PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Air Asia Again. (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/600726-air-asia-again.html)

RodH 15th Oct 2017 20:43

Air Asia Again.
 
This story is from the ABC News Web Site
This Air Asia flight from Perth to Bali turned around after mid-air emergency
By James Carmody
Posted about 9 hours ago

AirAsia X Airbus
PHOTO: The AirAsia flight was forced to turn around after a loss of cabin pressure. (Supplied: Wikimedia Commons)
RELATED STORY: AirAsia facing another safety probe after 'washing machine' flightRELATED STORY: Delays hit AirAsia flights after mid-air turnback; some passengers lose faithRELATED STORY: 'Passengers told to say a prayer' as AirAsia flight turns back
MAP: Perth 6000
An Indonesia AirAsia flight travelling from Perth to Denpasar with 151 passengers on board was turned back on Sunday morning after a mid-air emergency.

Flight QZ 535 was 25 minutes out of Perth when an indicator alerted the pilot to a loss of cabin pressure.

The pilot made the decision to turn back and emergency services were placed on standby at Perth Airport.

Video from passengers on board showed oxygen masks drop from the ceiling and passengers being told to brace.

The aircraft landed safely at 12:40pm and there were no injuries to passengers.

The flight was cancelled and passengers were re-booked on later flights to Denpasar.

Passengers told Channel Nine they had sent text messages to loved ones fearing they were going to die.

Engineers are tonight examining the aircraft. story from the ABC News Web site this morning.:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Bushboy68 15th Oct 2017 22:04

Geraldton area again..
Methinks AirAsia should avoid gero, seems to be a bad luck area :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

RENURPP 15th Oct 2017 22:06

It “PLUMMETED” - plunge, fall headlong, hurtle, nosedive, dive, drop, crash.
"the plane plummeted to the ground" the Airasia plane plummeted 22000 feet in seconds” I’m guessing it took about 240 - 300 seconds.
Or did it descend?

The cabin crew were panicking and screaming, or were they calling out their commands? (Maybe not the commands we might expect IF the reports are accurate.��������������)

Bushboy68 15th Oct 2017 22:34

Lost cabin pressure due to a technical issue, pilot would have descended to better air,
It’s more news worthy to say plunged, audio shows the crew screaming,passengers quiet lol

777Nine 16th Oct 2017 00:48

Taken from the SMH:

"A technical problem caused the aircraft to plunge from 32,000 feet to 10,000 feet without warning"


I seriously can't believe that journalists are allowed to write this nonsense. Then again, it is Farifax media.

RENURPP 16th Oct 2017 01:00


Originally Posted by 777Nine (Post 9926265)
Taken from the SMH:

"A technical problem caused the aircraft to plunge from 32,000 feet to 10,000 feet without warning"


I seriously can't believe that journalists are allowed to write this nonsense. Then again, it is Farifax media.

The ABC is no better😭😭😭

WingNut60 16th Oct 2017 01:16

From what I saw on TV (reasonably measured comments), reaction from cabin crew initiated similar reaction in passengers.

More important that they look good than know what they're doing.
What happens when you follow the SQ model but skip the training.

Seems many interpreted rapid descent as spiral dive - probably mindful of incident SUB-KUL 3 years ago.

PoppaJo 16th Oct 2017 01:24

Whilst I’m highly critical of the way this company has always operated and disregard for any sort of standard training procedures with no movement on that front, this is really a non event that occurs quite regularly and I have even had the joy of experiencing this in the same aircraft type a few years back.

Questions for Airbus I think.

Passengers should not be whining either. They had a choice to fly them, most of them would know, in what has been a very public thrashing over their operations in the media, that they are not well regarded. But lowest cost always wins right?

Moneymoneymoneymoney 16th Oct 2017 01:34

I guess Air Asia need to cut more costs to eliminate all the screaming flight attendants.

sierra5913 16th Oct 2017 02:00

I bet for a moment those passengers were regretting buying that $49 special....

They got away with it. Those unfortunate souls on QZ8501 didn't.

Apologies to those offended.

John Citizen 16th Oct 2017 02:31

"It plummeted/plunged (20,000 ft, for no apparent reason), and then is what caused the oxygen masks to drop"

The passengers later caught another flight. (ABC news)

Would most passengers seriously just catch the next flight after being in such a plummet/plunge (drop, freefall, weightlessness, negative g, drop out of the sky out of control) ?

Probably not even I would ever fly again.

stevieboy330 16th Oct 2017 03:33

When is CASA going to ban these idiots from Australian airspace?
They will kill a plane full of Australians soon.
They have incident after incident & CASA is doing nothing !!!!!
They had a disgraceful diversion back to Perth earlier this year & have killed a lot of people in two separate fatal crashes in the last couple of years !
People of Australia YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR.

morno 16th Oct 2017 04:11

Stevieboy,
Whilst I agree with what you say overall, these are 2 different airlines.

AirAsia X who had the engine failure I understand are Malaysian.

AirAsia who is under the spotlight for this incident, is Indonesian.

morno

PoppaJo 16th Oct 2017 04:27


When is CASA going to ban these idiots from Australian airspace?
They will kill a plane full of Australians soon.
They have incident after incident & CASA is doing nothing !!!!!
They had a disgraceful diversion back to Perth earlier this year & have killed a lot of people in two separate fatal crashes in the last couple of years !
People of Australia YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR.
They will never be banned it’s too political.

The Perth diversion is nothing compared to what’s yet to come. I’m still awaiting the outcome of the 150m near miss with an A320 above Coolangatta. Then they lugged that damaged A330 back to Melbourne instead of getting it down.

CurtainTwitcher 16th Oct 2017 04:30


das Uber Soldat 16th Oct 2017 04:59


Originally Posted by PoppaJo (Post 9926346)
Then they lugged that damaged A330 back to Melbourne instead of getting it down.

It was damaged? Did you mean the brain of the pic?

Capn Bloggs 16th Oct 2017 06:13

I've heard Melborn is allegedly the centre of the universe but didn't they lug it back to Perth? FOBF! :{

Emerg Descent on Flt Aware looked OK: max 3000fpm initially but around 2500fpm thereafter.

WingNut60 16th Oct 2017 06:39


Originally Posted by Capn Bloggs (Post 9926396)
I've heard Melborn is allegedly the centre of the universe but didn't they lug it back to Perth? FOBF! :{

Emerg Descent on Flt Aware looked OK: max 3000fpm initially but around 2500fpm thereafter.

No. Didn't you read the above?
It plummeted, PLUMMETED, I tell you.

Actually, main problem seems to have just been with the reaction of the cabin crew.

morno 16th Oct 2017 06:43

Can’t have been much of an emergency descent at only 3,000fpm

Glorified Dus Briver 16th Oct 2017 07:10


Originally Posted by 777Nine (Post 9926265)
Taken from the SMH:

"A technical problem caused the aircraft to plunge from 32,000 feet to 10,000 feet without warning"


I seriously can't believe that journalists are allowed to write this nonsense. Then again, it is Farifax media.

Not to mention, the "plunge" was over a matter of nanoseconds :ugh::ugh::ugh:

caneworm 16th Oct 2017 07:49


Actually, main problem seems to have just been with the reaction of the cabin crew.
Hey! Go easy on the 32kg princesses WingNut. If there's ever an evacuation all the pax need to do is follow them (& their duty free) out the door.

packapoo 16th Oct 2017 22:12


Originally Posted by morno (Post 9926340)
Stevieboy,
Whilst I agree with what you say overall, these are 2 different airlines.

AirAsia X who had the engine failure I understand are Malaysian.

AirAsia who is under the spotlight for this incident, is Indonesian.

morno

Above all else, sometimes, just sometimes, you get what you paid for.....:=

Jeps 16th Oct 2017 22:58

Sadly, if this trajectory continues (and there is no reason to think that it won’t) this airline and all of its subsidiaries will be responsible for another fatal incident.

caneworm 16th Oct 2017 23:01

This is truely crap journalism.
Any self respecting journo would have included a CGI video of what the aircraft crashing into a school/hospital/orphanage would look like.

PoppaJo 17th Oct 2017 07:18


It’s about time somebody at CASA got some big cahoonas and actually said, ‘until you resolve your maintenance issues, your flights to Australia are suspended’.
AirAsia scare: Experts warn against flying cost-cutting carrier

KABOY 17th Oct 2017 08:46


Hey! Go easy on the 32kg princesses WingNut

Any self respecting journo would have included a CGI video of what the aircraft crashing into a school/hospital/orphanage would look like.
Great contribution to the thread cane worm!

This Airline has buried one airplane in the Java Sea, had numerous runway over runs amongst its group airlines as well as other incidents and you want to dramatise the incident?

I think the facts are enough without you or the press embellishing the story.

caneworm 17th Oct 2017 20:45

Kaboy,
I have done my fair share of contracts & secondments to SEA carriers to know that product/service delivery failure may very well occur when it's needed most.

If you care to re-read my post you may note that my comments were not directed to those involved but squarely at the perennially disappointing media services. You missed the point completely which is easily done it seems when outrage goes looking for a home.

Sub Orbital 18th Oct 2017 04:29

So what actually happened?

AerialPerspective 18th Oct 2017 18:14


Originally Posted by 777Nine (Post 9926265)
Taken from the SMH:

"A technical problem caused the aircraft to plunge from 32,000 feet to 10,000 feet without warning"


I seriously can't believe that journalists are allowed to write this nonsense. Then again, it is Farifax media.

News are no different... remember they owned Channel 10 once and I well remember a bimbo journalist who knew nothing reporting on the scene (why would you need to go all the way out to an airport to stand in front of a Qantas aircraft to do the report???) and telling the audience that it had to turn back on a flight to Sydney because of "... a hydraulic fuel leak". I remember thinking at the time, gee, really, must be super eager to save money if they're using hydraulic fluid for fuel!!! Seriously, these people know nothing, report crap and never retract it.

Kelly Slater 18th Oct 2017 22:01

If it was going down at only 2500 fpm then it didn't plummet enough. Surely the Bus can do better than that.

morno 18th Oct 2017 22:06

That’s barely a normal descent. 320kts with the rumblers out tonight was an easy 5,500ft/min

myshoutcaptain 18th Oct 2017 23:12

Morno - A320 with Autopilot engaged only delivers half speed brake. To gain full , Autopilot Off. Autopilot is recommended and with unknown structural integrity it would appear on face value these fellas did ok. Bus can attain 5500fpm + if you get rid of the lot and pole it.

Ken Borough 19th Oct 2017 02:30

Let's put the reported pax reaction into perspective!

Most of us here are either seasoned aviators or seasoned travellers, and have probably experiened an emergency descent. We know what happens and what to expect. The casual passenger has no idea, especially if there isn't any warning. So, if one is sitting in 65k in relative serenity when all hell apparently breaks loose with masks appearing and the aircraft dropping like a proverbial brick with attendant noise and shudder, why in hell wouldn't he or she be terrified?

Ken Borough 19th Oct 2017 02:58

OK. Let’s seat him or her in 13E.

morno 19th Oct 2017 03:38


Originally Posted by myshoutcaptain (Post 9929450)
Morno - A320 with Autopilot engaged only delivers half speed brake. To gain full , Autopilot Off. Autopilot is recommended and with unknown structural integrity it would appear on face value these fellas did ok. Bus can attain 5500fpm + if you get rid of the lot and pole it.

I know. I still had the A/P on and 320kts pegged when I got to it last night.

Anyway, only pointing out that 2,500fpm doesn't really seem like much of an emergency descent, unless there was some serious structural integrity issues, which doesn't appear to be the case. However, what's to say they didn't have a higher rate of descent anyway. I wouldn't rely solely on flight aware.

Jeps 19th Oct 2017 06:03

Oddly enough Air Asia’s Wikipedia page doesn’t have an ‘incidents and accidents’ section. I must be mistaken about the 7 incidents in 20 months in Australia alone.

WingNut60 19th Oct 2017 14:27


Originally Posted by Jeps (Post 9929586)
Oddly enough Air Asia’s Wikipedia page doesn’t have an ‘incidents and accidents’ section. I must be mistaken about the 7 incidents in 20 months in Australia alone.

Simples. Add one and see if it disappears.

Metro man 20th Oct 2017 11:12

Add another, Plane malfunctions on landing, disrupts operations at Tacloban airport - The Manila Times Online

THE runway of the Daniel Z. Romualdez Airport in Tacloban City was briefly closed after an Airbus A320 of AirAsia flight Z2-321 from Manila stalled as it landed, the aviation regulator said on Friday. Passengers and crew are safe.

Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines (CAAP) said the incident occurred while the aircraft was about to turn toward the airport’s taxiway past 8 a.m.

The CAAP said the airport’s control tower received a call from the pilot saying that its plane nose wheel steering stopped working.

AirAsia management said that the airline ground crew rushed to the area and immediately transferred the 164 passengers and four crewmembers to safety.

According to CAAP spokesman Eric Apolonio, an arriving Cebu Pacific flight to Tacloban from Manila was unable to land on its scheduled flight while a departing flight of another Cebu Pacific plane had to wait until airport authorities cleared the disabled plane off the runway.

Airline officials claimed that the Daniel Z. Romualdez Airport lacked equipment such as a tow truck and other equipment needed to salvage the damaged aircraft.

The airport, in 2013, was ranked as the eighth-busiest airport by passenger volume out of the 45 commercial airports in the Philippines.

As of 11 a.m., AirAsia management announced that the plane was eventually towed from the runway and the airport resumed normal operations. BENJIE VERGARA

wheels_down 20th Oct 2017 15:15

Engineering costs money.

topcap 4th Nov 2017 04:18

I travel to and around Asia quite frequently using Air Asia, Air Asia X, Jetstar Asia, Jetstar Pacific Vietnam (which I call Jetstar Pathetic), Lion Air (the worst), Tiger, Vietjet Air (very good) and Vietnam Airlines.
As a Commercial Pilot I am fully aware of Safety Regulations and notice the cabin crews in many instances are not enforcing the rules - like passengers walking around while the aircraft is taxiing, mobile phones and laptops not being turned off, passengers getting luggage out of overhead lockers before the aircraft has parked , and in one instance a kid leaning over the top of a seat while the aircraft was on final approach into Singapore in full view of the crew who failed to act.
The other problem I have noticed with Emergencies is that frequently it is reported that Pilots are not communicating with the passengers to advise them what is occurring in order to calm the situation down and when as in the Air Asia flight the Flight Attendants are screaming in panic and crying as described by passengers on that flight then there is a serious training problem and the passengers claim that it was only when the Flight Attendants started to panic that they started to panic. Those staff should be sacked.
People are basically not stupid but the majority know nothing about aircraft so they are entitled to be calmly advised by Pilots during an emergency as to what is occurring and the Flight Attendants should at all times be calm and decisive in their actions.
It's not happening on many Asian Airlines.


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:42.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.