Interview Question
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Ireland
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Interview Question
Hi all,
Trying to do some interview prep on the hopes that I'll eventually get one. I came across an interview question someone was asked before but I cant seem to come up with an answer. Wondering if anyone can shed any light on this.
"Which is easier to navigate along, a meridian of longitude or a parallel of latitude?"
As far as I know both meridians of longitude and parallels of latitude are rhumb lines so that rules out the fact that rhumb lines are easier to navigate than great cirlces (which meridians of longitude are).
Any thoughts?
Trying to do some interview prep on the hopes that I'll eventually get one. I came across an interview question someone was asked before but I cant seem to come up with an answer. Wondering if anyone can shed any light on this.
"Which is easier to navigate along, a meridian of longitude or a parallel of latitude?"
As far as I know both meridians of longitude and parallels of latitude are rhumb lines so that rules out the fact that rhumb lines are easier to navigate than great cirlces (which meridians of longitude are).
Any thoughts?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Ireland
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Frank not sure how I contradicted myself. Meridians of longitude are both rhumb lines and great circles.
XX621, I think I get what your saying. A 1 degree of arc is a constant distance along all meridians of longitude, but if you are constantly travelling along the same parallel of latitude wouldn't each 1 degree arc, on that parallel of latitude, be the same distance? I know the distance of a 1 degree arc will be different for each parallel of latitude but we are talkin about travelling along the same parallel.
XX621, I think I get what your saying. A 1 degree of arc is a constant distance along all meridians of longitude, but if you are constantly travelling along the same parallel of latitude wouldn't each 1 degree arc, on that parallel of latitude, be the same distance? I know the distance of a 1 degree arc will be different for each parallel of latitude but we are talkin about travelling along the same parallel.
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: 50°-60°N
Posts: 130
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thoughts? A few...
Reality in many jobs is that the FMS won't care 
... my point being that it depends how you look at the Qn: as a trainee having done GNav this qn would seem important, but you are applying to join the working world and it could be good to demonstrate this understanding that your perspective will be changing, as long as you put it very tactfully.
As importantly, there may not be a 'correct' either/or answer. In interview it is not necessarily a problem to say this, as long as you can back up your thinking.
Rather the interviewer may be more interested in hearing how you think the problem through and how you deal with being put on the spot with a qn that doesn't have an obvious answer.
You seem to have thought it through logically and good on you for trying to put in the hard work preparing properly for an interview
HTH & Good luck, BM
... my point being that it depends how you look at the Qn: as a trainee having done GNav this qn would seem important, but you are applying to join the working world and it could be good to demonstrate this understanding that your perspective will be changing, as long as you put it very tactfully.As importantly, there may not be a 'correct' either/or answer. In interview it is not necessarily a problem to say this, as long as you can back up your thinking.
Rather the interviewer may be more interested in hearing how you think the problem through and how you deal with being put on the spot with a qn that doesn't have an obvious answer.
You seem to have thought it through logically and good on you for trying to put in the hard work preparing properly for an interview
HTH & Good luck, BM
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Ireland
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for the input lads. Some good ideas there. On the off chance that the question does come up for me at some stage at least now I'll be able to talk about the subject and make some good points pn it.
A parrallel of latitude is easier to navigate along than a meridian of longitude.
A parallel of latitude crosses all meridians of longitude at the same angle, therefore once you set off on a parallel of latitude at the same initial bearing you proceed along it as a straight line and so not changing your TRUE direction (not magnetic).
A meridian of longitude is a great circle, to navigate a great circle you continually need to keep changing your bearing.
Far too early tone thinking about Gen Nav again!
Thrillseeker
A parallel of latitude crosses all meridians of longitude at the same angle, therefore once you set off on a parallel of latitude at the same initial bearing you proceed along it as a straight line and so not changing your TRUE direction (not magnetic).
A meridian of longitude is a great circle, to navigate a great circle you continually need to keep changing your bearing.
Far too early tone thinking about Gen Nav again!
Thrillseeker
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: A place where something is or could be located; a site.
Posts: 455
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A meridian of longitude is a great circle, to navigate a great circle you continually need to keep changing your bearing.
As said earlier, meridians of longitude are BOTH great circles and rhumb lines.
Any other GC will not be a rhumb line, except the EQ.
Parallels of lattitude are just rhumb lines.
So you can navigate both just as easily using a constant heading.
Mabe the PofL is harder due to transport wander of the DI gyro.
I personally think it's an open Q. They are probably wanting you to talk about this nonsense for a while, giving you answer and using your knowledge to back it up. It would be text book for the interviewer to then disagree with you, giving their reasons and seening how you cope.
PAT, I would say you kind of answered the Q in your first post.
EK
Ah yes you are quite correct, forgive me, it was fairly early on a Saturday morning!
A meridian of longitude and a Parallel of latitude are both Rhumb lines, therefore you set your heading and off you go! ... Simples
A good question for an interview to get a debate going, the more I think about it the more I like it
A great circle apart from a meridian of longitude (or the equator) will require a constant change in heading to maintain it.
I'm glad the FMC takes care of it anyway
A meridian of longitude and a Parallel of latitude are both Rhumb lines, therefore you set your heading and off you go! ... Simples
A good question for an interview to get a debate going, the more I think about it the more I like it
A great circle apart from a meridian of longitude (or the equator) will require a constant change in heading to maintain it.
I'm glad the FMC takes care of it anyway
