PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Merry Christmas From China (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/437813-merry-christmas-china.html)

TEEEJ 31st Dec 2010 20:56

Comparison with J-10. It would appear that the J-20 is around the length of an Su-27?

http://www.centurychina.com/plaboard...1e0cdae342.jpg

TJ

TabulaRasa 31st Dec 2010 21:28

There's some cockpit photos here: Welcome to China Defense.com

subsonicsubic 1st Jan 2011 08:55

Congratulations PRC!

It looks awesome, even if its full capabilities may not be understood yet.

A well managed economy affords the developments of sexy equipment and this is a lesson to our politicians and bean-counters.

Best,

SSS

Load Toad 1st Jan 2011 09:50

Funny innit. When 'they' build a new 'plane its going to be ace and cause all sorts of mither but if we build a new 'plane the radar won't work the thing hasn't enough fuel, made of the wrong materials by cheap sub contractors, missiles fly backwards, bombs aren't smart, can't carry enough of anything too many crew, can't land on a carrier, too heavy, lacks commonality, can't communicate, made of peas, underpowered, not enough cup holders, smells of wee....

Stitchbitch 1st Jan 2011 10:25

LT, I wouldn't be too worried, half the kids christmas presents have broken already, and they were made in China. :E
On the flipside, at least they have a large manufacturing base and economy of scale, so they are able to do this sort of thing. I doubt we'd be able to produce anything more than a UCAV (or whatever they are called this month) in the future. Looks a little like the old Mig below mated with an F-23.
http://www.strangemilitary.com/image...ent/170133.jpg

ORAC 3rd Jan 2011 16:35

Ares: Every Day, It's a-Getting Closer

http://sitelife.aviationweek.com/ver...5de5a.Full.jpg

The most recent imagery from Chengdu shows further progress toward first flight, with the nosewheel off the ground. At the same time, Chinese defense bloggers have pulled up an image of an experimental simulator cockpit that emerged a couple of years ago:

http://sitelife.aviationweek.com/ver...5bf4.Large.jpg

The forward view of the aircraft on the left-hand display is much too like the J-20 to be the product of coincidence.

Other Chinese enthusiasts have been playing with CGI. It is hard to vouch for their accuracy, but it's visually impressive:

http://sitelife.aviationweek.com/ver...9e09.Large.jpg

Finally, Air Power Australia has released an updated assessment of the J-20, with some interesting thoughts on timing, numbers and roles and missions, and Feng at Information Dissemination has some good observations.

FoxtrotAlpha18 3rd Jan 2011 22:09

What? Air Power Australia thinks the J-20 is a ripper and that the F-35 should be cancelled??? :eek:

Holy crap, who could've predicted that? May as well start learning Mandarin now! :suspect:

Load Toad 3rd Jan 2011 22:16

Dui, hen hao!

GreenKnight121 4th Jan 2011 06:28


Finally, Air Power Australia has released an updated assessment of the J-20, with some interesting thoughts on timing, numbers and roles and missions,
Wild-@ssed guesses, pure imaginings, and desperate exaggerations designed to support their "the RAAF must buy F-22 only & completely rebuild the F-111" agenda.

tonker 4th Jan 2011 12:31

Sounds like a plan. We could have TSR2's:ok::ok::ok::ok::ok:

TEEEJ 4th Jan 2011 18:01

http://www.centurychina.com/plaboard...040148wX50.gif

Smoketoomuch 5th Jan 2011 14:52

JF said;
"What you can assess from such a picture tends to depend on your education, training, experience, knowledge of various aircraft design features "

Come on John, don't leave us hanging...
Care to share your impression?

TEEEJ 5th Jan 2011 14:53

Either landing or high speed taxi with chute deployment at Chengdu?



http://i737.photobucket.com/albums/xx11/VVbear/xcx.jpg

TJ

Willard Whyte 5th Jan 2011 14:58


bu dui hen hao qing yond cesuo zaoju zaii jain dong le dong bu dong
Hey!

That's my mobile 'phone ring tone!

John Farley 5th Jan 2011 16:06

Smoketoomuch
 

Surely not , you cant see much from the picture.
I was merely making the general case following the quote above.

Not suggesting that I had any such background.

In actual fact there have been several links to analysis that I find no reason to argue with.

Something that Anatoly Kvotchur said to me one day was "the bigger the aircraft the easier it is to meet the spec" Wise words but they do ignore visual signature and cost.

As to


Wild-@ssed guesses, pure imaginings, and desperate exaggerations designed to support their "the RAAF must buy F-22 only & completely rebuild the F-111" agenda.
I would have thought that a careful read of the introduction to the document referred to makes it very clear it is none of those things as it is full of very sensible caveats.

Load Toad 5th Jan 2011 22:25

Article from TIME: "You Provide The Pictures, I'll Provide The War" -... - StumbleUpon

TEEEJ 6th Jan 2011 04:23



TJ

LowObservable 6th Jan 2011 16:03

Buying a few more pounds or cubic feet of space is no bad thing on a stealth platform. Visuals aside, observables are not related to size (sometimes bigger is better) and you can't follow the F-16-like growth path of adding bigger drop tanks, extra spines and conformals. Also, a bit of extra surface area for LO comms and EW antennas can come in handy.

Agree on APA. They are not perfect, but for some reason have acquired a flock of detractors, some of them complete loonies.

TEEEJ 7th Jan 2011 14:26

The flight today at Chengdu has been cancelled, according to the Chinese forums. VIPs were noted getting a guided tour of the aircraft. The airspace was cleared and the nearby international airport was closed down for the period.

http://oi51.tinypic.com/10z0mt1.jpg

According to the Chinese forums many spectators were moved on from the best viewing spots. People were even up the trees!

http://oi55.tinypic.com/34nscpe.jpg

Looking at the images it is clear that the weather got in the way!

New video of J-20 being towed. Taken from eastern side of Chengdu.



TJ

MudRat_02 8th Jan 2011 01:23


Originally Posted by Rovertime
Can the F-35 already be considered 'toast'?
Discussed here:
What China's New J-20 Stealth Fighter Means for the F-35 JSF and F/A-18E/F Super Hornet

Yes, Carlo Kopp has had a field day with this one and has taken it as another opportunity to decry the F-35/F-18F combo in favour of the unavailable F-22. He knows his stuff far better than I do, but I don't know if anyone is in a position to make the claims he does based purely on the poor quality pictures available and without access to information on the true capabilities of the F-22/F-35/T-50/J20 (that is understandably kept well-guarded and the latter are only prototypes!), and if so they could be saving aerospace companies a lot of money by drafting advanced stealth designs without the need for all that testing and whatnot ;):


Originally Posted by Carlo Kopp
The stealth shaping is without doubt considerably better than that seen in the Russian T-50 PAK-FA prototypes and, even more so, than that seen in the intended production configuration of the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter.

He then goes on to say how the F-35 hasn't got a prayer against this jet in an engagement. F-35 capability controversies aside, it seems like force multipliers should have a significant impact on any hypothetical matchup. I think he tends to be a bit over zealous.


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:48.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.