Only 20 mins of phone calls?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Only 20 mins of phone calls?
Why is it that all our troops who are deployed get only 20 mins of telephone calls a week to call loved ones yet if you are in one of Her Majesty's establishments you get almost 2 hours per week to call loved ones (and visits). Surely this can't be right when you have soldiers etc fighting for their country and they get a whole 20 mins to talk to loved ones. On the other hand, if you are a bagsnatcher, murderer, rapist etc etc you can have the luxury of calling home every day for your punishment. Something needs to be addressed here and soon.
Red On, Green On
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Between the woods and the water
Age: 24
Posts: 6,487
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
20 minutes a week sounds a lot better than a handfull of blueys and a few family-grams that we could tx/rx when my Dad was in the Sth Atlantic in 79-81.
The logistics of giving everyone 2 hrs per week would be horrendous in some theatres.
The logistics of giving everyone 2 hrs per week would be horrendous in some theatres.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Airborne artist, I am not saying give everyone 2 hours, but a bit more than 20 mins would be more than welcome at this time of year.
I don,t see how logistics come into it when you already have the phones set up in theatre. Most people work all sorts of hours so are calling home at different times of day. There will hardly be soldiers etc standing in a line waiting to call loved ones rather than go carry out their duties. Also if they have time to send an e-bluey, which some do, then you can say a lot more in a 10 min phone call most days. Furthermore we are in the year 2004 so use the technology that is there.
I don,t see how logistics come into it when you already have the phones set up in theatre. Most people work all sorts of hours so are calling home at different times of day. There will hardly be soldiers etc standing in a line waiting to call loved ones rather than go carry out their duties. Also if they have time to send an e-bluey, which some do, then you can say a lot more in a 10 min phone call most days. Furthermore we are in the year 2004 so use the technology that is there.
In the Falklands over Christmas 1999, Cable & Wireless gave everyone a £10 card, Station Commande did the same. (There were no free 20 mins in them days). People were queuing for more than 6 hours to use their free cards, some were using their own cards as well. If evryone was given a free 2 hours, I would still be queuing now.
I feel lucky since I am sitting here in Baghdad and there is enough bandwidth for us to call for as long as we want - however, it is the US owned system so can cope with all the demand without upsetting operations. That said, I should point out that my own unit said it was all too difficult and we would have to use our own mobile phones!!!!!
Certainly I shall be counselling the officer at home base when I return. On second thoughts perhaps I'll encourage him to come out here and test the water......
Bottom line is that in this day and age there should be nothing preventing almost unlimited access to phones on deployment. 20 mins is a bit thin though.
Certainly I shall be counselling the officer at home base when I return. On second thoughts perhaps I'll encourage him to come out here and test the water......
Bottom line is that in this day and age there should be nothing preventing almost unlimited access to phones on deployment. 20 mins is a bit thin though.
Last edited by Big Unit Specialist; 16th Nov 2004 at 05:18.
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: EGYD
Posts: 1,073
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Furthermore we are in the year 2004 so use the technology that is there.
Does the Islas Malvinas yet have a BroadBenny link to the UK? Or even a mobile Bennyphone system?
Or is the '2 cans and a piece of string' system still the only alternative to Cab£e and Wire£e$$?
Or is the '2 cans and a piece of string' system still the only alternative to Cab£e and Wire£e$$?
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: UK
Posts: 806
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Still the same Beags . .. . . . . . .
As for " we don't go where technology is" what a crock. For instance, Basra and FI both have the facilities, I know cos I've used them !!!
The 20 mins works out at less than 3 mins a day.
Course, you could say that LSSA could/would/should supplement the free calls you get . . .. . . .
But if those held at HM pleasure get 2 hour a week, and we get 20 mins, then surely there's something wrong there . . .
As for " we don't go where technology is" what a crock. For instance, Basra and FI both have the facilities, I know cos I've used them !!!
The 20 mins works out at less than 3 mins a day.
Course, you could say that LSSA could/would/should supplement the free calls you get . . .. . . .
But if those held at HM pleasure get 2 hour a week, and we get 20 mins, then surely there's something wrong there . . .
Good job that Speckled Jim is still alive then......
The pitiful state of BennyComms has been an utter disgrace for well over 10 years now. I guess C&W have been laughing all the way to the bank though...
The pitiful state of BennyComms has been an utter disgrace for well over 10 years now. I guess C&W have been laughing all the way to the bank though...
But why? Back in around 1994/5 I showed people that I could call 1312 Flt crewroom from my car whilst sitting in a car park in the UK - so why shouldn't the reverse apply?
Intra-Bennycomms are indeed not bad at all - but trying to call overseas was always fraught with reliability and cost issues!
At a time when our colonial cousins were sending back live colour TV pictures from Pluto, we still weren't able to make basic overseas phone calls from the Malvinas!
Intra-Bennycomms are indeed not bad at all - but trying to call overseas was always fraught with reliability and cost issues!
At a time when our colonial cousins were sending back live colour TV pictures from Pluto, we still weren't able to make basic overseas phone calls from the Malvinas!
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: wilderness
Posts: 59
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There is a significant issue here that should not be lost within all the history of communication standards. If a convicted criminal can use a phone for 2 hours free, why on earth should a member of the Black Watch suffer only 3 mins. There a wider issues of rightly worried families, rather than a scr*te who is sorting out his next caper!
To all those who have moved along in life, living standards have changed and it appears the boys at the sharp end loose out again!
SIA
To all those who have moved along in life, living standards have changed and it appears the boys at the sharp end loose out again!
SIA
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: England
Posts: 136
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Telephone Access
Big Unit Specialist - you know that the Sgt in Allowances can't process your claim, because it is his golf afternoon at Cxxxxy Park. Same for comms access! Isn't N@pl£s great!
In Kosovo in 1999, welfare comms were more reliable than service links - where we had to use mobile phones to make otherwise sensitive calls via Yugocom in....Belgrade. In my experience, troops are able to get more than the 20 minutes a week (if they want it) by various means that we shan't expose. Moreover, what what does anyone have to say after the obligatory how are you, (fine) whats the wx like (****ty), and the food (love some bacon)..? Added to the pregnant pause, calls to loved ones are best avoided. Far too disruptive. If there is a welfare emergency, the 'Service will provide...'
Crash
In Kosovo in 1999, welfare comms were more reliable than service links - where we had to use mobile phones to make otherwise sensitive calls via Yugocom in....Belgrade. In my experience, troops are able to get more than the 20 minutes a week (if they want it) by various means that we shan't expose. Moreover, what what does anyone have to say after the obligatory how are you, (fine) whats the wx like (****ty), and the food (love some bacon)..? Added to the pregnant pause, calls to loved ones are best avoided. Far too disruptive. If there is a welfare emergency, the 'Service will provide...'
Crash
Guest
Posts: n/a
The figures are not exact, but are about ball park:
Funding for feeding service personnel at sea £1.70 pppd
Funding for feeding a convicted felon* £3.70 pppd.
This is due to prison dogs having a budget of £3.65 pdpd.
Easy to see where Pale and Pasty Fatso Brown prioritises us!
Apologies to anyone in Chogy, I did mean a victim of society.
This leads to an interesting recruitment banner:
"The armed forces - it's cheaper than locking you up"
Funding for feeding service personnel at sea £1.70 pppd
Funding for feeding a convicted felon* £3.70 pppd.
This is due to prison dogs having a budget of £3.65 pdpd.
Easy to see where Pale and Pasty Fatso Brown prioritises us!
Apologies to anyone in Chogy, I did mean a victim of society.
This leads to an interesting recruitment banner:
"The armed forces - it's cheaper than locking you up"
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: In the sun
Posts: 68
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There is another issue here for those of us who deploy on the crinkly stuff, there are 200 odd people on a Frigate/Destroyer and only 3 lines available, hence we would all be queing until the middle of next week to get on the 'phone if the limit was more than 20 minutes.
As already stated it is a hell of a lot better than it used to be, but then some of us always had the Portishead HF Radio/BT Landline phone patch
"Portishead this Army 1234 requesting phone patch"
And they never charged for the privelege, shame it went really, once heard a BA Captain discussing plans with his girlfriend about what she should wear to such and such a party and "no, there was no way his wife would ever find out", guess she would if his OpSec didn't get any better!!
Ref the food figures, they are a little inaccurrate, man at sea allowance is about £2.30 ish and a locked up lag is set at about £5.25, however the great one which raised a few eyebrows in the RN was the counter-narcotics dog taken to the West Indies last year, daily food allowance £6.42 of Her Majesties finest steak!! Lags getting twice what we did made me smart, dogs getting almost three times the sum juust makes me laugh!
As already stated it is a hell of a lot better than it used to be, but then some of us always had the Portishead HF Radio/BT Landline phone patch
"Portishead this Army 1234 requesting phone patch"
And they never charged for the privelege, shame it went really, once heard a BA Captain discussing plans with his girlfriend about what she should wear to such and such a party and "no, there was no way his wife would ever find out", guess she would if his OpSec didn't get any better!!
Ref the food figures, they are a little inaccurrate, man at sea allowance is about £2.30 ish and a locked up lag is set at about £5.25, however the great one which raised a few eyebrows in the RN was the counter-narcotics dog taken to the West Indies last year, daily food allowance £6.42 of Her Majesties finest steak!! Lags getting twice what we did made me smart, dogs getting almost three times the sum juust makes me laugh!
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: UK - North
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
20 minutes is enough and plenty to keep loved ones informed of your wellbeing. Please just think of the progress that has been made in this era of immediate communication over the last 3 -4 years. Texting works fine as I am sure everyone knows however, this now is every commanders nightmare. Instant communication to the world.
Wow! Some people have very strange relationships if phoning home is disruptive
I find 20 mins is never enough but it is better than squat, and you can always obtain more mins from someone who finds phoning home disruptive
As for getting less from those who are "banged up" why are we even suprised any more it long ago became clear to me that politicians don't care about us as we can do them no harm.
Instant communication brings its own problems. March 23/24 Kuwait during OP TELIC is a very good example (hope I got the dates right) and you really need to be careful about it's use.
I find 20 mins is never enough but it is better than squat, and you can always obtain more mins from someone who finds phoning home disruptive
As for getting less from those who are "banged up" why are we even suprised any more it long ago became clear to me that politicians don't care about us as we can do them no harm.
Instant communication brings its own problems. March 23/24 Kuwait during OP TELIC is a very good example (hope I got the dates right) and you really need to be careful about it's use.
Champagne anyone...?
Whether or not 20 minutes a week is enough isn't really the issue here. What is at issue is the fact that a prisoner's rights seem to be more highly regarded than do those of a serviceman.
I would frankly be happy to see our allowance remain at 20 mins and that of the cons reduced below that considerably. There we are: money saving initiative. Do I win a free phonecard?
I would frankly be happy to see our allowance remain at 20 mins and that of the cons reduced below that considerably. There we are: money saving initiative. Do I win a free phonecard?