FTRS Abatement, Index Linking and Commutation at 55
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Great Britain
Age: 51
Posts: 340
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
5 Posts
FTRS Abatement, Index Linking and Commutation at 55
Anyone know/experienced what happens on FTRS at age 55 with abated AFPS75 in payment when the Resettlement Commutation period finishes and Index Linking is supposed to kick in?
Does Xaffinity Paymaster recalculate? Does only the Commutation sum get re-instated or does the Index Linking only work on the abated sum?
Grateful for a steer as decision crunch point approaches...
CPL Clott
Does Xaffinity Paymaster recalculate? Does only the Commutation sum get re-instated or does the Index Linking only work on the abated sum?
Grateful for a steer as decision crunch point approaches...
CPL Clott
Join Date: May 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 261
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you are not already a member, join the Forces Pension Society and they will give you the answer as to what should happen. You can then compare this with what SPVA do and then take them to task, as they sometimes get it wrong!
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: uk
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I hope that as the commutation is taken as payback of pension you were not entitled to due to going overthe pay/pension threhsiold that at 55 you simply get your full pension entitlement - can't see how you will get anything back.
Last edited by tailchase; 12th Mar 2013 at 11:33.
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Scotland
Posts: 70
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not sure I altogether understand the question - however. I was a regular who then went FTRS for 5 years before leaving the Service aged 48. I passed the 55 point last year and the following happened:
My regular pension started to be paid in full (it pretty much doubled because the commutation period ended and 11 years of RPI inflation was added).
The FTRS pension will only be payable from age 60 - and will include a pro-rata lump sum payment on that birthday. It will have been index linked over all that time since the initial quote/estimate you receive on leaving.
Hope that helps!
My regular pension started to be paid in full (it pretty much doubled because the commutation period ended and 11 years of RPI inflation was added).
The FTRS pension will only be payable from age 60 - and will include a pro-rata lump sum payment on that birthday. It will have been index linked over all that time since the initial quote/estimate you receive on leaving.
Hope that helps!
My understanding (3 years of FTRS some time ago) is that you cannot earn any more or less than your last job/rank in the RAF. So, my guess is that any increase in RAF pension by passing the 55 point will be abated iaw the rules on earnings. Hope I am wrong for your sake.
Last edited by Wyler; 12th Mar 2013 at 12:52.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Great Britain
Age: 51
Posts: 340
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
5 Posts
Thanks for the replies. I'll try SPVA and Xafinity first as they're free - £30 to get a question answered by the FPS is a bit steep! I'm happy with everything else, it's just the "tricky Johnny" question of what happens at 55 if the Immediate Pension is abated and also reduced due to commutation.
I can see only 4 outcomes really:
1. Remain on abated pension with commutation deducted and no index-linked inflation increases on abated pension
2. Commutation deduction removed but no index-linked inflation increases on abated pension
3. Commutation deduction removed and index-linked inflation increases applied to abated pension
4. Commutation deduction removed and full index-linked non-abated pension paid
I always was cr@p at multi-choice but I hope it is 4 or maybe 3. Everything else would be sub-optimal...
CPL Clott
I can see only 4 outcomes really:
1. Remain on abated pension with commutation deducted and no index-linked inflation increases on abated pension
2. Commutation deduction removed but no index-linked inflation increases on abated pension
3. Commutation deduction removed and index-linked inflation increases applied to abated pension
4. Commutation deduction removed and full index-linked non-abated pension paid
I always was cr@p at multi-choice but I hope it is 4 or maybe 3. Everything else would be sub-optimal...
CPL Clott
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: London
Posts: 103
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Quote
"I can see only 4 outcomes really:
1. Remain on abated pension with commutation deducted and no index-linked inflation increases on abated pension
2. Commutation deduction removed but no index-linked inflation increases on abated pension
3. Commutation deduction removed and index-linked inflation increases applied to abated pension
4. Commutation deduction removed and full index-linked non-abated pension paid "
My understanding is that the abatement just continues - so you will not notice that your commutation (loan) deductions (repayments) have stopped. The pension increases will be added on when your pension comes back into payment when you leave the FTRS.
"I can see only 4 outcomes really:
1. Remain on abated pension with commutation deducted and no index-linked inflation increases on abated pension
2. Commutation deduction removed but no index-linked inflation increases on abated pension
3. Commutation deduction removed and index-linked inflation increases applied to abated pension
4. Commutation deduction removed and full index-linked non-abated pension paid "
My understanding is that the abatement just continues - so you will not notice that your commutation (loan) deductions (repayments) have stopped. The pension increases will be added on when your pension comes back into payment when you leave the FTRS.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Great Britain
Age: 51
Posts: 340
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
5 Posts
Voxpop
I understand that the abatement will continue but why will the abated amount not be raised by CPI at age 55?
Furthermore, on the subject of Resettlement Commutation:
Now the "reduction equal to the amount of pension commuted will be made from their pension" should cease at age 55 - as you rightly say, it is a loan and not a part of the abatement reduction. I cannot see, from reading the regulations why this amount should be lost after 55 - If I hadn't commuted I would have recieved this amount after abatement. Again, should this reinstated amount not be raised in line with CPI?
I think I understand what should happen, I just can't find it written down anywhere or anyone that has experienced it. Has no one with a commuted AFPS75 pension ever served past their 55th birthday?
CPL Clott
I understand that the abatement will continue but why will the abated amount not be raised by CPI at age 55?
Furthermore, on the subject of Resettlement Commutation:
Abatement of Pension. In accordance with current Treasury rules, anyone in receipt of an Armed Forces pension will be liable to have that pension abated on re-employment. This means that individuals will be allowed to retain that amount of their basic pension which, when added to their basic pay on re-employment on FTRS, equals the basic pay that they were receiving on the
last day of regular service, uprated by the percentage of pension ncreases applicable to the code under which their regular pension was assessed. This abatement rule is not restricted solely to just FTRS personnel (it also applies to Military Provost Guard Service). In cases where the total remuneration is greater than the level permitted, the AFPS pension in payment may be abated or suspended. Where an individual has taken resettlement commutation and their pension in payment is subject to abatement in whole or part, a reduction equal to the amount of pension commuted will be made from their pension.
last day of regular service, uprated by the percentage of pension ncreases applicable to the code under which their regular pension was assessed. This abatement rule is not restricted solely to just FTRS personnel (it also applies to Military Provost Guard Service). In cases where the total remuneration is greater than the level permitted, the AFPS pension in payment may be abated or suspended. Where an individual has taken resettlement commutation and their pension in payment is subject to abatement in whole or part, a reduction equal to the amount of pension commuted will be made from their pension.
I think I understand what should happen, I just can't find it written down anywhere or anyone that has experienced it. Has no one with a commuted AFPS75 pension ever served past their 55th birthday?
CPL Clott
Last edited by Corporal Clott; 13th Mar 2013 at 20:10.
Cpl Clott
That's my understanding but I too have not seen it anywhere in writing. Let me know if you find out, I'd be interested.
On the Forces Pensions Society (FPS), I read some poor advice at the time on whether I needed to leave for 30 days or not to get my AFPS75 pension in payment. Eventually the SPVA expert came good and I left one day and joined the next with AFPS75 in full payment. It would seem that as the 75 scheme had closed and was no longer open, the 30 day rule no longer applied. That experience left me slightly dubious of FPS' capability to deal with more complex pensions questions. However, that said, they are good at lobbying and also have helped significantly with advice for the Future AFPS.
I just need convincing that it's worth 30 quid!
LJ
That's my understanding but I too have not seen it anywhere in writing. Let me know if you find out, I'd be interested.
On the Forces Pensions Society (FPS), I read some poor advice at the time on whether I needed to leave for 30 days or not to get my AFPS75 pension in payment. Eventually the SPVA expert came good and I left one day and joined the next with AFPS75 in full payment. It would seem that as the 75 scheme had closed and was no longer open, the 30 day rule no longer applied. That experience left me slightly dubious of FPS' capability to deal with more complex pensions questions. However, that said, they are good at lobbying and also have helped significantly with advice for the Future AFPS.
I just need convincing that it's worth 30 quid!
LJ
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Great Britain
Age: 51
Posts: 340
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
5 Posts
I've had my answer from SPVA and it is as follows:
Happy days, that would see my take home increase by £5k overnight in his illustration - it will be a lot more when I really do reach 55
CPL Clott
When you attain age 55, repayment of Resettlement Commutation will cease. Your service pension will revert to its original level of £XXXXX (from its current commuted level of £XXXXX - £YYYY where YYYY is your commuted sum pay back).
Annual increases will be added to the pension at that point.
If you remain re-employed in FTRS at that point, your pension will continue to be abated. The abatement will be deducted from your new level of pension.
The current level of abatement to your pension is £YYYY and it will continue at this same level throughout your re-employment, unless you change post, rank or commitment, wherein the abatement will be reassessed at the point of change (adjusted to inflation).
As an example, if you were age 55 today:
Your basic pension would be £ZZZZZ (which is £XXXXX adjusted by inflation)
Less re-employment abatement £YYYY
At this point you would recieve £ZZZZZ-£YYYY
which is raised by index linking and the removal of the commutation sum
Annual increases will be added to the pension at that point.
If you remain re-employed in FTRS at that point, your pension will continue to be abated. The abatement will be deducted from your new level of pension.
The current level of abatement to your pension is £YYYY and it will continue at this same level throughout your re-employment, unless you change post, rank or commitment, wherein the abatement will be reassessed at the point of change (adjusted to inflation).
As an example, if you were age 55 today:
Your basic pension would be £ZZZZZ (which is £XXXXX adjusted by inflation)
Less re-employment abatement £YYYY
At this point you would recieve £ZZZZZ-£YYYY
which is raised by index linking and the removal of the commutation sum
CPL Clott
Cpl Clott
That's excellent news mate. Given that CPI has been 3.1% in 2011 and 5.2% in 2012 then that will be a significant increase. If CPI averages 3% for the next 8 or so years then I will see my pension go up by £9k per year and also my £4.5k per year commutation ceased. That will be a £1200 per month pay rise on my 55th birthday - kerrching!
That is if the bankers and politicians haven't nadgered the country by then!
LJ
PS. Looks like you saved yourself £30 as well by not using the FPS!!!
That's excellent news mate. Given that CPI has been 3.1% in 2011 and 5.2% in 2012 then that will be a significant increase. If CPI averages 3% for the next 8 or so years then I will see my pension go up by £9k per year and also my £4.5k per year commutation ceased. That will be a £1200 per month pay rise on my 55th birthday - kerrching!
That is if the bankers and politicians haven't nadgered the country by then!
LJ
PS. Looks like you saved yourself £30 as well by not using the FPS!!!
JJ
The 'no abatement' only applies to those on FAFPS15 and not AFPS75 or AFPS05. Therefore, the first individuals where 'no abatement' applies will be 22 years after 2015 - ie. those that are serving in 2037!!!
Not that generous really and I'm sure it is not what Lord Hutton intended!
LJ
The 'no abatement' only applies to those on FAFPS15 and not AFPS75 or AFPS05. Therefore, the first individuals where 'no abatement' applies will be 22 years after 2015 - ie. those that are serving in 2037!!!
Not that generous really and I'm sure it is not what Lord Hutton intended!
LJ
By the way, has anyone else been dissapointed with the Forces Pension Society, or is it just me? I do know of one other that canx'd his subscription after the first year having only confirmed what he knew already; which for £30 didn't really meet the value for money mantra!
As I said before, I have had better experience by speaking to SPVA, looking at the regulations and the AFPS information documents.
LJ
As I said before, I have had better experience by speaking to SPVA, looking at the regulations and the AFPS information documents.
LJ
By the way, has anyone else been dissapointed with the Forces Pension Society, or is it just me?
LJ
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Lincoln
Posts: 67
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cpl Clott,
Not sure if I am being a little numb here, but are you saying that once you get past 55 and are still employed as FTRS, the whole 'you cannot earn more than you did when serving' rule stops? They still take the abatement from your pension which they did when you were under 55 but you get the RPI pension rises and commutation sum back? If that is the case, it will make FTRS more attractive and help recruitment substantially!
Not sure if I am being a little numb here, but are you saying that once you get past 55 and are still employed as FTRS, the whole 'you cannot earn more than you did when serving' rule stops? They still take the abatement from your pension which they did when you were under 55 but you get the RPI pension rises and commutation sum back? If that is the case, it will make FTRS more attractive and help recruitment substantially!
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Great Britain
Age: 51
Posts: 340
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
5 Posts
Grumpy 106
Yes, kind of. If you have abatement applied then it doesn't change for life unless you change commitment, promote or change FTRS job. So if, like me, you join FTRS with a few years to run to 55 then you have your pension abated with resettlement commutation deducted as well, then your monthly pension will remain the same until 55.
After 55, the same abatement will apply at the same amount, but the resettlement commutation deduction will cease (which is about £4k for me) and then RPI/CPI will be applied to the whole new pension and awarded. So in effect only a small abatement worked out many years ago will still be deducted.
As LJ says, kerr-frickin-ching! That will see my salary rise by an estimated £10k on my 55th birthday - a happy birthday indeed.
Make sense?
CPL Clott
Yes, kind of. If you have abatement applied then it doesn't change for life unless you change commitment, promote or change FTRS job. So if, like me, you join FTRS with a few years to run to 55 then you have your pension abated with resettlement commutation deducted as well, then your monthly pension will remain the same until 55.
After 55, the same abatement will apply at the same amount, but the resettlement commutation deduction will cease (which is about £4k for me) and then RPI/CPI will be applied to the whole new pension and awarded. So in effect only a small abatement worked out many years ago will still be deducted.
As LJ says, kerr-frickin-ching! That will see my salary rise by an estimated £10k on my 55th birthday - a happy birthday indeed.
Make sense?
CPL Clott