PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Rail Link - Melbourne Airport. (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/619394-rail-link-melbourne-airport.html)

mickjoebill 26th Mar 2019 06:53


Sydney did it, but only with an Olympics looming, and they made it cost so much it’s cheaper to get a cab into the city with more than 1 person
Was in Sydney on Friday and Saturday, on a My first senior! opal card, $17 took me to and from the airport and as many ferry, train and train rides around Sydney as I wished.

mjb

Derfred 26th Mar 2019 13:10


Originally Posted by mickjoebill (Post 10429991)


Was in Sydney on Friday and Saturday, on a My first senior! opal card, $17 took me to and from the airport and as many ferry, train and train rides around Sydney as I wished.

mjb

Awesome!

Last time I was there with my wife and son it was cheaper to catch a cab.

Tankengine 27th Mar 2019 01:08


Originally Posted by mickjoebill (Post 10429991)


Was in Sydney on Friday and Saturday, on a My first senior! opal card, $17 took me to and from the airport and as many ferry, train and train rides around Sydney as I wished.

mjb

To be fair though; if you had not travelled from the Airport your fare with a Seniors Opal would only have been $2.50 for the day.

patty50 27th Mar 2019 04:57


Originally Posted by mickjoebill (Post 10429991)


Was in Sydney on Friday and Saturday, on a My first senior! opal card, $17 took me to and from the airport and as many ferry, train and train rides around Sydney as I wished.

mjb

Solution is for everyone to be a boomer then we can all enjoy reasonably priced public transport travel.

PoppaJo 15th Apr 2023 05:44

Andrews out of cash! Rail is now ‘on hold’

I mean, what’s another 20 years.

Capn Bloggs 15th Apr 2023 06:45

Don't worry, his labor mates/matesses in CBR will see to it that you get more of other state's GST to help out. "Their budget is in good shape", she (Zoe Daniel) said. :cool:

Icarus2001 15th Apr 2023 07:28

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....8c67ca79d.jpeg

ajax58 15th Apr 2023 07:32

Is there any source on this other than the HS article?

Capn Bloggs 15th Apr 2023 07:36

Oh that is a beauty, Iccy! :D

Ladloy 15th Apr 2023 08:56

I'd love to know how any of this has anything to do with socialism?

nonsense 15th Apr 2023 10:40

The problem with rampant capitalism is that eventually you run out of other people's children to send down the coal mines.




Originally Posted by Icarus2001 (Post 11420138)


neville_nobody 15th Apr 2023 11:59


The problem with rampant capitalism is that eventually you run out of other people's children to send down the coal mines.
It's not a problem really all that happens is that the cost of labour increases increasing the cost of your final product. If people agree that we shouldn't have child labour and can afford to pay more for products they will. That is the real beauty of true capitalism is that it is self correcting. If something becomes too expensive to produce the market will soon figure it out and people stop buying the product or change their spending habits.

Sunfish 15th Apr 2023 20:34

Strictly correct NN - in perfect competition in a free market.

However our markets are not free and there is no perfect competition.

Transport is most definitely not a free market!

Rail is a natural monopoly - unless you are prepared to build say 5 competing rail lines - so rial charges a monopoly premium.

Taxis and hire cars? Nope, the vehicles and drivers are licenced and numbers are capped.

Airport access? Nope - the parking nazis see to that.

PPRuNeUser01531 16th Apr 2023 01:35

Reckon extending the present tram line from YMEN to YMML could be a cost affective and viable option to consider in the short term. Not for everybody but sure many would take advantage of such a service.

Deaf 16th Apr 2023 02:25


Originally Posted by selfappointed (Post 11420498)
Reckon extending the present tram line from YMEN to YMML could be a cost affective and viable option to consider in the short term. Not for everybody but sure many would take advantage of such a service.

Timetable for route 59 shows ~45min to YMEN probably another 10 min to YMML. About the only time the bus has taken so long for me was when the B200 crash at YMEN blocked the freeway and we went via the ringroad.

PoppaJo 16th Apr 2023 04:47

How about we just build a train line from the city to the damn airport! As soon as bloody possible! How hard is it. Only in Oz. Embarrassing.

Capn Bloggs 16th Apr 2023 05:47

Poppa, read post #65. Comrade Dan has spent all his (taxpayers) money.

RickNRoll 16th Apr 2023 06:02

Capn, the cost has blown out to a massive amount due to years of delays. Land and corridors have long been built over. If they had built it at the same time as the airport it would have cost very little. The real reason it hasn't been built yet is because the airport is really a massive capark business. A train would impact those profits.

Global Aviator 16th Apr 2023 07:34

I know Asian countries are 3rd world and have no idea……

Bangkok - skyrail
Kuala Lumpur - fast train
Singapore - subway
Jakarta - train (45 min)
Osaka / Haneda / Narita - fast and easy bullet access
Hong Kong - super efficient
China - can’t remember been to long!

Straya - leading the way!

Sparrows. 16th Apr 2023 07:52


Originally Posted by Global Aviator (Post 11420583)
China - can’t remember been to long!

Shanghai - Maglev


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:56.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.