PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   21 years since first AN B747-300 operation (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/567089-21-years-since-first-b747-300-operation.html)

B772 3rd Sep 2015 05:36

21 years since first AN B747-300 operation
 
Hard to believe it is 21 years. Time does fly !

A rooster one day. feather duster the next.

Icarus2001 3rd Sep 2015 06:19

Feather duster indeed.
The report was valuable reading.

http://www.aussieairliners.org/b-747.../4630.039l.jpg

The Bungeyed Bandit 3rd Sep 2015 06:31

The Spaceship has landed!!!

Wunwing 3rd Sep 2015 08:20

The incident and the report are an interesting study in Human Factors and also a good example of the realities of introducing a new compex type into a long standing fleet.

There were heaps of holes in many slices of cheese and they all lined up that day. However, in the end, no one was hurt and the aircraft suffered comparitively minor damage.

Wunwing

catseye 3rd Sep 2015 10:36

onya Willie.wonder if he is still flying:(

B772 3rd Sep 2015 13:45

catseye,

The PIC would be around 80 now and the F/O mid 50's.

Dora-9 3rd Sep 2015 19:51

Yes, the PIC is still around! I was delighted to see him at the Antique Aircraft Assoc event at Echuca earlier this year (he has a beautifully restored Aero 145). Very fit and spry for his age.

"BJ" was enormously well-liked and respected in his Cathay days, and I had many enjoyable flights with him. What a very sad way to end your airline career...

TrailBoss 3rd Sep 2015 23:39

Checked the log book. First flight in a 300 series (N118KD) June 25th 1984, Dubai to London. How the years have flown by...

BalusKaptan 4th Sep 2015 09:53

Also checked log book. Last flew N118KD from ASSY (now YSSY) to WSSS early 1991.

Paragraph377 4th Sep 2015 12:12

Big Trev's baby. It was also a lesson in how not to add an aircraft to your AOC, especially when your plans are over ambitious and you have a timeframe of just a couple of months. Just can't be done, not successfully anyway.
I agree that human factors played a significant role, but you can't blame the pilots. Management were the problem with management putting unrealistic organisational pressure on everyone. It was a classic organisational mismanagemt stuff up because they had dollar signs in their eyes and wanted to cash in on Olympic revenue.
But they are good memories of a great airline filled with a lot of great people.
Do I miss her? Absolutely

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jMXQXmeqepo

Lookleft 4th Sep 2015 12:39

I think you have your timelines mixed up P377. Big Trev didn't arrive until after the AN888 debacle. If anything it was Big Graham's baby and he wouldn't be told by anyone, particularly pilots, that he was rushing.

TANUA 4th Sep 2015 14:17

Lookleft-

My memory is that TJ was employed to intruduce the B747 & that this was his "baby".:(

B772 4th Sep 2015 14:20

It was AN881 that landed in SYD with the nose wheel retracted. VH-INH if I remember correctly. Also 6 years before the SYD Olympics P377. TJ joined AN in 1996.

Lookleft 4th Sep 2015 22:26

TANUA-Your timeline is also incorrect. B772 thanks for the correction of the flight number. I knew it had lots of 8s in it as it is considered a lucky number in Asia.

TrailBoss 4th Sep 2015 23:11


I agree that human factors played a significant role, but you can't blame the pilots.
That's a pretty generous statement.

catseye 4th Sep 2015 23:31

how many greens have you got Who signed off the engineer. Don't blame the pilots.

OzSync 5th Sep 2015 00:04

With a gear horn blaring away at you perhaps a second set of eyes on the down lights would have been appropriate....It was a generous statement indeed.

Dora-9 5th Sep 2015 00:38


With a gear horn blaring away at you perhaps a second set of eyes on the down lights would have been appropriate....It was a generous statement indeed.
OzSync:

Enlighten me - have you ever tried to see the gear indicator lights on the aft end of the FE's panel from the captain's seat?

By George 5th Sep 2015 01:34

As always, more to it. BJ said, " Have we got all greens"? Uncle Les thought he said, "Have we got four Greens"? The lights were clustered in a way that you could miss the fifth. They painted a little white line around the panel after that.
' Wandering Will' gave up flying years ago. He was also the F/O with that nasty engine failure and fire out of BNE on the 727. I liked him and found him to be a good operator but his confidence was hit after too many people, without the real story, were too critical. You are only remembered by your mishaps, not your achievements in this weird industry. Will was under training at the time and could hardly be expected to 'Ace it'. Unfortunate but the number 1 engine had a few important bits hanging off it. Les was a lovely bloke too and I think it was his first solo trip on the line.

TrailBoss 5th Sep 2015 05:34

Consider the following:

A three engine approach followed by either a gear or flap failure is a well practiced simulator exercise, something an experienced 747 captain would have been exposed to on numerous occasions.

An experienced captain would also know that extension of the gear, using only the hydraulic ADP takes longer than when the EDP is operating.

Aircraft configuration abnormalities are best dealt with at altitude, and to go around is by far the safest option available when confronted by abnormal conditions, particularly during final approach.

It is the captain’s sole responsibility to support and supervise the actions of the F/E, particularly whilst carrying out abnormal/emergency check lists; otherwise he is left to operate autonomously, leaving both pilots out of the loop.

And yes, the gear lights on the F/Es panel can be viewed from the captain’s position; it just requires the F/E to position his seat accordingly.

So I think to say, that the pilots – and in particular the captain could not be blamed – was indeed a generous statement…


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:18.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.