PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Aviation History and Nostalgia (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia-86/)
-   -   WHAT, WHERE and WHEN (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia/227952-what-where-when.html)

treadigraph 29th Jun 2006 21:12

http://i74.photobucket.com/albums/i2...onwingover.jpg

I wonder if you are using the "insert link" icon (the globe with the chainlink) to post your pic rather than the "insert image" icon (mountain with stamp - well, looks like that to me!) Virgo? That might be the answer...

Treadders

PS keep the pics (or links!) coming, great stuff! I can hear those Griffons and props making that wonderful Shackleton sound! Or is it the tinitus...?

MReyn24050 29th Jun 2006 21:18

Virgo. Possibly the wing designed for the Avro Ashton?

Regarding your difficulties in posting pictures. When you paste in the URL details into the image box, check that http:// is not entered twice. Delete the second http:// so it reads http://i74 etc. (click on the photograph treadigraph has posted and then read the properties you will see how the URL should appear)Otherwise the photograph will not appear.

Mel

virgo 1st Jul 2006 20:24

Thanks for the posting tips.............done all that - correct "insert image" symbol, only one "URL" ...........but I'll keep trying !

Answer to the Shackleton MR3 wing..............it was actually the Argosy wing with the tip tanks added - which is maybe why the MR3s were all withdrawn before the MR2s, due to wing fatigue problems (being used in turbulent low-level conditions ????)........and of course why the older 2s were converted to AEW rather than the MR3s

shack 2nd Jul 2006 08:00

Thank you Treadigraph for putting up a picture of MY aircraft!!

If you could see the port side just below the cockpit you would see my name.

Happy Days. :)

JW411 2nd Jul 2006 14:05

virgo:

"It was actually the Argosy wing...."

Now that is very interesting for when I did the Argosy manufacturer's course at Baginton in 1962 with Whitworth Gloster we were told that we had a Shackleton wing!

MReyn24050 2nd Jul 2006 14:56


Originally Posted by JW411
virgo:
"It was actually the Argosy wing...."
Now that is very interesting for when I did the Argosy manufacturer's course at Baginton in 1962 with Whitworth Gloster we were told that we had a Shackleton wing!

Further to the debate regarding the wing of the Shackleton Mk3, Oliver Tapper in his book “Armstrong Whitworth Aircraft since 1917” published by Putnam also states that the wing of the Argosy was derived from the Shackleton.
At page 311 of Oliver Tapper’s book it states:-
“Considerable design and development time was saved by the fortuitous fact that the design parameters of the Argosy’s wing were found to be almost exactly the same as those of the existing Avro Shackleton. This basic wing design was therefore adopted for the new aircraft with such modifications as were necessary to allow for the different engine spacing, the mounting of the tail booms, the incorporation of thermal de-icing in the leading edge, and the fitting of large double-slotted flaps.”
He continues at page 315:- “The task of designing and manufacturing the Argosy was, to some extent, shared among other member companies of the Hawker Siddeley Group. As already noted the wing of the aircraft was derived from that of the Shackleton and it was, therefore, natural that the Avro Company should undertake the design and construction of this component.”
It is noted that the first M.R.3 WR970 first flew 2nd September 1955, first A.W Argosy G-AOZZ was rolled out for engine runs 21st December 1958 and flew on the 8th January 1959.
Mel

virgo 2nd Jul 2006 19:05

Shack, unless you are Van-Warmelo ?............I think not !

virgo 2nd Jul 2006 19:34

I must defer to MReyn..........obviously if the Shack MR3 flew some three years before the Argosy, I guess the wing was designed for the Shackleton - but at least the two aircraft types were correct !

Another similar story is that to speed up production of the Caravelle, Aerospatial bought the entire forward fuselage from DH and grafted the Comet nose onto their fuselage ?
(Please don't tell me DH bought a fuselage from Aerospatial and grafted their own fuselage onto the cockpit bit !!!!!)

But this is what A,H & N is all about, isn't it ?

MReyn24050 2nd Jul 2006 19:42

virgo
You are a Gent. At least you did establish a link between the Shack and the Argosy. I didnt even know that they were linked it was only after JW411's comment I did some reading. As you say "But this is what A,H & N is all about, isn't it ?" It certainly is not a case of scoring points.

Regards
Mel

virgo 2nd Jul 2006 19:44

OK, I'm trying Speechless Two's advice.................if it works, on the basis of What. Where and When, have a go at this.
The What and Where is pretty easy but the When is a bit more difficult, but I think the historians should be able to pin it down within a few years ?
http://i74.photobucket.com/albums/i2...irtoground.jpg

MReyn24050 2nd Jul 2006 19:48

Completely a WAG but the where. RAF Ballykelly?

virgo 2nd Jul 2006 19:52

Ballykelly................Nope !

Speechless 2................Thanks, it worked OK

treadigraph 2nd Jul 2006 21:56

I think it's Lossiemouth with those Shacklebombers? I'll chuck a dart at the late 1950s...!

treadigraph 3rd Jul 2006 12:26

Doh! I meant Kinloss... Honest!

shack 3rd Jul 2006 12:46

Virgo, have a look at your PMs.

virgo 3rd Jul 2006 20:48

Yep ! Kinloss.
A couple of interesting things......the photo shows four types of hangars - anyone know the identity of them ?

Secondly, the aircraft are either GR 1s or T4s, with no mid-upper turrets, with the post-1958 colour scheme, a squadron LETTER identification, rather than the unit number and no evidence of other squadron use of the airfield.

All rather confusing but I expect someone will be able to untangle it and place a year on it ? (My personal stab would be 1958 )

Fishtailed 5th Jul 2006 22:31

http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f2...d/oldjets2.jpg

Howz about this one then?:hmm:

MReyn24050 6th Jul 2006 08:56

First thoughts RAF Linton-on -Ouse between 1953 and 1956. With 66 Sqn RAF Sabre F-4s?

JW411 6th Jul 2006 09:13

Sabres - probably RCAF - Scottish Aviation - Prestwick.

henry crun 6th Jul 2006 09:52

MReyn24050: If you are right what is that big white nosewheel type in the left background ?


All times are GMT. The time now is 05:42.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.