Biggest Non Nuke Dropped in Afghanistan
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
SASLess, quite, but wasn't that the road you used in 'man and then decided it was not good? I think we refused to broadcast body count in recent actions.
My point is how did they know? What if they bad guys hid one
My point is how did they know? What if they bad guys hid one
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
I wonder how a pair of guided Tall Boys would work? One to kick the door in and the next to clear the basement. Or even 4, not that would rattle the cage.
@ Pontius, et al
I gave up on the body count when it got ridiculous, you know, one mission with trapped enema in a small wooded area they went to and the body count was over a hindred. I had many more "counts" when you consider 400 missions mostly CAS and not interdiction or such. So I soured on such "score". I just wanted to "win" and come home.
The big thing is to see the effect of the campaign/mission WRT achieving the "goal". So there are many things that determine military effectiveness.
Unlike Desert Storm or even 'raqi II, the most recent conflicts make it hard to determine the bad guys from the good guys and the innocent bystanders. Although I would personally move if I had known bad guys next door building IED's and sneaking about.
Gums opines...
I gave up on the body count when it got ridiculous, you know, one mission with trapped enema in a small wooded area they went to and the body count was over a hindred. I had many more "counts" when you consider 400 missions mostly CAS and not interdiction or such. So I soured on such "score". I just wanted to "win" and come home.
The big thing is to see the effect of the campaign/mission WRT achieving the "goal". So there are many things that determine military effectiveness.
Unlike Desert Storm or even 'raqi II, the most recent conflicts make it hard to determine the bad guys from the good guys and the innocent bystanders. Although I would personally move if I had known bad guys next door building IED's and sneaking about.
Gums opines...
https://youtu.be/R-Mm-zFW_nA
Now that is a penetration weapon.
Did they not drop one, or at least it's little brother, the Tallboy, on a German U-boat pen to great effect?
Now that is a penetration weapon.
Did they not drop one, or at least it's little brother, the Tallboy, on a German U-boat pen to great effect?
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: New Braunfels, TX
Age: 70
Posts: 1,954
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
And what is this absurd fixation on cost since Trump got into the white house? This was a military decision and the military simply does not factor in dollar cost in their tactical decisions. This complex was EXACTLY what this bomb was designed for. It would be beyond absurd to design, test and produce a bomb for a very specific task and then not use it because it's 'too expensive."
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
Albat, indeed, TB was better at that as it was a stronger bomb. On the viaduct attack GS was perfect for underground bursts.
Reported only 36 killed in MOAB strike which equates to $500K per kill. Not a good return on use of a limited asset. In Trumpet's world at $16M a piece the MOAB is three rounds of golf.
PN,
I would suggest the Oppo's removed fewer than the USAF did!
Probably more than a few shall only be a mere figment of some Mother's memory.
Bit of Vietnam Lore.....General Westmoreland (Sound of spitting heard) who was the architect of the Bodycount silliness, while inspecting the 1st Air Cav's CH-47 "Guns-A-GoGo" unit......asked a Door Gunner how many Enemy Soldiers he had killed....to be told "Thirteen, Sir!".
Westmoreland asked how the Gunner could be so sure of that....and the Gunner said "I soot them till something falls off!".
Which with a Ma Deuce (.50 Caliber Browning MG) is not that hard to do....would sound believable.
It is not how many you kill....it is destroying their capability and Will to fight that allows you to win.
Had we had Abrams from the outset instead of Westmoreland (Sound of spitting heard).....things would have been much different. Abrams was about Logistics and not mere attrition as a strategy.
I would suggest the Oppo's removed fewer than the USAF did!
Probably more than a few shall only be a mere figment of some Mother's memory.
Bit of Vietnam Lore.....General Westmoreland (Sound of spitting heard) who was the architect of the Bodycount silliness, while inspecting the 1st Air Cav's CH-47 "Guns-A-GoGo" unit......asked a Door Gunner how many Enemy Soldiers he had killed....to be told "Thirteen, Sir!".
Westmoreland asked how the Gunner could be so sure of that....and the Gunner said "I soot them till something falls off!".
Which with a Ma Deuce (.50 Caliber Browning MG) is not that hard to do....would sound believable.
It is not how many you kill....it is destroying their capability and Will to fight that allows you to win.
Had we had Abrams from the outset instead of Westmoreland (Sound of spitting heard).....things would have been much different. Abrams was about Logistics and not mere attrition as a strategy.
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
Body count from boots on the ground. Raises a question, if you can put boots on the ground was MOAB the right weapon. I guess it avoided the need to clear the bunker with close quarter action.
@Pontius
We already had "boots on the ground" there, and have had for 15 friggin' years!!
Another of my Spec OPs neighbors parachuted into the 'stan a week or two after 9/11 and rode about on horses using a wooden saddle as he made friends with the Northern Alliance.
The VietNam generals that ran Desert Storm and their contemporaries like me made it clear there would be no protracted effort once the goal was achieved. Hell , General Horner was my first senior officer student in the Viper back in 1980. He was a full bird and I was an lt col. We all shared the same philosophy ten years later.
Somehow we lost that attitude and started all this "nation building" crapola. Ain't worth it unless you wish to occupy a place and emulate the old Soviets and the Wehrmacht.
If you really wanna get mean and play for keeps with the grunts, then you throw gas down the tunnels and caves, then a few thousand liters of kerosene followed by a match.
The MOAB has its place as an effective weapon WRT casualties in the appropriate terrain and it is also a great psychological implement. In fact, my neighbor that dropped the daisy cutter did so after the psyops folks dropped many leaflets over the Iraqi unit for a few days And then one night..........
+++++++++
This was good choice for employing the MOAB compared to some small village, dontchya think?
And oh, BTW, one of our boots on the ground was a neighbor closeby that was killed there just a few days ago.
Gums opines
We already had "boots on the ground" there, and have had for 15 friggin' years!!
Another of my Spec OPs neighbors parachuted into the 'stan a week or two after 9/11 and rode about on horses using a wooden saddle as he made friends with the Northern Alliance.
The VietNam generals that ran Desert Storm and their contemporaries like me made it clear there would be no protracted effort once the goal was achieved. Hell , General Horner was my first senior officer student in the Viper back in 1980. He was a full bird and I was an lt col. We all shared the same philosophy ten years later.
Somehow we lost that attitude and started all this "nation building" crapola. Ain't worth it unless you wish to occupy a place and emulate the old Soviets and the Wehrmacht.
If you really wanna get mean and play for keeps with the grunts, then you throw gas down the tunnels and caves, then a few thousand liters of kerosene followed by a match.
The MOAB has its place as an effective weapon WRT casualties in the appropriate terrain and it is also a great psychological implement. In fact, my neighbor that dropped the daisy cutter did so after the psyops folks dropped many leaflets over the Iraqi unit for a few days And then one night..........
+++++++++
This was good choice for employing the MOAB compared to some small village, dontchya think?
And oh, BTW, one of our boots on the ground was a neighbor closeby that was killed there just a few days ago.
Gums opines
Last edited by gums; 14th Apr 2017 at 18:31. Reason: missed line
PN,
Cookies from the Heavens with scant risk to friendlies and max risk to the Oppo's sounds like a good Recipe!
''Tis a shame we never fielded the Neutron Bomb.....several places today where a few dozen of those could be put to good use!
Cookies from the Heavens with scant risk to friendlies and max risk to the Oppo's sounds like a good Recipe!
''Tis a shame we never fielded the Neutron Bomb.....several places today where a few dozen of those could be put to good use!
With the Donald talking of solving things I wouldn't expect a delivery to be made in isolation! A few targeted cruise missiles to create some confusion and degradation of command and control....cyber attack......?
Last edited by BlackIsle; 14th Apr 2017 at 19:29. Reason: additional text
Two MOABs were dropped in GW1 - although they were call Daisy Cutters then. We were told they would be delivered to avoid us going into NBC modes as we were in sight of the clouds.
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Near where the Wokkas live.
Age: 79
Posts: 112
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
MOAB
Wifey who is a tv news producer wants to know if its the first time moab has been used in anger? Apparently not?
There was a large bomb used in Vietnam which was referred to as a MOAB. I forget exactly what this stood for but at the time the troops said it was "Mother of all Bombs".
It was used for creating clearings in the jungle for helicopters to land and was dropped from a Sikorski Skycrane helicopter.
Perhaps one of the US guys can say more?
Polecat
There was a large bomb used in Vietnam which was referred to as a MOAB. I forget exactly what this stood for but at the time the troops said it was "Mother of all Bombs".
It was used for creating clearings in the jungle for helicopters to land and was dropped from a Sikorski Skycrane helicopter.
Perhaps one of the US guys can say more?
Polecat
Below the Glidepath - not correcting
Black Isle my point was simply that after 15 years of establishing Air Superiority against the mighty Toyota Hilux, things may be slightly different against a well organized Air Defence network and opposing air. I hope we haven't become too complacent in thinking we can just tip up over the drop zone without some preparation of the battlefield.
10,000 Pound Bomb with a ground level detonation.....dropped in the middle of the jungle and it created a very quick LZ for a Huey or Two....which then could be rapidly enlarged when Chinooks or Sky Cranes brought in Bulldozers.
The Bomb was dropped by C-130 generally.....with a try or two using a Sky Crane.
If memory serves me right....only a half dozen or less were ever dropped in anger.
Using the big bomb threw a monkey wrench into the NVA tactic of watching clearings most likely to be used for helicopter insertions of troops down to even LRRP Teams.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nfCdTRXj10
The Bomb was dropped by C-130 generally.....with a try or two using a Sky Crane.
If memory serves me right....only a half dozen or less were ever dropped in anger.
Using the big bomb threw a monkey wrench into the NVA tactic of watching clearings most likely to be used for helicopter insertions of troops down to even LRRP Teams.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nfCdTRXj10
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: England
Posts: 924
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The Atlantic magazine has an interesting take on it. ISIS forces in the region the bomb was dropped are or were in the number of 700. They are not popular within this region with local warlords and including the local Taliban. Its unlikely they would have gained a foothold anyway. Under Trump the recent number of USAF airstrikes has surged within Afghanistan anyway, possibly a reflection that this may deflect attention away from his other problems. Whatever, the local use of this weapon was entirely superfluous.
MOAB was designed to penetrate and destroy underground targets possibly nuclear or MMD within Iran or N Korea. Was the mission really to demonstrate to other nations that the USA has such a weapon and now intends to shortly use them elsewhere in the world? Who knows with the present Bash Street mob mentality of the POTUS and his family and friends.
MOAB was designed to penetrate and destroy underground targets possibly nuclear or MMD within Iran or N Korea. Was the mission really to demonstrate to other nations that the USA has such a weapon and now intends to shortly use them elsewhere in the world? Who knows with the present Bash Street mob mentality of the POTUS and his family and friends.
I'm fairly sure that the big buggahs that were dropped in Vietnam were US built version of Tallboys without the tail unit and a gert big long probe with the fuse on the end so that it detonated at ground level.