PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   RAF base awaits fighter decision (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/198794-raf-base-awaits-fighter-decision.html)

vecvechookattack 17th Nov 2005 10:21

RAF base awaits fighter decision
 
I hope that SMG stays open.

caspertheghost 17th Nov 2005 12:27

And another one bites the dust. Sad news indeed. Why don't they close the rubbish bases instead of the good ones?

ORAC 17th Nov 2005 12:30

But they got rid of the Jockistani CRC didnīt they..... :ok: :E

BEagle 17th Nov 2005 13:01

St Mawgan, Chivenor, Tangmere, Thorney Island - all far too nice. So the MoD either closes them or give them to someone else.

Valley, Kinloss, Lossiemouth? Hmm, not much potential for sale. So they hang on to them. Plus Grumpy Gordon will be happy as it'll keep his cronies content.

Why not close MoD Main Building and sell it - and move the MoD to Inverness!

effortless 17th Nov 2005 13:09


Why not close MoD Main Building and sell it - and move the MoD to Inverness!
Much too far from one's clubs dear boy, handy for the grouse though.

Jackonicko 17th Nov 2005 13:17

"St Mawgan, Chivenor, Tangmere, Thorney Island - all far too nice."

And if we're talking about places from which you can no longer have a flying tour, then add Abingdon, Brawdy, Church Fenton, Colerne, Honington, Hullavington, Leconfield, Pershore, Stradishall, Thurleigh, Wattisham, West Raynham, Wyton,

Soon to be joined by?:

Benson, Coltishall, Cottesmore, Leeming, Lyneham, Marham, Odiham, Wittering

Has Scotland actually lost a major airfield since 1957?

caspertheghost 17th Nov 2005 13:19

I don't know, Jackonicko, but since there are only 3 up there it would be a bit harsh!
What about Machra, Macraho, Makra:mad: Campbletown Minor Aerodrome?

Jackonicko 17th Nov 2005 13:38

There were wartime bases in Scotland that have gone. My Dad flew from Tain occasionally, and once crashed at Sumburgh, while there was Turnhouse, Dyce, etc. But Scotland seems to have escaped late- and post-Cold War cuts entirely unscathed, when the strategic rationale for ASW at Kinloss and for AD at Leuchars has vanished.

The logic of locating JSF as far as it's physically possible to get from the carriers it will serve also escapes me.

And on top of all that, there seems to be a slow but inexorable drift towards greater devolution for the 'Porridge Wogs' and with that in mind, it would seem sensible to limit the amount of national infrastructure on territory that may one day be part of some-one else's nation. Especially if the cost of doing so is that we throw away infrastructure on our own soil.

caspertheghost 17th Nov 2005 13:53

I would suggest they're keeping the Nimrods at Kinloss because of the considerable infrastructure that's already there or has recently been built for the MRA4.

airborne_artist 17th Nov 2005 14:31


Soon to be joined by?: Benson, ...
Doubt that CAE would be too happy to move MSHATF in a hurry.

Big Tudor 17th Nov 2005 15:20


Has Scotland actually lost a major airfield since 1957?
Yes, they lose Barra twice a day, every day! ;) Ok, a sorry attempt at humour I know.

I'm guessing (probably somewhat naively) that there are significant training opportunities to be had in RAF Jockistan. For the FJ boys, rapid access to some of the finest low flying systems in the country, same for the ranges. Does being close to the carriers home port really matter that much bearing in mind they won't be there most of the time?
For the Kipper Fleet, big play areas out in the Iceland Gap and North Atlantic that are far enough away from civil airspace to be useful. Plus the infrastructure already exists at ISK for the mighty hunter.

Of course, the cycnic in me wonders whether this is all a sweetener to Scotland following the decimation of the Army Regiments up there!

BEagle 17th Nov 2005 15:31

But the most apt name for a Jockistani base was, of course, HMS Tern in the Orkneys....

Because its real name was Twatt. It remained a reserve station under Lossiemouth's control until January 1949 and was then retained by the RN until sold off in 1957.

Other places for your list, Jacko:

Acklington, Andover, Bassingbourn, Binbrook, Bovingdon, Gaydon, Gravely, Kemble, Little Rissington, Manby, North Weald, Oakington, Strubby, Swinderby, Syerston

And those are just the ones in civilised parts of the world! All were still open when I joined the RAF.....

Krystal n chips 17th Nov 2005 16:36

Can we stop this nostalgic wallowing please ;) --it's making me feel very old as well as reminding me of several of the many reasons I joined in the first place :D ----all now closed of course !

Art Field 17th Nov 2005 16:46

Waterbeach, West Malling, Wymeswold, Booker, White Waltham, Upwood, Upavon.

An Teallach 17th Nov 2005 16:49


Waterbeach, West Malling, Wymeswold, Booker, White Waltham, Upwood, Upavon.
Mornington Crescent! :p

BEagle 17th Nov 2005 16:56

Finningley?? I was only referring to stations in civilised parts of the world. The Scargill Republic doesn't fall into that category in my view.

Somehow Doncaster and navigators deserved eachother....

althenick 17th Nov 2005 17:32


There were wartime bases in Scotland that have gone. My Dad flew from Tain occasionally, and once crashed at Sumburgh, while there was Turnhouse, Dyce, etc. But Scotland seems to have escaped late- and post-Cold War cuts entirely unscathed, when the strategic rationale for ASW at Kinloss and for AD at Leuchars has vanished.
Taking it from a defence-wide point of view I think you'll find that Scotland has taken its fair whack of cuts. Rosyth? Crombie? Pitreavie? Lochinvar? Dalgetty? Altbea? Turnhouse? to name but a few.

John Farley 17th Nov 2005 19:07

I appears you kids can't remember Driffield

Rakshasa 17th Nov 2005 20:27

So... when do they announce publically that Fylingdales has been sold off as a giant microwave? :}

BEagle 17th Nov 2005 20:52

JF - my list was restricted to places in nice parts of the UK which were still RAF flying stations when I joined.

Driffield had been a Thor base and then virtually abandoned years before I joined. But I understand that the Blackburn Aircraft Works test flew the odd Bucc from there whilst HoSM was being resurfaced in 1967-8.

But these days it's a grunt base where squaddies learn to drive lorries by numbers.

Now if Duncan Sandys had never been voted in, perhaps I might have flown P1121s from Merryfield.....

http://i14.photobucket.com/albums/a341/nw969/P1121.jpg


I was once told that 'they' were going to name the P1121 the Hurricane 2. As a former 'awker, do you know whether that was true?

passpartout 17th Nov 2005 21:12

"Somehow Doncaster and navigators deserved eachother..."

So what does that say about Valley and pilots?

Plank.

BEagle 17th Nov 2005 22:08

Well, plank dear, Valley was virtually free of talking-TACAN oxygen thieves, for one thing. Just the ones on the Whirlwinds.

I must admit to being somewhat mystified at the current hatred of the place - we had a great time when I was there. And that was when there was only 1 bridge off the island and you had to drive through Bangor to get to the mostly single lane A5. Nowadays there's a dual carriageway all the way to England.

And 6Z3, remember the legs on Dragon Room Mary? I'll bet you do....

Roadster280 18th Nov 2005 02:20

"But these days it's a grunt base where squaddies learn to drive lorries by numbers."

Non.

It is derelict. RAF Leconfield is the sole place (fish joke anyone?), and is tri service to boot. Blue jobs learn truck mashing there too.

Correct me if I am wrong here, but it was a highly foresighted individual or committee that came up with the 30s expansion period design of aerodrome. All the places that are/have been closed in the last 30 years are of this type. I.e bloody useful. No-one would complain if Netheravon was swapped for Coltishall on the grim reaper list.

As an aside, Upavon was the oldest station in the RAF when I was there. Went back years later on Army course. Middleton block was the RAChD HQ. Yes, I do know why it was called "Middleton". Bloody disgrace. Place was a shambles.

Grrr!

Blacksheep 18th Nov 2005 02:39


It appears you kids can't remember Driffield
I remember Driffield John, but then I'm no kid. Did anyone mention Middleton St George? ...or Thornaby for that matter, I used to go to the BoB open days at Thornaby. Teesside doesn't count as civilisation these days, of course. :(
At least my Alma Mater (Halton) is still open - almost.

When I joined up there were more overseas bases* to be posted to than there are UK bases today. There were about 110,000 more of us to serve there though. :(

*Lots of them were sh*teholes mind...;)

OKOC 18th Nov 2005 07:55

Syerston is still open-or it was when I was there a month ago-Vigilants & Vikings and doing a good job.

BEagle 18th Nov 2005 08:03

Cadet gliding is hardly in the same league, worthwhile though it undoubtedly is...

When I fist rattled along the A46 in my 100E Anglia, Jet Provost flying at Syerston was in full swing and the station was as busy as most.

But even back in 1978, some 10 years later, the old station looked like a ghost town and was slowly crumbling away...

teeteringhead 18th Nov 2005 08:29


Syerston is still open
... but the OM is now derelict - having been an Islamic Study Centre (!!!)


Wymeswold
.... aah Wymeswold ... JP first solo age nineteen-and-a-half in XP 667 after 6 hours 30 dual .....

...... you tell that ter the young folk today and they'll not believe yer........:D


in my 100E Anglia
..oh BEags ...:suspect: ... at least I had an MG TC in those days.....

Gainesy 18th Nov 2005 08:53

Just a quick mention for sunny Lindholme-on-the-Bog. Oh and Hemswell.

BEagle 18th Nov 2005 08:54

The Anglebox was inherited from the family business - we'd had it since 1958! 0-60 in about 29 seconds when new and still blessed with all of its 36 bhp. Flat out it would allegedly do 73 mph if you could stand the racket and vibration.

Eventually it was sold at auction for Ģ15 - a pile of railway sleepers from the old Taunton - Chard railway line went for Ģ16!

However, when I went back to Cranwell after university, I did so in a 3 year old MG Midget! Even that had boasted a mere 65 bhp...and 0-60 was a leisurely 14.6 seconds!

So many names of once proud RAF flying stations being recalled on this thread - and many were still active in the 60s and 70s; we've not even mentioned the likes of Weston Zoyland etc from the 1950s.

Logistics Loader 18th Nov 2005 09:33

As St M is no longer reqd, does that mean our burger eating cousins from across the pond are no longer there too..??

Also, surely more SAR is carried out in the Atlantic than the coastal waters of Scotland ????

How long before QBM is no longer reqd as the airport has International status. It will be easy to use in the future !!!

vecvechookattack 18th Nov 2005 09:42

Very Sad


very very sad

BEagle 18th Nov 2005 10:23

What a coincidence....

Adam Ingram, MP for East Kilbride, Strathaven and Lesmahagow, is Armed Forces Minister.

Dr John Reid, MP for Hamilton North & Bellshill, is Secretary of State for Defence.

Gordon Brown, MP for Dunfermline East is Chancellor of the Exchequer.

....and so an excellent base in Cornwall is effectively ruled out, whilst the porridge-wog bases are promised lots of jobs and future investment.

I smell a deep-fried Mars bar plot.

1.3VStall 18th Nov 2005 10:37

Don't forget the grass airfields that we have lost - Bicester (now a civilian gliding club) and Swanton Morley (no idea what goes on there now).:{

newswatcher 18th Nov 2005 10:53

Last I heard was that the Army had also moved into Swanton Morley - light armoured units?

Tim Inder 18th Nov 2005 10:53

1.3V - you don't want to know - really!

caspertheghost 18th Nov 2005 12:43

"What a coincidence....

Adam Ingram, MP for East Kilbride, Strathaven and Lesmahagow, is Armed Forces Minister.

Dr John Reid, MP for Hamilton North & Bellshill, is Secretary of State for Defence.

Gordon Brown, MP for Dunfermline East is Chancellor of the Exchequer."

Yes, that's nice, but since none of the bases in Scotland are anywhere near any of their consituencies what does it matter?
If one of the bases, say Lossie was to close, Scotland would lose a third of it's Stations. St Mawgan closes and the percentage is a lot smaller.

OKOC 18th Nov 2005 12:55

Casper...

How many bases have we got in Cornnnnwall then?

vecvechookattack 18th Nov 2005 12:58

2. St Mawgan and Portreath. Are there any others?

caspertheghost 18th Nov 2005 13:15

And Kernow is quite small, Scotland's quite big. I'm not trying to justify the closure by any means, just trying to put across the point that maybe it's not a huge conspiracy theory planned by them up north.

BEagle 18th Nov 2005 14:16

Well, sorry, but I'm convinced that some beancounter is being told to maximise the value of whatever they can flog off, and to keep Jocks in jobs. Defence interest coming a long way behind the land value and the labour party fan club's interests.

The loss of St Mawgan would also have a side effect on trans-Atlantic AAR trails as there'd be only Culdrose, Exeter or Cardiff to use for Bracket 1 abort aerodromes.....

How much was spent bringing Leeming up to the state it is today for the F3? A whole new road off the A1, plus gazillions on infrastructure. So guess what - it'll go to the damn dung-eaters like every other half decent base. Abingdon, Chivenor and Wattisham to name but a few.


All times are GMT. The time now is 15:12.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.