|
Max Hastings' Dambusters book
The Mail Online has been running a piece to promote Max Hastings' soon to be published book about Operation Chastise. The article, the core of which is, presumably, in Hastings' own words, says 56 crewmen of 617 Sqn died in the raid – whereas three survived, as is well known.
Makes me wonder how many other basic errors will be revealed when we finally see the book itself. |
As the publisher's blurb states:
Hastings vividly describes the evolution of Wallis’ bomb, and of the squadron which broke the dams. But he also portrays in harrowing detail those swept away by the torrents. He argues that what modern Germans call the Mohnekatastrophe imposed on the Nazi war machine temporary disruption, rather than a crippling blow. Ironically, Air Marshal Sir Arthur ‘Bomber’ Harris gained much of the public credit, though he bitterly opposed Chastise as a distraction from his city-burning blitz. Harris also made perhaps the operation’s biggest mistake – failure to launch a conventional attack on the huge post-raid repair operation which could have transformed the impact of the dam breaches on Ruhr industry. Here once again is a dramatic retake on familiar history by a master of the art. Hastings sets the Dams Raid in the big picture of the bomber offensive and of the Second World War, with moving portraits of the young airmen, so many of whom died; of Barnes Wallis; the monstrous Harris; the tragic Guy Gibson, together with superb narrative of the action of one of the most extraordinary episodes in British history As the owner of four of Hastings' earlier books: "Bomber Command", "Armageddon", "All Hell Let Loose" and "Catastrophe", "Operation Chastise" is on my shopping list for what will almost certainly be a good read. |
Can anyone recommend James Holland's book about the raid?
|
Hastings has always been a bit too right wing for me BUT he is a good historian.
I recently reread his Korean Way book and while could be rerevised as more files open it really is shocking how inept the UN side were, 8th Army collapse and aftermath almost allowed Korean to be reunited until Communists. |
The definitive book on Op CHASTISE was written years ago by John Sweetman; I very much doubt that Hastings' book will add anything of substance to that production.
|
Found it to be very readable for the non historian with an excellent level of depth of knowledge about the whole enterprise, in particular from the behind the scenes politics. |
Originally Posted by Downwind.Maddl-Land
(Post 10550142)
The definitive book on Op CHASTISE was written years ago by John Sweetman; I very much doubt that Hastings' book will add anything of substance to that production.
|
Originally Posted by howiehowie93
(Post 10550322)
Is there a Kindle version ????
|
Kindle has the Max Hastings book "Chastise: The Dambusters Story 1943" which will be available first week in September, but can be "pre-ordered" now.
Mods: hope this doesn't constitute advertising - seems to be no more so than the rest of the thread! |
Ref my earlier post, can I assume the James Holland book wasn't a big seller among PPrune folk? I read the excellent Sweetman account years ago.
|
Originally Posted by XV490
(Post 10550622)
Ref my earlier post, can I assume the James Holland book wasn't a big seller among PPrune folk? I read the excellent Sweetman account years ago.
|
Thanks, Trident. I'll give it s whirl.
|
Originally Posted by XV490
(Post 10549707)
Makes me wonder how many other basic errors will be revealed when we finally see the book itself.
|
Originally Posted by Airbanda
(Post 10553133)
Mail's errors rather than those of Hastings?
|
A piece by Mr Hastings in today's Times Magazine:
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/m...5e50ed7eb55215 |
TBH, I purchased Max Hastings book, 'Arnhem' when it was released and was very pleasantly surprised to find a whole wealth of new material within it's pages. I look forward to the same with this one.
|
His article in the "Times" colour magazine wasn't very complimentary about Gibson as a person........ but then we revert to the arguments in the Douglas Bader thread
|
'Johnny' Johnson who served under Gibson is not very complimentary about Gibson either.
|
A bit of thread drift, but fascinating background to Guy Gibson here: https://flashbak.com/fascinating-dam...phemera-36506/
….including music he chose for his appearance on desert island discs on 19th February 1944 and copy of "Valuation for Probate" of his effects after his death (his VC was valued at £250!) Gibson's Desert Island Discs Music Choices
|
Originally Posted by Downwind.Maddl-Land
(Post 10550350)
...the seemingly endless attacks mounted on the effectiveness of the raid by the post-war revisionists. .
I found it a great read; Hasting’s portrait of Guy Gibson in particular is nuanced and avoids any easy good guy/bad guy conclusion, although Arthur Harris is most definitely a bad guy in Hasting’s view. The raid was an epic feat of courage and technical improvisation which should make our generation shake our heads in awe. To me, this book is the fairest and most comprehensive telling of the story yet. |
| All times are GMT. The time now is 10:29. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.