PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Aviation History and Nostalgia (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia-86/)
-   -   mystery sea fury photo (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia/644893-mystery-sea-fury-photo.html)

exlatccatsa 28th Jan 2022 17:11

mystery sea fury photo
 
I found this photo, from the middle to late 40s I'm guessing, in amongst mum's hundreds of photos. As far as I know we've had no connection with carrier operations, aircrew or ships crew so I've no idea where this came from, which carrier etc. It would be interesting to find out. It looks like a Hawker Sea Fury but where when and what ship? I can make out VH under the wing. It obviously couldn't be an Australian civil reg.
https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....c3dd35ced0.jpg

treadigraph 28th Jan 2022 17:44

VW7** I think it is... VW700-718 were Sea Furies.

Self loading bear 28th Jan 2022 18:39

Edit:
this looks similar but perhaps too different:
VR-938 1951 HMS Glory


https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....b1f8a649c.jpeg


https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....6fd11e18c.jpeg

exlatccatsa 28th Jan 2022 18:58

Looks very similar but theyre not the same. On my photo the ac doesn't have the black and white stripes on the wing.
The props look as though they're curled forward which I would think would mean the gear collapsed at a very low speed or even the arrestor was dragging the ac slowly backwards?

DaveReidUK 28th Jan 2022 20:41


Originally Posted by treadigraph (Post 11176659)
VW7** I think it is... VW700-718 were Sea Furies.

I agree - which dates the photo to no earlier than 1949.

exlatccatsa 28th Jan 2022 21:38

Gnkfor the replies. Looking closely I think the serial is VW71* which narrows it down to 9 aircraft.

Repos 29th Jan 2022 09:04

I did a quick crop and re-size and...
 
I can't help with the history part of things but having had a closer look at the reg. may I suggest it's actually VH7 W* maybe?
https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....7b997a1ed0.jpg

Double Hydco 29th Jan 2022 09:07


I can't help with the history part of things but having had a closer look at the reg. may I suggest it's actually VH7 W* maybe?
U.K. military serials are two letters and three numbers…..

exlatccatsa 29th Jan 2022 09:41

I looks like one of the cables broke. You can see one guy holding one end whilst the other is curled up under the ac. The others are stretched straight across the deck.

Liffy 1M 29th Jan 2022 10:23

There may be an aircraft code on the main gear door, possibly starting with a "6".

treadigraph 29th Jan 2022 12:14

Aircraft in the VH*** serial range were largely batches of Fireflies, Lancasters, Seafires and Barracudas, most of which appear to have been cancelled orders. No Sea Furies.

Jhieminga 29th Jan 2022 12:20


Originally Posted by exlatccatsa (Post 11176688)
Looks very similar but theyre not the same. On my photo the ac doesn't have the black and white stripes on the wing.
The props look as though they're curled forward which I would think would mean the gear collapsed at a very low speed or even the arrestor was dragging the ac slowly backwards?

The blades being bent forwards means that the prop was producing power when it hit. That could be due to an attempted wave off or something similar.

DaveReidUK 29th Jan 2022 15:13

With the Sea Fury FB.11 retiring from service in 1953, I'd be surprised if the accident aircraft was repaired.

Four of the VW71x series Sea Furies are recorded as being written off in service (VW710/712/716/718), with most of the remainder of the VW batch either going to the Australian Navy or being sold back to Hawkers.

Pilot DAR 29th Jan 2022 23:01


The first unit to receive the F.B.11was No 802 Squadron at Eglinton in May 1948
I have a question: Why would a Sea Fury, which entered service no earlier than 1948, have invasion stripes on the wings? Didn't invasion stripes end with WW2?

The late XV105 29th Jan 2022 23:11

Having just deleted my first post because on second thoughts, I agree that the number will be VW71n.

Consequently searching the National Archive online for VW710-VW719 reveals:

Accident to Sea Fury FB11 VW710 on 7th June 1952
Accident to Sea Fury XI VW711 on 31st March 1950
Accident to Sea Fury FB11 VW718 on 7th September1953

Unfortunately, none of these records are digitised - but they are available at the National Archive in Kew Garden if there's a real desire to follow up and read them.
None of the other serials return any hits.

megan 29th Jan 2022 23:42


Why would a Sea Fury, which entered service no earlier than 1948, have invasion stripes on the wings
A Sea Fury FB.11 launches from HMS Glory in 1951, suspect during the Korea conflict. Glory deployed to Korea in April 1951 for the first of three wartime deployments. The first deployment ended in September of that year, but Glory was back on station from January to May 1952 and November 1952 to May 1953.


https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....1802eb1cac.jpg

Australian Sea Furys were similarly adorned.

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....d52650c992.jpg

lauriebe 30th Jan 2022 07:07

Interesting photo. Pity there is no code visible on the vertical tail surface. That would help narrow the search down.

The style of dress worn by the deck crew would seem to indicate summertime in the northern hemisphere or the tropics. ‘Chiefy’, visible between the prop blades, has a white top on his cap and what appears to be an officer, just in front of him, looks to be in shirt sleeve order.

The aircraft code on the u/c door mentioned in post #10 might not be a code. I think it could be a handle on a piece of equipment being carried by one of the deck crew standing there.

Of the three accidents mentioned in post #16, it is unlikely to be any of those. The 7 June 52 accident happened on the airfield at Culdrose when the stbd wing folded on take off and the aircraft, VW710, rolled and skidded upside down along the runway.

The incident involving VW711 on 31 March 52 occurred when the aircraft was en route from Vengance to Lee. Engine trouble meant the aircraft force landed. I cannot find a location but would think it unlikely to be the aircraft in the OP’s photo.

The last accident referred to involving VW718, happened near Crail airfield. The aircraft had been practicing RP attacks on the airfield when it came down a short distance to the NNW of the field.

Several other Sea Furies had barrier engagements. Those were:

VW713, serving with 807 NAS aboard HMS Theseus. On 23 March 51, suffered partial engine failure, and caught No.9 wire in an emergency landing with the prop going into the barrier. I believe the ship was at that time in Far Eastern waters.

VW714, served with both 736 and 738 NASs. In July 52, whilst with 736, it caught the No.10 wire and went into the barrier onboard HMS Illustrious. On 4 February 53, the same aircraft, whilst with 738 NAS, bounced on landing and went into the barrier onboard HMS Triumph. Both incidents appear to have been in UK waters.

Lastly, VW717. When with 738 NAS, this aircraft had two barrier engagements in a short space of time. Firstly, on 30 September 53 and then, again, on 30 October 53. Both incidents occurred onboard HMS Triumph in, I think, UK waters.

All info above taken from the excellent Air-Britain book FAA Fixed Wing Aircraft since 1946.

Fournierf5 30th Jan 2022 09:09


Originally Posted by Pilot DAR (Post 11177136)
I have a question: Why would a Sea Fury, which entered service no earlier than 1948, have invasion stripes on the wings? Didn't invasion stripes end with WW2?

According to Wiki, Korean War: After USAF Boeing B-29 Superfortress shot down a Fleet Air Arm Seafire on July 28, 1950, all Commonwealth aircraft were given black and white invasion stripes.

treadigraph 30th Jan 2022 09:20

Weren't similar stripes adopted by French and UK aircraft during the Suez crisis?

oxenos 30th Jan 2022 10:10


Weren't similar stripes adopted by French and UK aircraft during the Suez crisis?
Suez stripes were black and yellow.

DaveReidUK 30th Jan 2022 11:04


Originally Posted by oxenos (Post 11177298)
Suez stripes were black and yellow.

And typically narrower than invasion stripes.

Fournierf5 30th Jan 2022 11:52


Originally Posted by lauriebe (Post 11177223)
Interesting photo. Pity there is no code visible on the vertical tail surface. That would help narrow the search down.

The style of dress worn by the deck crew would seem to indicate summertime in the northern hemisphere or the tropics. ‘Chiefy’, visible between the prop blades, has a white top on his cap and what appears to be an officer, just in front of him, looks to be in shirt sleeve order.

The aircraft code on the u/c door mentioned in post #10 might not be a code. I think it could be a handle on a piece of equipment being carried by one of the deck crew standing there.

Of the three accidents mentioned in post #16, it is unlikely to be any of those. The 7 June 52 accident happened on the airfield at Culdrose when the stbd wing folded on take off and the aircraft, VW710, rolled and skidded upside down along the runway.

The incident involving VW711 on 31 March 52 occurred when the aircraft was en route from Vengance to Lee. Engine trouble meant the aircraft force landed. I cannot find a location but would think it unlikely to be the aircraft in the OP’s photo.

The last accident referred to involving VW718, happened near Crail airfield. The aircraft had been practicing RP attacks on the airfield when it came down a short distance to the NNW of the field.

Several other Sea Furies had barrier engagements. Those were:

VW713, serving with 807 NAS aboard HMS Theseus. On 23 March 51, suffered partial engine failure, and caught No.9 wire in an emergency landing with the prop going into the barrier. I believe the ship was at that time in Far Eastern waters.

. . . 713 is a possible - it also appears to have been "struck off charge" on 30-4-51. HMS Theseus was escorted by two C-class destroyers in Korea - HMS Consort & HMS Comus . . . the destroyer in background could be one of these two! But '1951' is a long time since the July 1950 'incident' after which 'invasion stripes' were supposed to hv been painted on [see my prev post!]

DogTailRed2 30th Jan 2022 13:22

Was there a reason why sripe colour changed from white, black to yellow,black?

Warmtoast 30th Jan 2022 15:35

A bit of thread creep, but I was stationed at Biggin Hill in 1954 when the station hosted the annual ROC "Recognition Day". Among the visitors was this Sea Fury the only one I ever saw close up. ISTR the large 'C' on its tail indicated it was based at RN airfield at Culham not far from Abingdon.

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....8155025e11.jpg

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....175fc6b9ab.jpg


DogTailRed2 30th Jan 2022 18:29

Always remember Biggin Hill Air Fair in the 70's and 80's watching a certain Royal Navy Sea Fury doing low level hesitation rolls.

POBJOY 30th Jan 2022 20:11

I well remember seeing a Sea Fury land at one of the Air Fairs and folding its wings soon after touchdown with some speed on, Looked great.

sycamore 30th Jan 2022 20:38

That would have been the incomparable Pete Sheppard...

Haraka 31st Jan 2022 07:48

I recall also watching the RNHF Sea Fury suffer a ground loop and u/c collapse at Yeovilton in 1974. (Tail wheel lock not engaged IIRC).

( BTW apparently not all Invasion stripes during the 1956 Suez Crisis were Yellow and Black.. Due to local paint shortages some were White and Black)

The late XV105 31st Jan 2022 18:59

Thanks to lauriebe and Fournierf5's excellent additional insight and deductions and consequently enabled further searching that I have done, I agree that it is most likely 713 on Theseus, "invasion" stripes or not. Just a shame I can't find a clear picture of the deck to show "500" painted in precise proximity to the line. It is unlikely that another carrier would have had truly identical paint.

longer ron 31st Jan 2022 21:30


Originally Posted by POBJOY (Post 11177478)
I well remember seeing a Sea Fury land at one of the Air Fairs and folding its wings soon after touchdown with some speed on, Looked great.

Not sure if same year Pobjoy but I took this pic at Biggin 1979,a/c on rwy - photo taken from the ORP.

https://i.imgur.com/dgKjpUh.jpg

Warmtoast 31st Jan 2022 22:03


Originally Posted by longer ron (Post 11177945)
Not sure if same year Pobjoy but I took this pic at Biggin 1979,a/c on rwy - photo taken from the ORP.

https://i.imgur.com/dgKjpUh.jpg

"M" on the tail represents Merryfield I assume?

Fargo Boyle 31st Jan 2022 23:25


Originally Posted by Warmtoast (Post 11177957)
"M" on the tail represents Merryfield I assume?

VX302 was built as a T.20, and then exported to Germany as a target tug. It was one of the a/c imported by Doug Arnold and eventually returned to Germany where it is being restored to it's target tug markings by Air Fighter Academy at Bremgarten
https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....a5b527c658.jpg

exlatccatsa 1st Feb 2022 09:32

Thanks forcall the replies. Sorry I've been a bit quiet, trying to stop buildings blowing away after Saturdays gale.
All the information is much appreciated , although I'm still no closer to finding out how the photo got into mums collection. The maritime history of our family mum had traced back to Napoleon being exiled to Elba, Scott and Shackleton, through to the search for the North West passage and of course the whaling, North and South, before and after the wars. But there's nothing I can find about carrier ops. I can only surmise that it must have been a friend and not relative who sent the photo. But its great to have all the information and it will go on the back of the photo further future generations.
Thanks again.

treadigraph 1st Feb 2022 09:54

Somewhere I have a photo I took of VX302 being run up outside Doug Arnold's hangar at Blackbushe as N613RD (?) in about 1985 just before it headed Stateside. Mystery is how I came to be there without being told to "go away"...

First saw TF956 being displayed at Greenham Common in 1976, assume Pete Sheppard was at the helm in those days...

VictorGolf 1st Feb 2022 14:58

"Go away" treadi, you were lucky. More normally it was "F*****t O***r" I seem to recall. Never did make it in to the hangar.

treadigraph 1st Feb 2022 15:23

I did get one look round the hangar in September '78 and saw the Griffon Spits still partially entombed in wooden crates I think - summat like "the boss isn't here but be as quick as you can in case he returns unexpectedly..."

Fargo Boyle 1st Feb 2022 19:05

Yes, Doug's Rolls Royce was always prowling around airside... those were heady days spotting at Blackbushe in the 80's, there was always something exotic parked up there. Sea Fury's, Ju52's, Mosquito, Comet, CASA 2111's, etc etc (apologies for thread drift).

goofer3 1st Feb 2022 19:09

Re Sea Fury VW713. 23.3.1951. HMS Theseus off Korea. Emergency deck landing after partial engine failure; entered safety barrier.

treadigraph 1st Feb 2022 19:18

continued drift... Yep, Jeff Hawke's Hanover Street B-25s were there amongst various WoGB heavies on the southern side on that occasion. Farnborough Week, well worth a cycle up from North Camp before attending the afternoon display!


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:19.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.