PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Best & Worst Mil Aviation Film and Why (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/302382-best-worst-mil-aviation-film-why.html)

Inspector Dreyfuss 29th Nov 2007 14:44

Best comedy:- Dr Strangelove with Sellers as the Brit Gp Capt exchange officer (and the US President and indeed the mad scientist) with Slim Pickens (I believe?) as the bonkers B52 commander. Highlights include the US President trying to reason with an intoxicated Russian president about the slight error in launching SAC and the B52 commander's finale after dislodging the nuke.

Wader2 29th Nov 2007 14:46

Gathering of Eagles reminds me,

Anyone know the name of the B47 film? I seem to remember airborne alert off Newfoundland, a fire, AAR sequences etc. Quite a story line really following a B47 wing work up, ops and then deployment to Kadena (?).

teeteringhead 29th Nov 2007 14:52


Dr Strangelove with Sellers as the Brit Gp Capt exchange officer (and the US President and indeed the mad scientist) with Slim Pickens (I believe?) as the bonkers B52 commander.
... and today's movie trivia is:

Apparently Sellers was to play the B52 captain's part too, but was not happy with his characterisation - not a very nice man, but certainly a perfectionist.

goudie 29th Nov 2007 15:08

Best:- BoB
Worst:- Top Gun, can't stand the little sh*t TC.

Has anyone mentioned John Wayne? Didn't he win a dog fight or two in the Pacific? Can't remember name of film.

stickmonkeytamer 29th Nov 2007 15:14

One to stir the heartstrings: the Chipmonk AEF film, staring Paul Young (before he got his record contract!) ;) as John Andrews.
Those immortal lines:
"Jump jump John"!
"Jump jump Sir"!!!!

Why did he not get an Oscar???

The best war film for me was "A matter of Life and Death" with David Niven. You've got to watch it for the bit when he is on the beach and assumes he is dead- fantastic acting!

I used to have all of the Top Gun flying bits merged into one video- I was young then...:=

SMT

BEagle 29th Nov 2007 15:23

Well, if you're going to mention Susannah York......

I give you.....


Aaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrghhhhhhhhh

MG 29th Nov 2007 15:48

How about The Bridges at Toko-Ri for one of the best. Some great Korean War, carrier-borne jets (F9F Panther) and Grace Kelly to boot!

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...of_Toko-Ri.jpg

goudie 29th Nov 2007 15:50

There are now two Threads (the other's about hats)
that are now showing saucy pics of women. Is there a conspiracy out there to corrupt us old farts?

MG 29th Nov 2007 15:51

Sorry Goudie, but I'm an old fart as well. You have to keep us oldies happy somehow!

dakkg651 29th Nov 2007 15:52

Goudie

The Duke flew P40s in The Flying Tigers. This included the famous out take of the chap walking across the sky outside the cockpit.

He also flew Hellcats in The Flying Leathernecks.

He also taught some Russian bint to fly a P80 in Jet Pilot. The pilot who did most of the flying sequences for this was Chuck Yeager.

That has just reminded me of the film The Sound Barrier which featured the prototype Supermarine Swift which was called the Prometheus if I remember correctly.
Pushing forward on the stick to recover from a supersonic dive. Shows that aerolastic distortion does have it's uses then! Yeager really enjoyed this film by all accounts.

scudpilot 29th Nov 2007 15:56

Peter Jackon is rumoured to be remaking the "Dambusters" should be excellent, just wonder how they will get around the black pet dog in these politically correct times!

chiglet 29th Nov 2007 16:05

Surprised that no one has mentioned The Right Stuff....or Those Magnifcent Men in their Flying Machines. I haven't seen the film, but Hells Angels is supposed to be good and hows' about Up in the Air with George Formby
watp,iktch

Winco 29th Nov 2007 16:09

Oh BEagle,

If only........................................................ ..........more like her today eh?

Winco

NST 29th Nov 2007 16:11

I quite like this Dambusters remake .. http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=_NMfBKrdErY .. :ok:

Recently watched Speed and Angels. Documentary of the last class of Tomcat Pilots to go through, some of the air to air camera work is pretty good.

But the worst for me has to be Iron Eagle .. :yuk:

Fg Off Max Stout 29th Nov 2007 16:23

Did anyone sit through Behind Enemy Lines long enough to get to the world's longest, most far-fetched surface-to-air missile sequence. The whole sequence was long enough to see the launch, go away and brew some coffee, come back see the damn thing in flight, go back to the kitchen and bake a jacket potato, come back to the TV and they were still jostling around trying to evade the missile. An irritatingly crap bunch-of-arse.

As for the best, The Battle of Britain is a classic in every way and there's always a time and a place for Top Gun.

In a slightly different category: The Boys From Bahrain. Amazing. More or less started the Sqn vid genre and motivated a number of young bucks to sign on the dotted line. I still get a shiver down my spine watching that.

I'll be interested to see how the Dambusters remake turns out. I suspect it will either be very, very good or utterly rubbish. There is no middle ground. Let's hope for the former.

ShyTorque 29th Nov 2007 16:24


Quote:
Surprised no one else has mentioned Battle of Britain.
Fantastic movie, but you mean there were actually aeroplanes in it?
There certainly were aeroplanes in it. Tim Mills, who sometimes posts here, flew one of the Spitfires in that film when he was still a serving RAF squadron pilot.

(I know because I helped teach his daughter to fly in the early 1990s). :)

Worst Aviation film? The TV series, "Tales of the Golden Monkey", takes my vote. For example, the pilot (of a WW2 flying boat, somewhere over the Pacific) received a radio call asking him to give his position. He immediately looked out of the window....... and gave his exact latitude and longitude... :rolleyes:

stevef 29th Nov 2007 16:24

I'd recommend these three:

Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo
(1944) based on the Doolittle Raid:
http://www.archive.org/details/thirt...nds_over_tokyo

The Purple Plain 1954 A Mosquito crashlands in a Burmese wilderness.
http://www.amazon.com/Purple-Plain-G.../dp/B00079ZACW

Journey Together (1943). RAF Pilot training in America.
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Journey-Toge.../dp/B00004CQ7S

sitigeltfel 29th Nov 2007 16:36

When Dr Strangelove was first shown the USAF were amazed at the accuracy of the Nuclear Release procedures depicted in the movie and tried to find out who had been advising the director.

One of my favourites is "By Dawns Early Light". A very political film but it shows the dilemmas facing a crew sent on a Nuclear mission.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/By_Dawn's_Early_Light

LOTA 29th Nov 2007 16:40

Can't really comment on the whole of Top Gun; walked out out after 20 minutes because it was so boring and went to the pub instead!

The Battle of Britain, though, bloody fantastic!

When I was a recruiter (!),the 12 Squadron Buccaneers film (we used to lug a 16mm projector around in the back of the MT Chevette)usedto send the Coventry comprehensive kids to sleep. No bad thing, in my view.

But Watchdogs, now that was a far more exciting affair. 'The squadron is manned. Is it real or exercise?' That's the stuff to give em!

RETDPI 29th Nov 2007 18:15

"No Sleep Till Dawn " was pretty good for its genre in the '50's. This was the one all about bringing the B-52 into service.
"High Flight" c.1957 -Cranwell as it should have been. My old Flight commanders boots star in a marching sequence.
"Tiger in the Sky" Absolutely dire crude progaganda about the Korean War. F-84's playing the part of Mig's.
"The Man in the Sky". '50's Tosh with Jack Hawkins trying to land a Bristol Freighter.
Best of all for me for sheer atmosphere and story telling. . "The Great Waldo Pepper" in the 70's.
Worst - difficult to choose!
And then there was "Q" Planes............
Time for me Cocoa.


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:59.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.