 
There was also some concern about the luminescent dial that glowed green in the dark. This effect came from a small glass tube of tritium gas, which gave off beta radiation and made the dial fluoresce. Although the radioactivity was equivalent only to that given off by a wristwatch it was felt wise to withdraw this facility as public concern over radioactivity grew.
Trimphone - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Wonder where all the old ones are stored.:confused:

BEagle 20th May 2012 19:28

Ah yes, the good old Trimphone! We had a couple of those back in the early 1970s.

A little known feature was that the microphone wasn't at the end of the handset, there was a transducer somewhere in the middle of the handset connected by a stethoscope-type tube to the speaking end. So if someone put their hand over the 'microphone' to prevent you hearing what they were saying to a third party, you could in fact still hear every word!

Windy Militant 20th May 2012 19:29


Wonder where all the old ones are stored.
Some were sealed in drums and dumped at sea.
Some were buried at Harwell, recently they were dug up, there was a great big inflatable tent erected over the excavations whilst they were removed and sent to Sellafield, where I believe they were dismantled and the Tritium recovered.
Apparently Harwell had broken the disposal regs by burying them, and were fined by Wantage Magistrates court.

NutLoose 20th May 2012 20:16

Ahhh the Trimphone, not deemed a hazard as such on its own, so what did they do when disposing of them, they put them all together, thus making them a Hazard. :D:ugh:

Shackman 20th May 2012 22:04

If they're worried about Kinloss, maybe they should start looking around Lossie as well - the number of aircraft scrapped there were considerably more than at Kinloss. Apparently the fields around the base were a great place for all the local kids to play at being bomber pilots - complete with their own bombers!

Beeline4 21st May 2012 04:54

Not sure if I am in the right forum here, but I wondered if anyone can help me. I am trying to find out some historical information about vehicles, objects and aircraft that were buried at WWII Dunino Airfield, (also known as Jackdaw II), in Fife during the 1940's/50's?

Fareastdriver 21st May 2012 09:53

Another good site would be RAF Edzell. My father delivered brand new Halifaxs there after the war to be broken up. When he was on 202 Sqn at Aldergove using Halifaxs for Met observation in the Atlantic they would fly to Dyce; send some airman down to Edzell to get some bits; and then fly back to Aldergrove

airpolice 21st May 2012 11:11

Beeline4, we could tell you, but then we'd need to kill you.

LowObservable 21st May 2012 11:22

NutLoose - My mum worked at the Basingstoke plant (then Kelvins) in 1940-41, inspecting altimeters.

Unkind people have suggested that this explains a lot, but they generally STFU when I shoot gamma rays from my eyes and set their ties on fire.

Doctor Cruces 21st May 2012 15:54

Draken 55 shows, yet again, the appalling general public understanding of what his district council (if it's not been unified yet) actually does.

He's probably bought firmly into the myth (that so many PPRuNers subscribe to) that tea drinking and doing bugger all else sits high on their work day duties.

draken55 21st May 2012 16:49

Doctor C

Until 1974 we had an efficient well run Unitary County Council for Ayrshire. It was abolished by the Conservative Government and replaced by a number of District Councils responsible for some functions with others becoming the responsibility of the Ayr Division of the huge Strathclyde Region.

In 1997 the District and Regional Council's were in turn abolished by the then Conservative Government. In Ayrshire they were replaced by three Unitary District Councils. Not long after, Devolution meant we got the Parliament in Edinburgh.

I am not questioning what needs to be done just where and how many it takes to do it! Is that so wrong?

Al R 6th Aug 2013 23:12

BBC News - Findhorn sand dune radiation testing begins

How do you decontaminate as much real estate potentially, as bad as this without spending more money than it would cost to close the place?


The land at Kinloss is no longer owned by the Ministry of Defence but..
?

Sandy Parts 7th Aug 2013 08:26

Large parts of the WWII airfield were sold off after the war and other bits have been 'sliced' off since. The area closest to Findhorn was sold to the Findhorn Foundation - home to the local hippy and anti-nuclear community. I'm sure some lawyers will be preparing a case against the MoD for 'past actions' even as we speak. This issue would seem to underline why the MoD doesn't sell off bases anymore - the legislation requiring ALL contamination be removed from the land would make it too costly.

teeteringhead 7th Aug 2013 09:11


Reminds me of a certain suburb here which made a big song and dance
about Nuclear Free Zone when it was all trendy,
Rather like Greenwich (London) used to do.

Pity no-one told them about the baby reactor (for training engineers) in the Naval College! ......:E

glad rag 7th Aug 2013 09:24


Originally Posted by draken55 (Post 7202719)
Doctor C

Until 1974 we had an efficient well run Unitary County Council for Ayrshire. It was abolished by the Conservative Government and replaced by a number of District Councils responsible for some functions with others becoming the responsibility of the Ayr Division of the huge Strathclyde Region.

In 1997 the District and Regional Council's were in turn abolished by the then Conservative Government. In Ayrshire they were replaced by three Unitary District Councils. Not long after, Devolution meant we got the Parliament in Edinburgh.

I am not questioning what needs to be done just where and how many it takes to do it! Is that so wrong?

:D:D:D:D:D

Far, far too many layers of self perpetuating bureaucratic non-sense in this country.

TomJoad 7th Aug 2013 09:33


Originally Posted by airpolice (Post 7198502)
It would take something like buckets of instant sunshine to Kinloss glow.


I hear it became all the brighter when you left.:ok:

Loved the place, little bit of heaven on Earth, especially for outdoor sports.

TomJoad 7th Aug 2013 09:38


originally posted by Agaricus bisporus

This is surely just another idiotic example of the massive job creation scheme that is the scottish parliament and all the stupidity that goes with it. All they want is $squillions in "compensation" from the MoD for a pointless job-creation "clean-up" and a big dollop of smug self publicity for the risibly named scottish Environmental Protection Agency. And, of course, never miss an opportunity to take a cheap shot at the "English" for being the cause of all their problems. As if.


Wow ! Upset of Tumbridge Wells, you even managed to get a pop at the Scottish Government and SEPA out of this. Did somobody drop you on the head as a baby!:p

just another jocky 7th Aug 2013 10:30


Originally Posted by Sandy Parts
This issue would seem to underline why the MoD doesn't sell off bases anymore.....

So the announcements that they're selling the airfield at Wyton are wrong then? In which case, why is there a survey team out there right now, drilling holes all over the airfield? :confused:

Sandy Parts 7th Aug 2013 11:59

maybe the 'survey team' at Wyton are assessing the contamination prior to the actual sale? As this report says (Land Contamination: Technical Guidance on Special Sites: MoD Land R&D Technical Report P5-042/TR/01):

"Many MoD sites were closed and decommissioned to standards of the day which may not have been consistent with current standards. Such sites may still be within MoD ownership. Historically surveys were conducted which concentrated on live munitions on the surface, but such surveys may not have addressed fully the potential risks from residual raw materials or from buried munitions.
A survey of an Armament Depot revealed that the majority of process buildings had been closed without decommissioning the plant, which was found to be contaminated with explosive residues. Soils surrounding the process buildings were found to contain explosive residues. At the time of investigation, this site was in MoD ownership."

Wonder which dept picks up the bill for any clean-up :ugh:

Davef68 7th Aug 2013 12:04


Originally Posted by glad rag (Post 7980774)
:D:D:D:D:D

Far, far too many layers of self perpetuating bureaucratic non-sense in this country.

In Scotland, there are only two, the Scottish Government, and the local Councils (All Unitary). I would argue that some of the councils are too small to be effective, but equally a lot of their functions (waste management, street lighthing etc) would not work if managed on a national basis.

Prior to the 76 reorganisation things were still two-tier (Lots of little Burgh councils doing things and duplicating management and admin).

As for SEPA, they do some of the functions that the EA do in England, but also a lot of the pollution and contamination things that are done by ~ 200 local Councils in England (Economies of scale again)

Anyway, back on topic, the problem with radium is when behind glass in instruments as it wasn't going to be ingested. It is especially hazardous when ingested/absorbed.as it accumulates in the bones.

Radium | Radiation Protection | US EPA

TomJoad 7th Aug 2013 12:17


Originally Posted by just another jocky (Post 7980893)
So the announcements that they're selling the airfield at Wyton are wrong then? In which case, why is there a survey team out there right now, drilling holes all over the airfield? :confused:

Guys no need to get in a tizzy about this it is all quite simple and regular. Before any agency (MoD, industrial or otherwise) ceases operations on a particular site and sells it on it has to undertake a process called remediation. Upon disposal the remediation certificate simply provides assurances that the land has been cleared of any toxic or harmful products or substances arising from its previous use. You would not want your son, grandson etc digging up an old bomb fuze while playing in the garden on the new housing estate now would you. So, all rather sensible in the end.

If Wyton has been sold and is currently in the hands of a developer then you will find its remediation process was rather straightforward with no real nasties being found. Simples!

just another jocky 7th Aug 2013 12:26

TJ - no tizzy m8, it's just that Sandy P simply stated "...the MoD doesn't sell off bases anymore..." and I was querying that as a fact. Perhaps I could have done a clearer job of that. :\

The airfield at Wyton has not been sold, yet.

TomJoad 7th Aug 2013 12:39


Originally Posted by just another jocky (Post 7981065)
TJ - no tizzy m8, it's just that Sandy P simply stated "...the MoD doesn't sell off bases anymore..." and I was querying that as a fact. Perhaps I could have done a clearer job of that. :\

The airfield at Wyton has not been sold, yet.


No worries fella, wasn't taking a dig sorry if it came across like that. From what I recall when I was down in those parts the Wyton airfield had alreday been partly sold/leased - lots of civil engineering sundries in storage or something on the airfield. What about the old HQ Logs site are the IPTs still in the pavillions?

just another jocky 7th Aug 2013 17:55

TJ - most/all moved out AFAIK. The new Pathfinder building is very impressive though and a great aid for student/AEF pilots when trying to locate the airfield from afar. Lots of dark blue & camo green uniforms invading the place now too. At least they painted the 'berra so they wont replace it with a tank or something else similarly inappropriate & the mess has a nice set of aviation pictures in it still. :ok:

Airfield definitely not sold.....yet.


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:23.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.