finding your way back to the carrier
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Up there
Posts: 342
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
finding your way back to the carrier
hi all,
Just a quick question from a civi pilot. I was wondering how the navy pilots find their way back to an aircraft carrier after going out on a sortie? is there a radio beacon on the carrier or do you just use coordinates tapped into a GPS?
If a radio beacon, do you not get strange reading due to the boat itself 'bending' the readouts?
Cheers
Foil
Just a quick question from a civi pilot. I was wondering how the navy pilots find their way back to an aircraft carrier after going out on a sortie? is there a radio beacon on the carrier or do you just use coordinates tapped into a GPS?
If a radio beacon, do you not get strange reading due to the boat itself 'bending' the readouts?
Cheers
Foil
I'matightbastard
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Texas
Posts: 1,747
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
If it can be done after an extended shore leave with the after effects of the Rolfies still making you a little woozy, I would have thought that stone cold sober would be a doddle.
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Seat 1A or 1B
Posts: 112
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
Unsure how they do it now, I assume some sort of moving waypoint in the INS or GPS with a memory dump switch (such as we had in the Puma after the Nav update) for rapid use in case you have to make make an off airport landing when still sausage side.
But an ex colleague of mine, who flew RN Fireflies and Sea Furies from carriers during the Korean War, said that the warships had a NDB type thingy which was split into four quadrants each giving dots or dashes or a combination.
This way the Chinese couldn't simply home in on the carrier and sink it as the Air Wing was turning from downwind to finals !
Aircrews used to write the gen on the back of their flying glove before each sortie, that's the QDM for each quadrant I assume.
Explained to me a long time ago, and dimly remembered, but something like that.
Having just re-read this, I see that's it's been of no help whatsoever.
Cheers,
MoT
But an ex colleague of mine, who flew RN Fireflies and Sea Furies from carriers during the Korean War, said that the warships had a NDB type thingy which was split into four quadrants each giving dots or dashes or a combination.
This way the Chinese couldn't simply home in on the carrier and sink it as the Air Wing was turning from downwind to finals !
Aircrews used to write the gen on the back of their flying glove before each sortie, that's the QDM for each quadrant I assume.
Explained to me a long time ago, and dimly remembered, but something like that.
Having just re-read this, I see that's it's been of no help whatsoever.
Cheers,
MoT
Cunning Artificer
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: The spiritual home of DeHavilland
Age: 76
Posts: 3,127
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
They open the cockpit canopy and follow their noses to dinner.
"You've gotta land here son. This is where the food is..."
"You've gotta land here son. This is where the food is..."
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: wherever I lay my headset
Posts: 538
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
Whilst it was just FAA squadron's onboard they relied on navigation and a bit of luck... in fact the suggestion that TACAN be fitted was positively scoffed at ("you couldn't use it in war therefore there was no place for it onboard")... but now the RAF have joined the party, the ships are being fitted with TACAN.
Now far be if from me to infer anything, but....?
Now far be if from me to infer anything, but....?
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: LFA 3
Posts: 64
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
Originally Posted by Aerofoil
I was wondering how the navy pilots find their way back to an aircraft carrier after going out on a sortie? is there a radio beacon on the carrier or do you just use coordinates tapped into a GPS?
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Lowlevel UK
Posts: 316
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
It was simpler for one destroyer. In the glorious days of DLGs, the fall back for HMS Norfolk's Wessex III was to recover visually, even in totally darkened conditions with silent EMCON. While the huge sliding door/port side hangar wall might be closed, there was a hinged triangular dogflap in the bottom left hand corner which was always left open. It was just large enough to squeeze through on your knees. There was a red light outside the Flight office on the starboard side of the hangar so the trick was to establish the ship's cse/speed before switching off the radar then approach low level on a bearing of red 170. It was impressive just how far out you could pick up the light - simple combat id.
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
Slightly OT as I don't recall a Beverley doing a carrier landing, but the saying about 34 Sqn at Seletar was that they navigated outbound by dead-reckoning and then RTB'd by back-tracking along their oil slick!
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
There's a bit in the movie 'Apollo 13' where 'Jim Lovell' (Tom Hanks) recounts a time when he lost all electrics at night in a carrier aircraft. He wonders how he's going to find his way back to the carrier. Then he spots a fluorescent trail in the sea which leads back to the carrier. Apparently, the wake of the boat had churned up phosphorescent plankton in the sea making them glow.
I don't know if the story is from Lovell's original story about Apollo 13 ('Lost Moon') upon which the movie is based or whether it was added by the sometimes overly sentimental director of the film, Ron Howard.
I don't know if the story is from Lovell's original story about Apollo 13 ('Lost Moon') upon which the movie is based or whether it was added by the sometimes overly sentimental director of the film, Ron Howard.
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
Miles Off Target,
Moving waypoints is not far from the truth. The Shar also has a Radar which helps, but the ATCOs are quite key to the recovery IMHO, especially for the non radar fitted GR.
Very basic skills are used. Primary Radar primarily using ident turns.
Direction Finding even LLQGH if required.
SSR is available, although not as useful for reasons I will not discuss here.
and TACAN is now available.
"The Sea Harrier has an AD 2770 Tacan tactical air navigation system from BAE SYSTEMS and MADGE Microwave Airborne Digital Guidance Equipment from Thales Defence. The Royal Navy Sea Harrier FA2 update programme includes the fitting of a reversionary IPG-100F GPS from Rockwell-Collins (UK) Ltd."
But this comment above is redundant after Mar 06.
WEBF you are banned from taking part in this conversation!
Moving waypoints is not far from the truth. The Shar also has a Radar which helps, but the ATCOs are quite key to the recovery IMHO, especially for the non radar fitted GR.
Very basic skills are used. Primary Radar primarily using ident turns.
Direction Finding even LLQGH if required.
SSR is available, although not as useful for reasons I will not discuss here.
and TACAN is now available.
"The Sea Harrier has an AD 2770 Tacan tactical air navigation system from BAE SYSTEMS and MADGE Microwave Airborne Digital Guidance Equipment from Thales Defence. The Royal Navy Sea Harrier FA2 update programme includes the fitting of a reversionary IPG-100F GPS from Rockwell-Collins (UK) Ltd."
But this comment above is redundant after Mar 06.
WEBF you are banned from taking part in this conversation!
Re: finding your way back to the carrier
"and TACAN is now available."
We had TACAN available on our carriers in the 1960's. Didn't always work, mind, and since nobody could go up to the top of the mast until the funnel smoke had been switched off, it stayed U/S from (usually) the first day at sea until we got back to harbour.
We had TACAN available on our carriers in the 1960's. Didn't always work, mind, and since nobody could go up to the top of the mast until the funnel smoke had been switched off, it stayed U/S from (usually) the first day at sea until we got back to harbour.
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: uk
Posts: 118
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That's why you carried an Observer. He could do the DR and work doppler TANS. Destroyers/Frigates also displayed a mast head red light from a pre-determined time which could be seen from a long way.
Schiller,
That is progress for you.
When the old Ark was scrapped, the RN managed to get the CVS procured. Unfortunately, because it was a "through deck cruiser" with a mainly ASW focus, recovery of FW aircraft was not high on the list of priorities and so, things like TACAN got ditched/were not bought.
The best thing that ever happened to the CVS was when, during the recent refits, they removed Sea Dart. This finally emphasised to the Warfare fraternity (The RN Master Race), that the CVS was not a Type 42 on steroids but an aviation platform, there solely to project Air Power. Money has always been tight but finally, due to the efforts of some, Illustrious has TACAN and PAR has been lined up as well. Some way to go, but getting there. The Type 45 should also have some utility as well, in helping aircraft get back to mother. The CVS will hopefully be all singing and dancing in the ATC/WC aspects and not just focussed around firing missiles/launching torpedoes.
The ATCOs on ships have been living on the edge for years and finally are emerging, if not into the 21st century at least into the 1990s! So not all is rotten in the state of MOD. There is some good news on the equipment front!
Finally, to answer the original question, it is bl**dy difficult getting back to the ship. Even when you tell people where you are, sometimes they can still not find you. It is challenging flying and controlling, when one day you can be on the south coast in low lying areas and two days later in a loch or fjord in dog$h!t weather, with limited local knowledge. Easy for me, my ar$e stays firmly strapped to the deck! (2000 hours fixed and rotary chairs(apologies to Nigel Cole)).
I have nothing but admiration for those who chuck themselves off the deck at night into the Ocean Sky, not knowing if mother is going to be there when they get back, short of fuel with no diversion!
Respect!
That is progress for you.
When the old Ark was scrapped, the RN managed to get the CVS procured. Unfortunately, because it was a "through deck cruiser" with a mainly ASW focus, recovery of FW aircraft was not high on the list of priorities and so, things like TACAN got ditched/were not bought.
The best thing that ever happened to the CVS was when, during the recent refits, they removed Sea Dart. This finally emphasised to the Warfare fraternity (The RN Master Race), that the CVS was not a Type 42 on steroids but an aviation platform, there solely to project Air Power. Money has always been tight but finally, due to the efforts of some, Illustrious has TACAN and PAR has been lined up as well. Some way to go, but getting there. The Type 45 should also have some utility as well, in helping aircraft get back to mother. The CVS will hopefully be all singing and dancing in the ATC/WC aspects and not just focussed around firing missiles/launching torpedoes.
The ATCOs on ships have been living on the edge for years and finally are emerging, if not into the 21st century at least into the 1990s! So not all is rotten in the state of MOD. There is some good news on the equipment front!
Finally, to answer the original question, it is bl**dy difficult getting back to the ship. Even when you tell people where you are, sometimes they can still not find you. It is challenging flying and controlling, when one day you can be on the south coast in low lying areas and two days later in a loch or fjord in dog$h!t weather, with limited local knowledge. Easy for me, my ar$e stays firmly strapped to the deck! (2000 hours fixed and rotary chairs(apologies to Nigel Cole)).
I have nothing but admiration for those who chuck themselves off the deck at night into the Ocean Sky, not knowing if mother is going to be there when they get back, short of fuel with no diversion!
Respect!
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: twixt north & south pole
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
not knowing if mother is going to be there when they get back, short of fuel with no diversion!
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Lowlevel UK
Posts: 316
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Getting Home
Ah El-Dog - such memories. It wasn't always a problem with mother - if the recovery was successful, you could always throttle someone in the Ops Room. It was NATO that offered snags in finding the right deck and something to suck. Although never formally written down as doctrine, NATO seemed to regularly translate the instructions VERTREP and Helo Transfer in an ATO as the ancient WWII order for ships to scatter. This meant fuel on a friendly deck in the right place would be essential before you got anywhere near the final landing. I have horrible recollections of a suddenly empty Baltic at dusk when just trying to get some mail to a Yank frigate. Not exactly a punchy warrior-like excuse for mislaying a perfectly serviceable helo and taking a lonely and icy bath. Lets face it, no-one has ever accused a Lynx of being able to float.
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 1,089
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Remember Sub-Lt Watson and the Alraigo...
I was at Wittering soon after this event and foolishly remarked how lucky/quick thinking the fellow was. Gasps all round and some kind chap said "he did not know what country the ship was from before he landed. It may have been Russian" Good points made all round but what was the truth of that? Did he know anything before landing? Sorry if its a bit off topic.
I was at Wittering soon after this event and foolishly remarked how lucky/quick thinking the fellow was. Gasps all round and some kind chap said "he did not know what country the ship was from before he landed. It may have been Russian" Good points made all round but what was the truth of that? Did he know anything before landing? Sorry if its a bit off topic.
Suspicion breeds confidence
It was in daylight, so I'm guessing he had time to eyeball the registry and flag. Good point though. Donating an RN jet even a FRS1 to the Sovs would not have popular.
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
The RN is not the only flt deck hard to find.
Couple of S2 out of KSS in late '70s had difficulty finding mother. But then if you put 3E in the IN when mother is 3W.
Couple of S2 out of KSS in late '70s had difficulty finding mother. But then if you put 3E in the IN when mother is 3W.