Broadband Hub - Best Practice?
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2003
Aviation Qualifications: SLF
Posts: 739
Likes: 258
From: Midlands
Broadband Hub - Best Practice?
Trying to get a definitive answer as to what is the best practice - and why?. Leave switched on, or turn off when not in use?
More bang for your buck
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 3,513
Likes: 1
From: land of the clanger
I turn my entire system off each night, I very rarely have any serious problems with any of my kit. It means that the functions are refreshed each day so that any minor corruptions in memory are removed. It also means that you change your ip address every day (assuming you have a dynamic address.) which can be a security enhancement. Despite what some people on here will say, it makes no difference to the speed, it's a reasonably solid 7Mbs or so even immediately after switching on.
the next poster will probably say exactly the opposite.
the next poster will probably say exactly the opposite.
Per Ardua ad Astraeus
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 18,575
Likes: 4
From: UK
Sorry to disappoint you, gg, but I agree. I use EOM to connect to the router and turn off the whole thing every night with no problems (as long as I remember to turn it on again in the morning...............)
Router needs about 20 secs to 'boot up' (if that is what routers do....)
Router needs about 20 secs to 'boot up' (if that is what routers do....)
More bang for your buck
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 3,513
Likes: 1
From: land of the clanger
Oh well, wrong again.
My entire system is plunged into a multiway extension block, so at night it's a case of start>shutdown then when it has turn of the wall socket and everything is off, next morning all I have to do is to switch on the wall socket switch.
My BT hub takes about twice as long as Windows 7 to fire up. I will time it tomorrow just to see, mind you I think a lot of the time is spent initializing the VOIP side of things.
My entire system is plunged into a multiway extension block, so at night it's a case of start>shutdown then when it has turn of the wall socket and everything is off, next morning all I have to do is to switch on the wall socket switch.
My BT hub takes about twice as long as Windows 7 to fire up. I will time it tomorrow just to see, mind you I think a lot of the time is spent initializing the VOIP side of things.
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,133
Likes: 0
From: Bracknell, Berks, UK
Leave it on.
1) There is an automated process (which sometimes fails) that measures the speed capabilities of your line based on tweaking the speed upwards until the line drops and then backing off a bit. This can take up to 10 days to achieve a setting whereby the line is at it's fastest stable speed. You turning off the router at night can affect the results. (granted this is usually only done for the first 10 days of a new line, but sometimes the BRAS profile is amended mid-life).
2) Your wifi will be broadcasting on a defined channel (with overlaps) which is either manually set or automatically seeks to find the least congested airwaves. Since there are only 4 non-blocking channels that could be used, if you 'give up' your channel allocation at night, the chances are that another auto-roaming wifi access point in the vicinity will roam onto your preciously hoarded bandwidth, leaving your access point to either share with that when it turns back on (as auto roaming doesn't always happen without the AP having been rebooted) or you'll find your AP roams itself onto another channel which might not be compatible with your wifi card in your lappie (it does happen).
3) Having been out to install a router for a client an hour's drive away on Monday, only to be rung up just after i'd arrived home with them saying "there was a loud popping noise and i've got no internet again", there's something to be said for the resilience of components and power supplies when subjected to the on/off surges and heatcycles.
So, bottom line, leave it on....but I can understand why you wouldn't be affected if you turned it off.
1) There is an automated process (which sometimes fails) that measures the speed capabilities of your line based on tweaking the speed upwards until the line drops and then backing off a bit. This can take up to 10 days to achieve a setting whereby the line is at it's fastest stable speed. You turning off the router at night can affect the results. (granted this is usually only done for the first 10 days of a new line, but sometimes the BRAS profile is amended mid-life).
2) Your wifi will be broadcasting on a defined channel (with overlaps) which is either manually set or automatically seeks to find the least congested airwaves. Since there are only 4 non-blocking channels that could be used, if you 'give up' your channel allocation at night, the chances are that another auto-roaming wifi access point in the vicinity will roam onto your preciously hoarded bandwidth, leaving your access point to either share with that when it turns back on (as auto roaming doesn't always happen without the AP having been rebooted) or you'll find your AP roams itself onto another channel which might not be compatible with your wifi card in your lappie (it does happen).
3) Having been out to install a router for a client an hour's drive away on Monday, only to be rung up just after i'd arrived home with them saying "there was a loud popping noise and i've got no internet again", there's something to be said for the resilience of components and power supplies when subjected to the on/off surges and heatcycles.
So, bottom line, leave it on....but I can understand why you wouldn't be affected if you turned it off.
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 3,663
Likes: 0
From: Earth
So presumably, since they're the same type of power supply, you leave your mobile phone and other chargers on all the time as well?
Even if not the either of the above, due to circuitry inside, most modern chargers draw no or negligible power when not charging a device, so yes I do leave most things on all the time.
Also in my defence, anything that gets left plugged in and turned on is stuff that has a 99.9% chance of getting used daily. Anything else tends to get unplugged after use in order to reduce cable spaghetti.
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 1,761
Likes: 6
From: Lemonia. Best Greek in the world
I've got a BT BB hub, and I leave it on all the time for the simple reason that if SWMBO wakes up in the night and wants to use her ipad, then she can, and I sleep on in blissful ignorance.
If I had to, I would train her in how to turn on things computery, but I don't have to, so I don't.
The rest of the leccy stuff gets turned off as we've got one of those digital leccy usage monitor thingies.
If I had to, I would train her in how to turn on things computery, but I don't have to, so I don't.
The rest of the leccy stuff gets turned off as we've got one of those digital leccy usage monitor thingies.
Per Ardua ad Astraeus
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 18,575
Likes: 4
From: UK
Originally Posted by M-B
1) There is an automated process (which sometimes fails) that measures the speed capabilities of your line based on tweaking the speed upwards until the line drops and then backing off a bit. This can take up to 10 days to achieve a setting whereby the line is at it's fastest stable speed. You turning off the router at night can affect the results. (granted this is usually only done for the first 10 days of a new line, but sometimes the BRAS profile is amended mid-life).
Then, of course we have HSB via whatever, which is a whole new ball-game and again I think not rate adaptive?
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 3,663
Likes: 0
From: Earth
"LLU does not use that technology.
Then, of course we have HSB via whatever, which is a whole new ball-game and again I think not rate adaptive?
Oh, don't you worry BOAC..... the old tricks of contention, packet shaping and rate limiting will be there. Except they will be increasingly more coarsely applied downstream rather than granularly at the subscriber level.
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 2,173
Likes: 0
From: .
Leave the router on all the time (unless you are away for extended periods)
Turning it on / off on a daily basis will cause the line monitoring software to assume there is a fault, and will reduce the signal speed in an attempt to compensate.
Turning it on / off on a daily basis will cause the line monitoring software to assume there is a fault, and will reduce the signal speed in an attempt to compensate.
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 216
Likes: 0
From: EGNX country
I'm in the leave the router on camp.
From what I remember of my system integration and proving days, the ADSL subs line units can be a little tetchy if the far end comes and goes.
Things probably have improved since then of course but why put your router through heat cycling when they use so little power anyway.
From what I remember of my system integration and proving days, the ADSL subs line units can be a little tetchy if the far end comes and goes.
Things probably have improved since then of course but why put your router through heat cycling when they use so little power anyway.
More bang for your buck
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 3,513
Likes: 1
From: land of the clanger
Turning it on / off on a daily basis will cause the line monitoring software to assume there is a fault, and will reduce the signal speed in an attempt to compensate.
I turn my entire system off each night, I very rarely have any serious problems with any of my kit. It means that the functions are refreshed each day so that any minor corruptions in memory are removed. It also means that you change your ip address every day (assuming you have a dynamic address.) which can be a security enhancement. Despite what some people on here will say, it makes no difference to the speed, it's a reasonably solid 7Mbs or so even immediately after switching on.
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 647
Likes: 0
Re HH
Is it not established practice to keep the HH on. I agree with GG that you do get allocated a new IP address by your provider, but power cycling the router may reduce the life of the electronics.
We are talking about consumer electronics here. If you are using kit designed for industrial use this may not be a problem.
I'm a HH Mk1 user and I've reset the thing only a few times in the five years I used it (Wednesday the other week being one).
)
(GG: I'm within a mile of the Exchange and can get 10Mb download rates, if its left alone.
CAT III
We are talking about consumer electronics here. If you are using kit designed for industrial use this may not be a problem.
I'm a HH Mk1 user and I've reset the thing only a few times in the five years I used it (Wednesday the other week being one).
)
(GG: I'm within a mile of the Exchange and can get 10Mb download rates, if its left alone.
CAT III
Last edited by Guest 112233; 27th January 2012 at 19:11. Reason: too many things
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 2,173
Likes: 0
From: .
In answer to GG
My job (among other computer hassles) partly involves resolving problems on these on a daily basis. For several years I also went out to customers sites on behalf of BT on contract, both installing and diagnosing broadband installations and faults.
I can assure you that the training manuals of BT, TalkTalk and several other BB suppliers all emphasise the need to keep the router constantly turned on, and from personal experience (on a large number of installations) I can say that it DOES make a difference
GG may be lucky in his location and have a good connection to his exchange. Most are not so lucky and need every scrap of extra speed that can be wormed out of BT's creaking local wires
As for the other points
"refresh the IP address" - why bother? Keeping a constant IP address helps remote access when you want to dial in to your network.. OK, you can use DynDNS, but even then the more constant the address the better
"minor corruptions in memory are removed". Huh?? Joke of the day surely? Routers are embdedded systems running Linux or a BSD variant. You don't get windows type memory issues. Never known it to be an issue. Typically I find routers will run for months without needing to be restarted. What occasionally happens is they will "hang" after someone / something tries a port scan attack or similar. Then they'll lock up and need restarting, but that can be very very rare. No need to forgo the benefits of leaving them on continuously just for that odd chance
My job (among other computer hassles) partly involves resolving problems on these on a daily basis. For several years I also went out to customers sites on behalf of BT on contract, both installing and diagnosing broadband installations and faults.
I can assure you that the training manuals of BT, TalkTalk and several other BB suppliers all emphasise the need to keep the router constantly turned on, and from personal experience (on a large number of installations) I can say that it DOES make a difference
GG may be lucky in his location and have a good connection to his exchange. Most are not so lucky and need every scrap of extra speed that can be wormed out of BT's creaking local wires
As for the other points
"refresh the IP address" - why bother? Keeping a constant IP address helps remote access when you want to dial in to your network.. OK, you can use DynDNS, but even then the more constant the address the better
"minor corruptions in memory are removed". Huh?? Joke of the day surely? Routers are embdedded systems running Linux or a BSD variant. You don't get windows type memory issues. Never known it to be an issue. Typically I find routers will run for months without needing to be restarted. What occasionally happens is they will "hang" after someone / something tries a port scan attack or similar. Then they'll lock up and need restarting, but that can be very very rare. No need to forgo the benefits of leaving them on continuously just for that odd chance
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 2,173
Likes: 0
From: .
Mr Optimistic
thats reasonable
One point though, if you have an inkjet printer, leave that ON, though on standby
As long as the standby current is there, the print heads stay pressurised. If you turn the mains power off, the heads lose pressure and need to recycle when next turned on - which uses up 2-3% of the available ink, which simply ends up in the waste pads.
2% a day soon adds up to a full ink cartridge!
thats reasonable
One point though, if you have an inkjet printer, leave that ON, though on standby
As long as the standby current is there, the print heads stay pressurised. If you turn the mains power off, the heads lose pressure and need to recycle when next turned on - which uses up 2-3% of the available ink, which simply ends up in the waste pads.
2% a day soon adds up to a full ink cartridge!
