PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Rex incident YSSY (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/592317-rex-incident-yssy.html)

slocs 17th Mar 2017 09:39

Since when is a pan a mayday? When reported by GT!:

Rex plane issues mayday call before emergency landing at Sydney Airport | Perth Now

ozbiggles 17th Mar 2017 09:45

standby, fact checking

Ex FSO GRIFFO 17th Mar 2017 09:51

OOOpppsss... OK OK, I'll go quietly.

When I saw it, it was very corroded, and I am aware of the wing leading edge separating after a severe pull-up, so the 'story' was....

Apols for 'giving' this one to the US Navy....

logansi 17th Mar 2017 10:54

Is it possible that the prop shaft could literally rip itself apart due to an extremely excessive uncontrolled increase in RPM? That's what uncommanded engine operations would mean to me.

Ultralights 17th Mar 2017 11:14

If the prop seperated in the approx area of the map above. It should be relatively easy to recover, from someone's lounge room, back paddock or garden. If it's in the blue mountains national park, it would be nearly impossible to find.

Ozgrade3 17th Mar 2017 11:22

Isn't the CT7 engine a fixed turbine. Would the FCU be able to keep the RPM under disc explosion level once the prop came off. What sort of torque value do the SAABs use on descent.

Is there any mode of CSU failure that would drive the blades to fine pitch. I would imagine that the drag of accelerating the engine in this case would keep the RPMs much lower than on a PT6.

megan 17th Mar 2017 11:40


I'm pretty sure that P3 was flown by an exchange officer... possibly US Navy?
It was. And a repeat of a US Navy P-3 event at Cocos three years earlier that had similar leading edge collapse but landed safely. Interesting report on the investigation into the RAAF event by ARL. Design errors by Lockheed and manufacturing defects in the leading edge ribs part of the story.

Sad end for a plane IsDon.

http://www.adf-gallery.com.au/galler...754/A9_754.jpg

logansi 17th Mar 2017 12:18

^^ I was referring to prop RPM

The main reason I make the point is too me "uncommanded engine operations" (stated to ATC) likely means an increase in power, because a loss/reduction of power would more likely be referenced as failed engine.

cooperplace 17th Mar 2017 12:25


Originally Posted by Parrot Pilot (Post 9709249)
I'm pretty sure that P3 was flown by an exchange officer... possibly US Navy?

if I recall correctly, the US officer flying had played a significant role, and not a positive one, in the genesis of this disaster. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

Jetsbest 17th Mar 2017 12:44


Originally Posted by cooperplace (Post 9709407)
if I recall correctly, the US officer flying had played a significant role, and not a positive one, in the genesis of this disaster. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

The Canadian exchange officer & captain flying at the time was but one of the 'slices of Swiss cheese' in the event's evolution.🤔😉

IsDon 17th Mar 2017 15:31


Originally Posted by Jetsbest (Post 9709436)
The Canadian exchange officer & captain flying at the time was but one of the 'slices of Swiss cheese' in the event's evolution.🤔😉

Correct, the guy was on exchange from Canada, not the US.

I believe, happy to be corrected, he was also the Aurora display pilot prior to his posting to Australia. Doing air shows in the aircraft. I've been told this by others, I don't know it for certain.

shiftpattern 17th Mar 2017 15:32

SF340 VH-EKT had torque motor issues immediately prior to this incident.

https://www.atsb.gov.au/publications...aair199201222/

Crew elected to land without going to torque motor lockout. Prop runaway ensued resulting in loss of control and snapping of nose gear on touchdown. Not saying todays incident is similar but the CT7, like any engine, is not infallible.

https://www.geaviation.com/commercia...nes/ct7-engine

It's been around a while and is pretty reliable.

Job well done by the crew. I'm sure Rex will give them a little bit of extra nothing in their pay check as a reward.

corrigin 17th Mar 2017 16:34

Well done job by the crew, as well as ATC and emergency services.

Pistonprop 17th Mar 2017 16:47

Interesting that they declared it only as a Pan. Then again I suppose they did have full control of the aircraft and they were Ozzies ;)

I'm sure the pax said "sod councelling, where's the bar"! :)

Car RAMROD 17th Mar 2017 20:35

Auto feather.... Pffft... Auto-jettison!!

ChrisJ800 17th Mar 2017 21:05

Did the flight crew call it a pan pan or was that designated by ATC? Nicely managed by all given the additional medical pan pan at similar time. But should both planes have been allowed 16R then the runway check done? As the taxi time from 16L is long for the flight with the medical emergency.

mrred81 17th Mar 2017 21:23


Originally Posted by ChrisJ800 (Post 9709993)
Did the flight crew call it a pan pan or was that designated by ATC? Nicely managed by all given the additional medical pan pan at similar time. But should both planes have been allowed 16R then the runway check done? As the taxi time from 16L is long for the flight with the medical emergency.

The problem is the rex aircraft vacating the runway in time for the medical pan

CharlieLimaX-Ray 17th Mar 2017 21:45

Has GT come forward with a theory yet?

Was the aircraft turning from upwind to a downwind air mass?

Has ATSB checked Cash Convertors out in western Sydney in case they have Saab prop for sale?

topdrop 17th Mar 2017 22:25

Aviate, Navigate, Communicate - perhaps by the time they told ATC, they had everything under control and thought Mayday was no longer warranted.

Desert Flower 17th Mar 2017 22:26


Originally Posted by Raptor090 (Post 9708995)
Great job to the crew!

Can't wait for the headlines, "ultralight crash lands at Sydney Airport"

I can't wait for the headlines "aircraft are designed to land with only one prop"

DF.


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:47.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.