PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   BNE ATC Holding (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/450166-bne-atc-holding.html)

Capn Bloggs 24th May 2012 08:46

Stick to your COB times and holding shouldn't be too bad! :E

Jabawocky 24th May 2012 09:57


Too many Jabas and FTDKs there!! :}
Bloggs you are a funny bugger :}

Not much FTDK action down here....or TL for that matter. He has gone incognito and only seen in PTDK's and them CTTDK's of late.

Jaba's have even been bumped around of recent times even, so yes it is getting crowded!

Have to say the BN CEN / BN APP folk have been working their butts off and have been doing a stellar job under the pressure. :D:D:D

J:ok:

1Charlie 28th May 2012 07:15

http://a1.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphot...34719966_n.jpg

1Charlie 28th May 2012 07:16

Last Thursday evening. CAVOK

Jack Ranga 28th May 2012 08:47

What has CAVOK got to do with anything? Can you fit more aircraft on runways when it's CAVOK?

1Charlie 28th May 2012 09:48

Are you saying the arrival rate is not affected by the weather?

1Charlie 28th May 2012 11:26

I was only clarifying that weather wasn't causing all the holding. No point posting a traffic picture covered in holding patterns if terrible weather is causing it.

Livin the Dream 5th Jun 2012 07:47

Stop your whinging about traffic delays you 'flyboys'...

I flew on one of our Domestic airline carriers the other day and guess what......

# I had to WAIT at check-in (why couldn't they tell prior to leaving home that there would be delays);
# I had to line up & WAIT to board the aircraft even though I asked for priority...
# I had stand in the aisle & WAIT before reaching my seat (where's my boarding slot time...)
# I had to WAIT in the aisle (yes CAVOK as well...) before getting off
# .....& yes I had to wait to get my bag.....

Perhaps too many passengers per staff and limiting hardware processors...??

At least I realize it's a game of maths.....

ozbiggles 5th Jun 2012 07:49

How much money did all those delays cost you dreaming?

chuboy 5th Jun 2012 10:03


Originally Posted by ozbiggles (Post 7227315)
How much money did all those delays cost you dreaming?

I didn't realise airline pilots had to pay the fuel truck driver with their own money! :ok:

DutchRoll 5th Jun 2012 11:08

Livin the Dream,

How big a sweat did you break out in knowing that you were sitting at 30,000 ft running critically short of fuel because the traffic delays were in excess of the NOTAM'd time?

Stiff Under Carriage 5th Jun 2012 11:20


How big a sweat did you break out in knowing that you were sitting at 30,000 ft running critically short of fuel because the traffic delays were in excess of the NOTAM'd time?
Exactly.

I was on a flight inbound to BN Friday night. Was holding for 50 mins at what must have been 50nm out as it took at least another 20mins to get on ground. Admittedly the weather was very poor, but still not good enough. This is occurring national wide. With the implementation of the new traffic management system things have gotten worse. This is supposed to be a better product.

Wally Mk2 5th Jun 2012 23:23

Out of the 3 major "J" curve dromes the order of muck-around is BN,ML then SY in that order .
Yep to me it seems ML is more troublesome than SY mostly. BN you can forget they get first prize for working against 'Juliars' Carbon Tax rubbish!

BN really have gotta improve it's 2nd AP infrastructure, it's impossible to get off the plane! (Blacka):)

I'd hate to be an ATC'er working with their hands tied behind their backs.


Wmk2

Livin the Dream 6th Jun 2012 00:34

DJ & SUC - you guys still don't get it.....

It's the airlines that organise their own scheduling...

It's the airport owners who spend (or most time don't...) on airport infrastructure (2nd runways, more efficient high speed taxiways, etc)...

ATCers catch the mess.....and cop the blame...!!

I'm not saying it is not a problem - because it is....and it's only going to get worse. It's a simple game of maths.

As far as traffic notam delay accuracy.....it's the airlines that need to keep the system (Metron) up to date. So guess what - if THEY don't - IT don't tell the right story...

Just a thought....

LTD

Stiff Under Carriage 6th Jun 2012 02:57

LTD,

We get it mate, we get it!

None of us saying it ATC fault, that was your assumption. It is ATC who hold us, they might cop some flack from the drivers, we cop it from the pax, round the world it goes.

Whether its infrastructure, (BN), curfew, (SY), or some other reason, (ML) I don't care. The three busiest airports in Australia have excessive holding for whatever reason. That's what we are saying. It should be fixed. He government is the biggest problem here, what other government in the world forces an international airport to close at 11pm because some FW decides to buy a house near the airport and complain about noise. Why do we have only 1 RWY operating at BN? Use the other one. Build another one, start spending money where it's needed, not on some insane Carbon Tax scheme and handing it out to everyone to appanrently compensate.

The airlines arrange there own scheduling yes, but in accordance with slot times available. Close and airport, restrict an airport and you create a problem, don't accept more traffic without specific room for it, just because of revenue.

Willoz269 6th Jun 2012 05:59

Dont run out of steam....things are about to get worse with the works scheduled to commence on BN taxiways....notably A7....:ooh:

Hempy 6th Jun 2012 08:53


Originally Posted by 'Dutch Roll
How big a sweat did you break out in knowing that you were sitting at 30,000 ft running critically short of fuel because the traffic delays were in excess of the NOTAM'd time?

at the alternate I take it..

haughtney1 9th Jun 2012 13:09

Just one for you approach guys, arrived in the cripple from the west the other morning 5.15amish, and had the delightful experience of having to fly the full RNAV arrival for Rwy 19, rather than getting the usual direct to sinnk from 100 miles out or so.
Just wondering what the thinking was, given there where no departures or arrivals within 5 minutes of our arrival, and that the extra track miles ate about 1000 usd extra worth of jet fuel.
Is this something new? Also anecdotally, guys I'm flying with seem to be of the opinion that there seems to be a bit of a concerted effort (conspiracy if you will) to back guys into corners..and then try and trap them resulting in a violation i.e. "you have approx 45 track miles to run" then getting cut in on a 10 mile final 3000 feet high:ooh:
Never had it happen to me, but I'm now hearing it often enough with guys going into BNE to be wondering if there is anything to it.

haughtney1 9th Jun 2012 17:43

PM on its way P-Dubby :ok:

As for the conspiracy theory, I'm with you....it's just that I've heard it once to often to dismiss it out of hand (probably just means they are all paranoid idiots:E)

pcx 10th Jun 2012 00:03

Don't see any conspiracy there. Just the ATC guys and girls trying to provide the best service and maximize the use of the available airspace and runway.
Simple solution if it doesn't work for you.
Unable, request xxxxxx.


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:44.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.