PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Jetstar legal action update (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/462373-jetstar-legal-action-update.html)

PhoenixNZ 11th Sep 2011 08:32


In the UK first it was the low cost carrier. Then it was pay for your endorsement. Then it was pay a ****load of money for a cadetship, then pay for your endorsement. (meanwhile all the wages where coming down as supply of pilots rose).

It has finally culminated in pay for your cadetship, pay for your endorsement, pay for 500 hours line training along with your own accommodation at outports.

Guys are doing this because they think there is a pot of gold waiting for them at emirates if they do.

So basically unless you're in a legacy carrier in Europe, it is pretty hard to get an FO position that pays the bills at all. In fact, you pay to fly the aircraft!

All this because "I had a wife and kids, and needed to get ahead". Problem is there is always someone else willing to go lower as can be attested to the rot in Europe.

NZ will be next. Just wait till the boffins work out how much you lot are prepared to pay for 500 hours line training!

Living the dream.
And NONE of that has currently had any negative impact on the existing FOs has it? They haven't had to take paycuts or faced massive redundancies.

So what do the current FOs in NZ have to worry about when all this has done so far is impacted on new pilots to airlines.


If you belonged to a union and stopped thinking about yourself for 5 min you'd know the answer to that.http://images.ibsrv.net/ibsrv/res/sr...lies/yeees.gif
I dont currently work for an airline so I have no need to belong to a union. When I do get into an airline I'll by all means join one and when I feel my pay/conditions aren't up to scratch I'll be on the frontlines with the rest of you.

You guys are all responsible for yourselves. Your all saying I'm just being selfish but if I dont look out for me then who will? Something tells me none of you are any different. Your all looking at how these cadet schemes will affect YOU. Lets be honest, you wouldn't care if it wasn't affecting YOU. The difference is that there are lots of the YOUs out there that you can band together with.

Me on the otherhand, I'm on my own so I'm just looking out for me.

The Green Goblin 11th Sep 2011 08:33

The reason you are happy with 60k sheep shagger, is you are not a Pilot. You have not learnt your craft, you have no experience, and nothing to give.

Once you have a thing called experience and can call yourself a Pilot, you will realize your skills are worth far more than 60k.

You will then get pissed off when guys like you offer to prostitute themselves for next to nothing, have no real skills and pretty much dumb down and de skill the profession.

Would you be happy having your family driven across NZ by a 17 year old who just got his/her drivers licence at night in poor weather? Or would you offer to drive instead :ok:

PhoenixNZ 11th Sep 2011 08:37


You will then get pissed off when guys like you offer to prostitute themselves for next to nothing, have no real skills and pretty much dumb down and de skill the profession.
Thats the difference between the two of us. I wouldn't get pissed off at the guy doing the driving, I'd be pissed off at the guy who offered him the car

Can you really blame a 17 year old for wanting to drive? Isn't it ulitmately the car owners job to ensure that the drivers is up for the job.

Thats my whole point here folks. Your blaming the cadets for taking what is realistically a great offer for someone of our level of experience. When in fact its QF/JQ who are giving us the jobs in the first place.

The Green Goblin 11th Sep 2011 08:38

It has had a huge impact on existing FOs.

The FOs became Captains and bit their tongues.

Many potential Pilots could not afford to get into the industry due to the high cost of entry.

Those with experience went overseas and are now expats as they can't afford t work from home.

Your future ain't in NZ mate. Get used to speaking Arabic or mandarin if you ever want a return on what you think you're worth.

Pity though, cause guys like you will head over there too dragging those T&Cs down with them.

Like the Jetstar group contract or the substandard rishworth Jetstar contract. If not enough guys apply, the condition improve until they get their numbers. If no one applied to the cadetship, it will be modified to attract more applicants.

Unfortunately you're too short sighted to see it.

waren9 11th Sep 2011 08:40


Me on the otherhand, I'm on my own so I'm just looking out for me
So. How do you think thats gonna go for you when you're up against Buchanan, with his cheque book in his back pocket....all by yourself, and another cadet who'll do your job for $10 less than you will.

This is like shooting like fish in a barrel.

Here's a tip. Save yourself and your innocent family about 7 years of shaftings from Jetstar (about the time it'll take for you to finally pull the pin) and go do that Degree.

Di_Vosh 11th Sep 2011 08:44

Nothing changes, obviously...
 
The really sad part about PhoenixNZ's contribution to this thread is that he pretty much had the same conversation about a month or two ago. I'm not sure why he'd think that anyone would have changed their mind about him or the attitude that he's shown.

As I posted in that previous thread, if the J* cadetship is the financially best option for a Kiwi to get his/her aviation career, then I'd have taken a different career path.

Phoenix, just remember, you chose to get into this profession. Remember that in 6 years time when your contract isn't renewed because the crop of cadets are willing to do it for less than you.

DIVOSH!

PhoenixNZ 11th Sep 2011 08:46


Like the Jetstar group contract or the substandard rishworth Jetstar contract. If not enough guys apply, the condition improve until they get their numbers. If no one applied to the cadetship, it will be modified to attract more applicants
.

I totally agree that if no one applied then they would have to change it. But whats the likelyhood that your going to convince everyone who wants to be a pilot not to apply?

So instead, why dont the existing drivers say "We aren't willing to fly with anyone who has gone through the cadets program as they are unsafe to fly with". You guys are the ones with the numbers and the power. I have no power as an individual to change anything in the industry, you guys do. You want something changed, then get out there and change it.

PhoenixNZ 11th Sep 2011 08:52


The really sad part about PhoenixNZ's contribution to this thread is that he pretty much had the same conversation about a month or two ago. I'm not sure why he'd think that anyone would have changed their mind about him or the attitude that he's shown.

As I posted in that previous thread, if the J* cadetship is the financially best option for a Kiwi to get his/her aviation career, then I'd have taken a different career path.

Phoenix, just remember, you chose to get into this profession. Remember that in 6 years time when your contract isn't renewed because the crop of cadets are willing to do it for less than you.
If no-one protests against the unacceptable then it will never change. You dont think Martin Luthor King gave up just because the first time he tried everyone ignored him?

The Green Goblin 11th Sep 2011 08:55

Trust me sheepshagger, we would all love to shun the programs and refuse fly with anyone involved with it.

Check Captains would love to refuse to line train them.

Unfortunately this is called illegal industrial action. Individuals are liable for financial damages to the company.

Meanwhile everyone grits their teeth and gets on with it. This is why in Australia there has been a lot of court action, senate enquiries and a somewhat unified pilot body.

PhoenixNZ 11th Sep 2011 09:00

The real world:

Who has the problem: Existing pilots
Who is responsible for doing something about it: Existing pilots

The existing pilots world:

Who has the problem: Existing pilots
Who is responsible for doing something about it: Everyone else

Its the cadets who miss out under you guys solution. Cadets get punished for doing nothing more than taking the best opportunity available at the time.

And I would bet a lot of money that if ANY of you were in the same position today that you would be applying right along side me.

Also no one as yet has shown any sort of proof that cadet schemes have negatively impacted aviation as a whole. Also no one as yet has given any explanation of how a cadets scheme is any different to any other apprenticeship type program.

From my seat here: A bunch of old pilots who hate change for the sake of change. Well times are changing peoples, change with them or be left behind. Those are the choices.

The Green Goblin 11th Sep 2011 09:07

Bruce, haven't you got a Japanses Airline to kickstart?

I think you should stop wasting time stirring up the troops and get back to work :ok:

PhoenixNZ 11th Sep 2011 09:19

Also I'll mention that this whole thread started because of the news that the JQ cadets would be getting similar conditions now to standard F/Os. They can now only be used and abused for two years.

So its win/win for pilots/cadets. The cadets get better conditions and the pilots aren't being priced out of a job.

It may mean that JQ stops getting cadets but that would in part depend on exactly why the program came about in the first place. If it was purely a cost cutting measure then that may not work any more. However if it was partially due to difficulty recruiting enough pilots so they wanted to make it easier then that should continue.

Time shall tell.


Bruce, haven't you got a Japanses Airline to kickstart?

I think you should stop wasting time stirring up the troops and get back to work http://images.ibsrv.net/ibsrv/res/sr...ies/thumbs.gif
Can't see a belt without hitting below it? What are you doing on a forum if you dont want to have an open exchange of ideas.

Keg 11th Sep 2011 09:34


why dont the existing drivers say "We aren't willing to fly with anyone who has gone through the cadets program as they are unsafe to fly with".
You may be in for a shock. Whilst it's illegal to refuse to fly with a cadet- as others have pointed out- it's very legal to stand one down if they show themselves not up to the required standard. My understanding is that just this thing has occurred in J* recently.

So now you owe a huge training debt and aren't even being paid the pittance you were 'happy' to accept. You'd better hope you're an ace and don't find yourself in that situation.

waren9 11th Sep 2011 09:35

Phoenix

You are either mgmnt or HR.

Goodnight.

slamer. 11th Sep 2011 10:10

"The Roman leader Julius Caesar recorded the earliest known version of this proverb, 'Experience is the teacher of all things,'

PNZ... I think you will find this out the hard way.





The goo gobbler.... you are an idiot...... please continue.

Muff Hunter 11th Sep 2011 10:29

Or you can do what some JQ captains are doing, not let them have a sector.

I have heard a JQ Captain nearly lost his job due to a cadet fark up, visual approach I believe (on 34 into MEL I think).....:ugh::ugh:

Keg 11th Sep 2011 10:31


You'd better hope you're an ace and don't find yourself in that situation.
Another quick thought. Given that your cadetship was based upon min standard as quickly as possible and to minimum cost, the chances that you've actually got good enough training to know what you don't know is doubtful.

Muff, twas the example I was thinking of. Knew it was MEL but hadn't heard specifics.

Di_Vosh 11th Sep 2011 10:41

I gotta say that you're great entertainment for a Sunday night Phoenix.


Also I'll mention that this whole thread started because of the news that the JQ cadets would be getting similar conditions now to standard F/Os. They can now only be used and abused for two years.

So its win/win for pilots/cadets. The cadets get better conditions and the pilots aren't being priced out of a job.

In Australia! Not in NZ! Your T&C's will still be a **** sandwich! Because of people like you.


Also no one as yet has shown any sort of proof that cadet schemes have negatively impacted aviation as a whole.
Disagree. Plenty of people on this thread (and on the other one) showed you how this kind of cadet scheme has resulted in lowered T&C's. It's just that you refused to believe it because it didn't fit in with your viewpoint.

(Note, I'm talking about the J* "indentured labour" cadet scheme, as opposed to the traditional QF/CX cadet schemes that paid their cadets good money).

DIVOSH!

P.S. I'm not sure how comparing yourself to the good Dr. King has much relevance to this thread...

Di_Vosh 11th Sep 2011 10:43


I have heard a JQ Captain nearly lost his job due to a cadet fark up, visual approach I believe (on 34 into MEL I think).....
34 from sheed was it?

KRUSTY 34 11th Sep 2011 11:19

waren9, close old mate, but G.G. By Jove, I think you've got it!

I've just had a moment of clarity chaps. I thought I had heard some of PNZ's pontifications somewhere else.

It was with an ABC Journalist!

Most real pilots would deny that individual 02. Maybe time to do the same here. :suspect:


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:30.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.