PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Jet Blast (https://www.pprune.org/jet-blast-16/)
-   -   Accidental shooting (https://www.pprune.org/jet-blast/643337-accidental-shooting.html)

uffington sb 23rd Oct 2021 05:03

Accidental shooting

A very tragic event, but how can that happen?
Surely they would have had an armourer to check the weapons prior to use.

jolihokistix 23rd Oct 2021 05:05

From the latest information it sounds as if the holes in the cheese lined up. Utterly tragic.

pattern_is_full 23rd Oct 2021 06:06

A lot of complexities (and rumours) possibly involved (as with any investigation):

- Apparently some of the professional crew had walked off the set (before the fatal event) over safety concerns, possibly leaving the armourer's or prop-master's duties to be fulfilled by an asst. director, who may have had no experience managing prop firearms and their safety protocols. The AD thought and stated to the crew just before the shooting that the gun was "cold" (unloaded)
- the safety concerns may have been regarding this particular prop gun, which some people reported may have discharged "accidentally" on previous recent occasions (same film set).
- Generally, prop-guns are built with a unique calibre, that cannot accept any normal firearm ammunition, just specially-sized blanks. But it is not clear yet if this was actually true of the device in question.
- "Blanks" themselves are still quite dangerous explosive charges at close range, and produce some high-velocity ejecta even without a bullet present.
- it is not clear to me (yet) whether the prop weapon directly killed the cinematographer, or perhaps hit the camera and ricocheted, or blew off "shrapnel" from the camera or some other piece of gear in close proximity to the victims. A chunk of metal off a camera/mount, blown into one's heart or aorta, can kill as effectively as a bullet. I see pictures of this cinematographer working with both body-mounted cameras, and standard tripod assemblies.
- Rust was reportedly a low-budget project, which introduces all the same questions that can arise in "cheap operations" of any kind - rush to maintain schedule, corner-cutting, inadequate staffing, poor maintenance of this or that, etc. MAYBE!

I expect some of those questions will be answered fairly rapidly, although any medical stuff may take a while.

chevvron 23rd Oct 2021 06:58

Even when you 'know' a weapon is loaded wth blanks, you should still NEVER point it at any one directly if/when you squeeze the trigger.
I did a 5 day course with the RAF Regt and it was always drummed into us that you must open the action at all times and show others it is 'safe' whenever you handle it.

jolihokistix 23rd Oct 2021 07:16

He was probably required to point it at the camera and shoot.

blue up 23rd Oct 2021 07:16

If they were working to a small budget they'd probably forego buying in a 'Prop Gun' and just use a regular firearm.

Blanks are available for pretty much every common calibre, even in the UK. .22 calibre 'blanks' are what you use in a Hilti gun to blast a nail into timber. That tells you how much power there is in one.

pattern_is_full 23rd Oct 2021 07:36

Additional info from AP:

There was an armorer present (Hannah Gutierrez). She set out three guns on a cart outside the building where filming was taking place.

The AD (Dave Halls) picked up one of the three guns and took it into the building, announcing "cold gun" and handing it to Alec Baldwin.

Obviously somewhere in that chain of custody, there was an error or communication failure in determining the actual state of the gun.


uffington sb 23rd Oct 2021 07:55

But why would they ever need a “Hot” gun on a film set?

rudestuff 23rd Oct 2021 09:29

A close up of belted ammunition?
I doesn't take long to teach someone NSPs, surely all actors should understand how to check a weapon and be expected to clear it themselves? A cardinal rule is never believe someone who tells you a firearm is unloaded.

TWT 23rd Oct 2021 09:59

Muzzle flashes and audio 'bangs' are frequently added later in post production. However, it just adds to the costs.

There have been a few reports that this film shoot was 'low budget' (no information on what budget range is considered to be 'low')

It struck me that an investigation into how it happened would have many similarities with an aircraft accident investigation.

Human factors, equipment, communications between various parties, 'press-on-itis', authority gradients etc.

uffington sb 23rd Oct 2021 10:04

Absolutely. Never ever take someone else’s word, it only takes a few seconds to check.

spekesoftly 23rd Oct 2021 10:06

Never point a weapon at someone, unless you intend to kill them. It's what I was taught as a member of HM Forces back in the 1960s.

cattletruck 23rd Oct 2021 10:17

Media now reporting a single real bullet, which could explain the taking of two victims with the one shot.

This is very sad, and if the above is true then something very sinister has occurred as there is no place for real bullets on a film set.

back to Boeing 23rd Oct 2021 10:30

I listened to an armourer yesterday when the details were scant. He had worked with Alec Baldwin previously and said Mr Baldwin was extremely knowledgeable and safe with weapons on set and he would trust him implicitly to handle any weapon correctly as instructed.

Blacksheep 23rd Oct 2021 11:13

Rule Number One - All weapons are considered loaded until proven otherwise.

Hydromet 23rd Oct 2021 11:30

Originally Posted by spekesoftly (Post 11131057)
Never point a weapon at someone, unless you intend to kill them. It's what I was taught as a member of HM Forces back in the 1960s.

It's what I was taught as a 10yo by my father, before I was allowed to touch his .22.

Ninthace 23rd Oct 2021 11:32

I think you will find even then that was not strictly true. The challenge procedure for an armed guard required you to aim your weapon at the subject. At that point you have no intention of killing the subject, your rules of engagement prevent it and, in fact back in the 60s you couldn't, as ammunition was not routinely issued on the UK mainland.

On Exercise I pointed my weapon at loads of baddies but I never intended to kill any of them.

747 jock 23rd Oct 2021 12:36

Whilst that's fine in "real life", it would make the filming of a great many movies and TV series either next to impossible or they would end up being very unrealistic.

pilotmike 23rd Oct 2021 12:38

Originally Posted by jolihokistix (Post 11130925)
... it sounds as if the holes in the cheese lined up.

A rather unfortunate turn of phrase, given the circumstances.

ATNotts 23rd Oct 2021 13:16

Originally Posted by 747 jock (Post 11131145)
Whilst that's fine in "real life", it would make the filming of a great many movies and TV series either next to impossible or they would end up being very unrealistic.

Why is the use of firearms pretty well obligatory in movies and TV?

All times are GMT. The time now is 18:46.

Copyright © 2021 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.