PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Fire Fighting 737 Crashed in WA (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/651213-fire-fighting-737-crashed-wa.html)

WingNut60 6th Feb 2023 12:54

Try TACA flight 110.

However, in this case, I can't imagine how you'd injure the crew without damaging the aircraft

Capn Bloggs 6th Feb 2023 13:02


Originally Posted by Kulwin Park
How do you know that??? Nobody has even seen pictures yet to determine the condition of the hull.

Seriously? Probably take to the cockpit with a Phillips head screwdriver for bits but that would be about it. Especially a 27 year old 737.

BNEAU 6th Feb 2023 13:11


Originally Posted by Capn Bloggs (Post 11380925)

There isn't another 737 LAT in the Australian firebombing fleet.

There are two at RAAF Richmond, Bomber 137 (N137CG) and Bomber 210 (N138CG).

I’ve heard that the aircraft is a hull loss. Going to be a task getting it out. Though good to hear that it was a good outcome for the crew.

Start4 6th Feb 2023 13:27


Originally Posted by Sailvi767 (Post 11380919)
I have never known a airliner that made a off airport landing and flew again. I am sure it’s happened but incredibly unlikely. Even if zero damage the recovery effort would almost certainly render the aircraft unairworthy.

TACA 110

uxb99 6th Feb 2023 17:50


Originally Posted by 43Inches (Post 11380813)
I heard other assets were bombing the wreck to suppress fires as the crew escaped. Whether the wreck itself or it landed in/near the bushfire as well not sure.

Is there a protocol for suppressing any resultant fires if a fire fighting aircraft goes down? I can imagine it's potentially catastrophic in terms of making the fires worse especially for major forest fires.

LTP90 6th Feb 2023 18:03


Originally Posted by Finn47 (Post 11380931)
Perhaps he meant from the US? Coulson had six of them, now obviously five left.

Coulson, to my knowledge has only converted 3 of the 737's they have, their U.S. tanker numbers: 137, the red/White "Boeing" paint job.138 they sold to Australia and it now goes by 210, and 139 the one involved in this accident.
hypothetically if 137 is not already in Australia and not in heavy winter maintenance, it could be shipped over. Some of the U.S. Forest Service contracts start in March, but I do not know Coulsons start dates, if I remember right 137 has one of the earlier start dates.

LTP90 6th Feb 2023 18:07


Originally Posted by uxb99 (Post 11381084)
Is there a protocol for suppressing any resultant fires if a fire fighting aircraft goes down? I can imagine it's potentially catastrophic in terms of making the fires worse especially for major forest fires.

Yes, at least in the US, the protocol is put the fire out by all means. There have many several cases where the aircraft fire resulted in a large expansion of the fire perimeter, and loss of control lines.

Squawk7700 6th Feb 2023 19:24

Temps in the mid 30’s C over there at the moment.

PoppaJo 6th Feb 2023 19:29

Hard to imagine how it got down with no casualties after seeing the footage of the Canberra accident, happens very quick. Looks more like a forced landing perhaps, they got caught out in some specific situation, the only exit path was down, they must have had decent vis when making the decision, other aircraft had it in sight and able to distinguish flames. Will be interesting to see the photos and how much of it remains, sounds like it might still be in one piece.

mickjoebill 6th Feb 2023 20:37

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-02-...ital/101938070

vegassun 6th Feb 2023 20:56


Originally Posted by pinkpanther1 (Post 11380790)
N619SW a 27 year old 737-300


An old Southwest Airlines 300 sounds like.

Capt Fathom 6th Feb 2023 21:08

So you can put a 737 down in the bush, and it hardly makes the news! If it had a kangaroo on the tail…….

Obidiah 6th Feb 2023 21:24

This story is struggling to pass the pub test.

A PA28 lands on a golf course and it's all over the news, a 737 crashes and virtually nothing??
A 737 crashes, supposedly on drop run into the bush and both crew only minor injuries??
FR24 has GS at 100kts ??

KRviator 6th Feb 2023 21:34


Originally Posted by Obidiah (Post 11381188)
This story is struggling to pass the pub test.

A PA28 lands on a golf course and it's all over the news, a 737 crashes and virtually nothing??

And that should tell you all you need to know about the so-called "news" media both here and abroad.

I don't subscribe to the illuminati, flat earth society or any of that rubbish, but I do believe we only hear on the 'news' what editors and producers want us to hear, which is usually the most sensationalist tripe they can find to generate advertising revenue and clicks.

logansi 6th Feb 2023 21:36

First images

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....db650aff0e.jpg
https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....59199e63a4.jpg

mcoates 6th Feb 2023 21:50

Good job landing near the road for recovery access ! Lucky boys !

logansi 6th Feb 2023 22:11

Talking to someone in the know, apparently, the entire accident sequence was recorded by 2 of the HD cameras on the lead plane, doubt it will be made public for a while but will be an incredible bit of evidence for the investigators

43Inches 6th Feb 2023 22:14

I think the picture paints the reason for survival, flat terrain, low scrub, cockpit looks intact. Fire looks towards the aft where I presume fuel has leaked.

It's definitely not going to fly again, that's not going to be an intact recovery, the back end will be charcoal.


A PA28 lands on a golf course and it's all over the news, a 737 crashes and virtually nothing??
A 737 crashes, supposedly on drop run into the bush and both crew only minor injuries??
FR24 has GS at 100kts ??
No spectacular footage at the time and now today the earthquake in Turkey/Syria trumps any local news about a plane crash in the middle of nowhere where the pilots survived. Had it been a slow news day it would have headlined.


Talking to someone in the know, apparently, the entire accident sequence was recorded by 2 of the HD cameras on the lead plane, doubt it will be made public for a while but will be an incredible bit of evidence for the investigators
Birddog overhead was most likely spotting for them and recording the whole thing.

mickjoebill 6th Feb 2023 22:15


Originally Posted by Obidiah (Post 11381188)
This story is struggling to pass the pub test.

A PA28 lands on a golf course and it's all over the news, a 737 crashes and virtually nothing??

A light plane crash has few if any political strands which can inhibit a journo going full on with dramatic language.
It is the role the aircraft had which is tempering reporting. Firefighting is a sensitive subject with the public, I've never seen negative press in Australia of the cockups made by volunteer firefighters. The press and pollies tread gingerly.



​​​​

fdr 6th Feb 2023 22:23


Originally Posted by WingNut60 (Post 11380935)
Try TACA flight 110.

However, in this case, I can't imagine how you'd injure the crew without damaging the aircraft


Originally Posted by Capn Bloggs (Post 11380937)
Seriously? Probably take to the cockpit with a Phillips head screwdriver for bits but that would be about it. Especially a 27 year old 737.

flat head, the LRUs are Dzus mainly...
I think the hint that the other fire bombers were suppressing the fire while the crew escaped might suggest that there won't be a sudden increase in available EADI, EHSIs, FMS CDUs and EIS's etc from the site.

Gonna be interesting to see what plonks a B733LAT into the weeds at a reported approach speed of 101GS. Many birds "thermalling" around the fires of WA these days?

Wouldn't be questioning SOPs until a lot more info comes out, Coulson had a bad day with the Herc, stuff happens in that environment occasionally, even to competent operators.

Boys are fortunate that the industry hasn't yet started using the early years B738 etc, the ones that have the "fold here" ring frames that were bogus manufactured non compliant to the TCDS production data... only about 2000 of those out there. Those are the ones that we have seen zigged zagged after relatively low energy off piste events in the carribean, Indonesia, and other exotic ports of call.


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:57.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.