PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Fragrant Harbour (https://www.pprune.org/fragrant-harbour-19/)
-   -   Pilot Shortage in Hong Kong (https://www.pprune.org/fragrant-harbour/647319-pilot-shortage-hong-kong.html)

1200firm 22nd Jun 2022 01:47

Compulsory, uncompensated mini closed loops and quarantine for all passenger flights.
A tracking app that must be illegal in most countries.
AND.....prison is back for you, your crew, and your family if you, or someone on your crew, tests positive.

stevieboy330 23rd Jun 2022 06:43

Seriously, WTF are any of you guys still doing there ?

Oasis 25th Jun 2022 08:50


Originally Posted by stevieboy330 (Post 11250347)
Seriously, WTF are any of you guys still doing there ?

Why are you here? And if you already left, go bother someone else.

Gnadenburg 26th Jun 2022 08:11

Oasis

I’m ex-KA and I come here weekly, often in astonishment, to see how you are all going and to see what you are all bitching about now. I did almost 20 years in HK and half of my non-aviation friends have left in the last 18 months. It is intriguing, it is sad and how the leftover pilots have been treated horrendous.

jimsmitty01 26th Jun 2022 09:20

the only reason to stay is for the $$$$!

oh wait...

mngmt mole 26th Jun 2022 17:54

It is indeed sad to see how a once great airline (I am referring CX, but Dragonair was also a wonderful company) has been brought to a shell of its former self by truly the worst and most self-serving management group in the industry. They took it from what it once was, a place where the employees were motivated, loyal and dedicated (and passionate) to a company that is now lacking in all of those necessary sentiments. A tragedy that will eventually be highlighted in business school as a case study in management failure.

Sam Ting Wong 27th Jun 2022 06:56

Do passionate pilots in a great airline fly an ILS differently?


Busbuoy 27th Jun 2022 08:09


Originally Posted by Sam Ting Wong (Post 11252205)
Do "passionate" pilots in a "great airline" fly an ILS differently?

Over the years I reckon CX and KA crews of old would've completed more flights in difficult conditions than industry average. Safely, expeditiously and without fanfare because they were well-recruited, experienced and well-motivated pilots (and FEs in the day). So if we extend the narrow terms of your "fly an ILS" to the more general and perhaps more appropriate "conduct an airline operation"' then I think, conclusively, yes.

SaulGoodman 27th Jun 2022 08:44


Originally Posted by Busbuoy (Post 11252225)
Over the years I reckon CX and KA crews of old would've completed more flights in difficult conditions than industry average. Safely, expeditiously and without fanfare because they were well-recruited, experienced and well-motivated pilots (and FEs in the day). So if we extend the narrow terms of your "fly an ILS" to the more general and perhaps more appropriate "conduct an airline operation"' then I think, conclusively, yes.

Why do you believe so? What were the so called more “difficult” conditions a CX/KA pilot had to endure compared to other companies?

Busbuoy 27th Jun 2022 09:52


Originally Posted by SaulGoodman (Post 11252242)
Why do you believe so? What were the so called more “difficult” conditions a CX/KA pilot had to endure compared to other companies?

You misunderstand me sir. The CX/KA of old had a reputation for getting flights done when technical and operational challenges thwarted others.

Oasis 27th Jun 2022 10:23


Originally Posted by SaulGoodman (Post 11252242)
Why do you believe so? What were the so called more “difficult” conditions a CX/KA pilot had to endure compared to other companies?

You tell me why it's the same as other regions..

Busbuoy 27th Jun 2022 10:41

Yeah, what he said.....

SaulGoodman 27th Jun 2022 12:00


Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 11252271)
You tell me why it's the same as other regions..

Did I touch a sensitive subject? Honestly I couldn’t think of any reason why flying for CX/KA would be more challenging when you compare it to similar companies. But please enlighten me.

lucille 27th Jun 2022 12:43


Originally Posted by Sam Ting Wong (Post 11252205)
Do passionate pilots in a great airline fly an ILS differently?

Indeed they do. The Approach button has to be caressed with love and passion for the autopilot to respond in kind.

MENELAUS 27th Jun 2022 13:09


Originally Posted by SaulGoodman (Post 11252329)
Did I touch a sensitive subject? Honestly I couldn’t think of any reason why flying for CX/KA would be more challenging when you compare it to similar companies. But please enlighten me.

Because flying in to that aviation cesspit that is the PRC on a daily basis for the KA guys was not without its challenges, and the approaches in to the two airports in Hong Kong, and that’s not allowing for the extremes of typhoon conditions, were not on occasion that easy.
CX and KA have had their moments; no autopilot Go Arounds, attempts to fly the 25L ILS at 1500’ because they were “stable” however in the main they did a pretty good job. Compared to some other carriers. A few of which left aircraft in the harbour or upside down on taxiways.

Oasis 27th Jun 2022 14:10


Originally Posted by SaulGoodman (Post 11252329)
Did I touch a sensitive subject? Honestly I couldn’t think of any reason why flying for CX/KA would be more challenging when you compare it to similar companies. But please enlighten me.

It’s not sensitive, but thank you for your consideration.
Go ahead and explain why we have the same issues in the region as anywhere else in the world.

You brought it up, so make your point. I might agree with you if you make a good case.

Freehills 27th Jun 2022 16:57


Originally Posted by MENELAUS (Post 11252362)
Because flying in to that aviation cesspit that is the PRC on a daily basis for the KA guys was not without its challenges, and the approaches in to the two airports in Hong Kong, and that’s not allowing for the extremes of typhoon conditions, were not on occasion that easy.
CX and KA have had their moments; no autopilot Go Arounds, attempts to fly the 25L ILS at 1500’ because they were “stable” however in the main they did a pretty good job. Compared to some other carriers. A few of which left aircraft in the harbour or upside down on taxiways.

PRC pilots manage it (flying in the PRC) with, frankly, an excellent safety record.

SaulGoodman 27th Jun 2022 17:06


Originally Posted by Oasis (Post 11252395)
It’s not sensitive, but thank you for your consideration.
Go ahead and explain why we have the same issues in the region as anywhere else in the world.

You brought it up, so make your point. I might agree with you if you make a good case.

it was Busbuoy who was claiming that pilots in CX/KA have completed more flights in difficult conditions. I see no valid reason why but please enlighten me.

Having said this I am not disagreeing with you Oasis on the fact that you guys have different issues compared to crews in other reasons. But having flown on many of the same routes as CX/KA but also many more regions, terrain, warzones etc I am simply wondering why the CX/KA flight conditions are more difficult.

Sam Ting Wong 27th Jun 2022 19:02

In what way is the environment we operate in relevant?

Flex88 27th Jun 2022 20:30

Different ?
 

Originally Posted by Sam Ting Wong (Post 11252505)
In what way is the environment we operate in relevant?

Languages, accents, typhoons, sh*t ATC, lung destroying Cat III smog....... Naw, it's the exact same everywhere right ?? STW = fool .


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:33.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.