PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Middle East (https://www.pprune.org/middle-east-44/)
-   -   Dubai Crash (https://www.pprune.org/middle-east/426223-dubai-crash.html)

616200 5th Sep 2010 12:50

Crashed UPS 747 had smoke in cockpit

ning69 5th Sep 2010 13:41

dxb?????
 
Why in the world would they go back to DXB why not land at Bahrain they were on fire, remember Swiss air crash, instead of wanting to dump fuel and go to Halifax , if they would have gone to Muncton right away at first sign of fire they would have made it.

IndAir967 5th Sep 2010 14:20

for that matter DOH was close by ..

only the blackbox can tell us what made the crew head back to DXB .. :ooh:

MrMachfivepointfive 5th Sep 2010 14:24

Of course they do.
 

Emirates Airlines is very lucky not to lose around 500 of its pilots and families living less than 1000 feet under the path of the ill-fated UPS B744. I imagine they would not have a contingency plan for such a scenario.
They would have simply thawed the clone embryos they secretly hatched from the stem cells that were extracted during your joining medical.

But in the future EK crew accomodation will be dispersed and moved underground.

donpizmeov 5th Sep 2010 14:26

We always make perfect decisions after the event don't we. No-one except those two fellas know what indications they had or why they did what they did.

Just the same way the Swissair Capt did what he thought was right at the time. Happens every day, luckily we don't face the real life and death ones like this very often, and our not really perfect answer to the situation actions still get everyone down ok without the names needing to be published in the media.

the Don

jumbo1 5th Sep 2010 16:33

Quite right Don.
There but for the grace go any one of us.
Condolences to the families of the gentlemen involved.
This scenario has to be every pilots nightmare.
RIP fellas.......

goeasy 5th Sep 2010 17:04

For those curious about why/where they turned back.... Bahrain airspace does not mean they were actually close to Bahrain. Bahrain ACC controls a lot of airspace from UAE to Riyadh/Kuwait (almost).

So an aircraft can be closer to DXB but controlled from BAH.

And its a huge argument in these parts, as to whether its the Arabian or Persian Gulf ! Same splash of water either name.

palm 6th Sep 2010 06:22

On the radio it was Doha or Dubai, they choose Dubai and didn't make the approach ( to high, to fast), went around and crashed close to DSO. ( ATC told them, YOU ARE TOO LOW, TOO LOW)

I feel so sad for this 2 guys and they families,

Jet II 6th Sep 2010 06:43

What is the book procedure for fire on a freighter?

I understood that as no fire suppression/extinguishing systems are fitted, that the idea was that if a fire broke out you remained at altitude and depressurised - thereby starving the fire of oxygen.

Trader 6th Sep 2010 08:04

Jet---perhaps, but they radioed fire and smoke in the FLIGHT DECK. Could not even change freq's since there was so much much smoke.

They did the right thing---tried to get down ASAP!


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:14.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.