PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Senate Inquiry, Hearing Program 4th Nov 2011 (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/468048-senate-inquiry-hearing-program-4th-nov-2011-a.html)

Kharon 21st Apr 2012 21:34

Before and after
 
The picture presents new recruits awaiting processing at the training centre. This is the pre lobotomy and castration stage of training, where 'trough addiction' is taught.

Nice 1 GD - :D Made my day.

Kharon 31st May 2012 22:10

Once upon a time
 
In a land far far away :-


Do not consider it proof just because it is written in books, for a liar who will deceive with his tongue will not hesitate to do the same with his pen. Maimonides 1135 – 1204.
Even the old boys back then knew a fairy story when they heard it.

Keg 31st May 2012 22:15

Of course he did. The sad reality is that he has plausible deniability on this one. Contingencies are made but the decision wasn't made to execute the decision until the Saturday morning.

Everyone knows it- including the Parliament- but no one can do anything about it.

Again though, if he decided on a whim to shut the airline down on the Saturday morning then it shows an immensely flawed and dysfunctional decision making process at the exec and board level of Qantas.

Capt Claret 1st Jun 2012 00:13

The lock-out ramifications will flow on for some time.

I've just booked my sister-in-law a ticket with Virgin because I haven't forgotten yet.

gobbledock 1st Jun 2012 01:30

Tick tock
 

Again though, if he decided on a whim to shut the airline down on the Saturday morning then it shows an immensely flawed and dysfunctional decision making process at the exec and board level of Qantas.
It also shows his ridiculous decision was knee-jerk, not measured and riddled with emotion.
Where does that decison sit under CAA's 'fit and proper person' methodolgy? Safety first? An increased appetite for risk?
Try studying the phrases 'risk', 'rogue' and 'aviation management', it paints a telling picture when combined.

As for Madam Lash, she/he has been facing off Sheldon for ages now, listening to her is like listening to 2 pieces off chalking being scraped down a blackboard.

Collando 1st Jun 2012 02:25

Yes the decision was made on Saturday, it's just pure luck the couriers were all ready and able to deliver the lock out notices the next day that were quite by chance printed off and ready to go.hotel rooms booked in advance and managers who just happenened to be in the right place at the right time to assist with the PR disaster to follow, just bloody good luck eh.
Any decent investigative reporter could find the holes in the story, trouble is is there a decent investigative reporter who could publish such a tale of liesand deception out there?

Chocks Away 1st Jun 2012 15:47

Well HELLOooooo....
 
Qantas accused of misleading MPs on workforce lockout

by: EWIN HANNAN
From: The Australian
June 01, 2012 12:00AM

QANTAS executives discussed locking out the airline workforce two weeks before the company grounded its fleet last year, prompting union claims last night that the airline had misled federal parliament.

Gareth Evans, the airline's chief financial officer, told Fair Work Australia that the airline's executive committee had discussed the option of locking out the workforce "probably two weeks" before aircraft were grounded last October.


Wake up Australia!
Massive numbers of Hotel rooms booked well before the event (apparently)!
:ugh::ugh::ugh:

ALAEA Fed Sec 1st Jun 2012 21:06

If it was suspected that he misled parliament, couldn't that call for some sort of investigation? I'd be looking for -

-What instructions were given to the printers and when they started printing.
-How many hotel rooms they booked that weekend compared to the previous few weekends.
-movements of managers.
-What instructions were given to couriers and when they started asking their staff to work the weekend.

Any other suggestions? If there is an avenue here it may be explored.

The Kelpie 1st Jun 2012 22:13

With the revelations regarding FWA prosecutions regarding cadets and thai cabin crew that have come to light since both enquiries, the senators should have someone go through the Hansard and discover that both Alan and Bruce pulled their chain on a number of occasions.

What did BB constantly say "lets get to the facts". Hmmm. Well now someone has and exposed a catalogue of lies and, at best blatantly misleading statements.

More to Follow

The Kelpie

Kharon 1st Jun 2012 22:43

The Key
 
Is Hansard – but the lock is hidden deep within the questions on notice and the way that system is exploited. There are some tricky rules associated which, no surprise, are fully 'utilised'. There's a full days work for someone but the results will make you smile.

Kelpie - What did BB constantly say "lets get to the facts". Hmmm. Well now someone has and exposed a catalogue of lies and, at best blatantly misleading statements.

Perhaps some carefully framed questions with the wriggle room barred at both doors presented to the Senate could expose the whole mess.


But then again – their lips would be moving during the answers. QED.

Mstr Caution 1st Jun 2012 23:43

Fed Sec.

Perhaps the good senators should have gone straight the "print source".

Who worked on Saturday 29th October 2011 who usually don't work on Saturdays.

When was the print job booked?

When did the print run start?

What was the expected outcome of the print job on the morning of October 29th.

Why were the printers waiting for the 5pm call?

MC

Jetsbest 2nd Jun 2012 00:27

You may all be right but....
 
"Contingency planning" sometimes involves significant expense.

My take is that their defence will be something along the lines of;
"QF's only legal response was a lockout and, although it was a last resort, we had to put measures in place which enabled such a course of action to be effective with minimum inconvenience to the customers. As per Mr Joyce's testimony the final decision was not taken until the Saturday morning."

The cost of hotel bookings, couriers, printing etc were a necessary, if dispensable, expense which has been written off against that nasty industrial action by the unions.

Yep, you can call me cynical. :rolleyes:

ALAEA Fed Sec 2nd Jun 2012 00:36


QF's only legal response was a lockout
True. But within that scope they had countless options.

Lockout Adelaide LAMEs for one day.

Lockout Second Officers for one hour.

Lockout one Baggage Handler per crew for 4 hours.

The list is endless.

simsalabim 2nd Jun 2012 00:59

................ and were lockout notices also printed up for those or any other other locations ?

obira 2nd Jun 2012 02:32

QANTAS managers were already flown in place around the world when the grounding took place. Flights had departed at least the day before.

Could they not be made to appear before the Senate?

Could they be asked what discussions they had with others about their testimony?

halfmanhalfbiscuit 2nd Jun 2012 03:47

If there is enough doubt to suggest that AJ or others may have committed perjury and perverted the course of justice then the senators need to get them back.

If you want some parallels look at the News of the World inquiry in the UK. Andy Coulson is facing if not already charged with perjury for misleading that inquiry.

Geoffrey Archer served 2 years in prison for pejury and lost his knighthood.

So this could get very interesting!

unseen 2nd Jun 2012 04:01

Jetsbest is correct
 
Jetsbest summarizes the situation perfectly.

Livs Hairdresser 2nd Jun 2012 05:11


"QF's only legal response was a lockout and, although it was a last resort, we had to put measures in place which enabled such a course of action to be effective with minimum inconvenience to the customers. As per Mr Joyce's testimony the final decision was not taken until the Saturday morning."
That's kind of like a hitman who buys the ammunition, drives to the murder scene, loads his gun, waits 4 hours for the victim to arrive, shoots him in the head and then pleads it was only manslaughter because he only decided to pull the trigger in the last 10 seconds.

And besides, on how many other occasions had they planned for such "contingencies"?

TIMA9X 2nd Jun 2012 05:38


The cost of hotel bookings, couriers, printing etc were a necessary, if dispensable, expense which has been written off against that nasty industrial action by the unions.
I agree, then AJ used the cost of the lockout against Q international to make it look even worse.... here









For reference, the second inquiry here,



about 1.05 in part B, BB puts his foot in it, AJ tries to cover for him... the whole thing stinks but the good senators miss their opportunity to nail them... as usual... and AJ wanted to get to the airport all of a sudden



Even though it takes a long time to get through all this stuff I believe there are many things the media missed because it is so long which worked to AJs advantage at the end of the day....


.

KRUSTY 34 2nd Jun 2012 05:46

The sad reality of all this smoke and mirrors, is just that. Smoke and Mirrors! QF have 99% of the pollie's peckers in their pocket, and the vast majority of investigative journalists as well.

Nothing will come of any of it, despite the fact that both AJ and BB should spend considerable years in jail!

Don't delude yourselves that we live in a democracy. :sad:


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:03.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.