BBC get it wrong again?
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 1999
Posts: 4,432
Likes: 33
From: LHR/EGLL
BBC get it wrong again?
I've just watched the BBC Six o'clock News. During the first Falklands themed report (Thatcher radio broadcast and HMS Ark Royal sailing up the Thames), I'm sure I heard the reporter say something like "Ark Royal is of course the Navy's most illustrious veteran of the conflict." Was I hearing things?
I've just sent a comment to the BBC advising more time spent be on research.
(my italics....given the context, to name (one intentionally, one unintentionally) two carriers that were not involved in the war is rather crass.)
I've just sent a comment to the BBC advising more time spent be on research.
(my italics....given the context, to name (one intentionally, one unintentionally) two carriers that were not involved in the war is rather crass.)
More bang for your buck
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 3,513
Likes: 1
From: land of the clanger
"Ark Royal is of course the Navy's most illustrious veteran of the conflict." Was I hearing things?
The definition:
illustrious
adjective, well known and highly respected
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 2,142
Likes: 58
From: Temporarily missing from the Joe Louis Arena
Exactly. She might well be known and respected, but also three years premature it seems.
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 104
Likes: 0
From: west london
But Gonzo, they got it wrong on the news again last night when they reported that Gordon Brown, whilst on his whistlestop tour of Baghdad, was flown around by an Army helicopter...Since when did the Army equip with Pumas? Maybe this is why the RAF are trying so hard to waste money on new logos etc on the aircraft.
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 714
Likes: 0
From: ecosse
Ark Royal was one of the 3 "Illustrious" class carriers
Illustrious, Invincible, Ark Royal
I think she meant Illustrious, but she didn't try to 'spin' as her mind was probably spinning at the time and she was getting on a bit
BTW, I had cocktails on the 'old' steam catapult Ark in 72 and got "steaming" in the CPO's Mess - happy days
Gonzo
While your there, can you ask BBC to stop flashing up pics of MR1 Nimrods when MR2 are conducting vital SAR Ops in the N Atlantic
Illustrious, Invincible, Ark Royal
I think she meant Illustrious, but she didn't try to 'spin' as her mind was probably spinning at the time and she was getting on a bit
BTW, I had cocktails on the 'old' steam catapult Ark in 72 and got "steaming" in the CPO's Mess - happy days
Gonzo
While your there, can you ask BBC to stop flashing up pics of MR1 Nimrods when MR2 are conducting vital SAR Ops in the N Atlantic
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
From: UK, for now.
Our CVS are known as the Invincible class, after the first of the class (and actual Falklands veteran 
), despite the fact she's now in mothballs 
Can't believe that standards at the Beeb have dropped so low (well, actually I can, unfortunately) that they can't get the names of the carriers at the Falklands right - after all, it's not like there were that many to remember.
), despite the fact she's now in mothballs Can't believe that standards at the Beeb have dropped so low (well, actually I can, unfortunately) that they can't get the names of the carriers at the Falklands right - after all, it's not like there were that many to remember.
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 740
Likes: 58
From: Nottinghamshire
Theres also an article in todays Daily Express, under the headline "A Falklands Hero Returns" and a picture of Ark Royal on the thames. The article says an important componant of the ship is missing , and explains that there are no Sea Harriers on the vessal at the moment, as they are all away either training for, or actually in Afghanistan..
A scrap yard on the outskirts of Kabul presumably.
A scrap yard on the outskirts of Kabul presumably.
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 72
Likes: 0
From: london
You should all be emailing BBC and newspaper editors urging them to recruit more specialist defence correspondents, and give big pay rises to those they already have.
Thanks to Ark's crew who took time to show a few of us around this morning.
I met a real gem of an '82 veteran Sea Harrier pilot, whom I'm sure many of you will know. Now flies for Branson. Was whisked off to Hermes from Yeovilton in '82 without having finished his training, and came back with five (I think he said) kills.
Told us a great story about the Heath-Robinson contraption they rigged up on the way south to dispense chaff from SHARs which didn't have chaff dispensers, to defeat Mirage's radar-guided missiles.
For those who weren't there at the time, think chaff tucked into air brake and bits of string flapping around in the airstream, which snapped at the appropriate moment when air brake was deployed to fling out chaff. Somehow, it worked.
With equipment like that how did we win?
With ingenuity like that, how could we lose?
To those who were there 25 years ago, I salute you all.
Thanks to Ark's crew who took time to show a few of us around this morning.
I met a real gem of an '82 veteran Sea Harrier pilot, whom I'm sure many of you will know. Now flies for Branson. Was whisked off to Hermes from Yeovilton in '82 without having finished his training, and came back with five (I think he said) kills.
Told us a great story about the Heath-Robinson contraption they rigged up on the way south to dispense chaff from SHARs which didn't have chaff dispensers, to defeat Mirage's radar-guided missiles.
For those who weren't there at the time, think chaff tucked into air brake and bits of string flapping around in the airstream, which snapped at the appropriate moment when air brake was deployed to fling out chaff. Somehow, it worked.
With equipment like that how did we win?
With ingenuity like that, how could we lose?
To those who were there 25 years ago, I salute you all.
