Flying Adventurer or Flying Fool?
Guest
Posts: n/a
Flying Adventurer or Flying Fool?
Just read in this morning's Metro (a freebie montage of news stories for London Transport travellers) that this famous (I think - can't remeber name) adventurer is going to fly from the Artic circle to Chile via New York including a stint over the Amazonian rain forest. Sounds like a wizard prang until I read the bit about him having only 75hrs experience TT! Surely he is going to die!
Good luck to him. He is going to need it (so are the SAR guys tasked with finding him)!
Good luck to him. He is going to need it (so are the SAR guys tasked with finding him)!
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 0
Likes: 0
From: UK,Twighlight Zone
I seem to recall a couple of guys with no TT, building and flying an aeroplane around Kittyhawk. I also recall a few other low hours aviators flying the channel and the atlantic.
Wheres your spirit of adventure! It is every human beings god given right to be stupid, attempt to kill themselves, whatever.
As long as they don't kill others at the same time then when should aplaud the spirit of adventure not critisize it!!!
Wheres your spirit of adventure! It is every human beings god given right to be stupid, attempt to kill themselves, whatever.
As long as they don't kill others at the same time then when should aplaud the spirit of adventure not critisize it!!!
Moderator



Joined: Feb 2000
Aviation Qualifications: CPL
Posts: 14,480
Likes: 178
From: UK
I seem to recall a couple of guys with no TT, building and flying an aeroplane around Kittyhawk
G
niknak
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 2,335
Likes: 0
From: UK
.
I think the last post sums it up.
When Amy Johnson was flying, there were few or possibly no rescue services afforded to finding anyone who may possibly be in distress.
Today, we have an almost universal system of SAR made up of highly trained and genuinely dedicated people who regularly risk there lives looking for people who have had the misfortune to find themselves in peril, or alternatively idiots like this who flagrantly disregard common sense and will ineviatabley be a drain on the rescue services.
Of course it's a fine dividing line, an emergency is an emergency, but it annoys the crap out of me that those who set out on some half arsed mission to oblivion should put others at risk through their own ignorance, and not care a jot, when others who make genuine efforts to plan for every probable occurance are tarred with the same brush.
I think the last post sums it up.
When Amy Johnson was flying, there were few or possibly no rescue services afforded to finding anyone who may possibly be in distress.
Today, we have an almost universal system of SAR made up of highly trained and genuinely dedicated people who regularly risk there lives looking for people who have had the misfortune to find themselves in peril, or alternatively idiots like this who flagrantly disregard common sense and will ineviatabley be a drain on the rescue services.
Of course it's a fine dividing line, an emergency is an emergency, but it annoys the crap out of me that those who set out on some half arsed mission to oblivion should put others at risk through their own ignorance, and not care a jot, when others who make genuine efforts to plan for every probable occurance are tarred with the same brush.
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 616
Likes: 0
From: Essex, UK
There are plenty of people who have LOTS of hours and still manage to make a hole in a field when it all goes wrong.
I flew to IoW with a chap, for whom it was his first XC after getting the hallowed paperwork from Gatwick. On the way back, he had an engine failure. He calmly assumed best glide, thought about possible causes and realised he had knocked the ignition switch when messing about with his map. He re-started and continued, totally un-fussed.
I would love to think I could remain so calm.
Hours mean nothing, currency is everything.
I flew to IoW with a chap, for whom it was his first XC after getting the hallowed paperwork from Gatwick. On the way back, he had an engine failure. He calmly assumed best glide, thought about possible causes and realised he had knocked the ignition switch when messing about with his map. He re-started and continued, totally un-fussed.
I would love to think I could remain so calm.
Hours mean nothing, currency is everything.

Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 13,787
Likes: 0
From: EuroGA.org
I often wonder what the REAL challenge is on these trips which make the media.
Clearly there is no effort flying along on autopilot. Or even without an autopilot, if one doesn't mind getting knackered. I've done 1300 nm in one day without any trouble. Navigation is also completely trivial, with GPS, and in remote regions there won't be VOR/DMEs so there's no need to debate GPS failure. Satellite phones make it possible to keep in touch. So the difficulty has to be in the non-flying bits.
I reckon the hard bits must be
weather
weather
weather
sponsorship / media relations
getting overflight permits
aircraft paperwork/insurance to satisfy everybody
aircraft mods done and approved (e.g. long range tanks)
getting the survival gear together, some worn and some carried
making sure there is fuel at the stops
carrying spare GPS and spare batteries
making sure there is some prospect of rescue (in most of the 3rd world, there isn't a rapid-response SAR service) in case of an engine failure
planning a route so that an engine failure is probably survivable (or just take a big risk)
weather
weather
weather

What have I missed out?
Clearly there is no effort flying along on autopilot. Or even without an autopilot, if one doesn't mind getting knackered. I've done 1300 nm in one day without any trouble. Navigation is also completely trivial, with GPS, and in remote regions there won't be VOR/DMEs so there's no need to debate GPS failure. Satellite phones make it possible to keep in touch. So the difficulty has to be in the non-flying bits.
I reckon the hard bits must be
weather
weather
weather
sponsorship / media relations
getting overflight permits
aircraft paperwork/insurance to satisfy everybody
aircraft mods done and approved (e.g. long range tanks)
getting the survival gear together, some worn and some carried
making sure there is fuel at the stops
carrying spare GPS and spare batteries
making sure there is some prospect of rescue (in most of the 3rd world, there isn't a rapid-response SAR service) in case of an engine failure
planning a route so that an engine failure is probably survivable (or just take a big risk)
weather
weather
weather

What have I missed out?
Guest
Posts: n/a
Putting up with the high-pitched whining noise from unimaginative carpers

making sure there is some prospect of rescue (in most of the 3rd world, there isn't a rapid-response SAR service) in case of an engine failure
Moderator



Joined: Feb 2000
Aviation Qualifications: CPL
Posts: 14,480
Likes: 178
From: UK
I think you'd struggle to fly that route without overflying somewhere which is (a) extremely inhospitable, and (b) Isn't ICAO, or if it is (c) frankly it would be totally unrealistic to provide continuous SAR coverage anyway. Being brutal about this, you'd struggle to justify somebody else providing your SAR cover if you are 1000+ miles from the nearest human habitation.
Having said that, the gentleman in question has some track record of this sort of thing, I believe that about 15 years ago he undertook one of the toughest sea-kayak routes in the world, in a very small team, after only a few months training.
My guess is that if he does get "mislaid" in the middle of nowhere, he'll emerge largely unassisted a few months later and write a bestselling book about it - that's the nature of the beast.
G
Having said that, the gentleman in question has some track record of this sort of thing, I believe that about 15 years ago he undertook one of the toughest sea-kayak routes in the world, in a very small team, after only a few months training.
My guess is that if he does get "mislaid" in the middle of nowhere, he'll emerge largely unassisted a few months later and write a bestselling book about it - that's the nature of the beast.
G
Guest
Posts: n/a
Found it! http://www.icao.int/cgi/goto_m.pl?/cgi/statesDB4.pl?en
With my very basic ATPL level of knowledge of climatology I would say weather wise he has picked a safe route. His flight will be mainly south of the ITCZ (as it is approaching its northen most point) where weather is generally more predictable because of the large amount of water in that part of the world. Apart from the ITCZ he will be in mainly high pressure regions and in slack wind or in areas of with very good facilities.
With my very basic ATPL level of knowledge of climatology I would say weather wise he has picked a safe route. His flight will be mainly south of the ITCZ (as it is approaching its northen most point) where weather is generally more predictable because of the large amount of water in that part of the world. Apart from the ITCZ he will be in mainly high pressure regions and in slack wind or in areas of with very good facilities.
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 799
Likes: 0
From: Gt. Yarmouth, Norfolk
Are we not talking about David Hempleman Adams? He has something of a record of successful firsts. I read his account of crossing the andes by baloon when he was fairly low hours. He then went on to reach the North geographic pole by baloon and then crossed the atlantic. |He used one of the best climatologists and forecasters to help him. Not a man to cut corners or to plunge in unprepared.
Before "Ze Germans" get here
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 319
Likes: 0
From: ?
DAvid Hempleman Adams is NOT undertaking this flight alone. He is taking along Lorne White my PPL flight instructor. He has a US ATPL and 1600hrs+ and has completed fairly extensive cross country flights around the US, Mexico and Canada.
Canadian Spotlight
Smile
Edited to say: High Wing Drifter, Your statement about DHA having 75hrs Total Time is wrong, its actually 45 hrs
Canadian Spotlight
Smile
Edited to say: High Wing Drifter, Your statement about DHA having 75hrs Total Time is wrong, its actually 45 hrs
Last edited by My names Turkish; 8th June 2004 at 20:47.




