PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   F-35 Cancelled, then what ? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/424953-f-35-cancelled-then-what.html)

layman 25th Mar 2013 21:41

but it is an interceptor too!
 
...the F35 [is] a strike fighter not an interceptor and I doubt anybody is dumb enough to try and use one as such.


The RAAF was proposing a solely F35 fleet.

Now it will be mixed with the (currently) 24 SH. The SH was the replacement (sort of) for the F111, not the F/A18

cheers
layman

FoxtrotAlpha18 25th Mar 2013 23:24


Originally Posted by keesje
Of course the Australians didn't start their own program...

But...but...you said...

Originally Posted by keesje
...and it becomes clear countries like Australia, Japan, Taiwan are getting nervous and have started their own, independent programs...

What "independant program" is Taiwan doing by the way?


Originally Posted by keesje
Even the frigg'n Iranians are developping a light stealth fighter.

I'm sorry...you call that fibreglass mockup joke of a thing they did, a development? :}

Originally Posted by keesje
The Japanese are starting to loose their patience begging for F22s.

Ummm...but F-22 production ended in 2012, and the Japanese ordered the F-35 in 2011...so when will they lose patience begging for the F-22? :}

Quit while you're ahe...behind Keesje!

SpazSinbad 26th Mar 2013 00:42

12 (of 75?) F-35Bs for Singapore Soonish?
 
Singapore Poised To Announce Purchase Of 12 F-35Bs By Colin Clark 25 March 2013

Singapore Poised To Announce Purchase Of 12 F-35Bs

"WASHINGTON: Singapore is expected to announce sometime in the next 10 days that it plans to buy its first squadron --12 planes -- of some 75 of Lockheed Martin's F-35Bs,

Stuffy 26th Mar 2013 00:51

I am still going with Project Cancelled.

Single engine.

Can't land where it doesn't burn up the ground.

Cannot be fitted with an arrester hook.

Stealth = overated.

And, very very very expensive.

Cancel it and build/buy something more practical.

WhiteOvies 26th Mar 2013 01:46

Stuffy,

So was Harrier.

Not true.

It's a STOVL jet, no need for a hook. If you need a hook buy F-35C.

Ask a pilot, would you rather have it or not have it doing the sort of missions envisaged? If it gives them a better chance of surviving I'd suggest they'll want it.

Maybe you have a point on this one.

What other jets do you know that can go off a ski jump that are politically acceptable to UK?

Stuffy 26th Mar 2013 02:06

It's a pile of expensive junk. A Corporate toy.

The Sukhoi uses a ski jump.

WTF ????

What does politically acceptable mean ?

Strewth, give me strength.

flynavysomerset 26th Mar 2013 03:05

In my opinion this is excellent news. I personally can not see F35 being cancelled. This buy only goes on to strengthen the case of the aircraft, globally and in the Pacific.

The UK is correct to continue with the purchase of the Lightning II, it will be a formidable platform for many years to come operating from the maritime and land environment.

:ok:

FNS

JSFfan 26th Mar 2013 06:32

RAF Marham to be the base for the next generation of fast jet strike aircraft - News - Eastern Daily Press

Mr Hammon said Marham had always been the first choice to be home for the Lightning II.

He said the joint strike fighter will be based at Marham as part of a combined RAF and Royal Naval force which would operate the aircraft both from land bases and future aircraft carriers.

“That’s extremely good news for this station, extremely good news for this community and extremely good news for the RAF and Royal Navy.

I know you will share with me the excitement of having the world’s most advanced fighter aircraft based here and operating from here.”

keesje 26th Mar 2013 10:20


I'm sorry...you call that fibreglass mockup joke of a thing they did, a development?
The Iranians themselves said it was just a mock-up during the broadcast (not uncommon for new programs). "Don't let the facts ruin a good story" ;)


What "independant program" is Taiwan doing by the way?
Taiwan to Seek Development of an Indigenous Stealth Fighter | Defense Update - Military Technology & Defense News

Quit while you're ahe...behind FoxtrotAlpha18 ;)

Lonewolf_50 26th Mar 2013 12:22

That's funny, Peter, the close air support I worked and helped coordinate for our own and coalition forces in Afghanistan included Warthogs. The ground commanders I worked directly with always wanted more Warthog.

What were you saying, again?

CoffmanStarter 26th Mar 2013 19:47

Looks like Commander Ward doesn't like the F-35 in his latest missive from Sharkeys World :hmm:

Commander Ward on the F-35

Coff.

4eyed anorak 26th Mar 2013 19:59

I know this has been mentioned before. B.a.e to produce a naval Typhoon, create and safeguard jobs and get in my opinion a better aircraft. :ugh:

ian176 26th Mar 2013 20:31

Interesting executive summary - his beloved Harrier wouldn't do too well against his criteria...

Courtney Mil 26th Mar 2013 21:08

Indeed not, Ian. The SHAR fails on almost every point. But you have to be fascinated by a guy who's blogs have an executive summary. I did try to put JSFfan up against him a while back, but there was no interest. Maybe he wasn't so sure of his ground after all.

I'm sure the Minister will read Sharkey's 'paper' with interest.

peter we 26th Mar 2013 22:25


Given that only one appears to have been lost during and since OIF, I'd treat that with a fair amount of suspicion.

Op Desert Storm had four Hog losses, mostly to MANPADS and SHORAD.
Ok, maybe I'm mistaken, but I'd though I'd read it here that the A-10 was withdrawn due to vulnerability to manpads.

keesje 26th Mar 2013 22:35


I know this has been mentioned before. B.a.e to produce a naval Typhoon, create and safeguard jobs and get in my opinion a better aircraft.
I think the RAfale might be more practicle. The French could be asked to compensate the jobs otherwise e.g. Merlins

TEEEJ 27th Mar 2013 16:23

Stuffy wrote,


Cannot be fitted with an arrester hook.
Stuffy,
Your reply to WhiteOvies shows that you don't understand the F-35 variants. The only variant fitted for arrested carrier recovery is the F-35C. You do understand why the F-35B doesn't require an arrester hook? Did you also want a hook on the Harrier? :)

https://www.f35.com/the-f-35/f-35-ov...35b-stovl.aspx

https://www.f35.com/the-f-35/f-35-ov.../f-35c-cv.aspx

F-35C


The aircraft is designed to operate from large aircraft carriers using catapult launch and arrested recovery.
https://www.f35.com/the-f-35/f-35-ov...role-variants/

keesje 27th Mar 2013 19:21

Former USN chief suggests DOD should cancel F-35A in favour of C-model
 

Another senior official also says CAPE is looking at eliminating the A-model. "During the latest sequestration drill, CAPE took another run on cutting out one of the variants of the JSF," he says.
"The argument is the air force should do it and buy the C version. I went through that drill before, but it lost legs."

http://www.flightglobal.com/Assets/G...x?ItemID=48884

Additionally, three former officials also say their information suggests CAPE is once again examining the cancellation of the F-35A model jet.
CAPE had previously studied terminating the F-35A at the behest of then-undersecretary of defense for acquisitions, technology and logistics John Young, during his tenure which ended in 2009.
Former USN chief suggests DOD should cancel F-35A in favour of C-model

No need to ask any allies, or even consider their interests.

IMO Europe needs it own next generation fighter bomber.

GeeRam 27th Mar 2013 19:35

And at the same time.....:E

But Air Force pilots dismiss the idea of flying a heavier fighter jet, and instead propose that the Marine Corps abandon its version, the F-35B, arguing that its costly helicopter-style landing feature is useful only at air shows.


Prices soar, enthusiasm dives for F-35 Lightning; pilots worry about visibility problem - Washington Times

:p

glad rag 27th Mar 2013 21:29

New Pentagon super fighter will get pilots shot down, warns report - Washington Times


The report shows that the F-35A “is flawed beyond redemption,” commented POGO staffer and veteran defense spending analyst Winslow Wheeler.
und

Prices soar, enthusiasm dives for F-35 Lightning; pilots worry about visibility problem - Washington Times


Pentagon officials have said in audit reports that the F-35’s 30-year, $1 trillion operating bill is not affordable.
Like the song says it's a long way to the top.............



All times are GMT. The time now is 15:44.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.