Doctors usually only destroy one life at a time if they have bad day, and then they go home. A person scheduling surgery or booking patients doesn’t question a doctors decisions on a daily basis. Full reval of their qualifications every year?? Doctors......? Why do we compare ourselves to them? |
https://amp.adelaidenow.com.au/business/sa-business-journal/cobham-has-launched-a-new-cadet-program-for-aspiring-pilots/news-story/3eb37bf11cc79cc55ee8ea877cfa0d3a
"The cadetship is funded primarily by Federal Government vocational and education training (VET) student loans"... Um funded...No. Great journalism there. The cadetship is funded by the student... who has access to a loan. How hard is it to report accurately? |
Bazza,
Other pilots are the ones comparing themselves to doctors. I beleive that it's a bit fanciful to make that comparison. Medical doctors have to do a long stint at uni (5 years I think) and then two years of residency and after all of that try to get access to a college. GP's, Surgeons, Anaesthetists etc. If they get into a college then a few more years of training and maybe then they can relax. If your lucky you will be finished by the age of 30. If you dont make it through residency or college training you can be a supervised hospital doctor or you can go into research, administration etc. If you dont make it into the cockpit with your 100k CPL yoy have far fewer options. |
Pilotchute, I was basically making that point. Why are we comparing ourselves to a profession that has no resemblance to ours? Forget what other people get, we’re pilots and we should be more focused on making our jobs workable.
|
Contractual obligations
Woah, whats going on, the Border force contract has minimum requirements of experience and IRT renewals, no way a cadet would qualify to fly on these sorties unless Cobham extort the Government to make whole sale changes to their contractual obligations, or they commit to having a training pilot on every cadet flight, in which case there is no advantage. But hey it wouldn't be the first time they got away with conning the government.
|
And don't forget the $270 fee just to be hopeful of the pineapple!
|
Originally Posted by FMTAfterburn
(Post 10257611)
Woah, whats going on, the Border force contract has minimum requirements of experience and IRT renewals, no way a cadet would qualify to fly on these sorties unless Cobham extort the Government to make whole sale changes to their contractual obligations, or they commit to having a training pilot on every cadet flight, in which case there is no advantage. But hey it wouldn't be the first time they got away with conning the government.
|
doesn’t question a doctors decisions on a daily basis. |
You’re obviously an FO Icarus? |
No, over a decade left seat. Perhaps you could list three “decisions” that are not prescribed? |
Do you take much notice about what you’re doing? How about just managing the flight, everything involves a decision in one way or another. If you’re just showing up and making 3 decisions I’d be a bit worried. |
I think Iccy must have taken something...
|
Originally Posted by Icarus2001
(Post 10257640)
Doctors on the other hand start with someone complaining of a "sore belly" then start from there.
|
Originally Posted by Icarus2001
(Post 10257726)
No, over a decade left seat. Perhaps you could list three “decisions” that are not prescribed? 2. Can we close the last door. 3. Chicken or beef for lunch. :ok: :} :E |
4. One line NOTAMS or full text?
5. Intersection departure or full length? 6. Would you like poached eggs and bacon with hollandaise sauce on sourdough , or the cereal? :{ |
Would you like poached eggs and bacon with hollandaise sauce on sourdough |
We call it Eggs Benedict! |
|
Yes Iccy, I am appalled! You should hang your head in shame! :{
|
Icarus,
I'm with you, no one rates a Pilot as high as a Pilot does. For the love of god why do pilots keep thinking they're in the same league as Drs. Now, I'm not saying all Drs would make it as pilots, but if you looked at the requirements for Drs Vs Pilots I'd say it easily goes their way. Just to get into Uni for medicine you need to be in the top 2-3 %, then 6 yrs as it's post grad (as is dentistry and vet science), so you do your initial degree, then start your med degree, so 6 yrs at Uni, then your hospital training and that's at least 2 yrs. Like I said I don't think every Dr would make it as a pilot (and not based on intelligence), but I'd bet you > 95% would piss it in and I'd say < 15% of Pilots would get through the Uni program for medicine. Far easier to train a pilot than a Dr, dentist, vet, engineer etc. Not quite Dunning-Kruger, but on the way! |
I worked with doctors for several years. Academically they’re very smart, and while they know their craft very well, they weren’t always practically smart. So I would argue that they would easily make good pilots. Think how many of the good pilots aren’t actually that smart academically and then the number of really smart pilots who aren’t very good! |
For the best reaction postulate that the job of pilot is a "blue collar" job notwithstanding most wear white ones. No formal education requirements only vocational training undertaken via self selection, if you can pay you can undertake it, not like medical school as you say. If you want a good idea of education levels read some of the maintenance entries in the DL/ML.
|
Originally Posted by Icarus2001
(Post 10259488)
For the best reaction postulate that the job of pilot is a "blue collar" job notwithstanding most wear white ones. No formal education requirements only vocational training undertaken via self selection, if you can pay you can undertake it, not like medical school as you say. If you want a good idea of education levels read some of the maintenance entries in the DL/ML.
|
Really, how was this person admitted to the bar without any "formal study"? Do you have a name?
|
People who are comfortable with who they are and what they do don't spend time on the internet pontificating on whether their job is blue collar, white collar, professional, etc. Who cares?
|
Originally Posted by Icarus2001
(Post 10259771)
Really, how was this person admitted to the bar without any "formal study"? Do you have a name?
Anyway point being it's the same as being a pilot as you still need to pass a bunch of exams whilst there being no real formal educational prerequisite. However the reality is that in this day and age you need a degree if you want to be competitive in the job market. Same could be said for airline jobs too. |
Hi all
I see Cobham has advertised for FOs (EoI) on the Dash 8; out of interest how many hrs would FOs be flying annually? Is the Coastwatch job viewed as a viable long-term career option with a good work-life balance (cliché I know)? Cheers BE |
I don’t imagine a company having to recruit with a cadet program is having much success attracting enough pilots to cover its flying. Also the push to lower wages and increase so called productivity probably means you won’t be seeing any work life balance. |
Wages are going up in general at Coastwatch. When I was there my flying was typically limited by 90 in 14 duty limits and less frequently by my FAID score. Most duties were 10 hours for about 7 hours of flying. The 14 day limit meant you couldn’t usually do more than 9 duties in 14 days. My annual hours were typically around 650. This was with a reasonable crew numbers. My biggest year was 800 hours in 2007 when the company was facing similar crewing problems to now. Work life balance would be fine except for the bases. If you can adapt to the Broome or Darwin lifestyle then it could be a good career job. If not, you will always be looking for a way to leave. They have offered commuting options lately but don’t know if that is for FOs or not. |
Captains are on about 80 hours a month, if not more. I believe the FOs are similar. As Aerocat has stated, you’ll generally run out of duty. |
I don’t imagine a company having to recruit with a cadet program is having much success attracting enough pilots to cover its flying. |
Neville_Nobody,
Nice strawman / outlier argument. Early life and education[edit]Kiefel was born in Cairns, Queensland in 1954. She attended Sandgate District State High School, leaving at the age of 15 upon completing Year 10. In 1971, she completed secretarial training at Kangaroo Point Technical College on a scholarship. She worked as a secretary for a building society, an architect, and an exploration company before starting work as a receptionist for a group of barristers, Fitzgerald, Moynihan and Mack. During this time, she completed secondary school and began studying law.[3]In 1973, Kiefel joined solicitors Cannan and Peterson (which became Sly & Weigall Cannan & Peterson and is now Norton Rose Fulbright) as a legal clerk. Completing her education at night, she enrolled in the Barristers Admission Board course and passed her course with honours.[4] In 1984, while on sabbatical leave, she completed a Master of Laws (LLM) at the University of Cambridge, where she was awarded the C.J. Hamson Prize in Comparative Law and the Jennings Prize. In 2008, she was elected to an Honorary Fellowship of Wolfson College, Cambridge. You're comparing 1% of 1% of the population with the rest of us, nice try, but yeah....NAH! |
I always assumed Cadets didn't have to pay a penny - that was the whole point about being a cadet wasn't it? You get selected via a rigourous process, focusing on actual piloting attributes, and therefore the airline scholarship kicks in..... The kind of stuff you would have to be smoking to think it's a good idea to pay that kind of money for lower quality, sausage factory training would surely invalidate your class 1. If people don't research their chosen industry and the best ways to go about getting their licence and ratings, it's hard to be too sympathetic when they get swindled |
Airline scholarship? Snerk! |
Originally Posted by Capt. On Heat
(Post 10260465)
I always assumed Cadets didn't have to pay a penny - that was the whole point about being a cadet wasn't it? You get selected via a rigourous process, focusing on actual piloting attributes, and therefore the airline scholarship kicks in..... There are variations where the company stumps up the cash for training and then takes it out of your salary once you commence working etc... But in general, cadets need to cover the costs of training one way or another |
@ Bazza Stub, AerocatS2A & 717tech
Thanks for the information and your perspectives. Certainly on the surface it seems an appealing job (flying wise anyway) but I understand the other factors can take the shine off even the best job if they become excessive. Cheers BE |
Originally Posted by Capt. On Heat
(Post 10260465)
The kind of stuff you would have to be smoking to think it's a good idea to pay that kind of money for lower quality, sausage factory training would surely invalidate your class 1. |
Originally Posted by dr dre
(Post 10266297)
Why is flight training undertaken during a cadet program lower quality? How is doing CPL training through a non-cadet course at a normal flying school better? Aren’t they “sausage factories” too as they teach the same CASA syllabus? I mean it’s said as a derogatory term but essentially a training course that produces pilots who operate to the same standards and procedures is a “sausage factory” isn’t it? At the smaller school, my instructors were all charter pilots, flying heavy twins with a couple thousand hours each, guys who enjoyed to be there. At the sausage factory, my first instructor was a 250 hour grade 3 who was there simply to build a few quick hours for himself and move on, which he did. i’m sure that’s not the case with all schools, however I see that some of the meta instructors at certain flight schools have never flown a charter in their life, and haven’t touched a twin since their mecir flight test. They may know the ifr according to the aip, but do they really understand how to take advantage of the IF rules? Have they ever had to calculate fuel for a max payload flight during poor weather? I doubt it. I know they have to start somewhere, but should they be starting by teaching something they don’t really know? |
Originally Posted by 717tech
(Post 10260349)
Captains are on about 80 hours a month, if not more. I believe the FOs are similar. As Aerocat has stated, you’ll generally run out of duty. In saying that, there's a lot of things that could very quickly change, I beleive there is more pilots on a hold file than there is off one. |
All times are GMT. The time now is 08:58. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.