PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Stealth UH60(?) used in OBL raid... (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/450526-stealth-uh60-used-obl-raid.html)

chopper2004 17th May 2015 21:21

Back in action?
 
http://theaviationist.com/2015/05/17...pter-in-syria/

Cheers

Lonewolf_50 18th May 2015 13:55

chopper, the author notes that little is known, and then embarks on a pile of speculation.

/tongue in cheek
And as we all know, Delta Force doesn't really exist
/tongue in cheek

Mechta 18th May 2015 19:24

There's always the possibility in the OBL raid, that after the hit itself, a sizable piece of a redundant experimental helicopter was dropped on the site (maybe from one of the CH-47s reportedly involved in the raid) to:

  1. Make an iconic photo opportunity of an otherwise pretty nondescript location.
  2. Give other nations the impression that the Americans were further ahead with putting stealth helicopters into service than they really were.
  3. Add a significant amount of 'wow-factor' to the story.
  4. Establish the level of co-operation between the Pakistanis/Chinese and/or others, before the subsequent retrieval of the 'wreckage'.
The Americans would have been well aware that the wreckage would soon be inspected by knowledgable foreign parties, thus a film set type mock-up would have been rapidly outed. Whatever was left behind would have had to be pretty convincing.

chopper2004 19th May 2015 16:04

@Lonewolf,

Lol, you mean the 303rd Logistical Studies Group led by Lt Col Tom Ryan a.k.a The Terminator with Snake Doctor, Betty Blue, Cool Breeze, Dirt Driver.

@Mechta,

Ref your synopsis on the MH-47E dropping a nice tail rotor got one thinking and found another related link by the Aviationist, w.r.t related matter below

The Aviationist » The Stealth Chinook involved in the Osama Bin Laden raid and why the Stealth Black Hawk crashed in Abbottabad

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g2...pso5mbgnhp.jpg

Cheers

Surplus 19th May 2015 22:41

Google earth has some interesting past images at the Tarbela Dam airfield, some 60 clicks SW of Abbottabad. (Should Pakistan ever be implicated in assisting the raid and that the raid was announced prematurely after the loss of a helo during the op.) :hmm:

Surplus 20th May 2015 15:12

What, nobody going to deny, ridicule?

Tourist 20th May 2015 15:14

I'm more than willing to ridicule if I had any idea what you are on about.

Type with clarity and add links, and I promise to ridicule as requested.

Surplus 20th May 2015 15:26

I apologise for my lack of clarity, your Google must be broken.

BossEyed 20th May 2015 16:30

Ah, right. You give us a job and we all immediately rush off and do it to your satisfaction.

Seems fair enough.

Tourist 20th May 2015 18:32

I'm willing to ridicule, but not interested in expending any effort in the process.

Seems like I'm in the majority.

Mechta 20th May 2015 21:25

Chopper2004,

Thanks for the type correction (MH-47E).

I'll believe there is such a thing as a 'stealth Chinook' when I don't hear it.:}

As an idle thought, would a fuselage stretch to prevent the front/rear blade overlap, reduce the distinctive 'thump, thump, thump' that the Chinook produces?

chopper2004 8th Dec 2015 11:39

Worth a read perhaps?
 
Book Reveals New Details About Stealth Black Hawks Used In Bin Laden Raid

cheers

SASless 8th Dec 2015 12:30

Making the Wokka Stealthy is easy....try doing that for the Huey!

Pontius Navigator 8th Dec 2015 12:41

Mechta, as the tread has been resurected, you don't so much as hear a CH47 as feel it.

Same with the other big 'uns. Used to watch cattle vacate a target area long before you could see the helos.

chopper2004 7th Feb 2019 10:50

1978 Technical Report
 


Looks like the answer lies as far back as 4 decades ....


Origins Of Stealth Black Hawks Date Back Over 30 Years Before The Bin Laden Raid - The Drive

intersting report dated as far back to 1978 titles ‘Structural Concepts And Aerodynamic Analysis For Low Radar Cross Section (LRCS) Fuselage Configurations’


https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....a45eb6958.jpeg


https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....f45231e3e.jpeg


https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....a3a7349fe.jpeg

Lonewolf_50 7th Feb 2019 22:03

Thanks for the update. Tyler must have done his homework, so good for him.

megan 7th Feb 2019 22:44

Stealth helo has been around for a while.

https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/23...n-vietnam.html

tartare 8th Feb 2019 01:23

Thing looks like a flying Zumwalt!
With a cross section like that - no wonder it handles like a pig...!

chopper2004 10th Feb 2019 22:30

Low Observable Little Bird
 

Originally Posted by megan (Post 10383617)
Stealth helo has been around for a while.

https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/23...n-vietnam.html

The Aviationist speculates that it could be conceivable also to have a L/O Little Bird and sets out how one could look like:

https://theaviationist.com/2011/05/2...h-little-bird/

https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....e3bde5569.jpeg
cheers

chopper2004 1st May 2019 14:14

On this day 8 years ago
 
Just twigged on this day 8 years ago, Neptune Spear happened.

Cheers

Haraka 1st May 2019 16:06


Originally Posted by chopper2004 (Post 10460554)
Just twigged on this day 8 years ago, Neptune Spear happened.

Cheers

And STILL no sign of the Stealth Blackhawk :)

melmothtw 1st May 2019 16:35


Originally Posted by Haraka (Post 10460630)
And STILL no sign of the Stealth Blackhawk :)

That's kind of the point, no?

ORAC 18th Mar 2020 08:31

https://www.militarytimes.com/news/y...he-first-time/

Exclusive: Legendary special operations aviator reveals bin Laden mission details for the first time

Tashengurt 18th Mar 2020 21:42

I still think it was a handy excuse for Pakistan allowing the raid to happen.

MightyGem 18th Mar 2020 21:48

Thanks for that, ORAC. Very impressive.

Lonewolf_50 18th Mar 2020 21:53


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 10718346)
https://www.militarytimes.com/news/y...he-first-time/

Exclusive: Legendary special operations aviator reveals bin Laden mission details for the first time

From the article .....

Twice between 2013 and 2016, Englen was in hot pursuit of Iran’s Quds Force leader, Gen. Qassem Soleimani. But their order was “capture only.”
"It wasn’t ‘capture or kill,’ so if we couldn’t guarantee a capture, then we couldn’t take it to the next level,” Englen said. “But we were minutes behind him and his vehicles in Iraq, and we could’ve gotten him. But our rules of engagement was, 'capture only.’”
I suspected as much. I am both glad that my guess was correct, and disappointed that stuff like this is being discussed in open sources.

Haraka 24th May 2020 18:23

",,,,,,,and STILL no sign of the StealthBlackhawkhttps://www.pprune.org/images/smilies/smile.gif"
see my #181
And yet another year goes by................

ORAC 24th May 2020 19:23

Over 20 years since the last flight of the SR-71 and no sight of the TR-3 or the Aurora or whatever made the soap-on-a-rope contrails far above the airways off the West coast...

gums 24th May 2020 19:39

Salute!


Over 20 years since the last flight of the SR-71 and no sight of the TR-3 or the Aurora or whatever made the soap-on-a-rope contrails far above the airways off the West coast...
A great point, frequent poster. Been 9 years since the UBL raid, so guess there's been no effort to develop and field new, improved systems for covert and not so covert missions. We don't even know the exact configuration of the choppers used back then.

I wonder why the Guardian or Sun or NYT or WaPo doesn't have accurate scale diagrams of every bend and curve and angle on the platforms that the U.S. or any other country wishes to remain "secret". /sarc

And then the DuPont company or 3M could have their patent for their new, improved RAM coatings that have been developed and fielded since the late 70's and early 80's when one country seemed to have made a quantum leap in LO technology. Huh? Oooops, shouldn't have mentioned "quantum"....... Now waiting for the visit from men in black, sheesh....

Gums sends...





LowObservable 24th May 2020 20:29

I could tell you, but then I'd have to use a horrible old cliche from a movie about shirtless male beach volleyball that had some airplanes in it.

What I learned over many years is that the Gummint is very good at keeping certain things secret. Also, given the rather large piles of cash that have gone into such things, compared to the visible results we have seen, either something else was produced that we don't know about or somebody's got some splainin to do about where the **** that money went.

Jamesel 24th May 2020 20:35

The size of the money is hard to keep stealthy. The shapes it goes into can be several orders of magnitude harder to see.

gums 24th May 2020 21:36

Salute!

Enjoying the banter, today. But let's not forget the meaning of the holiday, huh?

'Follow the money". Yep, that's how the Aurora thread got started, wasn't it?

The best bet to see where a neat project was in progress was to follow the construction $$$ at Tonopah in early 80's. Maybe not easy to find in the annual budget, but all those trucks and semi-tractors loaded with stuff had to be a clue if you had a trailer park closeby, huh? Groom Lake was well known by all of us by then, but we didn't know exactly what the platforms were flying there (except for the saucers), and only knew a few of the pilots. We also knew many of the Constant Peg folks and some of us actually flew against them to "learn" some things. The heavy traffic was at Tonopah for both Constant Peg as well as the F-117 outfit. Some folks thot Michael AAF at Dugway couild have been a player, but not me. I was flying in that area then and can tellya that the strip was bare bones and nothing was going on. Not so with Tonopah.

I still haven't figured out how you can make a helo "stealthy". Guess the wizards have been very successful last 30 years since I was close to the business.

Gums sends...




ORAC 24th May 2020 22:23

:cool: :cool: :cool:


tartare 24th May 2020 22:53


Originally Posted by LowObservable (Post 10792316)
I could tell you, but then I'd have to use a horrible old cliche from a movie about shirtless male beach volleyball that had some airplanes in it.

What I learned over many years is that the Gummint is very good at keeping certain things secret. Also, given the rather large piles of cash that have gone into such things, compared to the visible results we have seen, either something else was produced that we don't know about or somebody's got some splainin to do about where the **** that money went.

Indeed.
One fact remains.
That tail-rotor, stabilator and the colour of them wasn't like anything in the current inventory at all.
The tail rotor boss was clearly aimed at reducing radar reflectivity - anyone seen anything like that on a helicopter before?
And the photo wasn't a fake.
As Gums points out - many, many people knew something was going on at Tonapah quite early in the piece.
But images of the F-117 didn't make it into the media for a long time.
And today - we all know there's something called the B-21 being built - the iron bird's been finished for a while.
But can anyone yet show me a real photo of it yet?
I have no doubt that there is some kind of LO Blackhawk or something similar - albeit in very small numbers...

Fonsini 25th May 2020 08:54

I always found this to be the most likely preview of things to come.


chopper2004 25th May 2020 17:32


Originally Posted by Fonsini (Post 10792690)
I always found this to be the most likely preview of things to come.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lSGLBb3k80U

Flying doritos more like LRS-B fly off a.k.a L-M and Boeing tad annoyed with decision to purchase Northrop B-21 Raider

cheers

gums 25th May 2020 19:03

Salute!

Don't think so, Fonz....

If you can see it and get a photo, then it must be intentional subterfuge, and we have to keep folks looking for ghosts. Huh?

Gums sends...




chopper2004 25th May 2020 20:07


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 10792253)
Over 20 years since the last flight of the SR-71 and no sight of the TR-3 or the Aurora or whatever made the soap-on-a-rope contrails far above the airways off the West coast...

Thing is though laughingly about Aurora, it was few years ago L-M announced SR-72 development

https://www.airforce-technology.com/...-71-spy-plane/

https://www.businessinsider.com/sr-7...18-1?r=US&IR=T

Then retracted the idea..

https://www.flightglobal.com/singapo...127007.article

unmanned_droid 26th May 2020 13:21

I still think that they were just mod-heavy uh60s, maybe with a completely different tailboom as that would be relatively easy to change out.

Lonewolf_50 27th May 2020 02:53


Originally Posted by unmanned_droid (Post 10793881)
I still think that they were just mod-heavy uh60s, maybe with a completely different tailboom as that would be relatively easy to change out.

Define what you mean by 'relatively easy' about UH-60 Tail boom replacement.


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:31.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.